G8 Spending: Tony Clement And John Baird Defend Use Of Infrastructure Money

Tony Clement

First Posted: 11/02/11 05:20 PM ET Updated: 11/02/11 08:54 PM ET

OTTAWA - Tony Clement sought Wednesday to put an end to controversy over the $50-million G8 legacy fund, appearing before a parliamentary committee to answer any and all questions from opposition MPs.

But the Treasury Board president's performance shed little new light on the affair and did nothing to quell opposition allegations that the money was little more than a political slush fund for Clement to dispense as he saw fit around his Parry Sound-Muskoka riding.

"I believe that my record is a good record, it's an untainted record. It's a record of probity and honesty," Clement told the committee.

"I try to do my job the best I can for the people who've not only elected me but for the people of Canada and I will continue to do so in my new role as president of the Treasury Board."

Clement was industry minister when the money was being handed out to municipalities in his Ontario riding, which hosted last year's G8 summit. Almost $45 million was ultimately spent on gazebos, park upgrades, public washrooms and beautification projects, often many kilometres away from the actual summit site in Huntsville, Ont.

He has since been named Treasury Board president, where he's in charge of overseeing government spending as it attempts to eliminate the federal deficit by 2014.

New Democrat MP Charlie Angus said Clement's handling of the legacy fund proves he's not competent to manage the federal treasury.

"You got your hands on $50 million of border infrastructure money. You blew it on projects like hockey arenas and summit centres, you told your mayors to keep their lines straight, let's not talk to the media until we get the story out," Angus said.

"Mr. Clement, simple question: Why should Canadians trust you with the $250 billion that you're now in charge of?"

Clement's appearance before the committee Wednesday marked the first time in months he's actually responded to questions from MPs about the legacy fund. In the Commons, Clement has remained seated while Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird fields all queries.

Baird attended the committee with Clement and answered some questions. As infrastructure minister at the time, he insisted he was the only one with legal authority to approve the 32 projects which ultimately received legacy funding.

He made no apologies for projects that had little bearing on or proximity to the summit. He said criteria for legacy funding was not just to support staging of the summit but also to beautify the area and thank the region for hosting the international event.

"The G8 legacy fund helped an already beautiful part of Canada put its best face forward to the world," Baird told the committee.

The legacy fund has been the subject of controversy since a draft of former auditor general Sheila Fraser's final report was leaked during last spring's election campaign. The leaked draft said the government misled Parliament and possibly broke the law by seeking parliamentary approval for a border infrastructure fund, without telling MPs that $50 million of it would be devoted to G8 legacy projects. It also said federal officials were shut out of the process of choosing which projects would get funding.

The final report, released in June, was toned down somewhat but the conclusions were the same. Acting auditor general John Wiersema has said rules were broken and that he's never seen such a complete lack of paper trail to explain how projects were chosen.

Clement and Baird admitted Wednesday only to some well-intentioned administrative errors in setting up the fund, prompted by the need to speed things up and get projects finished in time for the summit. But they vehemently denied opposition allegations of porkbarrelling.

In one snippet of new information, Baird said the government did not rob the border infrastructure fund to pay for the legacy projects. Rather, it topped up the border fund so that the additional money could be applied to the legacy projects.

He reiterated that he acted on the advice of senior bureaucrats that it would be faster to use the existing border fund than to create an entirely new legacy fund.

Clement explained the absence of a paper trail, saying he asked mayors in his riding to come up with proposals for the legacy funding. They came up with 242 projects, which he estimated would cost some $500 million, so he asked them to pare their wish lists to only the priority projects. They came back with 33 proposals, 32 of which were approved by Baird.

In hindsight, Clement said he probably should have forwarded all 242 proposals to Infrastructure Canada and allowed the department to review them and choose the best.

Liberal MP Gerry Byrne was incredulous at Clement's suggestion that roughly two dozen mayors "self-evaluated" their conflicting wish lists and, "with surgical precision" came up with 33 projects, all but one of which was approved.

"That's amazing ... Wow," Byrne said sarcastically.

But Clement rejected Byrne's suggestion he was the "guiding hand" behind the choices.

"I know that there's this mythology ... that I was at a bar somewhere in Muskoka with two other guys making the decisions," Clement said. "That's just a myth. It never happened that way. We were not involved in selecting the projects."

Clement said he simply played a "co-ordinating role" between his local officials and the federal government but had nothing to do with choosing the projects.

Opposition MPs didn't buy it, pointing to reams of municipal documents and emails gleaned through provincial freedom of information legislation that show Clement was deeply involved in scripting how, when and where funding announcements were made. He was also involved in ensuring at least one project — a renovated recreation centre in Huntsville — was chosen to be the international media centre, although it was never used for that purpose.

Angus told reporters later that his party has obtained 1,000 more pages of municipal documents, which it is sifting through now.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

OTTAWA - Tony Clement sought Wednesday to put an end to controversy over the $50-million G8 legacy fund, appearing before a parliamentary committee to answer any and all questions from opposition MPs.
OTTAWA - Tony Clement sought Wednesday to put an end to controversy over the $50-million G8 legacy fund, appearing before a parliamentary committee to answer any and all questions from opposition MPs.
Filed by Michael Bolen  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
greysells2
grey cells matter
12:46 PM on 11/03/2011
"I believe that my record is a good record, it's an untainted record. It's a record of probity and honesty," Clement told the [parliamentary] committee.

