Tony Clement: G8 Allegations From NDP Prompt Demand For Apology For 'Smear'

Tonyclementg8

First Posted: 11/29/11 04:55 PM ET Updated: 12/01/11 04:04 PM ET

OTTAWA - Tony Clement has been cleared of accusations that he doctored the official record of his testimony on the controversial G8 legacy fund.

Now the Treasury Board president is demanding an apology from the NDP, which levelled the accusation last week.

"Now they've been shown to be a bunch of liars and I want my justice," Clement said Tuesday, moments after being cleared by House of Commons Speaker Andrew Scheer.

Clement added that "a liar should apologize" and even hinted at legal action should New Democrat MP Charlie Angus refuse to apologize for initiating a "smear campaign full of lies."

Clement said if Angus does not to apologize, "he is not an honourable member and I will be obviously consulting to see what my next plan would be."

Quick Poll

Should Charlie Angus apologize to Tony Clement?

Yes

No

Not sure

Angus was visiting the Attawapiskat native reserve Tuesday and unavailable to respond. But fellow New Democrat Alexandre Boulerice said there's no need to apologize for asking a "legitimate question" about the transcript of Clement's testimony to the public accounts committee earlier this month.

The issue arose last week when the NDP noticed that the official transcript, known as Hansard, had been altered to delete Clement's response of "sure" when asked if he would publicly disclose all the applications from municipalities in his riding for a share of the $50-million G8 legacy fund.

At a news conference, Angus and Boulerice suggested the record must have been changed at the request of Clement or his staff, as is typically the case when Hansard is altered. Clement vehemently denied the charge and asked Scheer to investigate.

Scheer reported back to the Commons on Tuesday.

"I can assure the House categorically that no members or members' staff submitted proposed changes to the transcript," he said.

"The changes made were the result of normal editing protocols being followed."

Scheer explained that Hansard editors routinely delete "redundant words, false starts, hesitations, words that might lead to confusion as to the true intent of the statement and so on."

In the case of Clement's testimony, the minister frequently began his answers with the word "sure," some of which were deleted from the official transcript while others were left in.

Clement told reporters his repeated use of the word "sure" is a verbal tick, a way of hesitating while he formulates his response to questions, much the same way other people use "you know" or "OK." He said he had no intention of agreeing to the NDP request to produce the application forms for funding.

Boulerice said Clement's continued refusal to produce the documents shows the NDP has nothing to learn from Clement "about telling the truth."

"We were sure that (Clement's response of) "sure" meant, 'Okay, I'm ready to give you, to be open, to give you everything.' But now we see that he's playing games," Boulerice said.

The applications forms are of interest because they were not official government documents. They were handmade — produced by municipalities, according to Clement — and sent to his constituency office.

Opposition MPs maintain the irregular manner of applying for funding was done deliberately to hide the paper trail and obscure the fact that Clement was directly involved in choosing which projects would get money.

Clement insists he played only a "co-ordination role" and that John Baird, then infrastructure minister, was the one who chose the winning applications.

The fund was set up to beautify Clement's Parry Sound-Muskoka riding in Ontario's cottage country prior to hosting last year's G8 summit. It was used to renovate arenas, enhance streetscapes and build gazebos in towns that were often hours from the summit site in Huntsville.

The auditor general has slammed the government for misleading Parliament about the purpose of the fund and for its failure to produce any documentation showing why 32 projects were ultimately given a chunk of the cash.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

OTTAWA - Tony Clement has been cleared of accusations that he doctored the official record of his testimony on the controversial G8 legacy fund.Now the Treasury Board president is demanding an apology...
OTTAWA - Tony Clement has been cleared of accusations that he doctored the official record of his testimony on the controversial G8 legacy fund.Now the Treasury Board president is demanding an apology...
Filed by Michael Bolen  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 40
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Capital Ottawa
11:09 AM on 12/01/2011
Clement, honest? "Sure"

Charlie Angus should keep asking Clement what right he had to misappropriate $50 million dollars of taxpayers money. Canadians are pissed off and want answers, the opposition is doing what they should. Clement is a national disgrace and should be removed from office.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lulex
Made in Canada
11:21 PM on 11/30/2011
I cannot stand the HYPOCRACY of this Harper party of goons.
10:23 PM on 11/30/2011
I expect the apology on the same day the Prince of Pork is led in shackles from the courtroom for transport to a double-bunk prison cell.
04:28 PM on 11/30/2011
If Tony Clement was the MP for Timmins James Bay these people would be living in $50 million gazebos.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nathan Ottenson
The Christian Right are neither
04:13 PM on 11/30/2011
Where's our apology Tony??
georgee2
My Canada Includes Everyone
03:51 PM on 11/30/2011
I'm laughing so hard my sides hurt. Please Tony stop, stop, sto.....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tyler Austin
Women = people. Corperations ≠ people.
01:58 PM on 11/30/2011
Pick an excuse and stick with it Tony. First you had no idea. he the papers were lost. The you admit there were no records kept. Then you say you gave up all the papers. (which you didn't, Sheila Fraser submitted a report to Parliament on your non-cooperation) The you blamed a staffer before you realized that they'd sell you out in an instant.



I'm from Muskoka, I've talked to Tony Clement about this and other issues. He's guilty as the day is long. He's guilty of this and several other crimes, including his own 'dirty trick brigade' dating back to 2006 when then current MP Andy Mitchell lost by 20 votes- when not everyone was even able to cast a ballot due to being told the wrong day to vote.



