Attawapiskat: Harper Not Happy Federal Funds Haven't Alleviated Housing Crisis

First Posted: 11/29/11 02:31 PM ET Updated: 11/30/11 09:59 AM ET

OTTAWA - Prime Minister Stephen Harper says he's not happy that millions of federal dollars have not alleviated the housing crisis in the Northern Ontario native community of Attawapiskat.

"This government has spent some $90 million since coming to office just on Attawapiskat," he told the Commons on Tuesday. "That's over $50,000 for every man, woman and child in the community.

"Obviously we're not very happy that the results do not seem to have been achieved for that."

He and Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan said officials are looking into the situation.

But a 2010 audit of federal funds spent on reserve housing suggests there's a lack of oversight on the part of the federal government into how that money gets spent.

"There remain significant gaps to provide assurance that governance, risk-management and control frameworks are adequate to provide a reasonable expectation that funds for on-reserve housing are used for the intended purpose and that outcomes will be achieved," the audit of the Aboriginal Affairs department said.

It found that housing funds were allocated using dated reference levels, raising the risk it doesn't reflect actual need.

Meanwhile, the department didn't explicitly track the money it spent, so it couldn't say whether it actually achieved results.

The department also relied on reports from First Nations on the state of housing but did not double-check those reports, the audit said.

"There is a risk that housing-performance information being tracked and reported by the department is not accurate, complete and reliable," the audit found.

The study also found that government officials weren't regularly checking on housing projects and when they did, they didn't document what they found.

The federal government regularly spends about $272 million a year on reserve housing and allotted an additional $192 million over five years in the 2005 budget.

A further $400 million was allocated through the stimulus program.

The money flows through Aboriginal Affairs and Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corp., though the audit only examined Aboriginal Affairs funding.

A government response to the audit's seven recommendations suggested that as of last March 31, some changes had been made.

A formal monitoring and oversight program was also scheduled to be developed this year.

This week, the Conservatives said they'd give the Attawapiskat reserve in the James Bay region up to $2 million more to deal with a housing crisis — if the band produces solid, detailed plans for building more homes.

Getting all First Nations to develop more thorough plans was a suggestion raised in the audit, which said management practices and reporting expectations related to housing are inconsistent across the country.

"Formalized processes are not in place in regions for the review and challenge of community housing plans or for the monitoring of the extent of implementation and current status of existing housing plans," the audit said.

According to figures providing by Aboriginal Affairs, the Attawapiskat Cree band has received just over $3 million in funds specifically for housing and a further $2.8 million in infrastructure money since 2006. In total, the department says the community of around 2,000 has received over $90 million since 2006.

Yet families are living in tents, uninsulated shacks or abandoned construction trailers in the snows of early winter.

The community has declared a state of emergency three times in the last three years, once over air quality concerns following the demolition of a school, once over a wastewater backup that forced homes to be evacuated and now over housing.

"The community has a number of challenges, one of them being its financial challenge," Duncan said in the Commons last week.

"Part of our overall next steps is to get to a place where proper local administration and governance can ensure there is progress being made in the community," he added.

Loading Slideshow...
  • A child with a facial rash from lack of clean water and sanitation.

  • Many children are scalded and burned from living in densely overcrowded houses with makeshift wood stoves.

  • Inside a makeshift tent -- home to a family of six.

  • A young mother stands in front of the tent she has shared with her husband and four children for two years.


