Attawapiskat: Grand Chief Sees Short-Term Solutions Forming

First Posted: 11/29/11 06:34 AM ET Updated: 11/30/11 02:04 AM ET

Attawapiskat Reserve Chief Crisis
Regional Grand Chief Stan Louttit says five families living in tents on the Northern Ontario reserve should be able to move into homes fairly soon — likely before Christmas.

TIMMINS, Ont. - A solution to some of the most immediate problems in Attawapiskat seems to be taking shape.

Regional Grand Chief Stan Louttit says five families living in tents on the Northern Ontario reserve should be able to move into homes fairly soon — likely before Christmas.

That's because federal funding has allowed the Cree band to start repairing several houses that had been abandoned because they were too run-down.

And if the band comes up with robust and detailed plans for building more homes, Ottawa has agreed to provide up to $2 million extra.

But Louttit says the progress only deals with some of the immediate problems on the reserve, and those problems will return again unless chronic overcrowding, poor construction and poverty are dealt with in a meaningful way.

"This is band-aid stuff," he said in an interview. "It doesn't deal with the overall issue."

The Attawapiskat community near James Bay has been struggling for years to deal with a deep housing shortage, Louttis said.

More and more houses have been abandoned because they are too dilapidated. For a while, families doubled up in the stronger homes. But now, there are not enough quality houses for everyone to live in.

So entire families have moved into tents, or uninsulated shacks, or abandoned construction trailers left behind by miners.

Tired of trying to persuade Aboriginal Affairs officials that Attawapiskat needed special consideration, the band took their complaints public by declaring a state of emergency last month.

Their plight has gradually attracted attention. Federal and provincial officials were in Attawapiskat on Monday to see if they can figure out what went wrong. And now, NDP interim leader Nycole Turmel is on her way to the remote community, as is the Red Cross, the regional grand chief, and extra health professionals.

"The good thing is, everybody knows about it. The government is embarrassed as hell," Louttit said. "We're beginning to see some progress."

Several James Bay communities are experiencing similar trouble, but First Nations leaders have focused on Attawapiskat because conditions there are the worst, Louttit added.

Housing for First Nations crumbles party because families are large and homes are often crowded, says John Beaucage, a former grand chief who advises Ontario on improving aboriginal living.

Homes built on top of permafrost have extra challenges, Beaucage says, because the large families heat up the homes, and then melt the permafrost underneath. So foundations and beams sink and then crack, and mould infestations spread.

The Cree community in Attawapiskat has had years of problems with its buildings. The elementary school had to be shut down in 2000 because of health and safety concerns, and has not yet been replaced with a permanent structure.

The Assembly of First Nations estimates that 80,000 additional homes are needed in First Nations communities. The advocacy organization says almost half of the existing housing stock is substandard, and much of it should be condemned.

Prime Minister Stephen Harper has spoken pointedly about needing to find a better route to aboriginal prosperity. But he is focusing fairly narrowly on improving education.

Loading Slideshow...
  • A child with a facial rash from lack of clean water and sanitation.

  • Many children are scalded and burned from living in densely overcrowded houses with makeshift wood stoves.

  • Inside a makeshift tent -- home to a family of six.

  • A young mother stands in front of the tent she has shared with her husband and four children for two years.


Video and photos courtesy of Charlie Angus

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

TIMMINS, Ont. - A solution to some of the most immediate problems in Attawapiskat seems to be taking shape.Regional Grand Chief Stan Louttit says five families living in tents on the Northern Ontario ...
TIMMINS, Ont. - A solution to some of the most immediate problems in Attawapiskat seems to be taking shape.Regional Grand Chief Stan Louttit says five families living in tents on the Northern Ontario ...
Filed by Michael Bolen  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 52
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:00 AM on 11/30/2011
It's not just a housing crisis... more detail is needed publicly i.e. the unlikeliness that people could get out of the trailers if there was a fire, and also to show pictures of existing health problems rather than say health threats. And what about the math? $90 since 2006 is NOT enough for anyone to have good living conditions divided between 2,000 residents and the government is a humiliation to Canada implying that the monies had been frivolously spent!!
03:27 PM on 11/29/2011
4) lack of organizations to support local service delivery.

