Gerald Tremblay, Montreal Mayor, Says Crumbling Infrastructure, Bad Roads, Plague Canadian Cities
MONTREAL - Montreal's mayor says the crumbling infrastructure in his city serves as an ominous warning for the entire country of what could happen unless urban centres get more funding.
Gerald Tremblay held a news conference near a partly collapsed tunnel Tuesday to argue that federal and provincial governments need to invest more political capital in cities.
He derided recent funding as a drop in the bucket compared to the needs of cities — estimated by some economists at $120 billion.
Tremblay said his administration has been forced to take unpopular measures with fees and parking meters, and he urged his counterparts at the federal and provincial levels to show similar courage.
He cited two possible examples: provincial toll booths and an increase in the federal gas tax.
"Sometimes it takes a crisis to make decision-makers move faster,'' Tremblay said. ''But it's not just a Montreal problem.
"When I talk to my colleagues in other big Canadian cities it's the same issue — we have a $120-billion hole...
"Eighty per cent of people in Canada live in cities. We need to recognize their needs better, on a financial level."
Montrealers have reached a boiling point in the wake of road shutdowns, collapsing concrete, and warnings of potential danger to major existing infrastructure.
The city already deals with monster traffic jams at odd hours, and there are fears the problem may get worse.
In the wake of Montreal's woes, the Institute for Research on Public Policy think-tank reissued a three-year-old study Tuesday from University of Waterloo professor James A. Brox that warned infrastructure issues are eating away at Canada's economy.
The author argued that Canadian infrastructure required an injection of up to $200 billion — $72 billion for new projects and $123 billion to repair existing structures.
He said U.S. productivity levels zoomed past Canada's after the mid-1990s in an era where, in the U.S., infrastructure spending ramped up 24 per cent while it declined 3.5 per cent in Canada. A 10 per cent annual increase in infrastructure spending would, Brox said, reduce costs for Canadian manufacturers by five per cent.
He included a chart illustrating a drastic increase in the burden being shouldered by municipalities when it comes to infrastructure spending, compared to a plummeting share shouldered by federal and provincial governments since the 1960s.
His study was produced in mid-2008, just before Ottawa embarked on a major round of stimulus spending. The federal government now says it will have spent almost $13 billion through a pair of stimulus funds and $13 billion more, through 2014, from a gas-tax fund.
The Quebec government has taken much of the heat during Montrealers' summer of discontent.
Some observers call Montreal's problems a special case — the result of too much road salt, too little inspection, shoddy workmanship and winters far colder than Toronto's.
The provincial government has sought to divert the blame, in part, to past administrations that either ignored infrastructure or laid off inspectors because of fiscal constraints.
Quebec also defended itself amid reports Tuesday that an engineering study three years ago accurately warned about the potential ceiling collapse above the Ville-Marie expressway.
A 2008 engineering report warned the tunnel's deteriorating condition was in a "critical" state and had become dangerous to users.
But Transport Minister Sam Hamad said the province had already conducted the necessary safety inspections and maintenance work recommended in that report. He suggested Sunday's incident, where a 25-ton chunk of concrete smashed onto the expressway, was unrelated.
Hamad said it was work at a nearby construction site, and not long-term damage, that may have destabilized the tunnel's ceiling.
Still, Hamad admitted more work is needed on the provincial road infrastructure.
"It's clear that over the last 20 years there was not enough investment," he told reporters Tuesday.
"Citizens are asking, 'What's going on with our infrastructure?' And they're right."
The concrete cave-in comes at a time when Montreal's aging, decaying road network has forced the closure of several sections of major overpasses and bridges.
The state of the city's road network — which has caused monstrous traffic jams for years and, now, safety concerns — has long been a local frustration.
The heightened tension was palpable at Hamad's news conference Tuesday when one of his staff members got into a shoving and shouting match with reporters during a testy question-and-answer session.
That came after a column in a prominent newspaper Tuesday that included a swear word in its headline, in reference to the transport minister.
Hamad says his department will be transparent and release all engineering reports on the tunnel to the public.
The mayor acknowledged the public frustration.
"When you look at citizens' comments, when you read the newspapers, citizens are feeling insecure — they're worried," Tremblay said.
"And when citizens are worried, that has consequences on economic prosperity."