Air Canada Obesity Class Action Lawsuit Given Green Light By Quebec Judge

Air Canada Obesity Lawsuit

First Posted: 12/12/11 10:58 AM ET Updated: 12/12/11 11:34 PM ET


A Quebec judge has authorized a class action lawsuit against Air Canada on behalf of obese travellers who had to pay extra because of their disability during a three-year period ending in December 2008.


The Montreal law firm BGA Barristers & Solicitors LLP announced the ruling on Monday. David Bourgoin, a lawyer with the firm, said a similar suit against WestJet was thrown out because of a technicality, but the firm has about 30 days to fix the problem and continue the case against WestJet.


The case against Air Canada is aimed at reclaiming fees the airline charged obese passengers for a second seat or a seat for an attendant before a tribunal and court ruling outlawed the practice.


In January 2008, the Canadian Transportation Agency ruled that Canada's major air carriers — Air Canada and WestJet — must offer a single fare to those with disabilities, including the severely obese, who require two seats to accommodate them. The ruling also said people with disabilities did not have to pay extra for medical attendants who must be seated with them on flights.


The agency estimated the requirement would cost Air Canada about $7 million a year and WestJet about $1.5 million a year.


In November 2008, the Supreme Court rejected an application by the two airlines for permission to appeal the tribunal's ruling, which had the effect of upholding it.


Justice Catherine La Rosa of the Superior Court of Quebec gave the go-ahead to the class action on Oct. 3, BGA said in a news release.


The lawyers said the action was launched on behalf of "all persons domiciled in Canada who are disabled or recognized as having a functional disability by reason of their obesity who had to pay additional fees to Air Canada for the seat of an attendant and/or for a seat adapted to their condition on a domestic flight operated by Air Canada or by another carrier on its behalf between December 5, 2005 and December 5, 2008."


Bourgoin said the parallel case against WestJet was thrown out because the plaintiff who represented the class did not qualify as a member of the class. BGA has to find a qualified representative within about 30 days or the case will expire, he added.


FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA BUSINESS

A Quebec judge has authorized a class action lawsuit against Air Canada on behalf of obese travellers who had to pay extra because of their disability during a three-year period ending in...
A Quebec judge has authorized a class action lawsuit against Air Canada on behalf of obese travellers who had to pay extra because of their disability during a three-year period ending in...
Filed by CBC  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 24
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
09:14 PM on 12/12/2011
Some law firm is going to make a tidy sum on fees for this and consume vauable taxpayer paid court time with a nonsense lawsuit. If you can't fit in one seat (..yes they are tiny seats for everyone) then you should pay for two rather than making life miserable for the smuck beside you when you intrude into their seat space. What about their rights to a comfortable ride that they paid for ?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dread
08:44 PM on 12/12/2011
If you need one seat for each cheek then you have to pay for 2 seats.
05:49 PM on 12/12/2011
My solution is simple.
Since weight = flight cost, I propose that we are all weighed with our baggage at the airport.
For example, a trip from Toronto to Vancouver could be rated at say, $2.05 a pound.
If I weigh 175 lbs. with my 50 pounds of luggage I would pay $461.25 one way.
However, if I weighed 450 lbs. with 100 lbs. of luggage, I would pay $1127.50 one way.
If there are handlers, they also pay. Hmmmm, me thinks problem solved!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
meronnotu
05:43 PM on 12/12/2011
I think if you take up 2 seats you pay for 2 seats. Same rules when I flew with my kids when they were babies. If I didn't want to pay the kid would have to sit on my lap...don't get any ideas.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:05 PM on 12/12/2011
Suck it up fatties. When you weigh as much as 2 people you should pay double. If you're not happy about it, then lose weight
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:32 PM on 12/12/2011
People are animals and it shows.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MsCanuck
Wife, Mother, New Democrat, Pro-Choice, Atheist
04:30 PM on 12/12/2011
Since when is obesity a disability? Most times - I will give you that there are medical explanations for "some" of the obese, but for most it's a lifestyle choice, they just consume too much calories and don't exercise enough.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Whistlejackett
Hey stop doing that
04:15 PM on 12/12/2011
Obesity isn't a disability in the first place. Obese people know airplanes have limited space so take a train or a truck and trailer.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AC Fraser
bend before you break
04:06 PM on 12/12/2011
Who decides when morbid obesity is the result of a disability? Or is morbid obesity, in and of itself, considered to be the disability, even if it's a direct result of a person's own actions?
photo
Jay from Ottawa
sovereignty sale, 1.3T OBO
04:00 PM on 12/12/2011
The only problem here was the original ruling stating Air Canada and friends had to have a one-person one-price and free seats for those who need a assistant.