“Over the decades, provinces have established many organizations and structures to support local delivery of programs and services to communities…there are few similar organizations to support service delivery within First Nations communities.”

Ah. So much less simple than just blaming the community.
03:26 PM on 11/29/2011
3) lack of an appropriate funding mechanism, and

“The federal government uses contribution agreements to fund the delivery of services on First Nations reserves…[which] may also inhibit appropriate accountability to First Nations members. … [and] this situation creates a level of uncertainty for First Nations and makes long-term planning difficult.”
03:25 PM on 11/29/2011
2. lack of a legislative base,

Provincial legislation provides a basis of clarity for services delivered by provinces. A legislative base for programs specifies respective roles and responsibilities, eligibility, and other program elements. It constitutes an unambiguous commitment by government to deliver those services. The result is that accountability and funding are better defined.

The federal government has often developed programs to support First Nations communities without establishing a legislative or regulatory framework for them...as a result, the services delivered under these programs are not always well defined and there is confusion about federal responsibility for funding them adequately.
03:24 PM on 11/29/2011
I suspect many won't bother to actually read the auditor general's 2011 report, so I'll highlight some of the main findings for you.

source: http://www.oag-bvg.gc.ca/internet/English/parl_oag_201106_04_e_35372.html#hd3b

"In our view, many of the problems facing First Nations go deeper than the existing programs’ lack of efficiency and effectiveness. We believe that structural impediments severely limit the delivery of public services to First Nations communities and hinder improvements in living conditions on reserves. We have identified four such impediments:

1) lack of clarity about service levels

“Mainly through INAC, the federal government supports many services on reserves that are normally provided by provincial and municipal governments off reserves. It is not always evident whether the federal government is committed to providing services on reserves of the same range and quality as those provided to other communities across Canada.”
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
03:34 PM on 11/29/2011
I suspect many did read it, and rejected the notion that big government and big government spending can solve all the world's problems. Probably why the NDP are polling in 3rd place again.
03:49 PM on 11/29/2011
Uh-huh. "Big government" is good enough for the funding and provision of your own services like education and healthcare...but suddenly it is 'rejected' when it is for First Nations?

So, not even a nod to the auditor general for identifying the flaws in the Federally funded system? No nod for the recommendations made to improve service delivery and maximise funding dollars?

I see. So this isn't actually intended to be an honest discussion. Nice to know.
03:07 PM on 11/29/2011
Where did all the money go that has been poured into the reserves needing housing over the years? Why are Canadian taxpayers once again on the hook for this? If the chiefs and the bands won't look after their own people, it is not the job of taxpayers to do so.

Yeah, this is a disgrace............for the chiefs and the bands.
03:38 PM on 11/29/2011
A link to Attawapiskat's financial statements since 2005: http://www.attawapiskat.org/financial-statements/

A link to the auditor general's report detailing the problems with INAC funding and service provisions to First Nations reserves: http://www.oag-bvg.gc.ca/internet/English/parl_oag_201106_04_e_35372.html#hd3b

If you actually care, you should really read that auditor's report...and write to Minister Duncan to ask why his ministry has yet to implement all but a few of the auditor general's recommendations made over the past decade.

You SHOULD be outraged that this issue has been so thoroughly studied, and concrete recommendations have been made, with little to no action on the part of a government ministry funded by your tax dollars. Time to look at your own people.
BritishColumbian
American/Canadian liberal
05:01 PM on 11/29/2011
Thank you for taking the time to relay this information. You provided answers to some of my questions about the administration/bureaucracy involved.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Reel Recordings
...everybody look what's goin' down...
11:15 AM on 11/29/2011
Canada's national shame - the treatment of our First Nation's people.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
01:37 PM on 11/29/2011
This comment is ignorant.