Video and photos courtesy of Charlie Angus

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

OTTAWA - Prime Minister Stephen Harper says he's not happy that millions of federal dollars have not alleviated the housing crisis in the Northern Ontario native community of Attawapiskat."This govern...
OTTAWA - Prime Minister Stephen Harper says he's not happy that millions of federal dollars have not alleviated the housing crisis in the Northern Ontario native community of Attawapiskat."This govern...
Filed by Michael Bolen  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 443
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
03:28 PM on 12/27/2011
Of course he's scratching his head trying to fit the $90M he claimed into the actual $3M or as a backup fitting the $90M into more like $84M total including stimulus spending. He'd propably also like to keep the fact that de Boers spent as much on housing as he did on the down low. He's clueless enough to congratulate our natives on their valuable contributions as immigrants to Canada (sad but true). Federal staff were on the ground just a few weeks before he made this statement.
12:44 AM on 12/06/2011
where did the money go
12:58 PM on 12/05/2011
The first priority is to ensure that the people living in these conditions are looked after. Secondly, let's not cloud any debate on the allocation of funds by using the "Racist" epithet.
Let's stop playing politics also. This is not a Conservative/liberal/NDP issue.
This constituency is represented by Mr. Angus. Did he just find out about the conditions in the area ? How was the $ 90 M spent ? Who is accountable ?
To those who are saying it's the governments fault, you would probably accuse the government of being paternalistic if they exercised more control over the cash flow. If it is tax money, then we have the right to expect due diligence. If there is evidence of incompetence or malfeasance at any level, it should be identified and dealt with. Enough political correctness.
12:56 AM on 12/05/2011
its not that harper was not happy, its because harper is hiding millions dollars from these people
12:59 PM on 12/02/2011
apihtawikosisa.wordpress.com has some really good information for people that need to get educated about First Nations Issuess and how the Federal government oversees and approves ALL spending.
10:46 AM on 12/01/2011
Harper is RACIST!!! This never happened under the Liberals.

If you don't support sending MORE MONEY to Attawapiskat, then you are RACIST.

I am a proud Liberal and I will be voting for Bob Rae!
09:32 AM on 12/02/2011
Let me guess, everything is black and white for you and you're sort of a control freak right?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
colpy
12:18 PM on 12/03/2011
What part of $50,000 per PERSON do you not understand???

The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over, but expecting a different result.

And being Liberal is nothing to be proud of...........especially on policy with First Nations.

Or have you never heard of residential schools??
10:14 AM on 12/01/2011
The government of Canada, last night, it has ordered 3rd party management, of these Native affairs.
It's about time. Band leaders now have no choice but to fork over financial records, there will be a full investigation and audit. The new relief money will be delegated by government officials not band leaders. Apparently most of the 90 million previously allocated was for education, there is no school, on the grounds, these people are not educated enough to manage their finances or simple budget.....What Education?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MCTSilverlakeCA
retired Sr Litigation Insurance Fraud Manager
12:33 AM on 12/01/2011
"...a lack of oversight in the government about how this money gets spent..." - sounds like the American Government. (Boy I came up "here" hoping for some clearer heads and clean air,(grandmother was Canadian) but I can see the same dirty politics is fogging up the public windows just as badly as in the US) ... hope you get a handle on it faster than we did.
06:06 PM on 11/30/2011
This has most likely been happening for a long time and possibly not in just one department.

Without detailed accounting that is open to the public the voters can not make informed choices
or know if money is being spent the way they think it is.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:46 PM on 11/30/2011
I'm no fan of The Steve but I'm not to happy about it either. Internal corruption is the #1 problem for the native community. If they don't demand better from their own leaders nothing will change and they have no one to blame but themselves. Hard to feel sorry for the victims when they volunteer to be victims over and over again..
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Adrian31
60% of the time, it works everytime...
03:38 PM on 11/30/2011
"This government has spent some $90 million since coming to office just on Attawapiskat," he told the Commons on Tuesday. "That's over $50,000 for every man, woman and child in the community."

That statement alone just goes to show how little oversight leads to massive corruption.

"Obviously we're not very happy that the results do not seem to have been achieved for that."

