Wang Yue, Chinese Toddler Grieved By Chinese-Canadians Who Also Question Western Media Coverage

First Posted: 10/18/11 07:06 PM ET Updated: 12/18/11 05:12 AM ET

Chinese Toddler

TORONTO - The tragic story of a Chinese toddler struck by two vehicles while more than a dozen bystanders stood idly by has stirred up a hive of mixed emotions for Canada's Chinese community.

As English-language media detailed the video capturing the moments when two-year-old Wang Yue of Foshan was run over by two separate cars and ignored by the 18 people who left her lying in the road, the Chinese-Canadian community struggled to reconcile their anxiety over moral norms in their homeland with disgust at the way the incident was depicted in the international press.

Shock and dismay over the plight of the girl _ who Chinese doctors say will likely remain in a vegetative state if she ever recovers _ was tinged with chagrin that long-standing biases against Chinese culture have re-emerged in the Western media.

Ray Chan, Toronto editor at Chinese-language newspaper Sing Tao Daily, said the story warrants only moderate coverage.

The fact that the incident took place five days ago in an area well outside of its usual Canadian focus, coupled with tepid community interest, ensured the paper never treated it as a top story, he said.

The approach contrasted sharply with western news outlets, many of which gave the story top billing and prominently displayed photographs extracted from the surveillance video capturing the hit-and-run.

Victor Wong, executive director of the Chinese Canadian National Council, said the English media treatment plays to a long-standing tradition of portraying China as a backwards and irresponsible nation.

While lamenting the toddler's plight, he questioned why the accident should draw more attention than the many other similar incidents taking place around the world each day.

"It's almost like the old Cold War stories about China. They're not civilized, they're not ready for Prime Time," Wong said. "There's that kind of holdover from the Red China days, and we still see this in our North American news outlets today."

Chan said Chinese-Canadians have expressed dismay at the tone of the English-language coverage, but said their frustration is tempered by the anxiety they feel about the state of society in their homeland.

Chan said the Chinese have grown leery of acting as good Samaritans in recent years thanks to a similar incident that took place a few years ago. A Chinese bus driver who stopped to help the victim of another hit-and-run was publicly upbraided and ultimately accused of causing the accident himself, Chan said, adding the story dampened enthusiasm for civil co-operation. Chinese who are living in Canada who may not have witnessed this change are now lamenting the effects of the attitudes that took route since they left, he said.

"We feel, 'it's a small baby,somebody should do something. Calling the police, or something," Chan said. "How some people can do this kind of thing? In Chinese saying we call them cobra -- their blood is cold."

James Miller, associate professor of Chinese studies at Queen's University, said the shifting social standards may also have roots in the country's exponential economic development. The past few decades have seen Chinese society shake off the mantle of communism as the economy becomes more liberalized and rural residents flock to the rapidly evolving cities in quest of new jobs.

Such massive upheaval can't help but tear at a society's moral fabric, he said.

"The old ways of doing things, the old social networks, the old kinship ties based on extended families, all of those values that are associated with that have really gone out of the window," Miller said. "I don't think yet Chinese society has solidified in a way that it knows what its ethical values are."

The hit-and-run has sparked outrage in China as people begin to question the society that has evolved, he said.

Similar concerns were voiced on social media targeting Canada's Chinese Community.

At info.51.ca, a chat board billing itself as an information gateway for Chinese people in Canada, a thread discussing the story drew about a dozen comments condemning those who failed to help the girl.

"The driver involved in the accident, the passers-by, the peddlers on the street, even the woman who walked by with a child ... Damn it! They're no better than animals! It's the shame of the local people, shame of the nation," one poster wrote in Chinese.

"Seeing this happen, I realize that if this sort of thing keeps going on, the nation is finished. Maybe it is already finished," wrote another.

WARNING: GRAPHIC VIDEO




Description of the video

The video clip showing the toddler being hit, ignored, then dragged away by the woman. Later in the clip, it features interviews with the elderly woman in Cantonese. Here’s a translation of what the woman said.

While cameras looked on, she tried to comfort a grieving family member, saying she was trying to call for help from many people.

Later on, in interviews, she described how she dragged the girl to side, then how she went out looking for help.

