Marriage And Children: Should You And Your Partner Have Kids, Or Will It Ruin Your Marriage?

Divorce

The Huffington Post Canada   Sarah Treleaven First Posted: 09/20/11 08:35 AM ET Updated: 10/05/11 06:12 AM ET

Kids aren't for everyone. And according to Ellen L. Walker, author of "Complete Without Kids: An Insider's Guide to Childfree Living by Choice or by Chance," life sans baby may be better for you than you think. We spoke to Walker for some insight on why.

What are some of the key reasons some couples choose not to have kids?

Walker: Many couples say they enjoy their time together so much they aren't willing to do anything that might jeopardize their relationship. They feel complete and don't see the need to have a child to round out their family unit.

Half of all marriages end in divorce, and growing apart due to not having time for one another is one contributor. Bring a child into the family and all kinds of changes occur -- a couple will have less time and energy for sex, less leisure time together, less discretionary income and more day-to-day responsibilities. These changes can all put stress on a relationship, even one that's solid.

Some couples who've had the opportunity to be around friends and relatives with children may recognize that, even if they like kids, the lifestyle and the sacrifices they'd have to make to be parents are not for them.

Why did you decide not to have kids?

I'm one of a majority of child-free women who woke up one day and realized I forgot to have kids.

I know this sounds absurd, but just as it's true that more than half the pregnancies in the U.S. are unplanned, it's equally true the majority of child-free adults didn't spend a lot of time contemplating whether or not to have a child. For me, it just didn't happen.

Often, by the time a couple gets around to talking about children, they either can't get pregnant or they decide they're too old or their lifestyle isn't conducive to child-rearing. I was very busy in my 20s and 30s going to school, travelling, participating in hobbies and volunteer work, and building a career. By the time I felt any significant "baby-lust" I was almost 45. It simply didn't make sense at that point to start a family.

What are some of the biggest misconceptions about couples who choose not to have kids?

One huge misconception is child-free couples are unable physically to have children (they're infertile) or they're in a perpetual state of grief. The reality is most child-free adults feel quite content with their lives -- they spend very little time thinking about how their life would be had they had a child.

A second common misconception is child-free couples don't like kids. Many couples and singles without them love to spend time with nieces and nephews or their friends' children. Others enjoy volunteering with kids in programs such as Big Brothers/Big Sisters.

In researching your book, did you come across any couples (or individuals) who regretted not having kids?

Don't we all have some decisions we regret? Some common ones include not finishing a college degree, passing up a job opportunity, ending a certain relationship and choosing one career over another. Not having a child is certainly a regret for some, but I've also been told by a number of parents that, if they could be go back and do it over again, they'd choose to not have children.

For the most part, the men and women I interviewed for my book had no regrets about not having had kids. Their lives were full with rich, satisfying activities and they made the choice to embrace, rather than regret, their child-free life.

What is the best thing about a child-free life?

Child-free adults truly value their freedom, independence and the ability to control their lives. It takes an estimated eight hours a day to parent a child -- adults without this responsibility have, in comparison, an abundance of time. I'm able to come home after a day at work and do what I please, including having dinner out, serving on a volunteer committee, going to bed early or spending the evening on the phone with a friend. I don't have to consider the needs of others in the way I would if I were a parent. This kind of life may sound selfish, but if we believe parenting is a choice, so is deciding not to be a parent.

WATCH:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA LIVING

Kids aren't for everyone. And according to Ellen L. Walker, author of "Complete Without Kids: An Insider's Guide to Childfree Living by Choice or by Chance," life sans baby may be better for you than ...
Kids aren't for everyone. And according to Ellen L. Walker, author of "Complete Without Kids: An Insider's Guide to Childfree Living by Choice or by Chance," life sans baby may be better for you than ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 154
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RhiannonRings
Childfree and loving it!
12:52 PM on 09/25/2011
Heck yes!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bruisersmom
03:59 PM on 09/23/2011
In Los Angeles, on meetup.com, there is a meet up group for people, single and married, who don't have children. Child free people in other areas should start them. It's nice to be around people who aren't asking you all of the time, "Why don't you have children? You would make a great mom!" Some people meet spouses at the group, other people meet friends.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RhiannonRings
Childfree and loving it!
12:52 PM on 09/25/2011
Is that the one that meets in Long Beach?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Melanie226
Former Riotgrrl & Current Jewish Suburb Mom
05:48 AM on 09/23/2011
I have 2 kids, and my husband and I rarely argue, but when we do, 90% of those arguments are about the kids. No regrets on my part, but I'm just saying.
sonoffestus
Got smart & got out!
01:32 PM on 09/22/2011
My wife of 29 years and I found that visiting friends with children was the best form of birth control. Now in our late 50s and childless, we are very happy to have had friends who had children.
07:16 PM on 09/21/2011
We childfree people get so very tired of the same tired sentiments we hear from *some* (not all) parents to try and convice us that our choice is wrong and to try and make us feel bad/guilty about our choice...

