Chinese Toddler Video Showing Child Run Over Twice, Ignored Sparks International Outrage

Chinese Toddler Hit By Van

First Posted: 10/17/11 06:48 PM ET Updated: 12/17/11 05:12 AM ET

UPDATE: News site Storyful rounds up more coverage from China on the horrific incident. The story has been front-page news and sparked huge online discussion.

The post includes more details on Wang Yue's recovery in the hospital. Warning some of the images are graphic.

A horrific video showing a toddler struck twice by two vehicles and left bleeding on a narrow market road in southern China while a dozen bystanders do nothing to help is sparking outrage around the world.

The incident, which occurred last Thursday in the city of Foshan in Guangdong province, was captured by a surveillance camera and aired by a local TV station.

It showed a two-year-old girl being knocked down and then run over by the wheels of a white van that paused briefly before speeding away, leaving the girl bleeding on the sidewalk.

Over the next several minutes, more than a dozen people can be seen walking by the injured girl, not one of them trying to help. In at least one case, a passerby steps over the girl's motionless body. In another, a motorcycle slows, then veers around the girl before continuing on its way.

The girl was struck a second time by another vehicle before a woman is seen pulling the girl off the street, leaving behind a pool of blood. Local media reports identify the woman as a trash collector who ran off to alert the girl's mother.

The video, posted on YouTube, was making headlines around the world Monday — including in China, where many viewers and readers weighed in online to question the morality of society.

China's Twitter-like service, Sina Weibo, has drawn 4.4 million comments and organized them under the heading "Please end the cold-heartedness."

The Chinese news agency Xinhua said the two-year-old girl, identified as Wang Yue, remains in hospital in a deep coma.

State media on Tuesday quoted the Guangzhou Military District General Hospital as saying that the child is unlikely to recover.

Chinese police said the drivers of both vehicles have been arrested.

Warning: Disturbing Video

Description of the video

The video clip showing the toddler being hit, ignored, then dragged away by the woman. Later in the clip, it features interviews with the elderly woman in Cantonese. Here’s a translation of what the woman said.

While cameras looked on, she tried to comfort a grieving family member, saying she was trying to call for help from many people
Later on, in interviews, she described how she dragged the girl to side, then how she went out looking for help.

The reporter at the 2:20 mark asked “at that point, were you looking for people to help?”

The woman said she asked people all around, but no one acknowledged my pleas.

Then the reporter asked at the 2:30 mark: When you took her aside, was she conscious?

The woman said, “Yes, she was awake. One eye was closed, one eye was open,” then added that the girl was really heavy, and she didn’t have the strength to carry her, leaving her to look for help.

“Why didn’t so many people walking help?” she asked reporters at the three-minute mark, saying she walked all over the place, including the nearby stairs. She said she was asking passersby “why aren’t you helping?”

The reporter asked at the end, “Were you scared about the inconvenience of helping out?”

The women replied: “I wasn’t thinking about that. I wasn’t thinking about whether I should bother.”

Translation by The Huffington Post Canada

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

UPDATE: News site Storyful rounds up more coverage from China on the horrific incident. The story has been front-page news and sparked huge online discussion. The post includes more details on Wang...
UPDATE: News site Storyful rounds up more coverage from China on the horrific incident. The story has been front-page news and sparked huge online discussion. The post includes more details on Wang...
Filed by Christian Cotroneo  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 168
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
12:18 PM on 10/20/2011
I couldn't watch this video all the way through, it made me so outraged over these useless scum of the earth, so called humans.I'd like to see every one of them run over by a 18 wheeler. I am so heart broken over this little innocent girl. I pray she survives.
photo
PleaseNoPolitics
Ignorance is bliss... Reality TV anyone?
04:06 PM on 10/19/2011
Took me 2 days to build up the courage to watch the video.

First time I've ever had tears run down my face while sitting in front of a computer.
11:15 AM on 10/19/2011
I always suspected China was hell. Now I know for sure.
03:59 PM on 10/21/2011
Is it much different in North America?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Juanne Michaud
Proud Canadian, loony lefty
11:13 PM on 10/18/2011
Does anyone remember the Kitty Genovese case in New York? She was stabbed to death in her apartment's courtyard while a number of her neighbours watched from their balconies and windows. No one helped, and worse, no one even bothered to call the police. Harlan Ellison wrote a short story based on this incident, "The Whimper of Whipped Dogs".

(In contrast, last summer in Toronto, some idiot left his dog in his car and the poor animal nearly died. People called for help, and when the dog was being taken away for treatment, the idiot in question tried to stop them. The civilian rescuers proceeded to beat the turkey out of him. Yay! If a poor dog can (and should) be defended, then a baby even more so.)

That being said, I haven't watched the video because I think my head would explode from rage and my heart would rupture because of sorrow.

I hope that the people who walked by can be identified via the video, arrested and charged with whatever works.

What also breaks my heart is the thought of that poor baby, lying on the road, frightened, in pain and not receiving even the most minimal of human contact or comfort.
03:27 AM on 10/22/2011
Almost everything we think we know about the Kitty Genovese case turns out to be untrue.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Juanne Michaud
Proud Canadian, loony lefty
01:32 AM on 10/24/2011
You are right; I stand corrected.

I went to Wikipedia (my first stop when researching but generally not my last when I'm doing serious research) and it's an interesting read. Not as dramatic as Ellison and the New York Times' version, but still interesting.

