Buddy Tavares Sues Over Kick To The Head From RCMP Officer Geoff Mantler

Buddy Tavares

First Posted: 07/12/11 08:38 PM ET Updated: 09/11/11 06:12 AM ET

THE CANADIAN PRESS -- KELOWNA, B.C. - A British Columbia man who was kicked in the head by an RCMP officer while being arrested at gunpoint has launched a civil lawsuit over his injuries.

The arrest caught on video shows Const. Geoff Mantler ordering Buddy Tavares to the ground and seconds later kicking the man in the face.

The 28-year-old constable has been charged with assault stemming from the incident in Kelowna, B.C., last January. His lawyer entered a not guilty plea to the charge during a brief hearing Tuesday.

Tavares' lawsuit accuses Mantler, the B.C. government, the City of Kelowna and another unnamed female officer of negligence and malicious misconduct.

The lawsuit, filed with the court late last month, said the officers pulled Tavares over at a Kelowna city intersection, ordered him from his vehicle at gunpoint and told him to lie on the ground.

"The plaintiff was in the process of complying with the defendants ... at which time the defendant Mantler, wrongfully and without provocation from the plaintiff, delivered a kick to the head of the plaintiff," the lawsuit states.

His lawsuit claims Tavares, 51, suffered a broken nose and injuries to his mouth, teeth and brain, as well as shock and trauma.

Accusations of negligence in the civil claim include excessive and unnecessary force and failing to observe provisions of the Criminal Code for proper police behaviour and procedure.

RCMP have said the officers were responding to reports of shots fired at a golf course when they stopped Tavares' vehicle.
Tavares has said was on leave from a job at the golf course while recovering from a brain injury suffered in a previous motorcycle crash.

The man was handcuffed and spent the weekend in an RCMP holding cell after the Jan. 7 arrest.

He was originally charged with careless use of a firearm, but the charge was later dropped. Tavares agreed to an 18-month ban on possessing firearms.

Release of the video set off public protests and RCMP Assistant Commissioner Peter Hourihan visited Tavares six weeks after the arrest and apologized for what happened.

Tavares' lawsuit claims punitive and exemplary damages for "high-handed, reprehensible and, or oppressive actions in the assault and battery or negligence."

It doesn't state a dollar figure for compensation.

RCMP and the B.C. solicitor general declined to comment with the matter before the court.

None of the claims in the lawsuit have been proven in court.

Mantler was placed on paid suspension a few days after the alleged assault. In May, Mounties announced his pay was being revoked while he remained on suspension.

Last month, Mantler's lawyer entered a not-guilty plea on his behalf in a separate assault charge stemming from the arrest of another man last August.

Mantler was not in court Tuesday when his lawyer, Neville McDougall, entered the plea on his behalf in the Tavares case and reiterated the not guilty plea in the other case.

McDougall said Mantler is frustrated by the way he has been treated by the national police force. He said his client has been a scapegoat.

"Geoff Mantler was thrown under the bus based on public perception and to try to maintain the integrity of the RCMP as a unit, as opposed to what he was acting on that day," McDougall told reporters outside the court.

A date for his assault trial will be set later this month.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

THE CANADIAN PRESS -- KELOWNA, B.C. - A British Columbia man who was kicked in the head by an RCMP officer while being arrested at gunpoint has launched a civil lawsuit over his injuries. The arres...
THE CANADIAN PRESS -- KELOWNA, B.C. - A British Columbia man who was kicked in the head by an RCMP officer while being arrested at gunpoint has launched a civil lawsuit over his injuries. The arres...
Filed by Christian Cotroneo  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 23
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
abuckley23
Published author. Visit me at Planet Kibi!
12:12 PM on 07/13/2011
As an Okanagan resident I'm tired of this media circus. Yes the constable was obviously wrong and yes there are reports he's committed similar offenses before. As soon as Tavares came forward others came out of the wood work. The community got behind Tavares and held public rallies for the guy. The reason Tavares was arrested in the first place was because he went to a golf course where he no longer works and shot off a shotgun to scare geese. Tavares seems a little weird himself. But he was still a victim and his noble journey was just in helping to expose police brutality.