1. Who's going to take care of you in your old age?
2. You don't know real love until you've had a child.
3. You are not a "real" woman until you've had a child.
4. What if your parents had felt the same way as you? You wouldn't be here.
5. You were a child once...
6. Why bother getting married if you don't want children?
7. How could you not want a child?
8. You are selfish, immature, etc.if you don't want a child.

Etc, etc, ad nauseum...
03:45 AM on 09/22/2011
Then again, those who have children get tired of hearing these things:

1. Why bring a child into the world when it is so screwed up?
2. You're selfish because you wanted to have a child to boost your ego
3. Your children won't take care of you in your old age
4. You will have a lot more disposable income and you're free to buy all the things you want and travel the world
5. You can always have access to nieces, nephews, and the children of your friends if you want to spend time with children
6. You will be a lot more successful in your career if you don't have children
7. Your dogs can be your children
01:13 PM on 09/22/2011
Still, there are more of you breeders than there are us childfree by choice people, so trust me, we get it more than you, and usually only respond with your list when prompted by the first mentioned list of insults.
11:50 AM on 09/23/2011
I'm a parent and I've never heard those things.

If anything, I acknowledge that more often than not, it's the childless couples who have to endure a barrage of questions and judgments about their choices, not us. No one ever wonders what ever possessed a married couple to have children.
03:44 PM on 09/21/2011
Childfree author of Families of Two here..."should" you have kids does not seem to be the right question. Each person in the relationship has to answer for him/herself whether they Want to have the experience of childrearing, and if they have differing stands and marry anyway (thinking it will work itself out), that is when the probability of the marriage ending increases. Or if you don't really talk about it seriously before you marry. Having no kids is more likely to ruin a marriage when one wants them and the other does not. Being on the same page about kids is what is most important. The non-existence of kids in and of itself is not what will ruin a marriage; not being able to reconcile wanting different things in this regard is far more likely to be the reason. ~Laura http://laviechildfree.com
photo
blarneydude
I can handle the truth. Now let's talk about you.
03:05 PM on 09/21/2011
As someone who has three, I feel very qualified to chime in here.

1) YOU BOTH BETTER WANT THEM. Do NOT give in because [S]He's So Hawt. Kids will take care of that, big time. DO YOU WANT kids? This isn't a car or a boat or townhouse vs. McMansion. It is the rest of your life.

2) BE REALISTIC. There were things I did not want to lose as a result of having kids. I negotiated for those things. If you presume that having children means you have to stop being human - or if it's "unfair" to negotiate how your lives will be with children or "she'll break up with me" - you likely don't want them enough. And will likely regret it if you have them.

3) DON'T HAVE KIDS FOR WHAT THEY WILL DO FOR YOU. They may not do it. I knew I'd be OK having kids with my wife when she told me: I want the experience of raising kids. I watched my mom's experience, firsthand, and I know it was difficult. It'll be tough. But I want to do it.

4) YOU DON'T HAVE TO WANT THEM "EQUALLY." I don't think I have ever seen a couple that did. One thing we did was talk about that. See 2. above.

5) ONCE YOU HAVE THEM, IT WAS A JOINT DECISION. Not wanting them equally almost always happens. You can't bring it up as a weapon later. When you say OK, you want kids.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RhiannonRings
Childfree and loving it!
12:55 PM on 09/25/2011
Great advice, thank you.
05:53 AM on 09/21/2011
I believe people who are selfish should not have kids. i dont think everyone is cut out to be a parent.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Yam716
For CurlTalk, Visit: lillian-mae
12:02 PM on 09/21/2011
Agreed, but that would be asking society to make conscious decisions to have children, rather than to have accidents.
11:51 AM on 09/23/2011
I think this is unnecessarily judgmental. There are people who choose not to have kids because they do important development work in dangerous places around the world. They don't seem very selfish to me.
05:23 AM on 09/21/2011
I think it all depends on the circumstances. If you have children, you must be aware of the fact that you pretty much give up your life for them. I have 3. It puts a strain on your relationship with your partner, your finances and your time. It is not always a joy, but it is love like no other. I hope that the people who decide not to have kids at least volunteer to give of themselves in other ways. As for the people who don't have children for selfish, narcissistic reasons, they are very sad. They don't get love at all and need to get over themselves.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wskrs
If it pleases and sparkles... sunshine!
10:27 AM on 09/21/2011
I actually think having children is a very selfish thing (and sometimes there's nothing wrong with selfishness). Most people have children because they WANT them, and for no other reason. They want their own DNA furthered, they WANT something to love, they WANT somebody to love them. Many people that don't have children find love in other places - for instance, I have no kids nor do I want them, but I have 3 cats and a dog of my own, and I foster cats. If I had children, I wouldn't have the time or money to be able to help these animals. That being said though, why should someone who doesn't have kids automatically have to "volunteer" or be selfless. Having and caring for your children benefits nobody but you and your family and is a personal decision. How is having children equal to, let's say, volunteering at a homeless shelter? It's not. The only people you feed and clothe are your own kids. By having children, you add people to the earth and reduce resources for all, so I'm not sure I understand how having children is a selfless thing. Also, frankly, I think the viewpoint of "I'm having children so I'm giving to society" is pretty narcissistic, and shows you (not YOU, just "you" in a general sense) think pretty highly of yourself.
photo
blarneydude
I can handle the truth. Now let's talk about you.
03:09 PM on 09/21/2011
As someone who also has three:

