PETA And Fiddler Ashley MacIsaac In Fur Clash

Peta

First Posted: 11/04/11 03:51 PM ET Updated: 11/05/11 10:39 AM ET


World-renowned Cape Breton fiddler Ashley MacIsaac confronted PETA protesters in downtown Windsor, Ont., on Friday afternoon.


MacIsaac arrived at an anti-fur demonstration alone, unannounced and wearing a muskrat fur coat.


He was also carrying a handmade sign reading "I support the Canadian Seal Hunt."


MacIsaac's coat, which he playfully stroked while talking to reporters, was reversible with a leather lining.


"It’s people, then it’s animals," MacIsaac told reporters.


Two provocatively dressed PETA members wearing tight-fitting faux police uniforms were protesting the fur and leather clothing industry, which they called violent and cruel.


PETA member Emily Lavender called Friday's demonstration fun and upbeat.


But MacIsaac takes exception to many of PETA's protests. He said they are often extreme and need an extreme opposition.


"PETA has a good cause, which is to ethically treat animals, but the focus hasn't been on that, it’s been on being extreme. I’m just offended by some of the things PETA does to protest," MacIsaac said. "I’m for the ethical treat of animals, I’m also for farming and hunting animals."


Supports seal hunt


MacIsaac said he strongly supports the annual seal hunt on Canada's east coast. He claims there are three million extra seals than can be naturally sustained.


"I’m against anybody telling a fisherman who is out at five in the morning, on the ice in the North Atlantic, that they know better than [the fishermen] know about what it’s like to make a living out there and what is a humane way to do the seal hunt," said MacIsaac, who is originally from Cape Breton and now lives in Windsor. "I was raised a hunter. I know how to hunt with proper technique without harming animals."


MacIsaac said Canada was born out of the fur trade. And that fur is a necessity during harsh Canadian winters.


"To assume I live in Brazil and don’t need to wear warm clothes in the winter, go to Winnipeg at Portage and Main in the middle of winter and you’ll be happy you had a fur," MacIsaac said.


PETA member Emily Lavender disagreed.


"There is no excuse to be wearing fur or skin," Lavender said. "There are so many fashionable, durable warm, comfortable options."


RELATED VIDEO:
FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

World-renowned Cape Breton fiddler Ashley MacIsaac confronted PETA protesters in downtown Windsor, Ont., on Friday afternoon. MacIsaac arrived at an anti-fur demonstration alo...
World-renowned Cape Breton fiddler Ashley MacIsaac confronted PETA protesters in downtown Windsor, Ont., on Friday afternoon. MacIsaac arrived at an anti-fur demonstration alo...
Filed by Christian Cotroneo  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:18 PM on 12/19/2011
." I know how to hunt with proper technique without harming animals." as a direct quote from MacIsaac - excuse me? how do you kill without harming? I get that it is cold in the north (I used to live in Michigan) but fur is not the best insulator against the weather anymore. There are different materials now that are as warm or warmer than fur. to kill just for the fur is abhorrent and (to me) extremely cruel. all over the world, the 'workforce' is changing or needs to change to come into the current century. bashing seals on the head and skinning them is not a necessity as it once was when our countries were being formed.
11:11 AM on 11/09/2011
we are no vegetarians if you where left in an island just eating vegetables without taking multivitamins and protein you are a dead person. Killing animals just for the fur i don't agree leather from animals that where use for food is a different study and if PETA wants to take it further what about the abortion issue is the killing of a baby, where do they stand on this.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
alsm9
Bombshell
11:23 AM on 11/05/2011
It's a very complicated issue. I'm a vegetarian, but I still wear leather shoes and boots. Not all synthetic clothes are great for the environment. Artificial leather is made from oil. While I agree that PETA can be very heavy handed at times....if they weren't no one would pay attention to them and they wouldn't get their message out and I think they have some valid points. I also think MacIsaac's arguments are ridiculous. How does one hunt an animal without harming it? And over-fishing and greed are to blame for the seal hunt. The fishing industry doesn't want the seals to eat the fish because then they have less to sell and make money from.
06:59 AM on 11/05/2011
The PETA people need to respect choice. We all agree to the ethical treatment of animals....but to be "big brother" to our choices of clothing fabric is where I draw the line. They should change the spelling of their group to PITA pain in the a..............
07:52 PM on 12/20/2011
And who in their right mind would "choose" to let a baby animal be beaten to death infront of it's helpless mother just so they can look fashionable??! I applaud PETA for standing up for those animals who do not have their own voice.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sandra MacKay
09:44 PM on 11/04/2011
Oh go flash your kilt..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gathled
I am an extreme moderate...
09:43 PM on 11/04/2011
I also support the seal hunt.
07:54 PM on 12/20/2011
Very sorry to hear about you losing your heart gatled- hope it turns up soon
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
opprobrious
More speech. Less Flagging.
06:54 PM on 11/04/2011
Hunting without harming the animal. Hmm. Do tell more, Ashley.
06:29 PM on 11/04/2011
I think MacIsaac needs to learn the difference between hunting and the seal slaughter. Shooting a bullet through the heart of a deer so it dies instantly without suffering is far far different then taking a pik and shoving it through a baby seals eye to drag it away from it's mother so it can be beaten with a club.