Canadian Immigration: More Tolerance As Number Of Newcomers Grow, Study Says

Canadian Immigration

First Posted: 12/05/11 04:11 PM ET Updated: 12/07/11 03:25 PM ET

MONTREAL - A new study suggests Canadians have grown more tolerant of the country's immigration levels — even as the number of newcomers has increased over the years.

A poll of 2,020 people, taken for the Institute For Research on Public Policy, found that 58 per cent of Canadians surveyed last year supported the country's level of immigration.

The findings also suggest that Canadians have had positive views of immigration levels for more than a decade.

The results tell a contrary story to one occasionally found in news headlines that suggest Canadians might be increasingly fed up with accommodating newcomers.

There were actually two prominent news stories Monday in Quebec related to disputes over minority accommodations.

Talk TV was exercised over a report on a Montreal-area municipality's decision to remove Christmas and Hanukkah decorations at city hall. A community group had requested to have Islamic symbols erected as well, and the Town of Mount Royal responded by taking down symbols from all religions, save for a Christmas tree.

There was also a report on the city of Gatineau's immigrant guide book, asking newcomers not to take part in honour killings or cook smelly foods.

But the research director for IRPP's diversity, immigration and integration program said while disputes make flashy headlines, they overshadow the many positive stories of integration that are never told.

"We think sometimes these debates are kind of tough in Canada and things are getting worse — but we're in a lot better shape, in all kinds of ways, than a lot of other countries," Leslie Seidle said Monday in Montreal.

"Contrary to many other countries, particularly in western Europe, we have a strong majority who think that the level of immigration we have right now is about right."

The IRPP study cited a 2010 survey that found close to 60 per cent of people in the United Kingdom thought there were too many immigrants in their country. By comparison, less than 20 per cent of Canadians felt the same way.

In the poll taken by the German Marshall Fund of the United States, Canadians were also found to be more tolerant of immigrants than people in Italy, Spain, the U.S., France, Netherlands and Germany.

But Canadians' views toward immigrants haven't always been as welcoming.

The study by IRPP, a non-partisan, Montreal-based public policy think-tank, suggests there was a shift in public opinion about a decade ago.

From the late 1970s until the early 1990s, the majority of Canadians held negative attitudes about the country's immigration levels.

Following a shift in the 1990s, Canadians' view of immigration has been more positive than negative since the latter part of that decade.

The country opened its doors to 280,000 immigrants last year and has accepted more than 200,000 newcomers annually since 2000, according to Citizenship and Immigration Department statistics cited in the study. In the mid 1980s, fewer than 100,000 immigrants per year came to Canada.

The report argued that Canadians who support immigration believe that multiculturalism is a source of national pride and creates economic benefits.

The research also found that attitudes about immigration varied by region, though each area had majority support for existing levels.

The Prairies (62.8 per cent), Atlantic Canada (62.5 per cent) and Quebec (61.8 per cent) scored higher than the Canadian average. The other regions, included British Columbia (57.4 per cent), Alberta (54.4 per cent) and Ontario (53.5 per cent).

Seidle was asked whether he was surprised the study found one of the most pro-immigration areas in Quebec, a province that has been at the centre of heated debate over minority accommodations.

He blamed Quebec media for putting too much emphasis on disputes, such as a request a few years ago by a Montreal Jewish community group that a local YMCA frost its windows.

The group no longer wanted its youth to be able to see people wearing revealing clothes as they exercised inside.

"These stories have been blown up," said Seidle, who, for example, added that little adjustments to accommodate diet, dress and days of religious observance are made in schools throughout Montreal every day.

"But maybe we end up paying too much attention to this kind of stuff because it's got conflict underneath it."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

MONTREAL - A new study suggests Canadians have grown more tolerant of the country's immigration levels — even as the number of newcomers has increased over the years.A poll of 2,020 people, taken for ...
MONTREAL - A new study suggests Canadians have grown more tolerant of the country's immigration levels — even as the number of newcomers has increased over the years.A poll of 2,020 people, taken for ...
Filed by Ron Nurwisah  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
spytheweb
Black Democrat
11:22 AM on 12/14/2011
Then ship our illegal aliens there. Hey illegals, go to Canada, they have free healthcare!!!
10:24 AM on 12/06/2011
 
Cobourg Legion Village,
164-111 Hibernia Street,
Cobourg, ON, K9A-4Y7.

March 29, 2010,

Rick Norlock, MP.
277 Division Street, Unit #2,
Cobourg, ON, K9A-3R2.
 
Dear Rick Norlock, MP :
Thank you for your response to my letter of February 28, 2010, received March 29, 2010.
Being locked out of my Senior’s apartment by Northumberland County and steeling everything I had left after the Port Hope Police stole my car for filing a complaint against them for doing nothing in the kidnapping of my son and the attack on me. Happened during the time period under the jurisdiction of the Ombudsman’s mandate. Steeling my home and furnishings were prior to the mandate.
I understand you personally were involved in the cover-up of the investigation by Northumberland OPP when I filed a complaint against Northumberland County for the roll they played in the kidnapping. .
I have been advised that you were present at the time. If this information is incorrect please advise.
As you may remember, an investigation was started by Northumberland OPP, but then closed down when everyone realized that the County was involved. The inspecting officer was suddenly sent on holidays then transferred to Campbelford. I was then told to stay away from the office because nothing would be done.
It is amazing how many people have been involved, then ran and hid, when I was serving in the North Atlantic what would have happened if we had done the same?
Richard E. Bridges.
 