If you decide not to have them, it is your decision. You are totally OK, and nobody gets to say anything bad about it. If you spend your days hiking, waterskiing, reading, drinking beer, watching baseball or jumping out of airplanes, and at the end of the day the last thing you think before bed is BOY I'M HAPPY! then you are.

And anybody who gainsays that happiness is just jealous. And should focus more on the "joy" of having kids.
01:16 PM on 09/22/2011
I do everything you listed!!! And boy I'm happy.
photo
Ms NYC
Republicans for Voldemort
02:09 PM on 09/22/2011
Thank you. When I decided to read the comments I was scared I was going to see the usual comments about how selfish those of us who are childless by choice are. It's very nice to know everybody doesn't think that way. If we all wanted the same things from life wouldn't it be boring? What's right for one isn't right for all.
Thanks again.
photo
liephman88
Drum roll please! And the truth is...........
05:22 AM on 09/21/2011
My wife and I decided when we got married some 23 years ago not to have kids and I in no means regret it. Nor does my wonderful wife, she and I stay busy all the time and if we had had children we couldn't have made the life for ourselves that we have today. It's like the Honeymoon never ends unlike many friend and family we know who in some cases had kids even before they got married. And if ever we need reminding why we didn't have them we just look across the fence at our younger neighbors who have kids and look ten hard years older than us. NO KIDDING!
12:25 AM on 09/22/2011
Then again, what caused your neighbors to look older could more likely be the result of other lifestyle choices such as smoking, drinking, too much tanning, or working at stressful jobs. Until recently I had a co-worker who had no children and he looked at least 20 years older than me even though he was about a year younger. He wasn't married either.
04:52 AM on 09/21/2011
I'm 36 and pregnant with my first (and mostly likely,only) child. I can't even tell you how many times,during this pregnancy,I have wondered if we're crazy for having a baby. I can read all I want on how my life will change,but I realize that I will never understand how much,until we get there. We're thrilled to be having a baby,we both adore children and are still madly in love with each other,with a strong marriage. I worry,at times,that having a baby could change things with our relationship ( actually,I know it will),and I hope that our relationship can withstand these changes. We love to travel and have so many dreams for ourselves,and they all include having a child to give him these experiences as well,but now that our son is on his way,I can't help but be a bit terrified at what's to come.The only thing that makes this whole thing feel less scary is when I think about how much I would regret not having a child. Still,I can understand why couples,or people in general,would chose to remain childless. It's a scary new world you enter when you bring another life into the world.
wetcoastm
Free Speech As Dictated By Our Sponsors
01:42 AM on 09/21/2011
I don't have a problem with someone who doesn't want kids - why would anyone? However this "researcher" comes across as rather biased in this interview. I don't get why should could not just say yes some people regret not having children rather than having to somehow qualify it as if she is trying to sell people on the idea of not having kids.