Now Tavares, or his lawyer, or both are out to make money. Plain and simple. Someone please kick me in the head so I don't have to see or hear about this crap everywhere I go.
12:49 PM on 07/13/2011
If we didn't all hear about it, your chances of getting that kick would have been a lot better.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
abuckley23
Published author. Visit me at Planet Kibi!
01:17 PM on 07/13/2011
Exactly! See how much trouble it's causing...?
12:22 AM on 07/13/2011
We need the BC Provincial Police looking after our province again.
12:12 AM on 07/13/2011
ONCE AGAIN I HAVE TO STATE MY DISGUST IN THE RCMP... DOES IT EVER END...TO STATE I HOPE HE SUES THE BUTT OFF THIS MORON OR THEM MORONS WILL ONLY MEAN HE'S REALLY SUING US... THEREFORE MY REAL DESIRE IS THAT WE THE PEOPLE OF B.C WILL INSIST TO CLARK SHE DOESN'T RENEW THESE REJECTS CONTACT AND WE WILL BE RID OF THIS DINOSAUR ORGANIZATION ONCE AND FOR ALL.THERE IS A LOGICAL REASON WHY ONTARIO AND QUEBEC HAVE THEIR OWN PROVINCIAL POLICE FORCE AND NO RCMP....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
abuckley23
Published author. Visit me at Planet Kibi!
12:02 PM on 07/13/2011
Why are you shouting?
11:52 PM on 07/12/2011
Not a lot of support for the RCMP on this case and so many others. Kick to the head for what? There was no threat of danger to the officer. We pay their salaries. Maybe take it down a notch and remember that 99.8% of Canadians are law abiding and do not pose a threat. Maybe a different level of brainwashing in Saskatchewan basic training is in order?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jake Thomas
elastic
11:10 PM on 07/12/2011
Sounds like business as usual for the RCMP. Time to do a top-down purge of that organization.
photo
CarlyQ
Without followers, evil cannot spread.
10:41 PM on 07/12/2011
"Geoff Mantler was thrown under the bus based on public perception.."

Geoff Mantler was caught on video kicking a compliant man in the face who was already on his knees, hands on his head and nowhere within reach of his gun.

Under the bus is exactly where he belongs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Vivian Alicia Evans
11:11 PM on 07/12/2011
Yes that is where he belongs.
09:41 PM on 07/12/2011
I live in Kelowna, I don't get why he is suing the City here. We don't have a local police force, its just the RCMP. i can see no possible reason why he would sue the City over this. Tavares has enjoyed public support including a few public rallies, but suing the City will end that here quickly. I get that it's probably just his lawyer naming everyone in the civil suit right off the bat, but this won't play out well in our limited local media.
01:40 AM on 07/13/2011
Suing the city would cause people there to stop supporting Tavares? I hope you are not representative of your community. Why wouldn't he? The city has a responsibility for his safety and instead of being protected by the police he was assaulted. I would hope everyone in the community would support him. What is the alternative? Support former Cst. Mantler? If this had been done to you, and that could happen, wouldn't you want the city to recognize the problem and do something about it?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
abuckley23
Published author. Visit me at Planet Kibi!
12:08 PM on 07/13/2011
Why he kicked him in the face was unclear and the constable in question has had a few complaints against him prior but the video was taken on a cell phone with no audio and it was a short clip. My understanding was Tavares was at a local golf course where he used to work shooting a shotgun to scare geese...that dude isn't all there either. Probably less so after being kicked in the head.
09:22 PM on 07/12/2011
Cst. Mantler's lawyer states Mantler is frustrated by the way he has been treated by the police force? Maybe he wants a kick in the face, too.
09:55 PM on 07/12/2011
Wow, that's raw. Your neighbors should be worried about you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Vivian Alicia Evans
11:15 PM on 07/12/2011
What we are worried about is the excessive force used by the RCMP and lack of ethics. We have RCMP officers lying on the stand in the Robert Dziekanski's inquiry. The Buddy Tavares' case is just another of many where the public is losing trust in the RCMP to provide law and order.
01:29 AM on 07/13/2011
Not really. I assume he believes himself to have been a good officer doing good police work, even though this apparently wasn't the first time he has been accused of brutality. He expects the police force to support him? Or the rest of us to feel sorry for him?
09:05 PM on 07/12/2011
"RCMP have said the officers were responding to reports of shots fired at a golf course when they stopped Tavares' vehicle."

Is there a process in the police force to weed out recruits/veterans based on their tolerance for fear? If an officer is so afraid of taking a bullet that his aggression is raised to dangerous levels then perhaps he is in the wrong line of work.
09:04 PM on 07/12/2011
Nice police work Constable Mantler. To quote from Issac Asimov, "violence is the first resort of the incompetent." Telling that they've got the young barbarian working his magic as a plain clothes officer.
photo
canadianperspective
My micro-bio is empty.Big wup.Wanna fide aboud id?
09:02 PM on 07/12/2011
Mantler was practising for the CFL's million dollar kick competition. Seriously though, what makes cop act this way? They guy was obviously compliant. That is what I don't get. I know the cops have a hard enough job day in day out, and they have to deal with some pretty heavy stuff. But this behavior is gratuitous.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ConDsenXieN
The Right is usually wrong.
08:18 PM on 07/12/2011
As he should. The RCMP have felt like they're above the law for years.