Attawapiskat Housing: Ottawa Ups Offer Of Modular Homes To 22, Flies In Supplies

First Posted: 12/11/11 11:43 AM ET Updated: 12/12/11 09:06 PM ET

Attawapiskat

OTTAWA - Attawapiskat Chief Theresa Spence says her community appreciates the federal government's decision to send more modular homes to the isolated Northern Ontario reserve. But she insists she will not co-operate with a third-party manager appointed by the Harper government to review the band's finances.

Her comments followed a statement by John Duncan, the Minister of Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development, who said on Sunday that Ottawa has purchased an additional seven homes on top of the 15 previously announced, to help the community deal with a housing crisis.

The minister's statement, however, stated matter-of-factly that "Chief Spence has acknowledged the necessity of working with our government, the third-party management team, and Emergency Management Ontario to get help to the residents of Attawapiskat."

"This statement is completely false and untrue and the minister has been misinformed," Spence said in a stern statement issued late Sunday.

Spence said she got a call from Duncan's aid on Sunday morning informing her of the minister's expected announcement.

"I informed the aide that third-party management is not to be part of the announcement. I requested that a copy of the release be emailed to me to verify our conversation," Spence said.

A call from a reporter asking her to comment on Duncan's statement arrived before the email she had requested from the minister's office.

"I appreciate and my members appreciate the assistance being provided for renovations, trailers and expertise," wrote Spence.

"I will not accept our First Nation to operate under third-party management, nor will I pay for them out of our band support allocation."

Ottawa's latest offer also included renovations to the community's healing centre so it could temporarily house vulnerable residents until the new homes arrive.

An official with the minister's office said they hoped winter roads would quickly freeze so that the shipment of the pre-assembled homes can start sometime in January.

Duncan also said wood stoves, composting toilets, plastic sheeting and other supplies were flown into the isolated Northern Ontario community Saturday.

"Our government is working to ensure the people of Attawapiskat have access to safe and warm shelter for the coming months," he said.

NDP critic Charlie Angus, whose riding includes the native community on the coast of James Bay, said the critical issue is who will wind up footing the bill.

"If the government is covering the cost then the community can start dealing with the other massive infrastructure problems, but if the community ends up paying for it through the third party manager, then they will not be any further ahead," he said.

Angus said he is hopeful that government's most recent concession can be the beginning of bringing relief to the impoverished community of about 1,800.

Duncan's press secretary, Moira Wolstenholme, said in an interview that the homes would be paid by Ottawa from new funds. However, the government has told the third-party manager to put any surpluses he finds in the band's housing budget toward the homes.

The plight of the James Bay community is only the highest profile of dozens of First Nations communities across Canada dealing with chronic overcrowding, poor health, poverty and a perpetual lack of decent housing.

The conflict between Attawapiskat and Ottawa comes at a crucial time in First Nations-government relations. Harper and the top First Nations chiefs are meeting at a unique summit at the end of January in an attempt to "reset" the relationship.

Both sides want to end the cycle of dependence and to create the conditions for more autonomous First Nations communities. But so far, no clear plan has emerged from either side, and they continue to fight old battles over money and decision-making power.

Spence said Sunday she was willing to continue negotiating with the government.

"Let us proceed with your (Duncan's) invitation to meet, so that we may discuss and arrive at a compromise," she said.

FLOOR PLAN FOR THE MODULAR HOMES:
FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

