Sharon Carstairs Surprises Colleagues And Retires From Senate With Speech On Perils Of Tory Reform Plans

The Huffington Post Canada   First Posted: 10/07/11 09:15 AM ET Updated: 10/07/11 09:35 AM ET

Sharon Carstairs
In a speech intended to be a reply to the Conservatives' legislative agenda, the Speech from the Throne, Sen. Sharon Carstairs, the former leader of the Liberal Party in Manitoba and a past Leader of the Liberals in the Senate, shocked everyone by announcing she intends to retire in less than two weeks just before the Senate returns to work.

Attention defeated Tory candidates in Manitoba: Are you interested in a Senate seat?

Prime Minister Stephen Harper now has five Senate seats to fill after a long-time Liberal Senator surprised colleagues, and her own party, Thursday by announcing she's retiring.

In a speech intended to be a reply to the Conservatives' legislative agenda, the Speech from the Throne, Sen. Sharon Carstairs, the former leader of the Liberal Party in Manitoba and a past Leader of the Liberals in the Senate, shocked everyone by announcing she intends to retire in less than two weeks just before the Senate returns to work.

"When I leave this place today, colleagues, it will be to mail a letter to the Governor General indicating my decision to retire from the Senate, effective at 11:59, Monday, October 17," Carstairs told the upper chamber Thursday afternoon.

"This means that this will be my last day in this chamber and my last speech. I have never particularly liked our system of tributes, so I have chosen this way, and I ask for you to respect that. Do not do tributes now or at any time in the future."

In her twenty-minute speech, Carstairs, a senator with a strong personality who has often butted heads with fellow Liberals and those across the aisle, urged her colleagues to look seriously at Senate reform but cautioned the Conservatives plans are ill thought-out.

"It is inappropriate in today's day and age that we should sit in the Senate for potentially up to 35 years or more," she told the chamber. "I urge us to look seriously at term limits. I could, as you know, remain until 2017. I have chosen not to do that."

"At the same time, I urge us to proceed with caution. I would be remiss not to speak in my closing remarks about how important this institution has been to me for the last 17 years and why I urge caution about any changes we make to it."

Carstairs talked about the changes she witnessed since first taking notice of the Senate in 1959, when her father Harold Connolly was sitting in the upper chamber.

Security, she suggested, had changed dramatically. "No one even intervened when I took my father's car and managed to drive it between two black Cadillacs and smashed into both of them," she told the upper house.

But the Manitoba senator mostly talked about her work on palliative care and the numerous reports the Senate had done on the issue of aging.

"No member of Parliament has the time to do this kind of work, and therefore we must be cautious to not turn this place into a mirror image of the place down the way," she said.

"Honourable senators, we do good work, but it is frequently not the same kind of work that they do in the other place. I urge caution. I believe there will be unintended consequences of the changes this government proposes, and I believe they will not be in the best interests of our great country. To have two chambers with identical mandates chosen in identical ways would be unworthy of our nation.

Honourable senators, I bid you farewell. Keep healthy and happy and continue to put your country ahead of politics. You make this place a special place and a country to be admired around the world."

There are currently four vacancies in the Senate: one in Newfoundland and Labrador, one in Quebec and two in Ontario.

There are none in New Brunswick, where Premier David Alward recently announced he plans to introduce legislation that would establish province-wide Senate elections.

Harper's associate director of communications Andrew MacDougall told HuffPost last month the prime minister plans to fill the seats.

"(There is) nothing to announce now. Appointments will be made in due course," he said in an email.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

Attention defeated Tory candidates in Manitoba: Are you interested in a Senate seat? Prime Minister Stephen Harper now has five Senate seats to fill after a long-time Liberal Senator surprised coll...
Attention defeated Tory candidates in Manitoba: Are you interested in a Senate seat? Prime Minister Stephen Harper now has five Senate seats to fill after a long-time Liberal Senator surprised coll...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 39
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
MyTake
Release the Hydrogen Economy now!
12:18 PM on 10/10/2011
I say, make a couple of changes.

Empower the Voter with a "None of the Above" option on all political voting ballots.

Provide the Voter with Fixed Election Dates to prohibit the abuse of the party in power to call an election.

Provide the Voter with a Right To Recall a politician who fails to administer to his/her campaign promises.

Once these are in place, then abolish The Senate and replace it a small and powerful Canadian Political Ombudsman's office which has the power to subpoena government officials and government records.

Oh, I almost forgot, they can abolish that insufferable Government Question Period and replace it with a DEBATE period in which SHOUTING AND GESTERING are not permitted!
photo
Add In Canadia
Egotism is a weakness
04:15 PM on 10/08/2011
Either make the Senate reflect proportional representation or abolish it. The Governor General is an appointed level of our government, but we offer that position no real powers; so why should an appointed Senate have power? Any appointed position is questionable at best (especially the more power they have), and typically does not reflect what the majority of people want.

Term limits wouldn't change much, it just means a quicker cycling of loyalists that were put into the system.
07:47 PM on 10/08/2011
Rep by Pop is a ridiculous idea in a nation as large and sparsely populated as ours. If you are looking to drive separatist movements.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
06:24 PM on 10/07/2011
I would guess she's stepping out with a full pension.
photo
Cameron Hodge
"Liberal Elitist" ;)
04:47 PM on 10/07/2011
The senate doesn't need reform, the senate needs to die. It serves no purpose but to add an extra layer of politicians to be pandered to and bought out.

