Gloria Taylor Right-To-Die Case: B.C. Woman Pleads For Legal Right To End Life

Gloria Taylor

First Posted: 11/30/11 02:41 PM ET Updated: 12/01/11 04:05 PM ET

VANCOUVER - One of Gloria Taylor's greatest fears is suffocating before she dies, her weak body struggling for air like a fish out of water.

It's part of the reason the 63-year-old grandmother has "gritted her teeth" to appear before a crowd of media and before a B.C. Supreme Court judge on Thursday in her quest for the right to a doctor-assisted suicide.

Taylor has Lou Gehrig's disease, or amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, which damages the neuromuscular system. She is the reason the hearing on assisted suicide has been accelerated in B.C. Supreme Court.

The right-to-die challenge has been hearing expert evidence for two weeks and the plaintiffs case will open tomorrow.

Taylor won't testify, but she told reporters Wednesday she wants to be present so the judge can put a face to the court affidavit she filed that requests assistance in her death.

"I must make this very clear: I do not want to die," she said. "I want to live every day that I can to the fullest, one day at a time. What I do not want is to die an agonizing, slow, difficult, unpleasant, undignified death."

While she's fighting for the right to end her life, she said she isn't ready to make any decisions about doing that soon.

"I'm not there today, so it's hard for me to say what I will do, how I will do it, with who I will do it — other than my family — or if I will do it. I don't know until I get there."

The fight isn't just for her. Taylor's voice faltered as she spoke of a friend's recent, gruesome death, saying it wasn't peaceful nor dignified, and she does not want to die that way.

She visited with Peter Fenker, who also had Lou Gehrig's disease, in the days before his death and they talked about assisted dying.

"He expressed to me how he wished that he could have that ... and he said 'Gloria you gotta go and you gotta win, you gotta win this for everybody.' He said 'It's too late for me, but you just gotta win this case.'"

Fenker also filed an affidavit with the court asking for the right to die without pain and with a doctors help.

He died just weeks before the hearing began in what Fenker's wife Grace described to the court as a horror-filled four days in hospital where he pleaded with her to help him die.

The trial has already heard from expert witnesses on both sides of the argument.

The B.C. Civil Liberties Association is one of the other five plaintiffs in the case, and the association's lawyer Joe Arvay told the judge when the hearing started in mid-November that the association hopes the lawsuit will prevent Taylor from suffering the same fate as Fenker.

The lawyer for the federal government told the court that if assisted suicide were allowed, there would be no system of safeguards that could guarantee there wouldn't be wrongful deaths.

It's been 18 years since Sue Rodriguez challenged assisted suicide laws and lost in the Supreme Court of Canada.

Taylor said the beliefs of Canadians have changed since then and it's way past time for the "archaic" laws to change.

"The majority of Canadians want this. For the few people that don't they don't have to do it," she concluded.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

Filed by Christian Cotroneo  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:40 AM on 12/01/2011
About 20 years ago thanks to a misdiagnosis, a doctor told me that I had 3 months to live. I had to go home, tell my wife and make plans. A year earlier I had supported a close fried who's father was dying of cancer and the last 6-8 weeks were a nightmare because of pain (not even morphine & heroin helped). It was terrifying to see.

When I spoke with my wife, I had come to terms with the end and only asked that I be let go - DNR kinda thing, especially if I could not have a peaceful end. I simply could not face the fate my friends father.

There comes a point in life (death) when we need to be able to make these choices without interference and knowing that our families can be assured that we have a calm peaceful death by our choice - what is wrong with that choice. Dying is a normal part of living, making it subject to someone elses political or religious belief is wrong. Should there be safety mechanisms, absolutely, but to expect people to die in agony, strip them of dignity and let their family watch is barbaric.
08:36 AM on 12/01/2011
Just let the woman die with dignity and without suffering. You go through life being told to fight for what you believe in. To take responsibility for oneself because no one else will. That only you have control over your life. Unless you have an incurable disease that causes you to suffer and you want to die. Then you have no control and the decision is not yours. I applaud her for what she is standing up for. I support her in her decision and hope that the courts will do the same.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Vapula
Failure is not an option
01:30 AM on 12/01/2011
If she wants to die she would be allowed to. It is the ultimate insult to freedom to insist that a person must do what they are told to do when the opposite harms no one else.Dying with dignity is as important as living with it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AlisonCarnie
I am unique ... just like everyone else
12:59 AM on 12/01/2011
The great love of my life, my dog Tucker, was suffering .. he was twelve and his heart was giving out ... because I loved him I had him put to sleep.

Why can't we give the gift of dying with honour to people ... like so many of us do with our beloved animals?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lulex
Made in Canada
12:25 AM on 12/01/2011
To kill means to cause the death of a person but when death is inevitable, and there is the ability to end life on grounds of compassion, the death cause is still the illness. Without the illness there is no grounds for ending life at all. It's not an unreasonable or immoral to facilitate such a request in my view. It's not killing. It's compassion.
12:20 AM on 12/01/2011
I agree that Gloria is a very brave and heartful woman. One method of ending our life legally and relatively peacefully is outline on this website http://www.thebestgoodbye.com/ My own father at age 88 with a broken hip mended badly and with prostate cancer and COPD elected to leave the earth by not eating or drinking. He was a man of great will power as that is what he did. My sadness is that we didn't have the tools to make this an easier passing. He did tell us he did not have pain and early on he said he felt quite peaceful. I am 73 with fairly good health and have instructed my children that if I get dementia or Alzheimers or have a stroke and cannot talk, that I be allowed to pass peacefully following the method written about by Dr. Thurman. One can learn more about thirst control here http://thirstcontrol.com/article-four-day-fast.php I have also the legal papers necessary. My preference would be to have assisted suicide and I highly support that being legalized. Oregon, Montana and Washington have instituted successfuly assisted suicide for those with a terminal illness with no abuse. I send you the blessings of a peaceful passing on your terms Gloria.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lulex
Made in Canada
12:19 AM on 12/01/2011
I believe in some cases, the right to die should be honored on grounds of human dignity and compassion backed up by reasonable scientific evidence. To allow for a slow painful frightening death is in my view cruel and a form of physical and emotional abuse since clearly circumstances like this can be reasonably prevented to allow for a peaceful death. We must evolve beyond theological references to guide our way on decisions of this nature because Science has evolved. The truth of what these people are actually facing physicall is not something we can simply pretend away. There is in my view no moral justification to deny a compassionate form of death to avert death by way of extended human suffering in cases when death is inevitable.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:41 PM on 11/30/2011
Gloria Taylor is a brave person. For her to forfeit her privacy in the face of such emotional and physical duress is an inspiration to me . I am hopeful her sacrifice will not be in vain.
09:52 PM on 11/30/2011
It is so sad that she has to fight for this while struggling with this disease. She is an amazing woman for doing so. I hope she wins this case so that she has the right to choose her death, and may clear the path for others to do the same.
09:35 PM on 11/30/2011
"The lawyer for the federal government told the court that if assisted suicide were allowed, there would be no system of safeguards that could guarantee there wouldn't be wrongful deaths." That is a blatant lie and scare tactic many safe guards can be put into place. Get out of these peoples lives with your religious crap which is exactly what drives the government and let them die in dignity.
photo
MochasMom
Common sense since 1968
05:57 PM on 11/30/2011
Thank you, Gloria. I hope that the courts will allow you to leave this world on your own terms, because that's how it should be.