I'm going to do you a favour and post a comment made by someone in the other article, so you can realize what the real issues here are:

"I am Attawapisk­at Band Member and today i found out Trust fund account only has 8 Million Dollars..f­rom the IBA...Wher­e is the 5.5 Million? Also the leaders has a way to use the Money before it goes to the Trust fund,we the Grass Roots people want to fine out where the money went? I feel if assessment is going to be done in Attawapisk­at,why not do an assessment on the Band Office account also and see if the money has been misuse..Be­cause i hear Inac officials are going to be in Attawapisk­at too do an assessment on Housing.
There is more than Housing crisis happening with us..we need answers from our local Leadership­, i wish the grass Roots people were ask question by the reporters,­but sad to say only the members who are well like are ask to speak to the reporters. Thank you for the freedom of speech.
03:03 PM on 11/29/2011
It is disgusting that you are not copying and pasting this fellow's comments as though they somehow negate (or were ever intended to negate) the fact that the situation in Attawapiskat is indeed a national shame. I'm going to flag your post as an abusive used of someone else's words.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
03:09 PM on 11/29/2011
Posting it in every thread doesn't make it true.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shandra Brown Valyear
Political Addict
11:10 AM on 11/29/2011
11 years without a proper school is unacceptable. Without education these children will be permanently stuck in poverty limbo.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
01:38 PM on 11/29/2011
Agreed. The band leaders need to be changed and have someone competent and honest put in charge.
03:05 PM on 11/29/2011
I see you are spewing the same tired refrain in any discussion of Attawapiskat.

Please do read the auditor general's report on how INAC has consistently failed to provide First Nations students with acceptable levels of education. Please do once again demonstrate your ignorance about how education is funded for non-native students (claiming things like 'they pay for it themselves' and other such trash).

The 2011 report: http://www.oag-bvg.gc.ca/internet/English/parl_oag_201106_04_e_35372.html#hd3b
BritishColumbian
American/Canadian liberal
09:15 PM on 11/29/2011
As should the Minister of Aboriginal Affairs and all involved in not doing the propper accounting and inspection of what has been done with taxpayer money. Works both ways.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
09:58 AM on 11/29/2011
The adults in these communities choose to live there as the means to live a traditional lifestyle. The children however are offered no choice.As such they are forced to exist in deplorable conditions.The 'myth' of this traditional lifestlyle needs to be scrutinized in order to set aside the bias of native elders and other well meaning agencys and get down to doing whats right for the children.
12:10 PM on 11/29/2011
The 'myth of the traditional lifestyle' exists only in your mind and in the minds of others who so mischaracterise and misunderstand the situation.

Traditional lifestyles are built on certain fundamental values such as communal versus individual priorities, on kinship ties, on relationship with the land (which does not mean leaving in squalid and substandard homes with no running water or adequate sanitation) and on sustainable economic practices, etc. I don't know what image you have in your head about what it means to be 'traditional', but a lot of people erroneously assume it must mean eschewing all technology an traipsing around the bush all day. Sorry, but that has never been reality.

When guns were introduced, aboriginal peoples were quick to adapt to them. What made their use 'traditional' was the values that guided their use, and those values are not technology dependent.

Your children are given no choice to live in a greedy, capitalist society that favours individual rights over communal rights, that entrenches class-based division and teaches people that you get to enjoy life when you retire (if someone hasn't run off with your pension plan in the meantime) and which apparently accepts child poverty as a fact of life rather than a serious issue needing immediate solutions. Perhaps your children should be removed and put into more humane homes?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
01:36 PM on 11/29/2011
aapihtawikosisaan, It's undeniable that those 'certain fundamental values' lead to conditions that are unfavourable. It's why there's so many problems in every reserve across Canada. Especially with this one particular one, where their system allows the band leaders to misuse the reserves money, leading to such terrible conditions.

Is it worth it? Is it worth it to have your children suffer so you can hold on to some obscure form of "values"? I don't think so.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
03:08 PM on 11/29/2011
What ever you choose to call it man, It ain't working so good. Is it? That's why I call it a myth.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
franny68
04:11 PM on 11/29/2011
yes f&f