Sadly the lure of being able to stack it with sypathetic political hacks and friends is just too much of a lure to power hungry politicians. A fact Stephen Harper has rammed home in his time as PM.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LeftyNeoCon
What happens when extreme left and right combine.
10:02 PM on 10/09/2011
FnF
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Vere15
Vero nihil verious (nothing truer than truth)
02:16 PM on 10/07/2011
A bit of reflux from the Manitoba election perhaps
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Maria Korovessis Sewell
To decimate is to reduce by one tenth.
12:54 PM on 10/07/2011
Abolish the senate. We don't need the Appointed "soberly" scrutinizing the work of the Elected.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Firestarterfive
Canada Calling....
12:33 PM on 10/07/2011
"...put your country ahead of politics..."

Nice.
11:23 AM on 10/07/2011
Good riddance !! What has she accomplished in her political life ? Nothing except annoy us with her high pitch nasal twang !!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sandra MacKay
11:34 AM on 10/07/2011
Shut up neocon!
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
11:35 AM on 10/07/2011
Such a brilliant and cleverly articulated analysis.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
04:22 PM on 10/08/2011
Thanks. I knew you would appreciate it ! I like a good compliment once in a while . Thank you, thank you !!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Capital Ottawa
11:16 AM on 10/07/2011
"I believe there will be unintended consequences of the changes this government proposes, and I believe they will not be in the best interests of our great country. To have two chambers with identical mandates chosen in identical ways would be unworthy of our nation."

Harper stacked the Senate in order to ram through bills like C-10, which has not been properly priced out. A bill which flies in the face of all substantiated facts (vs "unreported crime"). The role of the Senate is to carefully review changes to legislation in the best interest of Canadians not to simple do Harper's bidding.

The Senate should be appointed based on proportional representation to ensure that the house of Commons work cooperatively with the Senate in the best interest of all Canadians. Sharon Carstairs is retiring because her role as a Senator is undermined by the Conservative government.
09:30 AM on 10/08/2011
Senate based on proportional representation. YES. Give smaller parties, and therefore all Canadians, a voice and keep 40% 'majority governments' in check.
10:53 AM on 10/07/2011
The Senate must be reformed. The job the Senate used to do is now being done in the Commons. The job the Commons used to do is now being done by no one.

We don't need a new Senate. We could entirely do with out it.

We need a new Commons - the Senate has nothing to do because the interests it used to represent are all being represented by the Commons and no one is now representing the constituents properly.

Lobby groups are taking the other half the load the Senate used to have, and they are doing so in an utterly abhorrent manner.

While our system is certainly screwed up, we could be worse off. We could have the EU appointees at the top level of governance. Apparently Europe has decided to recreate the Roman Senate and span it across the entire union, pederasts and all. I guess sleeping old men with nothing to do is better than that.
photo
CarlyQ
Without followers, evil cannot spread.
10:29 AM on 10/07/2011
Conservatives don't argue that Harper (or any other conservative leader in the past) is trying to mold Canada to be exactly like the USA. This seems to be a given.

The question is, with the USA being brought to it's knees on the world stage largely due to conservative policies, WHY would anybody want to do this to Canada?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gx5000
Life's too short, be happy..
11:03 AM on 10/07/2011
Why do they hate Canada ?

(let's see, less nuts, nicer people, better beer, oh ok...)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Capital Ottawa
11:09 AM on 10/07/2011
Corporate profits.
photo
CarlyQ
Without followers, evil cannot spread.
11:28 AM on 10/07/2011
Yes, I believe that's the right answer, sadly.
09:58 AM on 10/07/2011
It is really not complicated.

Harper does not simply want to rule Canada;
Harper wants to transform it into a mirror image of the American model.
He is also shooting for the Holy Grail - a permanent Tory majority.

Governing is much more profitable that way.
For the politicians.

Stop Harper.
Stop the Neo-conservative movement at our border.
BritishColumbian
American/Canadian liberal
11:52 AM on 10/07/2011
There is no way Harper can model the Canadian gov't after the American model without rewriting the constitution.

I agree his major goal is to create the fundamentals that will support a Tory dynasty but he will do it through the parliamentary system and though the road map of the Reform Party.
12:20 PM on 10/07/2011
Canada is finished. Harper will remake it to whatever he wants it to be, and NO ONE will stop him.
04:19 PM on 10/08/2011
Hail Steven !! Do your stuff !! That's we elected your for !!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
piceaglauca
The picture says it all....
09:52 AM on 10/07/2011
The Senate is an ineffective old boys club. The money could be better spent. I can't imagine how anyone would want to do this for 35 years unless it was to closet them. Good for you Ms Carstairs for leaving. Any chance you will be looking for Dr. Gerrard's job? Just a thought.
BritishColumbian
American/Canadian liberal
11:46 AM on 10/07/2011
Salary, benefits and pensions.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
piceaglauca
The picture says it all....
09:38 AM on 10/07/2011
Always a stink bomb before they leave. Work within, thank without.