When I'm wrong, I admit it!

However, I think we can both agree that those 18 arse****s who walked by that child definitely did not stop and help.

Heard on the news that the 2 drivers have been charged. I'm waiting to hear that the Evil Eighteen have been likewise.
10:36 PM on 10/18/2011
Sick, sick people, where human life has been devalued to the point where it's not worth the time it takes to help.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GiaMTL
10:24 PM on 10/18/2011
Who took the video and why arent they in prison?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Juanne Michaud
Proud Canadian, loony lefty
10:58 PM on 10/18/2011
In the article, it states that the video comes from a traffic camera.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GiaMTL
11:23 PM on 10/18/2011
Oh, I missed that. Thank you for clarifying. I was afraid it was a monster behind a phone taping the whole thing...A horrific tragedy, so difficult to understand.
10:13 PM on 10/18/2011
A number of years ago in Calgary, a number of Asian children were left in a common arena in a building on the Stampede grounds while their parents gambled in the casino. Is this a cultural thing.
Bianca S
You can't go trick-or-treating. Ever. For a week
05:16 PM on 10/19/2011
You're asking if child neglect is a "cultural thing"-the culture in this case being Asian? Because white, black and spanish people NEVER leave their children unattended.
09:13 PM on 10/18/2011
if you have any doubt of the dark human hart. watch the video.
otherwise, nothing good can come of it.
photo
novabird
Lover of Life, Radical Centrist
05:40 PM on 10/18/2011
Those who have a reverence for life and the ability to show compassion are often the same people who hold spiritual beliefs (whatever those may be).

People who see themselves as primarily animals (and I have read that opinion often here on Huffpo) sometimes find it very easy indeed to justify the ending of another life. (I read these types of arguments often here: example: re: abortion - its just a clump of cells - re: euthenasia - well, Granny was old and useless. re: war - we need to kill those people... etc.)

We are being called to choose reverence and compassion for humanity over a culture of death. It appears that China has chosen a culture of death. What will we choose?
04:59 PM on 10/18/2011
Where was the mother? How did she let a two year old walk around in the street unsupervised? The first driver has most of the blame because he should have stopped before (He saw her) he hit the girl and after he hit her he should have stopped. The second driver should have also stopped but he probably didn't see her but once he drove over her he should have stopped. The people who stood by and did nothing should be ashamed of themselves. I have a little girl and this video is hard to watch
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:50 PM on 10/18/2011
I can't believe people are leaving comments regarding the actions or non-actions of others because of the political or religious system they're in. Truly disgusting. If you can't leave a sympathetic comment or even a prayer for the child and her family, perhaps you should say nothing at all. My sympathies to the mother and family and I hope the baby recovers fully.
02:24 AM on 10/19/2011
It's legitimate to ask why this injured, bleeding toddler wasn't helped.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:01 PM on 10/19/2011
I agree. It is a legitimate question to ask why she wasn't helped, but from some of the comments I was reading people were blaming it on the fact that these people aren't Christian or because they live in a communist/ socialist country. I've watched many horrific videos of people dying from knife wounds, gun shots, hit and runs, accidents of all sorts. Many of the videos are from North America and Europe where it appears people just freeze up or just don't know what to do, perhaps they are in shock, but to say it's because they don't believe in a particular god or political system is just moronic.
04:28 PM on 10/18/2011
I can't watch this video,but I think we are generally on a slippery slope as a humans.Once you remove absolutes,these types of things will happen.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Suemoni
Trying To "Write" All The Wrongs Of The World.
04:05 PM on 10/18/2011
I agree that this video is horrible to view. I truly respect and understand why some people refuse to view it, but I still believe it needed to be posted. It was a horrible thing that happened to a toddler. It really doesn't matter in which Country, State, Region it happened. The true hard to face fact is a toddler was struck then run over. Crushed by the wheels of a van and a car and left to die because No One stopped to help her.18-20 people passed right by her until this one lady took charge and dragged the baby out of the street and pulled her to safety. As I see it all around the world Humanity, Compassion, Respect for human LIFE is slowly becoming obsolete.. That's my personal oppinion.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GiaMTL
10:25 PM on 10/18/2011
Why not write the story (for awareness purposes) without the video?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Suemoni
Trying To "Write" All The Wrongs Of The World.
08:20 AM on 10/19/2011
You know I agree with you. But I also believe we all have a choice "To Click or Not To Click." (smile) I had the choice to read the article and not click on to the video or I could have clicked on to the video and choose not to read the article. I did both I read and I clicked and watched that horrible video and I blame no one for my choices. Some people take in the news by watching and some people take in the news by reading. I guess when it balls down we all have the right to choose what we feel is best for ourselves.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mnjmike5
03:56 PM on 10/18/2011
I agree with some people on here saying it's no worse than the way Americans leave their kids in a hot car to burn a slow death. At least in China they do it quick.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
HorsemanM1
03:55 PM on 10/18/2011
I am Sorry I watched this

Please dont watch it

I apologize for my posts

I want to make someone pay. This does not happen where I move about and spend my time

I am justice. I wish i had it withen my means to meet those people
photo
novabird
Lover of Life, Radical Centrist
05:30 PM on 10/18/2011
thank you friend, I will not watch it. I do not need those images imprinted in my consciousness.