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
mirabay
stand for something or you will fall for
03:32 AM on 12/06/2011
I guess they have never been to Cape Breton..................
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JackHoffman
Pundit
12:39 AM on 12/06/2011
Since we are all immigrants they asked immigrants what they thought of immigration. They compared the report to attitudes in the pre-early seventies. What is missing here is how did they determine which immigrants to ask? The pre-seventies 'intolernce' was from immigrants too. White immigrants. Is this study attempting to gauge white immigrant attitude? That's the only reason this study would make sense or even be undertaken. Am I making any sense here?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Vapula
Failure is not an option
11:01 PM on 12/05/2011
More tolerant about what or in juxtaposition to who?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bbertaud
Je ne regrette rien, rien de rien
09:08 PM on 12/05/2011
As long as they respect Canadian laws, learn our official languages and don't become a burden to the our social services they are welcome to come, settle here, work, thrive and contribute to the economic development of this wonderful country
photo
Elk Hunter 1
Organic=Profit
12:24 AM on 12/06/2011
I hope that is how it stays for you guys. You have a good immigration policy, it's fair and pretty reasonable.

The sad thing is, I beleive if things don't start to turn aroiund in the US and Europe you will start to see the "benifits" of illegal immigration.
03:48 PM on 12/06/2011
This immigrant (1970) cound not agree more.
Faved
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dtairtime
It is what it is
05:51 PM on 12/05/2011
Pretty easy to be tolerant when you have more land, open spaces everywhere, no man made environmental disasters all over, no shortages of anything and one tenth the population of the US.
09:14 PM on 12/05/2011
A lot of the Canadian population lives in Cities, not rural areas, especially the immigrants. Peoples ideas have changed, and Canada has become more populated since the 1970's. 5 million people live in Toronto, and Canada's populations is 33 million (ish). People are just becoming more tolerant and accepting towards other ethnic groups, which should be a given since Canada and the US are immigrants countries. I personally am really glad, and I have always embraced other cultures, having best friends who were Korean, German, and from the Bahamas, and I am currently dating a Japanese woman. It doesn't have anything to do with man made disaster, it is a change in the general publics outlook on other cultures.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dtairtime
It is what it is
12:11 AM on 12/06/2011
While that may be some of it you would be naive to admit that a country like the US that has less land mass yet ten times the number of people that those density levels are a point of friction.

It has little to do with cultures (although the increase of the use of spanish has grated a lot of nerves due to costs and time) but everything to do with numbers. We also have most of our people in cities. The amount of land in the us that is parks, tribal, forest service, DNR or otherwise not private is massive.

To put it into perspective we had your current population levels in about 1860. We had much fewer people worried about immigration then too.

We are expected to hit 600 million this century. Virtually all of that via immigration. What will Canada be in the year 2100? 60 million? Yeah we had that in 1890.
photo
Elk Hunter 1
Organic=Profit
12:26 AM on 12/06/2011
America is very tolerant of legal immigration, just like Canadians are. This survey was done on the topic of legal immigration. Give the Canadians 20 years of people comming illegaly and then we will see how tolerant they are of that.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
ModerateCentrist
Independents think for themselves
11:18 AM on 12/08/2011
Exactly. Plus they only have US bordering them, not a bunch of 3rd world countries where illegals can just walk across the border, bringing their 3rd world problems and 3rd world culture with them....when we can't even solve our own problems right now.
Apples And Oranges.
04:44 PM on 12/05/2011
This is nice to see. Any number of studies have demonstrated that all immigrants, even illegal immigrants, create more economic activity than they consume and are therefore good for the country Nice to see a more general acceptance
05:37 PM on 12/05/2011
How'd that work out for the States??
05:52 PM on 12/05/2011
The studies I refer to are American, most particularly the Marielitos study regarding the affect of the Cuban refugee boat-lift on the city of Miami. Immigration in general, and illegal immigration in particular, gets trotted out when we need someone really weak to blame for our troubles. When the economy improves the argument is put away again because of the fact that their labour and talents contribute to the economy and we need all the cheap help we can get.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dtairtime
It is what it is
05:53 PM on 12/05/2011
So far not so good. We have more foreign born people here right now then the entire population of canada. Not including illegals.

Our illegals number enough to be somewhere between about 30-50% of the total population of canada.
photo
Elk Hunter 1
Organic=Profit
12:31 AM on 12/06/2011
Go to So, California and look at thier hospital system and tell me they don't cost money.

Then look at Mexico's influx of American money that is sent to them from the states.

Illegal immigration does cost money, lots of money. Just the cost of keeping the ones who do commit violent crimes is a joke.

Also this survey was done on legal immigration.. If you did the same survey in America most people would also have a good opinion on the subject.
04:38 PM on 12/05/2011
I wonder how many of those 2020 people have recently become Canadian citizens?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EQ8Rhomes
09:34 PM on 12/05/2011
You mean EXACTLY like your clone?: NONE. Nor should they be. Don't expect them all to fill your emptying churches or pick overeating and OBCT--when a car has to labour to get U from A to Diversity is Nature imperative so that we can all survive --it a biological imperative--We have been diverse for a fundamental natural reason--whith out, it we will swim in shallow gene pools and become cretins and die out.