The reporter at the 2:20 mark asked “at that point, were you looking for people to help?”

The woman said she asked people all around, but no one acknowledged my pleas.

Then the reporter asked at the 2:30 mark: When you took her aside, was she conscious?

The woman said, “Yes, she was awake. One eye was closed, one eye was open,” then added that the girl was really heavy, and she didn’t have the strength to carry her, leaving her to look for help.

“Why didn’t so many people walking help?” she asked reporters at the three-minute mark, saying she walked all over the place, including the nearby stairs. She said she was asking passersby “why aren’t you helping?”

The reporter asked at the end, “Were you scared about the inconvenience of helping out?”

The women replied: “I wasn’t thinking about that. I wasn’t thinking about whether I should bother.”

Translation by The Huffington Post Canada

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

TORONTO - The tragic story of a Chinese toddler struck by two vehicles while more than a dozen bystanders stood idly by has stirred up a hive of mixed emotions for Canada's Chinese community.As Englis...
TORONTO - The tragic story of a Chinese toddler struck by two vehicles while more than a dozen bystanders stood idly by has stirred up a hive of mixed emotions for Canada's Chinese community.As Englis...
Filed by Christian Cotroneo  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 125
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
02:48 PM on 10/21/2011
This playing the victim of the "Western media" position is totally pathetic and unfounded. I would be willing to bet that 99.99% of people couldn't care less if it happened in China or here in Canada. The location has absolutely no impact on the level of disgust this story incites. A two year old baby was the victim of 2 hit and runs and then left on the road side to die by nearly 20 people. That is the story, not the race of the monsters who did nothing to help her. Period.

Quite frankly. I find this pulling of "the race card" very insulting and disingenuous to say the least. I can only assume that these people who passed on by have children, brothers and sisters, friends, someone they care about. How on earth could anyone leave a child on the side of the road like trash, and then go home to their own children?
I understand the fear of being sued and not wanting to get involved, but you have to be a whole new kind of cold-hearted to treat a child this way.
This is not an indictment of the Chinese people, it is a sad reminder of the deep inhumanity human beings are capable of.
08:04 AM on 10/20/2011
He listen, don't try and pin your own xenophobic tendencies on me. I hear toddler run over by car on CNN, the fact that it occurred in China is a footnote to me at this point; not really relevant to me. If you live in a country, and you are a citizen, act like one. Stop getting offended by perceived slights to your "home" country. Didn't you leave it for a reason? (If not, by all means go where your heart is.)
01:19 AM on 10/20/2011
so shameful...
photo
MyFatCat
I'm paid in catnip
08:39 PM on 10/19/2011
This reminded me of the Kitty Genovese murder in New York City, back in...1972? She was attacked by a man, who left her lying in the park, and then returned and murdered her. Eighteen people watched from the safety of their windows. Zero people contacted the police.

It's not a Chinese thing, it's a human thing, and ugly. The bigger the group that's spectating, the less likely any individual will break ranks and move.
06:25 PM on 10/19/2011
Isn't it also "saving face" when the Chinese don't admit to any number of things.. saving face seems to be more important than saving a human life. How sad... perhaps every culture can do the right thing, admit a wrong, try to understand it and fix it for the future.
So sad for this family, their little girl....is there anywhere to donate to the care for this child and the family?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sean Ferry
The only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothin
05:29 PM on 10/19/2011
The American media is biased, but that's besides the point, What happened on that Chinese street was despicable and beyond comparison in any way, The Canadian Chinese and the country of China can try and spin this any way they want, but the point is that the Act of the Chinese people that day, was inhumane and callous to levels I never thought I would see coming from a human being. And that in fact Colors the Chinese as less than human, more like an Animal. So Again, that is fact. If you don't like the reputation, stop being So disrespectful of human life. Plain and simple, in the mean time, I am boycotting China until it becomes part of the human race.. that my friend is what an being a regular, respectful American is all about. I honor the life of others as well as my own.
04:12 PM on 10/19/2011
Nowhere else in the world would this happen to a child. An adult lying in the streets? Maybe. But never a child. Something is rotting from the inside out...
02:47 PM on 10/19/2011
I had a hard time watching it ... I have tears dropping down my eyes... What tha f**** is happening to the world? 18 ppl just passed like it was nothing ...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RespectMyAuthoritah
My best comments are still pending
02:31 PM on 10/19/2011
So a toddler gets intentionally hit by 2 vehicles, after which 18 people stroll by like nothing, and these folks are more concerned about the portrayal of their country in Western media?

