Calgary Stampede: Second Horse Dies at Chuckwagon Races

Chuckwagon

First Posted: 07/16/11 10:34 AM ET Updated: 09/15/11 06:12 AM ET

THE CANADIAN PRESS -- CALGARY - A second horse has died during the chuckwagon races at the Calgary Stampede.

Stampede spokesman Doug Fraser said Friday that a horse belonging to Jim Knight suffered a fractured leg.

Knight's rig had been involved in a collision with the rig of Cliff Cunningham, but Fraser said it's not yet clear whether it was the collision that caused the injury.

"Both teams finished the race but immediately after our veterinarian discovered that one of Knight's horses had suffered a fractured leg, and after further assessment the veterinarian made the decision to euthanize the horse," Fraser said.

"We have to determine whether the collision caused the horse's leg to break ... or whether that leg might have broken elsewhere during the race."

The chuckwagon safety commission has asked to review the race and will interview the drivers and judges Saturday morning.

However, Fraser noted the judges immediately fined rookie driver Cunningham -- who is competing at the Stampede for the first time -- $2,500 for interference, which means he either cut off the other team or allowed his rig to bump the other team's rig.

Fraser said the safety commission could increase or decrease that fine depending on their findings.

One week ago, one of Cunningham's horses had to be destroyed after suffering a broken leg during a chuckwagon race on the Stampede's first night of competition.

Fraser said in that case, a review concluded the horse suffered a "catastrophic" injury that was not the result of driver error or a collision.

"It's unfortunate Mr. Cunningham is having a bit of a rough go at it as a rookie," said Fraser. "I'm sure nobody feels worse than Cliff Cunningham."

There are still two days to go in the competition, but overall Stampede officials have been having a better year than 2010, when six horses had to be destroyed.

Two died of heart attacks, two were destroyed after suffering injuries and another broke its back from bucking too hard.

The sixth died after experiencing health difficulties 40 minutes after a chuckwagon race.

Animal welfare organizations complained that rodeo is simply cruelty masquerading as entertainment. In Britain, a group called League Against Cruel Sports called on Ottawa to end ``the immense cruelty'' inherent in rodeos and suggested to British travel agencies that they refuse to offer vacation packages to the Stampede.

More than 50 MPs signed a motion in the British House of Commons that asked the Canadian government to improve how animals were treated at the rodeo.

Stampede officials instituted an overhaul of animal care standards at the event, including microchipping horses to track how often they are used and cutting the number outriders in the chuckwagon races to two from four.

"In general terms, we've had a relatively safe event," Fraser said Friday. "Unfortunately, we've had these two horses die and we have to continue to try and improve our system. It's not just a one-year fix."

He said the goal is always to have no animal deaths, but pointed to comments recently made by noted animal science expert Dr. Temple Grandin who argued rodeos themselves are not at fault.

"It's the way breeding has taken place over the last 30 or 40 years," Fraser said, summarizing Grandin's argument. "These horses are bred so that they're big and powerful but not necessarily as strong as they could be."

That hasn't placated animal welfare organizations such as the Vancouver Humane Society, which has noted more than 50 chuckwagon horses have died since 1986.

After the first horse death a week ago, the society called for the immediate suspension of the Stampede chuckwagon races.

"The Stampede's claims to have made the race safer have been proven false," society spokesman Peter Fricker said at the time.

"It is totally unacceptable to continue this event when horse after horse is dying just to entertain a crowd."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

THE CANADIAN PRESS -- CALGARY - A second horse has died during the chuckwagon races at the Calgary Stampede. Stampede spokesman Doug Fraser said Friday that a horse belonging to Jim Knight suffered...
THE CANADIAN PRESS -- CALGARY - A second horse has died during the chuckwagon races at the Calgary Stampede. Stampede spokesman Doug Fraser said Friday that a horse belonging to Jim Knight suffered...
Filed by Lauren Strapagiel  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 44
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
exPatPatti
Eyes Wide Open
08:51 AM on 07/17/2011
As a horse owner, I find this very saddening.
04:22 AM on 07/17/2011
And every year over nine million children die of starvation. and millions more die from drinking dirty water. but the death of a horse means morethan the death of a professional athlete.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cameron d
Good Guys Win
10:49 PM on 07/16/2011
If a cowboy breaks his leg are we putting him down too?
10:17 PM on 07/16/2011
We all know some horses are going to die at the Stampede. Wouldn't it be simpler just to line up 3 or 4 horses, at the parade, and then shoot them in front of the crowd, so more people could get to see it? Not everyone can get tickets to the chuckwagon racing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cameron d
Good Guys Win
04:49 PM on 07/16/2011
How boring is your life if you think that a Chuckwagon race is entertaining?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Altario
Among nerds, I'm cool.
09:49 PM on 07/16/2011
How dead inside are you that you can't find the excitement in one?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cameron d
Good Guys Win
10:47 PM on 07/16/2011
Why not watch paint dry? Or grass grow? Or a NASCAR race?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:32 PM on 07/16/2011
Rodeo's belong in the history books.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CanAmFam
07:42 PM on 07/16/2011
Agreed... along with dogfighting, cockfighting and other blatant forms of animal cruelty.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Peacefrogg
09:14 PM on 07/16/2011
Rodeos are part of our Canadian Heritage and History, those animals are not abused infact they have better lives then most animals. If you need to add anything to the history books add religion.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cameron d
Good Guys Win
10:48 PM on 07/16/2011
Japanese Internment Camp's are part of our history too. Should we keep that as part of our heritage too?
Rodeos are a waste of time and effort.
03:25 PM on 07/16/2011
...despite the carnage, I can't quit ya Calgary Stampede™!!!!
photo
Daniel Kilgallon
Calgary Heavy Oil
02:18 PM on 07/16/2011
As a Calgarian love the Stampede! Yes animals die, and efforts need to be made to prevent this. At the same time you can't tell people that the defining event in their culture is backward and pointless and they need to stop doing what they have been doing for 99 years of 127 of their history.

