Thomas Mulcair: NDP Leadership Bid Could Be Stalled By Lack Of Quebec Party Votes

Thomas Mulcair Ndp Leadership Topp Party President

First Posted: 09/19/2011 5:22 am Updated: 11/19/2011 4:12 am

UPDATE: Speaking to reporters Monday morning, NDP House leader Thomas Mulcair repeated what he told Huffington Post Canada about the institutional disadvantage he faces in Quebec, but added that he would like the party to help fix the unbalance.

"We are disadvantaged, it's not a complaint, it is a simple observation," the NDP leadership hopeful said.

"The party should look at the possibility of having a membership drive in Quebec in a non-partisan way and not sectoral way. This wouldn't be about one candidate over another but it would compensate the mathematical fact that Quebec is the only province that does not have provincial wing of the NDP. And perhaps it would be a question of putting some resources aside so that the party could seek out memberships," Mulcair said.


Quebec NDP MP Thomas Mulcair is trying to decide whether he can overcome a large institutional disadvantage and mount a successful leadership campaign, he confirmed to The Huffington Post.

Mulcair, an MP for the Montreal-area riding Outremont since 2007, said he spent the past weekend speaking with “well-known and strong supporters” from across the country, from British Columbia to Newfoundland, who offered their support and encouraged him to run.

But despite having the support of the “vast majority” of the NDP’s 59-member Quebec caucus, Mulcair said he is still consulting and gauging support from different regions.

“It’s not something that you can jump at without serious consideration,” he told The HuffPost about joining the race.

“One thing that is often overlooked in the rest of Canada is the fact that Quebec is the only province that doesn’t have a provincial NDP. The concrete result of that, is that in a place like British Columbia where there was a leadership race recently and where tens of thousands of membership cards in the provincial NDP were sold, those provincial memberships become an eligible vote in the federal race.”

Mulcair also note that the large numbers of provincial elections this fall will also swell membership numbers as the NDP holds nomination battles in ridings across the country.

These factors pose an uphill challenge for Mulcair, who was the NDP's lone MP in Quebec until the party's electoral breakthrough in May. While some of his colleagues may enjoy name recognition in their own NDP membership-rich provinces or have strong links to party officials in different regions where the NDP has enjoyed strong labour support and political success, Mulcair has a much lower profile in the rest of the country and enjoys no such benefit.

“We have no such institutional advantage in Quebec, there is no provincial NDP here in the province. There is a federalist tent and a sovereigntist tent that accommodates both left and right with interesting results but it is a very different set-up. So the simple fact of the matter is that of the 80,000 or 90,000 existing (NDP membership) cards… less than 2,000 (come) from Quebec,” Mulcair said.

“In other words, 1,600 or so, and that’s less than two per cent so that is something that also has to be considered,” he added.
Still, the NDP MP suggested he wants to step in the race. He’s just not sure the numbers are there.

"It is something that I’m going to do in the best interest for the party and what I think the party can do for all of Canada," he said.

The NDP's historical gains in Quebec — which saw the collapse of the Bloc Quebecois and propelled the party to the status of official opposition —were the result of five years of relentless work pounding the pavement, Mulcair said.

"Jack (Layton) and I worked shoulder to shoulder non-stop for years to achieve that result in Quebec and I would love to bring that sort of energy and drive across Canada, campaign, and produce the first NDP government in Canada. And that is exactly, if I do decide to take a run at the leadership, it will be for one purpose and one purpose only, to form an NDP government.”

Mulcair said he plans to make a decision in the coming weeks about whether he’ll jump in the race — after more cross-Canada consultations and a frank discussion with his wife of more than 35 years, Catherine, and his two adult sons.

“I’m very honoured by the level of support and encouragement that I have received from across Canada and it is all going to be part of the consideration as I come to a decision,” he said.

In the meantime, the former lawyer and civil servant is questioning whether the party’s current leadership front-runner, Brian Topp, should be allowed to remain party president while he organizes his leadership bid.

NDP interim leader Nycole Turmel told her caucus last week that leadership hopefuls would have to resign from their critic duties and relinquish the public spotlight that comes with top parliamentary positions last week.

For Mulcair, that means he’d have to give up his role as NDP house leader. Topp, however, can remain NDP president, one party official told The Huffington Post, because there are no rules against it.

Mulcair said the leadership race will pose challenges but the parliamentary caucus planned to work as a team and be respectful of one another as the contest unfolds — characteristics drilled in them by the late leader Jack Layton.

Still, the NDP MP suggested, the rules should be fair across the board.

“Right now, Brian Topp is still the president of the party even though he said he wants to take a run at the leadership,” Mulcair said. “He will also have to take a close hard look at whether it is his personal interest or the party interest that are going to be at the table at any given time. And he’s going to have to look at that carefully, as we all will.”

“It will be important that the party avoid any appearance of possible conflict and I’m sure that is something that is in Mr. Topp’s thinking right now,” Mulcair added.

Topp’s spokesman Jim Rutkowski told the Huffington Post Sunday that Topp would resign as early as this week.

“He does intend to that (resign from the NDP presidency) when he files his papers in the coming days,” Rutkowki said.

