Home Schools Outperform Public Schools In Study

School Kid

First Posted: 09/19/11 09:32 AM ET Updated: 11/19/11 05:12 AM ET

A small study out of Concordia and Mount Allison universities suggests children in structured home school programs do better academically than students in the public school system.


The study looked at the academic performance of 74 students, aged five to 10, in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia: half were home schooled and half went to public schools.


It showed home school children in a structured program scored half a grade higher in math and about two grades higher in reading.


"The parents know their children very well," said study co-author Sandra Martin-Chang.


"They have a very accurate sense of how their children were doing at home."


The public school students tested did not do poorly, performing at or above grade level, but the home-schooled students did that much better.


The study included a set of children educated in an unstructured home environment. These children showed the worst academic progress of the three groups.


Pleased with home school decision


Hilary Sowa of P.E.I. has been schooling her children at home for three years. The Sowa family wasn't happy with their local public school. Aiden, now 12, wanted to learn more, faster.


"I thought that we were moving a little bit too slow in math," he said.


"In spelling, the words weren't getting much harder."


Grace, now eight, said her experience supports the study findings. She's advanced beyond the grade she would be in if she was in public school.


"One of them I actually think is fifth grade," said Grace of the subjects she is studying.


"Most of them are fourth grade. I don't think anything I have anything third grade."


The study was published in the Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science.


FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

A small study out of Concordia and Mount Allison universities suggests children in structured home school programs do better academically than students in the public school system. ...
A small study out of Concordia and Mount Allison universities suggests children in structured home school programs do better academically than students in the public school system. ...
Filed by Ron Nurwisah  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:29 AM on 09/20/2011
The good home school programs are really just Mini schools set up by the home schoolers they just band together......
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JJJSchmidt
12:15 AM on 09/20/2011
Home schooling is nothing more than the attempt by some parents to isolate their children from socializing with children of different religious background and to further indoctrinate their children with an overdose of mommy and daddy's religion. The idea that these home schooled children could actually learn something that is even remotely close that of children their own age in the public school system is frankly quite shocking. Something tells me that evolution and Darwin would not be part of the home schooling experience.

My former neighbour's children were home schooled by their mother for religious reasons. It seemed that between doing laundry, getting groceries and making meals that their three kids, of various ages, experienced 7 periods of recess to perhaps 1 period of learning. It would be amazing that their children might learn something that might prepare them for high school or post secondary considering their mother only had a high school education.
10:14 PM on 09/19/2011
The sample was not large enough to provide a factual basis for the title of the piece.

Now if they measured how many kids were also fed a 100% organic diet together with their home schooling we could really see if children of the granola set are besting normally socialized kids who went through public school.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:41 PM on 09/19/2011
That isn't surprising. Most people home school their children because they think they can do a better job then the public school system. They could be working full time, but they choose to dedicate themselves to their children's education, and really make an effort to teach their children in a style that is best suited to the children. Not every parent can or is capable of home schooling, and not every child is best suited to be home schooled. It takes a lot of planning, and a lot of trial and error, but it can produce amazing results, it can also produce a child who lags behind because the parents best intentions didn't materialize as planned.
photo
gwinegarden
She's an Arctic Wolf
02:57 PM on 09/19/2011
What a poor excuse for a study.

"The study included a set of children educated in an unstructured home environment. These children showed the worst academic progress of the three groups. "

So, what constitutes a "structured home environment."? What percentage of home-schooled fall into this category as opposed to the unstructured?
01:21 PM on 09/19/2011
Poorly worded article.

It says those kids in a "structured home school program" do better, but what percentage of all home schooled kids are in such structured programs vs the unstructured programs.

This article clearly states that children in an unstructured home environment performed the worst. So what percentage of children are in such environments?

Plus, the sample size is a joke. Someone should talk to these people about statistics.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
freddychef
Tue,4 Nov '14 Dems take House! & Majority Senate!!
12:36 PM on 09/19/2011
"structured home school programs", is a double negative.
02:03 AM on 09/24/2011
I think you mean oxymoron... either that or you are a product of the public school system :). Just saying.