OTTAWA - Attawapiskat Chief Theresa Spence says her community appreciates the federal government's decision to send more modular homes to the isolated Northern Ontario reserve. But she insists she wil...
OTTAWA - Attawapiskat Chief Theresa Spence says her community appreciates the federal government's decision to send more modular homes to the isolated Northern Ontario reserve. But she insists she wil...
Filed by Lauren Strapagiel  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
09:36 PM on 12/12/2011
I'd love to see someone go in and document/photograph the state of these homes the day they go in, and then once a year for next decade.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
elizlucinda
a mind is a terrible thing to waste
08:06 AM on 12/12/2011
I'm not sure why the Chief doesn't want a third person advisor. If a hospital has problems that effect the health and safety of patients...which can also include financial health....the Provinces can and will appoint a Supervisor for a short length of time to assist in getting things back to normal. The Province gives money for Hospitals and part of the responsibility when you accept this money is ensuring the money is used properly. I would think the same principles apply here.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Good to know
02:54 AM on 12/12/2011
Hang in there Chief Spence! You are doing an outstanding job in protecting your constituents against horrendous ignorance and blatant racism. You are absolutely right to refuse to pay for a '3rd Party Consultant' that is being imposed upon you. Do not allow them to divert the attention away from the real issues. Stay strong and keep your arguments simple - there is a lot of ignorance - but hopefully the truth will be heard.
06:44 AM on 12/12/2011
"Outstanding job"? Are you kidding me??? Look what she's let things get to. "absolutely right to refuse to pay for a '3rd party consultant'"? Ever heard..."Don't bite the had that feeds you"??? She definately has something to hide.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Good to know
12:41 PM on 12/12/2011
She has nothing to hide. The financial statements are on-line - read them. She is not interested in using the tiny amount of funds they get to pay for a government consultant - it is a waste.
01:16 AM on 12/12/2011
When did it become the people of Canadas' responsibility to provide housing for our aboriginal population? Government has never provided me with free housing.
It has been noted that the reserves with the worst problems don't have year round road access. The typical response would be to suggest building a road. Why not offer each band member with a one way ticket to anywhere else in Canada and a lump sum payment to get them off the dole?
Currently the government spends 12 billion dollars per year on our native population of 400,000. That works out to $30,000.00 per man woman and child per year! I don't see the government spending that kind of money on any other people group. This has to change!
Cheif Theresa Spence should immediately be removed from office and a comprehensive investigation begun into the operations of the band council.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
basinr
The truth and nothing but the truth
07:40 PM on 12/11/2011
I have no problem giving my tax dollars to help them ,but i want the government to look at this Chief Theresa Spence books.She comes off as an ungrateful,ignorant thief !
goleafsgo
A Lie stands on one leg, Truth on two.
12:04 PM on 12/12/2011
Why are you making such accusations based on hearsay?  Show me where this woman has done anything wrong.  Unless you can, I suggest you consider what we do know is a blatant wrong -
the huge amount of money this Emergency Manager is being paid.
photo
novabird
Lover of Life, Radical Centrist
02:48 PM on 12/11/2011
If "Chief Theresa Spence also agreed to renovations to the community's healing centre to temporarily house vulnerable residents until the homes arrive." why did she not do this earlier? She and other band leaders live in the community. Did they not see the dire straits in which their own people were living?

Why did it take an outside manager to force the band leaders to do something to take care of the immediate needs of their own people?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lizsandyotto
05:22 PM on 12/11/2011
My sentiments exactly.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
01:42 PM on 12/11/2011
So the reserve needs all new housing every year?
What happened to the old ones?

Our old farm house was built in 1928.
photo
novabird
Lover of Life, Radical Centrist
02:43 PM on 12/11/2011
I have been working since I was a teenager. One thing I have learned from experience is that I value and take care of things I had to work for and earn. I have noticed over the years that often when people are given a lot of things without working for them they tend to not take very good care of their belongings. I don't know if that is the case here, but it makes me wonder how long it will take before these homes need replacing.
06:17 AM on 12/12/2011
I 100% agree with you. I've worked hard for the things I have for 22 years. I take care of them and have pride in what I have. I will add to that, it is easier to blow away money that is not earned as well. Been there, done that when I was younger and on compensation for an injury. Partied and boozed up my cheques when they came. Good thing I had a boss that got my butt back in gear because I was very close to falling in a deep, dark hole.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ejais
06:16 PM on 12/11/2011
One thing I do know is that house back then were built and made to last....even off reserve and in the cities people realize that materials built for new housing isnt as great as it should be and in fact is bare minium code. It has nothing to do with taking care of a home...anything will slowly degrade over time its how things were built and what materials was used. On reserve time and time again you have been told they do not have bare minium code in fact alot of the materials for any building on reserve is substandard. Rarely does govt official goes out to check to see if things are done properly.They are not asking for new housing every year they just want housing that will with stand their environment and growing population...things that have not been done in decades.
02:25 AM on 12/12/2011
Why don't reserves take responsibility and keep them in good repair. They don't own them - and do not look after them. With no pride in ownership - these people are not functioning, contributors of their own destiny.

They exist but do not live - they are beaten down and suppressed by their own leadership and no one else.. There is no motivation to work or set goals - they have not moved forward. We need to stop feeling guilty about what happened long ago and putting our never ending shame into a bank account for the band councils and chiefs. We all want to be kind and understanding and never insensitive however it is a broken system. The attitude on reservations is blame and victimhood. There is a pay off for that - free money? But they paying a huge price - young people feel hopeless, helpless, and their health is not good They do not grow vegetables, or work the farm land they own near my town - they rent out. What is the reason for this? Survival is natural - but it has disappeared in Aboriginal People. They have a white man's hierarchy - with little self determination possible, yet govt. is the enemy. Social Services/Health Care, courts/penal system are heavily weighted percapita by Aboriginal People. A huge drain on taxpayers and an ongoing sad legacy for Aboriginal People. We need love and discipline in our lives - telling people what they want to hear and giving