Topp and another Quebec NDP Romeo Saganash, who was elected in the riding of Abitibi-Baie-James-Nunavik-Eeyou on May 2, are the only two officially declared candidates to replace Layton, who died Aug. 22 from cancer.

NDP members will elect their new leader on March 24, 2012, at a convention in Toronto.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

UPDATE: Speaking to reporters Monday morning, NDP House leader Thomas Mulcair repeated what he told Huffington Post Canada about the institutional disadvantage he faces in Quebec, but added that he wo...
UPDATE: Speaking to reporters Monday morning, NDP House leader Thomas Mulcair repeated what he told Huffington Post Canada about the institutional disadvantage he faces in Quebec, but added that he wo...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:55 PM on 09/19/2011
Both Mulcair and Topp need to go on record whether they support the Sherbrooke Accord:
http://m.facebook.com/NDPSherbrookeDeclaration?_rdr
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ethrop
micro-bio-tic
10:11 PM on 09/19/2011
I was a bit surprised that Mulcair is completely unknown outside Quebec. He does have a pretty large profile in Quebec and turned out to be the first (and only) NDPer elected with Jack Layton before the last election. Right now the strength of the NDP rests in Quebec, at least in terms of representation in the House of commons. Whether it stays remains to be seen but electing Mulcair as leader would certainly contribute to give the NDP some staying power in Quebec.
07:58 PM on 09/19/2011
Personally I think he could beat up everyone except maybe Baird in the HOC.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
04:24 PM on 09/19/2011
ha ha hhhh aaah ahhhahah ahhhah aa

'NDP' hha hha haaha

You get what you vote for ... !
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jon Jony
02:56 PM on 09/19/2011
The problem with Muclair is that he is seen as politically ruthless and manipulative by many. In addition, his views on minority rights in Quebec are not seen as sympathetic. And many NDPers outside the province are turned off by the more nationalistic tone of some MP's from Quebec.

Overall, Topp being from the province and being fluently bilingual would probably be much more accomodating for the majority of NDPers (and probably the majority of Canadians in general).
11:35 AM on 09/19/2011
The NDP must deal with a new but fundamental discrepancy: its elected members are not representative of its historic party membership.

Topp's star could dim quickly in Québec when people will be reminded that his mentor Broadbent was a fervent promoter of Trudeau's 1982 repatriation of the constitution.
As well, that he worked for Romanow, a person quebecers associate as one of the plotters in the 1981 "the night of the long knives" episode of these negocations, who actively worked to isolate Québec from the other provinces in the these negociations.

Hard choices to come for the NDP in harmonizing voter priorities to historic member priorities.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jon Jony
02:58 PM on 09/19/2011
Nah... they would be accepting of him... Besides Trudeau was right. Levesque basically made a scene to make Trudeau look bad (and he succeeded in doing so).
05:51 PM on 09/19/2011
Your preference for Topp is one thing,,,underestimating his opponent is another.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
piceaglauca
The picture says it all....
11:11 AM on 09/19/2011
It's easy to criticize other people from afar but to take personal criticism yourself is another matter. Personally, I feel that is a double standard. If this off the cuff comment seems blind then you aren't the problem.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
piceaglauca
The picture says it all....
11:09 AM on 09/19/2011
No one would have anticipated the election reults and the NDP prior to the Federal Election. The demise of the Bloc and unraveling of the Parti Quebecquois indicates the potential for a strengthening of the NDP party in Quebec. As it stands now you have a group of NDP MP's with no consolidation. The time is ripe for Quebec unification politically but that window will close soon with every passing day. The time is now Mulcair.
08:40 AM on 09/19/2011
A national party leader from Québec is so passé.
11:26 AM on 09/19/2011
It will likely continue to happen from time to time. We are still about 1/4 of the population of the entire country. Only Ontario has a larger population.
08:36 AM on 09/19/2011
Canadian consumers running out of credit ... http://canuckreport.ca
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
06:31 AM on 09/19/2011
What is most important for the NDP to consider is to nominate the most qualified and experianced leader they can put forward.If they elect a weakling like Dion or an elitist like Ignatieff they will get hammered by the finely tuned conserative machine that Harper and company have nurtured through all those years of minority governance.Agree or disagree with their politics, you have to respect what they have accomplished.Failing to do that will cost the NDP dearly.Mulclair, in my opinion, would be an excellant leader. He's got all the bonafide's required.Hopefuly the NDP faithfull will recognize his ability and credentials and put him in charge of keeping Harpers feet to the fire. I think Canadians are past the 'blind faith' of partisan politics.
photo
butchcliff
The future is unwritten
07:38 AM on 09/19/2011
Respectfully, you should get yourself a spell check. Pretty hard to read your comment seriously with so many errors.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
09:27 AM on 09/19/2011
wouldn't want you to strain yourself.lol
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ethrop
micro-bio-tic
10:08 PM on 09/19/2011
Actually, butch, I can only find two or three spelling mistakes in Warren's post. The lack of spaces after the periods is what throws you off... As these things go, Warren's post is actually exemplary.