From that statement can we assume the The Secretary of the Treasury Board thinks that everything he did was "good" and "honest", therefore, the Clement method of allocating funds is the new "standard" for government disbursements and that he would do this again? Sort of looks that way.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rickthaluddite
What noisy cats are we
08:02 AM on 11/03/2011
Conservative backbenchers are going to have to cross the floor and sit in opposition if we're going to stop this doomed Harper agenda. The spending required for this government's crime bill and ill-suited jets are going to make this $45 million fiasco look like pocket change. Otherwise we wait 4 years and replace them with the new Liberal Party who will get their vote out again.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alexandra Mandelis
Occupy.
10:30 PM on 11/02/2011
The Opposition must address Minister Clement as the Chair of the Treasury Board, framing his pork-barreling history around a serious question that affects all Canadians under Harper's majority government: Is the Minister responsible enough to chair this Board?

The Opposition would be wise not to believe Mr. Clement if he promises that he will manage the Board with utmost accountability and transparency standards. After all, by the time that scandal of closed door deals, pork barreling and cover up blew up in the media, the next federal election would be approaching...and THAT would be a great opportunity to get rid of Harper and his clowns like Clement once and for all.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rickthaluddite
What noisy cats are we
07:50 AM on 11/03/2011
If the rest of Canada supposedly hate Ontario so much, why have they elected rejects from the Ontario Legislature in Toronto, John Baird, Jim Flaherty, and Tony Clement specifically, to seats in the House of Commons. Another Toronto boy, Stephen Harper, goes and gives them plum cabinet positions that they are wholly unqualified for. Harper and his toadies made damn sure we weren't going to forget adscam. He might be surprised when he finds out we remember how to vote conservatives into obscurity. Mulroney is only remembered in punchlines now. Harper is going to wish he was a punchline when he sees the disregard and contempt Canadians will have for him.
09:41 PM on 11/02/2011
The adjective "smarmy" immediately comes to mind in reference to Clement and Baird.

Smarmy as defined by Urban Dictionary: A certain attitude often accompanied by a squinty look and a superior smile that makes you instantly hate a person.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
MyTake
Release the Hydrogen Economy now!
08:36 PM on 11/02/2011
Ah.... does this fellow and the "coiffed haired" PM like use the same LIP GLOSS!

Their media photo's always show really red lips.

Here is my suggestion for the next G-20 or G-8 or Commonwealth or Economic meetings.

Instead of spending these millions on land based security, let them RENT a CRUISE SHIP for 3 days and park them 5 miles off shore of the host country and surround the ship with Military destroyers and sub-marines.

This Conservative Crew would have never gained office had there been a MANDATORY voting requirement in Federal Elections.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
greysells2
grey cells matter
12:56 PM on 11/03/2011
A cruise ship sure! Or a military base, sure. Both would be secure. Except the real reason for these international extravganzas is to throw money around to impress the press, their fellow politicians and the public with their wealth and power. Minister Clement was the perfect guy to fill the role of spender in chief, at the time, and that of spinner in chief, after the fact. Spend, spin, spend, spin with our money and making our collective heads spin.
yer
Stop the Alberta Taliban
07:55 PM on 11/02/2011
jail please
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
BCPATRIOT
British Columbia
07:17 PM on 11/02/2011
Clement should be fired then charged for miss using tax papers money.

Baird is just as bad.

Mr. Harper time to fire these two...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shandra Brown Valyear
Political Addict
06:55 PM on 11/02/2011
Baird says the fund was topped up......where did that money come from? I am guessing the slashing of yet another social program!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mtnestr
06:36 PM on 11/02/2011
I'd like to see that smarmy grin wiped off his face.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shandra Brown Valyear
Political Addict
06:56 PM on 11/02/2011
Just creepy!
06:32 PM on 11/02/2011
Wow, is this guy ugly, or what !!??!!
06:18 PM on 11/02/2011
This minuet is absurd.

Dandy and Dainty are dancing to their delusions.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
05:59 PM on 11/02/2011
Remember when he ran away from the CBC crew when they asked him about Canadians paying the highest telecom rates in the world?
05:45 PM on 11/02/2011
>>>>saying every cent was accounted for.

Every misspent cent was accounted for ?
What a relief.
I hate it when the books do not balance.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
06:00 PM on 11/02/2011
The auditor general made several recommendations on how our corruption can be even more transparent and we accepted all of them.

Baird
05:28 PM on 11/02/2011
Why is this not a surpise. Money flows when you are a tory and water always seeks its own level.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Willow2
An Old Bat who Follows Current Affairs
05:24 PM on 11/02/2011
Yes, it is just fine to pour money into your riding - as long as you are Tory. Bah! Humbug! The smile on his face in the photo says it all - "I can do what I want and screw you"...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
greysells2
grey cells matter
12:58 PM on 11/03/2011
The smile on Clement's face is laughing at us for accepting his over the top drivel.