Canadian Beer: Huffington Post Readers Weigh In On Favourite Brews And American Tastes

The Huffington Post Canada     First Posted: 06/22/11 01:13 PM ET   Updated: 08/22/11 06:12 AM ET

All week, The Huffington Post Canada and OpenFile are looking more closely at how Canadians consume and enjoy beer as a part of our #BeerEh collaboration. We asked you to tell us if you thought Canadian beer is better than American beer, what brands you prefer, and what's the cheapest brew in your city.

Hundreds sent in tweets with the #BeerEh hashtag, voted and commented on Facebook and on our website to become a part of the conversation.


CANADIAN VS. AMERICAN BEER

It wasn't even close on our Facebook poll. Of the 269 votes cast by Wednesday morning on the choice between American and Canadian beer, 80 per cent of respondents picked Canuck brew.

And the American beer jokes came fast and furious:

  • Papineau 2000: "How to make American beer? Easy. Take Canadian beer, add water, leave open overnight, recap in the morning and voila ! Budweiser. No after taste. No before taste. No during taste."
  • Bud Latanville on Facebook: "There's a classic Monty Python bit from 'Live at the Hollywood Bowl.' Why is American Beer like making love in a canoe? It's F*&*#ing Close to Water.' Okay, that's a generalization. :) But any of the major breweries (USA'n or Canadian, or American-owned Canadian), produce the blandest, most boring beers..."
  • Ryan Doherty on Facebook: "Yank beer is tired, bland and pointless. Canadian beer is fun, tasty, and loves to party."
  • Rosemary Keutzer on Facebook: “Yellow alert - ‘We’re running out of beer’ Orange alert - ‘We’ll have to drink it warm’ Red alert - ‘There’s only american left!!!’”

Of course, you had plenty to say about the quality of beers outside North America. A sampling:

  • rotary: "Nothing beats Hoegaarden from Belgium." #beereh
  • @adventures_alc: "Schlenkerla is from #Bamberg, Germany the home of the Rauchbier/Smoked beer style. #beereh"
  • @annkearnsphoto: "Stella!! Not just my dog, but a great beer, too! :) #beereh"

YOUR FAVOURITE BEERS

There's still time to vote in our poll of favourite beer brands. If you don't see your brew listed, mention it in the comments.

So far, the top three rated beers in the gallery are Alexander Keiths, Stella Artois and Steam Whistle.

Many of you had harsh words for our gallery of brews and argued in favour of microbreweries and smaller-scale Quebec beers over the big guys.

  • ruffdeezy: "All these suck. My favourite is Phillips Amnesiac Double IPA. Regular Guiness is no good either, people should try Guiness foreign extra stout ."
  • StephenMaturin: "There's lots of great Ontario beer that hasn't got a mention including the consistent­ly lovely Creemore Springs Premium Lager. Also, branch out a little and try: Neustadt 10W30 Brown Ale, Sergeant Major's India Pale Ale, Mill Street Tank House Ale. (OK, apparently I'm a little ale biased but there are also lovely pilseners and lagers that are easy to obtain that aren't InterBrew clones with different packaging)"

Check out this list of beer suggestions on our Facebook page.

On Twitter, you had more than a few recommendations. Some we've heard of, many we haven't:

Keep the recommendations coming! Tweet us with the #BeerEH hashtag


WHERE'S THE CHEAPEST & BEST BEER IN CANADA?



The Huffington Post Canada has teamed up with OpenFile, a collaborative local news organization operating in seven Canadian communities, to look more closely at Canada's thirst for beer.

OpenFile will examine the story of beer as told through the mouths and wallets of Canadians. Using input from the public and a network of professional reporters, we'll get answers to questions such as, what's the cheapest city and province in Canada to get a beer? Has a craft culture emerged and how is it changing beer-drinking habits? Do beer prices fluctuate during those hot summer months?

The result will be an interactive picture of the price and popularity of beer in different cities, and the culture of beer-drinking across Canada.

What's the best and cheapest beer in your city? Files are open and ready for your feedback in each of these cities:

Your city not listed? Tell us the best and cheapest beer in your city through our comments.

these pamphleteers
1 of 25
Total comments: 24 | Post a Comment
1 of 25
This Tweet
Okay
Great

  • 1

  • 2

  • 3

  • 4

  • 5

  • 6

  • 7

  • 8

  • 9

  • 10
Current Top 5 Slides
Users who voted on this slide
loading...

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

All week, The Huffington Post Canada and OpenFile are looking more closely at how Canadians consume and enjoy beer as a part of our #BeerEh collaboration. We asked you to tell us if you thought Canadi...
All week, The Huffington Post Canada and OpenFile are looking more closely at how Canadians consume and enjoy beer as a part of our #BeerEh collaboration. We asked you to tell us if you thought Canadi...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:06 PM on 06/27/2011
Proof is in the pudding or in this case beer! I am not a budweiser fan but it is funny how everyone says how bad Bud is when it is the leading seller in Canada and this isnt because it is less expensive.........it is the same price or more expensive as Molson and Labatt.