Listen, it's a airline. It's also a business.

You need two seats ? Pay for two seats. Can my wife and I duct tape eachother together and pay for a single ticket arguing that we're really just one big person ? What if a family of 5 has a family member that's so disabled they need 4 'personal assistants', can the entire family travel on a single ticket ?

If 310 people want to board a 300 seat plane and 10 of them are seriously obese, do we tell the 10 big ones to wait for the next flight ? Or do we put 290 people on a 300 seat plane and ask 20 people to wait for the next flight ?

Sadly Air Canada is on the hook for this one. That's their fault for not complying with the new rules. The real problem here though, are the new rules.
04:37 PM on 12/12/2011
Anyone else thinking of the "Homer gains 63 pounds to go on disability" episode of The Simpsons?
"I'm sorry, sir. Our seats aren't designed for a man of your.... carriage. We'll offer you a garbage bag full of popcorn to go away."
photo
Jay from Ottawa
sovereignty sale, 1.3T OBO
09:41 AM on 12/13/2011
lol - I remember all too well :D
03:54 PM on 12/12/2011
Flying from YVR to LA I was seated between two obese people who were travelling together, but had chosen to take the window & aisle seatss. I was squashed in the middle. Their fat was literally spilling over onto my seat. It was not possible to put the arm rests down. My choice was to spend the entire flight with my arms straight out in front of me or up in the air, or resting my arms of the excess flesh of two strangers, which is the option I went with. I do not think I shoud have paid for an entire seat for myself, because I did not in fact get an entire seat to myself. Maybe I should have filed a lawsuit. Or they should each have paid a portion of my seat cost.
04:25 PM on 12/12/2011
You should filed a lawsuit! You did pay for a ticket, which means you bought a space between two armrests on particular data and flight. Period! Call captain abd ask to move to monsters into cargo compartment!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
russell merifield
07:36 AM on 12/13/2011
On modern planes, like one I just travelled on between Bucharest and Paris, the seats are not wide enough for three fairly normal people to travel three abreast. On my full flight I sat in the middle of two largish but normal sized men. I was the smallest at about 77Kg or 175 pounds. My two companions were both maybe closer to 85 or 190 pounds. Height was about 180- 185 cm so weight is proportionate. There was no arm rest really for anyone, and the leg room and distance to the seat is so short that moving at all is a challenge.

What do we do about this?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JTCan
03:39 PM on 12/12/2011
My pet peeve is that when an overweight person doesn't buy the second seat and the person sitting next to them is squashed in. That person has paid the full price for a full seat. They should not have to suffer thru a flight on half a seat.
03:28 PM on 12/12/2011
I have a disability: I'm nearsighted. Do I launch class-action lawsuits demanding that every document put in front of me from restaurant menus to government forms be printed in two inch high letters so I can read them? No, I pay for glasses out of my own pocket.

Same deal if you're obese: Suck it up (if you'll pardon the expression) and pay the price.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jane Claymore
03:16 PM on 12/12/2011
I mean..I have to pay for extra baggage..isn't that the same thing? And so disgusting to get crowded..put them in first class where there's more room.
09:26 AM on 12/14/2011
Why don't we just put them in labor camps until they are thin enough not to be so disgusting? That'll teach em.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jane Claymore
03:14 PM on 12/12/2011
Yeah. They should pay extra.