What upstanding citizens you are. Don't forget to send her a card along with those flowers, a$%holes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Scoville Scale
Canadian Contrarian
11:03 AM on 10/19/2011
Very hard to watch that.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gx5000
Life's too short, be happy..
10:11 AM on 10/19/2011
In a country of 1,331,460,000 people...life might seem cheap to some, there's also the stigma of getting involved, as we've seen with an assaulted person being ignored on a busy New York Street. This is something that could happen anywhere, let's just make sure it doesn't happen here, or ever again. The threads here that get into politico just phase me out...
photo
turkeylurky
Just keepin it real........
11:17 AM on 10/19/2011
"there's also the stigma of getting involved, as we've seen with an assaulted person being ignored on a busy New York Street"
----------------------------------------------------
There's danger and risk in getting involved in an altercation between 2 people - and many good samaritans have paid for their lives getting involved.
But to walk past a badly injured 2 year old lying in the street? - where the heck is the risk in helping the kid?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gx5000
Life's too short, be happy..
11:41 AM on 10/19/2011
It was a general statement to avoid the comment feedbacks I'm now getting..
Last poster is so in the clouds as to suggest something like that could not happen here, geebus.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stopgeorge
Paper Ballots WORK. Unverifiable e-voting doesn't
11:20 AM on 10/19/2011
And that is a load of BS.

This is distinctly NOT something that could happen "anywhere". Hence, the outrage.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gx5000
Life's too short, be happy..
11:40 AM on 10/19/2011
Hence the nonsense..this Can and DOES happen everywhere, look around.
This is NO different that the drive by shootings of innocents and the like.
Indifference is a Universal language that we must combat, we, unfortunately have the same issues.
photo
turkeylurky
Just keepin it real........
09:15 AM on 10/19/2011
"Victor Wong, executive director of the Chinese Canadian National Council, said the English media treatment plays to a long-standing tradition of portraying China as a backwards and irresponsible nation".
----------------------------------------------------
Ummmm, no Wong, you are definitely incorrect.
Had this happened in say, Stockholm or Amsterdam or Paris, it would have been a much bigger story.
Can you guess why?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alain Posteur
07:35 AM on 10/19/2011
Something revealing about the darker side of chinese culture happens. How do the chinese interpret this event? As a "western media exageration" ... thus proving, by their very reaction, that their is definately something very rotten in the chinese mindset. They only pay lip service to the girls' faith. Its obviously not their priority.

Nationalists concerns over the concern for human life is simply wrong. I would write the same thing about any culture that has such a disregard for human life. Especially little girls' in the case of the chinese.
photo
steveinfos
http://medialinkscolumn.com
04:56 AM on 10/19/2011
test
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
peter sfikas
Yia sou
04:16 AM on 10/19/2011
Let's not mince words here. The driver should be charged with attempted MURDER, NOT for running over the child the FIRST time; BUT for driving over the child the SECOND time, and driving away. And all those who walked by the injured child without stopping to help, are equally guilty. Same charges.
These people, proved by their actions, they are very dangerous to the society they live in. They must be rehabilitated before they are allowed to rejoin their society again. The appropriate sentence for this crime; 20 years hard labor. In addition, by Government decree, all newspapers, tv, radio, twitter, and facebook, must carry the story, including the sentence, for ten consecutive days, as a way to educate, and hopefully to stir, and awaken, the human quality that all humans possess, namely, COMPASSION ! I, too, now am traumatized, and will suffer for the rest of my life, after viewing this video.
photo
novabird
Lover of Life, Radical Centrist
05:52 AM on 10/19/2011
To those who have not watched the video yet: DO NOT WATCH THE VIDEO. Do not allow that mind virus access to your brain.
01:56 PM on 10/19/2011
It haunts me..I wish I had not seen the video
02:50 PM on 10/19/2011
i wish I didn't see it, but too late... I fell my body shivering for about 5 sec and tears coming out my eyes.