This is polite political-speak for, "What the F@ck is going on and where the f@ck is the money?"
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
hollace
I told you I was sick
01:12 PM on 11/30/2011
'm surprised at the comments that sound like they're rooted in ignorance and prejudice. I wonder if the person who compares HER income and how she only makes 35 thou ( her own fault) compares money that goes for a school to her daily life. Pay for milk up where it's been flown on and it's not the same. I'm stunned that peeps think it's just part of Canada and don't know they ..and De Beers rake in a mass of money from leased property. I think our education system is in the toillet which might be a good place for Harper and his stooges.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
02:59 PM on 11/30/2011
This is so disorganized that I can only barely decipher what you're trying to say.
For one, who is "her"??

I'd love to have a discussion with you, and maybe correct some of your inaccuracies... but not until you communicate a little more effectively.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:49 PM on 11/30/2011
debeers employs over 10% of the band in very high paying jobs and have done lots to help the band but the help never makes it past the band office. and $90mil divided by 2400 people buys a lot of milk no matter where you live.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
04:13 PM on 11/30/2011
1800, and its worth noting that this band makes $35 million per year, in addition to the 90 million spent on housing.
04:49 PM on 11/30/2011
Hell it buys the cow!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kris Dubuque
Proudly Progressive
12:46 PM on 11/30/2011
So basically the Harper Government threw $90 million at a problem and then just walked away? No follow up? No oversight? No audits? In other words, someone in the federal government wasn't doing their job. No wonder this government is running a record deficit, they throw money around like its candy. Fake lakes, gazebos, advertising... the list is endless.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
01:13 PM on 11/30/2011
The aboriginal's want self-governance, we can't baby them and tell them how to spend 'their' money.

Either you're arguing that aboriginals are less intelligent than we and need our help, or you're arguing that finances are just too complicated and require government intervention - against the wishes of the aboriginal population.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kris Dubuque
Proudly Progressive
01:21 PM on 11/30/2011
Neither. I'm saying that the federal government has an entire department dedicated to Aboriginal Affairs and another department that is supposed to monitor government spending. If the government spends $90 million of our dollars and it can't show how it’s been spent that's a problem. Just like the $50 million that was sprinkled in Muskoka that was supposed to be spent on border infrastructure. It would appear that finances are too complicated for the Harper Government.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:57 PM on 11/30/2011
Let's get to the elephant in the room. Perhaps this community is being screwed by its leaders. Where is the money?
11:22 AM on 11/30/2011
People get fooled with this story every year, close to Christmas. yes they live like that, yes they choose to spend money on other things. No they dont want to be treated like every one else, they want to whine and beg for more money. They are "entitled". We work, do better with so much less money, we get up fix the plumbing and heating, wash our kids, send them to school, all for an average of about $30,000-$35,000 per normal family. Don't get me started.
12:35 PM on 11/30/2011
'Normal' families get funding to the tune of about $11,000 per student per year from the province of Ontario. So add that on. 'Normal families' also get provincial funding for healthcare to the tune of anywhere from $1000-$13,000 per person depending on your age and health needs. So please add that on. 'Normal families' get all sorts of provincial funding for programs the feds provide to First Nations that you have no factored into what I assume is merely an income figure. You might do better, but it's on MORE money. Not less.
01:04 PM on 11/30/2011
and where does that "funding" come from? Oh right from the people who are getting that so called funding. The gov't doesn't just create money, they get it from TAXPAYERS. This reserve spend $5,000,000 on WAGES for teachers at a school that doesn't exist.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
01:11 PM on 11/30/2011
At least this is true. The average person receives quite a bit in social benefits.

Unfortunately, aapihtawikosisaan fails to mention that we all pay for these social benefits in taxes. If you make an average income, you typically pay for 100% of ALL services you receive. (If you make less, you pay for less, if you make more, you pay for more than your share)

The Reserve's 35 million in income does 0% of that in taxes, the only taxes they pay is the individual taxes on income made outside the reserve, as well as a minuscule amount of GST.

While a below average income person may pay 50% of the social benefit they receive, a reserve pays next to nothing.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
hollace
I told you I was sick
12:56 PM on 11/30/2011
chill out... it's too early in the morning to go postal...