TOP FIVE CANADIAN BEERS (2010)
1. Budweiser
2. Molson Canadian
3. Labatt Blue
4. Coors Light
5. Molson Dry

Source(s):

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_be
http://www.cbc.ca/news/background/realit
09:01 PM on 06/27/2011
OK you Lug heads........Everyone is saying Canadian beer is much better than our lower Ameican cousins but let us get the facts out......Budweiser is the #1 selling beer in Canada with Coor being the #4 best selling beer in Canada. Post all you want but the facts are the facts!!! Our Canadian beer can't even come close to American micro-brews.....we are years behind in taste and cost! If only we could have the variety of beer that the USA has and also the price they have for a great beer for even a greater price!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
10:31 PM on 06/27/2011
is it possible that us lower cousins are drinking all the crap beer in Canadia?
aintnoliberalnow
Old,cranky and retired
05:48 PM on 06/26/2011
As early as 1989, I was finding and drinking U S craft brew products in some really strange locations like the Radisson University in Minneapolis Mn. Yes, they were ahead of us because the major breweries fought as hard as they could to kill independent brewers in Canada. Anyone in Ontario remember Formosa Breweries? How about Hart? Formosa was pretty much the first in Ontario to be moderately successful but because they kept brewing during the strike of the late 60s and again in the early 70s, they were taken over by Carling before they could become a long term threat. The Brewers retail did their level best to exclude all small brewers and it took a provincial law to smarten them up. When it comes to micro and craft beer, there are more in the US but the quality of the products in both countries are equal. The commercial junk however has a Canadian edge to it only because of a little more alcohol and a slightly different brewing method giving the Canadian soup a stronger taste. All in all, contemporary choices in both countries are so far ahead of what we had to put up with 40 years ago that I really don't care which is best, I'm just happy we have a quality choice where ever we go now.
JaffaKree
No... NOT "Only in America".
03:12 AM on 06/24/2011
Not to be pedantic, but everyone born on this continent is American. ;)

We should be talking about Canadian vs Unites States beer.
06:27 PM on 06/22/2011
I have to agree with one of the people mentioned: Neustadt 10W30 Brown Ale is FREAKING AWESOME. Seriously. Silly name GREAT BEER.

Also, Wellington Arkell Bitters. *THE* best bitters outside the UK.

Disclosure: My fave beer of all time? Theakston's Old Peculier, from the UK.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Miss Ann Thrope
Left or right-wing, it's all the same bird
11:21 PM on 06/22/2011
Ditto on the Neustadt. Unfortunately my local pub stopped serving it right after I discovered it. 8-(

I'm also partial to wheat beers like Hoegaarden and I like local Ontario brewery Hop City's Lawn Chair.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Astronomy Guy
05:51 PM on 06/22/2011
I haven't had one since I left Belgium but give me a Chimay Blue any day of the week (and at least twice on Friday and Saturday nights).
04:17 PM on 06/22/2011
Phillips from Victoria BC is my favourite. Specifically the Amnesiac Double IPA. There are tons of great micro brews in Canada, just gotta look.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sdgreen
06:01 PM on 06/22/2011
Phillips Beers are just outstanding! Great brewers in Victoria too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GreenCanadian
is mixing the new record
06:43 PM on 06/22/2011
If you like Phillips (and I really do) try Nelson Brewing Company beer. Everything they make is the stuff of legend and it's certified organic to boot. Hard to come by in Calgreedy, but I've found a few places.
01:13 PM on 06/22/2011
These comments are idiotic - very few Canadians have access to good American microbrews because of the neo-prohibitionist beer rules that typify Canadian provincial liquor licensing boards. I sincerely doubt most of the posters could differentiate Molson, Labatt's, Bud or Coors in a blind taste test. The poll is mostly naval-gazing pseudo-patriotism wrapped around some stereotypes - good stuff, HuffPo.
01:47 PM on 06/22/2011
not true at all. I grew up in Seattle, and drove frequently to Portland, the birthplaces of NW microbrew culture. I've also lived in Ontario and now live in the interior of BC, and there are great beers all over Canada. your suggestion that Canadians can't tell the difference between corporate breweries and quality brew is just wrong.

Fave beers in Ontario: Wellington Brewery does a brilliant SPA and Imperial Stout while the Granite Brew Pub's Dry Hopped Bitter is off the charts.
Best in BC: Spinnakers is great for classic, British styles. Loved Swans when I was living in Victoria. Now I live in Kamloops and spend many a night sipping IPA at The Noble Pig brew pub.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
henrypapillon
Put a Psychiatrist in every NRA meeting.
10:16 AM on 06/23/2011
The differenc is that a lot of microbrews taste like horse offal, and the only reason most people drink the awful stuff is snob appeal. My son-in-law tried to sell me on how good Oberon was. I tried it once, and I thought it maybe was flat, that it had been out too long and that  it tasted like stale beer the day after a kegger. I gave it anothyer chance last week and it was just as bad, freshly opened. My wife bought him a half gallon at the local micro brewery and he was raving about it . I thought it was awful. It tasted like Bock beer with peach juice in it.
02:17 PM on 06/22/2011
Well of course I couldn't differentiate those four beers in a blind taste test. They are all generic and interchangeable. I can definitely tell a English draft bitter from a European lager though.
04:35 PM on 06/22/2011
Go to better bars. NYC is currently one of the best cities in North America for beer (I just moved back to Canada after spending 5 years there). Rattle N Hum, The Blind Tiger, Ginger Man, etc have better beer on any given night than I can find in 3 months of scouring the LCBO. Canada is getting better - there's no doubt, but the US is a good five to ten years ahead of us in terms of the craft beer market. More adventurous brewers, more skilled brewers, and more amenable beer laws certanly help.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bbertaud
Je ne regrette rien, rien de rien
01:07 PM on 06/22/2011
Any beer not made in Kwackbec will do for me
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:09 PM on 06/22/2011
I don't know, Le Fin du Monde is easily my favourite and its from Quebec.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Miss Ann Thrope
Left or right-wing, it's all the same bird
11:26 PM on 06/22/2011
Yeah man. I challenge anyone to find a beer that has both a 9% alcohol content and is that smooth tasting. I also like Unibroue's Blanche de Chambly.