How about I go to Vancouver and tell them to shut down the aquarium because that can be seen as cruel to animals with the number of whales they've killed over the years. That's pointless and counterproductive.

Well, I'm off to the grounds to drink some beer, watch some blacksmiths, see the chucks, and dance 'till I drop.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tnanimation
04:29 PM on 07/16/2011
How about you just stop killing horses for sport.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bestuvall
12:22 AM on 07/17/2011
are you saying Daniel killed the horses himself.. Have fun Daniel ..that is more than most of the morose , depressed and holier than thou people on this blog will do. Ones whoa are "super users" who spend all of their time on their rear ends telling others what to do..
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CanAmFam
07:44 PM on 07/16/2011
"At the same time you can't tell people that the defining event in their culture is backward and pointless and they need to stop doing what they have been doing for 99 years of 127 of their history."

That's what the Southerners said about slavery. And segregation. And restricting women from voting... need I go on?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bestuvall
12:22 AM on 07/17/2011
oh please spare us the "going on"
01:59 PM on 07/16/2011
Maybe it is time that this anachronism Calgary calls the stampede be abolished. This happens every year and is a complete disgrace. Shame on the organizers for organizing this and shame on people for supporting it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tnanimation
04:29 PM on 07/16/2011
Alberta is one giant anachronism itself so good luck with trying to tell them anything.
01:27 PM on 07/16/2011
This disgraceful circus masquarading as culture will one day end, but probably not in my lifetime. It's sad that one of the only groups to aggressively take on this barbaric cash cow is the Vancouver Humane Society, 1000 kilometres away. That's because the Calgary Stampede wields tremendous power in Alberta, including over the media. People are scared to speak out or protest because the mindless hordes would crush anyone trying to spoil their YEE HAAAH good time, and those who are against it, know it.
cdnman
Still a free spirit...
02:50 PM on 07/16/2011
Tilley63 f and f
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ascoli
03:11 PM on 07/16/2011
X2
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AC Fraser
bend before you break
01:13 PM on 07/16/2011
This poor horse ran the majority of the race with a broken leg. Can you imagine the pain that animal was in? The Stampede obviously has no way of preventing this kind of thing from happening, as evidenced by two broken legs despite "advances" in safety monitoring. Time to ban the Chuckwagon Race. Well past time.
photo
Blodo
Time to build a better world
12:54 PM on 07/16/2011
Shut it down. Now.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jake Thomas
elastic
12:50 PM on 07/16/2011
Stuffing horses with fireworks and lighting them off would be a more honest packaging of this entertainment. The chuck wagon races are gladitorial and should be banned completely. Pure cruelty and it needs to stop.
12:45 PM on 07/16/2011
Animal torture and cruelty disguised as entertainment.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:43 PM on 07/16/2011
I never understood why they killed horses with broken legs. Can't they just put a cast on it and let him rest for a few months? If the rider broke his leg, would they euthanize him too?!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tooldude
01:31 PM on 07/16/2011
That thin of a bone will not support the weight of a horse after it has been broken. No amount of time in a cast will ever give it the strength required to hold up the horse.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
greenmonk
The Only Thing We Have to Fear Is Fear Itself
01:47 PM on 07/17/2011
That just doesn't seem right somehow. Why would Mother Nature be so cruel to such a lovely beast? Humans can be mended this way, even birds, like eagles, have broken wings mended where it takes incredible power to use them.

Even if this has been the case in the Wild Wild West, have they not made medical advancements since then to use supportive implants or something? What I suspect more than anything is that that the horse is no longer a commercially viable commodity. I just don't buy that the horse could not be repaired enough to stand in a field and chew grass for the rest of his/her life.
09:19 PM on 07/16/2011
If any "human" (and I use that term loosely) rodeo "participants (read: animal torturers) DID break a limb at the event, it surely would be fitting if they were euthanised by a vet... in front of the crowd.