It's an open secret here that 'Cottager Clement' is corrupt but we tolerate this as he supposedly brought in all sorts of money to the community. And he did, but the thing is, that's 50 million dollars that are a bribe and it only goes into some pockets. We have the second highest unemployment rate in Ontario- we also have the highest turn around for profits if you are a developer and connected the the Conservative party.
The projects he personally approved for 50 million dollar (with no minutes of the meetings kept) jacked the price of the land around them up tenfold. His friends and party backers and big regional donors own that land.

Figure it out.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
PortlandZoo
Wait... what?
02:13 PM on 11/30/2011
thanks for the first hand info, tyler. f&f.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kris Dubuque
Proudly Progressive
01:01 PM on 11/30/2011
Hey Tony, we want you to repay this stolen money to us, the taxpayers, before you recommend cutting ANYTHING.
photo
Jay from Ottawa
sovereignty sale, 1.3T OBO
12:48 PM on 11/30/2011
"The fund was set up to beautify Clement's Parry Sound-Muskoka riding in Ontario's cottage country prior to hosting last year's G8 summit. It was used to renovate arenas, enhance streetscapes and build gazebos in towns that were often hours from the summit site in Huntsville.
The auditor general has slammed the government for misleading Parliament about the purpose of the fund and for its failure to produce any documentation showing why 32 projects were ultimately given a chunk of the cash."

"Clement added that "a liar should apologize" and even hinted at legal action should New Democrat MP Charlie Angus refuse to apologize for initiating a "smear campaign full of lies.""

Good luck finding anybody outside of your party and party supporters who support you on this one Tony. To the most of us, you're an embarrassment.
photo
EllaMai
Non-violent complainer. From North of the border.
12:51 PM on 11/30/2011
A 50 million dollar slush fund so he could get re-elected? Clement should be facing a judge and jury for misappropriation!

This was no simple oversight! One does not forget to add a line in official documents about where 50 million dollars was going to be spent and think a simple "oops!" covers it!

After all, the Sponsorship scandal that ousted the Liberals from power was only 3 million dollars misappropriated!
photo
Jay from Ottawa
sovereignty sale, 1.3T OBO
12:56 PM on 11/30/2011
I'm sure if you asked them about it they would say, as was their explanation of the election in/out scandal, that they didn't outright 'break' the rules, they just bent the living hell out of them.

A sad state of affairs we have up here.
12:43 PM on 11/30/2011
If you can't take the heat, get out of the kitchen.

Weenie
photo
EllaMai
Non-violent complainer. From North of the border.
12:12 PM on 11/30/2011
45-50 million dollars was taken from Canadian tax payers and strewn about Clements riding. The official records for that money say it went to "border security". This was not an oversight. This was misappropriation by Clement and Baird.

THIS is the story we should be talking about. Since when is a 50 million dollar slush fund not continuous news?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ted Rosa
12:24 PM on 11/30/2011
Absolutely.
The CBC has dropped the ball on this one.
I don't expect CTV or GLOBAL to carry this as their owners are big supporters of the CONservative party.....
Where's the Public's Enquiry on this can of worms ???
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
PortlandZoo
Wait... what?
02:23 PM on 11/30/2011
are the cons in bed with the mounties too? why isn't there an ongoing investigation?
12:01 PM on 11/30/2011
Shorter Clement :

The NDP accused me of lying, cheating and stealing !

I have proof that I did not cheat !

Now watch this drive.
photo
fromdnorth
OK I checked my micro-bio (didn't know I had one
11:04 AM on 11/30/2011
Arrr - Poor Tony Clement - his reputation has been hurt!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Karmazenuk
Author, Freelance Journalist, Curmudgeon
10:59 AM on 11/30/2011
Alexandre Boulerice, deputy for Rosemont-La Petite Patry, who refuses to post information in his riding in English, or respond to English queries to his Facebook page is defending the integrity of his fellow NDP-ers?

The new Orange has about as much credibility as the new Tories.
photo
fromdnorth
OK I checked my micro-bio (didn't know I had one
11:06 AM on 11/30/2011
Go learn some French and sit down...

Is there a French word for bigot?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Karmazenuk
Author, Freelance Journalist, Curmudgeon
11:29 AM on 11/30/2011
I have a right to be served by my Federal MP in the Official Language of my choice. I speak French. But until my language, culture, history and heritage start getting some respect in the land of my birth, in the land of my ancestors, I see no reason to use French at all.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tyler Austin
Women = people. Corperations ≠ people.
02:05 PM on 11/30/2011
...question. Why are you bringing this up in a story about how 50 million dollars when missing if not to distract people from the article above?

Also I don't think that a Dipper is refusing to speak English. I know a few in Quebec that can't speak passing French, but that's more of an embarassment hten anythign else. My French is sub par. I use a tranlator service for my corrispondence but even thats not good enough. When that happens I politely request a translaton and even the Bloc du Quebeqious are good enough to send me one.

Did you try saying please?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Karmazenuk
Author, Freelance Journalist, Curmudgeon
02:52 PM on 11/30/2011
Boulerice's official parliamentary newsletter is in French only and he has refused all requests to correct this.

As to why I posted it here, because Boulerice doesn't deserve to be painted a hero in this very slanted story.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Adrian31
60% of the time, it works everytime...
10:47 AM on 11/30/2011
"Clement added that "a liar should apologize"

You should take your own advice Tony. I'm waiting...