I would think that normal people would not care if their neighbor or sister decides to have children and plenty of people are not having kids so why sound so defensive.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wskrs
If it pleases and sparkles... sunshine!
10:33 AM on 09/21/2011
A lot of people have problems with people that don't have or want kids - that decision is constantly getting scrutinized, judged, and it's something people feel they can just chime in on. Our society has programmed into people that they should have kids, you should want kids, and if you don't, there's something wrong (especially for women), and the childless often get harsh judgment for not having/wanting them. Most people *don't* care if their neighbor or sister decides to have kids, but almost every time, I guarantee a childless person will get questioned about their decision to NOT have them. There are far more articles glorifying parenthood than articles frankly showing the other side.
photo
blarneydude
I can handle the truth. Now let's talk about you.
03:13 PM on 09/21/2011
There are so many articles glorifying parenthood because so many people with kids need constant reassurance that they did the right thing. People who didn't want them so they didn't have them wouldn't think about it at all if nobody else brought it upl.
01:28 AM on 09/21/2011
I think that in order to have children you have to have a large support network of extended friends and family. My husband and I have 2 grandmothers and a grand-pa, as well as aunts, friends and cousins who all pitch in and help babysit. We go out on as many dates as we did before and our sex life actually improved! But we know it's because we're so lucky to have so much help and especially FREE help. My brother plans on having no children, a decision I completely respect, since where he lives he has no close family nearby and while he likes kids, he's not crazy about rearing his own.I really feel for those families who have no one to rely on for assistance, and I think in those cases, kids can really put a strain on the relationship. I also think it's selfish to HAVE kids if you don't really want them. Even with all the help, it a big-time committment and if you are not whole-heartedly in love with the idea, you will regret it.
04:50 PM on 09/21/2011
If you have a network of extended family/friends who are willing to help, that's wonderful. But to have children with the expectation that these people are somehow obligated and WILL help is just plain wrong. Your kid=totally your responsibility.
07:38 PM on 09/21/2011
I think I mentioned that I knew I was lucky. But I knew my family when I had kids and while I certainly didn't (and don't) expect them to help, it was very clearly conveyed to me that I would get help BEFORE I had children and I do. I also understand that they won't be around forever. But in my family, we put each other first and we make sure that everyone is taking care of when they need it. Read what the experts say on grandparents and extended family and the importance of them in a child's life. I also know that when my relatives are old, I will be right there by their side to take care of them. They don't expect that either. But neither will it be a surprise to them when it happens. For many families, it simply is part of the culture. In my case, I am Hispanic and my husband is Jewish, and in our cultures, there is a strong tradition of making sure everyone in the family is supported and helped. I think you could say the same for many other cultures as well, such as the Chinese, Italian, Greek, Indian... I know that other parents aren't so lucky, but I know many families that are like mine, where the relatives give assistance in various ways to the family members that need help.My point is, with a support system in place, having children is a much less stressful experience.
01:20 AM on 09/21/2011
Not having sex is another good reason for not having kids.
02:20 PM on 09/21/2011
Not true.....my husband and I have two kids, 9 and 13 - they need our attention and our time 100% of the time, as it should be.

But, we still have very satisfying, fun and exciting sex almost daily.
photo
blarneydude
I can handle the truth. Now let's talk about you.
03:16 PM on 09/21/2011
If they need your attention and your time 100% of the time, and you're having sex "almost daily," isn't that neglect? Or are they joining in?

Sorry, I just couldn't resist that one.
01:14 AM on 09/21/2011
I never had the slightest desire to have kids. Nothing about being a parent ever appealed to me on any level, and especially not the sacrifices of time, money and freedom that having children entails.
I am now in my later 50s and have zero regrets about the choice I made. I'd make the same choice again.
02:41 AM on 09/21/2011
It's a good thing your parents never felt as you do. You wouldn't be alive, today.
03:32 AM on 09/21/2011
How could I possibly miss life if I had never existed?

Thankfully, my own mother was very supportive of my choice to be childfree. Thankfully she was honest enough with me to not sugarcoat parenthood like so many parents do, nor to have the attitude that I "owed" her grandchildren. She also said that if she'd had the choice to make again, she wouldn't have had children. I believe my father would have been a lot happier without children considering he had little patience or tolerance for them.

I will never understand why someone else's choice to be childfree is so offensive to some. It affects your life? How? Do you feel that it somehow invalidates your choice? Not everyone is cut out to be a parent, and people who don't want children shouldn't have them.
photo
blarneydude
I can handle the truth. Now let's talk about you.
02:25 PM on 09/21/2011
I know, it is a good thing.

And it has no bearing, absolutely none, on whether I decide I want them or not.
photo
UDKM2010
Life is better in Boardshorts.
11:58 AM on 09/21/2011
It would be great if more people were like you. Too many people having children without thinking. I've got one son and I'm good.
06:34 PM on 09/21/2011
There are too many people who have children by default--because the birth control failed (or wasn't used in the first place!), because of pressure by society, family, religion, etc., because it's the expected thing to do, in an attempt to hold onto a partner/save a failing relationship, and on and on. All the wrong reasons.

I truly believe that if more people thought it through, and considered what having a child really entails, there would be many fewer people having children.