Calgary Stampede: Chuckwagon Driver Gets Record Fine After Horse Euthanized

Stampede

First Posted: 07/17/11 11:28 AM ET Updated: 09/16/11 06:12 AM ET

THE CANADIAN PRESS -- CALGARY - The Calgary Stampede levied its largest fine ever against a driver Saturday, after a chuckwagon race collision led to the death of a horse.

The chuckwagon safety commission fined driver Cliff Cunningham after investigating the Friday-night incident which saw an injured horse put down.

Stampede spokesman Doug Fraser said an initial fine of $2,500 was upped to $12,500 after the commission reviewed video of the crash and spoke with the drivers involved.

"It was the judgement of the commission that the cause of the collision was clearly a case of driver error," Fraser said.

"The commission wanted to send a strong message that action has consequences."

Fraser also said the commission ruled that the horse broke its leg in the crash.

Both teams involved in the collision finished the race on Friday, but a Stampede veterinarian discovered one of Knight's horses had a broken leg and the animal had to be euthanized.

Much of the fine — $10,000 — will go towards driver Jim Knight to compensate him for the loss of his horse.

It was the second horse to die during the chuckwagon races at the Stampede this year.

A week ago, one of Cunningham's horses had to be destroyed after suffering a broken leg during a chuckwagon race on the Stampede's first night of competition.

Fraser said in that case, a review concluded the horse suffered a "catastrophic" injury that was not the result of driver error or a collision.

In 2010, six horses had to be put down during the Calgary Stampede.

Fraser said in Friday's collision, Cunningham admitted right away that he was at fault, and that there are no hard feelings between the two drivers over the incident.

Fraser said he was with the two drivers in a room shortly before the announcement of the fine was made.

"Cliff was sorry. He admitted his mistake. Jim, I think, was very, very forgiving, stating that accidents do happen. And although this was a case of driver error, Jim has no hard feelings with Cliff," he said.

"The two are pretty good friends in the long run."

Both Cunningham and Knight were scheduled to race again Saturday night.

Stampede officials, in order to cut down on the number of deaths, instituted an overhaul of animal care standards at the event this year.

They include microchipping horses to track how often they are used and cutting the number of outriders in the chuckwagon races to two from four.

Despite the Stampede's actions though, animal welfare organizations have complained that the rodeo is simply cruelty masquerading as entertainment.

The Vancouver Humane Society, which has noted more than 50 chuckwagon horses have died since 1986, repeated its call for the immediate suspension of the Stampede chuckwagon races following Friday's horse death.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

THE CANADIAN PRESS -- CALGARY - The Calgary Stampede levied its largest fine ever against a driver Saturday, after a chuckwagon race collision led to the death of a horse. The chuckwagon safety com...
THE CANADIAN PRESS -- CALGARY - The Calgary Stampede levied its largest fine ever against a driver Saturday, after a chuckwagon race collision led to the death of a horse. The chuckwagon safety com...
Filed by Lauren Strapagiel  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 26
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:54 AM on 07/18/2011
A lifetime ban from the stampede should also be a part of the fine.
09:26 PM on 07/17/2011
The Vancouver Humane Society is a predatory organization full of its own self importance and out to suck up money in any way it can. The Society is in no way interested in animal welfare solutions but is a clone of PETA and the other radical vegetarian agenda driven orgs that exist in the world. It is all about anthropomorphic fanaticism.
photo
SuperRyan
Still as sexy as ever.
09:43 PM on 07/17/2011
What a bunch of horse malarky.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tnanimation
08:19 PM on 07/17/2011
Yeah! That'll learn 'im. And the next time you kill a horse the fine will be DOUBLE!
04:10 PM on 07/17/2011
These animals are bred to be athletes and, just like human athletes, sometimes things happen and they die. It's sad and unfortunate but that's life. I suppose a horse that pulls a plow for 15 years has a better life. I think not.
05:45 PM on 07/17/2011
No. It's not just like human athletes. There's no one out there hand-picking human beings to breed them in order to produce a superb athlete. And yes, there are accidents and horrible things that happen when humans compete, but as my reply to another comment, we're not euthenised when we break a limb.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:31 PM on 07/17/2011
I imagine a free horse has a better life. Besides who pulls plows with horses nowadays, Deere's pull plows.
11:19 PM on 07/17/2011
A free horse is much more rare than a horse that pulls a plow. I guess your experience is only limited to what happens in the western world. There is a good many farmers on this planet still using livestock to help till the soil. Try and expand your mind a little. Anyhow, my point is that we use animals in many different ways that maybe aren't so pleasant for the animal but it enhances our lives. As soon as we eradicate human suffering then maybe we can start worrying about animals.
02:19 PM on 07/17/2011
Despite the fact that it's kills multiple animals annually, and includes some of the worst exploitations of animals in the rodeo, the Stampede persists because of simple economics. Up to a million people travel to the event and so it brings in a lot of money from tourists. The government spends millions on the event as well.

It's a city-endorsed spectacle of animal cruelty.
09:29 PM on 07/17/2011
Oh spare the overblown hyperbole. " ... worst exploitation..." such high toned piety!
12:39 PM on 07/19/2011
I would like to presume you know how to read.

But if not, here is the quote you took out of context - "includes some of the worst exploitati­ons of animals in the rodeo" that is very different than "worst exploitation".

SOME OF. That is not hyperbole. The chuck wagon race (derby), calf roping and steer wrestling are SOME OF the worst exploitations of animals in the rodeo. Those are the events at the Calgary Stampede that result in the most number of deaths and injuries, and by their very nature, put both human and animal in unnecessary physical danger (other events may put just the human or the animal in danger).
11:14 AM on 07/17/2011
People want entertainment and the thrill of a race? Go to a local high school and watch the track and field events. They want a higher quality of competition? Go to a local college university and watch their track and field competitions. Not enough? Catch the inter-collegiate track and field competitions. Want something more thrilling? How about watching a down-hill ski race? A slalom? Moguls? My point? And those participants are there willingly. They're not forced to run/race. And heaven forbid if anyone suffers a broken limb, they won't be euthenised because thankfully, the way our bodies work, once a broken bone is healed, it can support our full body weight.

I wrote this before and I'll repeat myself. Rodeos are nothing more than cheap excuses for animal torture and cruelty disguised as entertainment.
11:38 AM on 07/17/2011
I'm not a huge fan of the chucks or rodeo but you people are getting to be serious fun sponges. You act as if there are horses roaming free across the plains of Alberta, living the good life. These horses are born and bred to be in the rodeo or the races. If they weren't there they would be in a can of dog food.
11:43 AM on 07/17/2011
Or they wouldn't be bred at all if there was no need for such horses.
10:34 PM on 07/17/2011
You should learn your facts.
(1) There are horses roaming the plains of Alberta and have been for generations. The Wild Horses of Alberta Society (WHOAS) has a website and facebook presence.
(2) These horses weren't born for rodeo. No Thoroughbred is 'born' for rodeo, Thoroughbreds bred and trained to run fast on a track and try to outrun the horse next to them while carrying a rider and very small saddle, not as a team pulling a wagon.
(3) In Alberta (and Quebec) the companion and sport horses, much like the Thoroughbreds in question, are actually slaughtered for human consumption, not dog food.
These are all well documented facts.
cdnman
Still a free spirit...
11:44 AM on 07/17/2011
I'm with you jt ... faved and already fanned