Attawapiskat: John Duncan, Aboriginal Affairs Minister, To Meet With Chief Theresa Spence

Theresa Spence

First Posted: 12/12/11 03:30 PM ET Updated: 12/15/11 11:33 AM ET

OTTAWA - Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan says he's setting up a meeting with the chief of the troubled Attawapiskat First Nation in an attempt to resolve the impasse that has raised tempers on the remote reserve.

Chief Theresa Spence fired off a second, sharply-worded letter to the minister on the weekend, accusing Duncan of being misinformed about her willingness to co-operate with a third-party manager.

But she said she also wanted to meet him face-to-face to come to a compromise.

The two met in Ottawa last week while Spence was in town for annual meetings of chiefs, but parted on shaky terms over Ottawa's insistence that all financial decisions be handed over to a third party.

Duncan's officials say they are now trying to arrange a time and place for a second meeting, although they would not say whether Duncan would be willing to travel to the northern Ontario community.

Duncan also says the third-party manager is already delivering fruitful results for the government — a claim that is likely to be a non-starter for the Cree band.

"This continued insistence of third party management is causing yet another crisis in our community," Spence writes in bold typeface in her weekend letter.

Ottawa and the band have agreed to what kind of emergency aid should be provided. They have also agreed to a full audit of the band's spending over the past five years.

But the federal government's decision to place the band's day-to-day finances under the control of an outside consultant continues to be a major roadblock to progress in Attawapiskat.

While the band has no choice in the matter, Duncan did not repeat the controversial statements on Monday that he said on Sunday — that the band leaders were ready to work with the appointee.

But Duncan did defend the appointment of Jacques Marion of BDO Canada's Winnipeg branch as productive.

"He is already getting results for the community with the purchase of 22 modular homes (using federal funds) to address the urgent housing needs," Duncan said in a statement released by his office.

"He will also ensure that programs and social services continue to be delivered to the community. Our government has acted in good faith and full transparency."

New Democrat MP Charlie Angus, whose riding includes Attawapiskat, said the minister is just spreading false information since the band itself had already made arrangements for new housing and emergency aid.

"The third-party manager is not co-ordinating relief. That is a fiction," Angus said in the House of Commons.

"It was the community that ordered the trailers; it was the community that asked for emergency measures, and it is the community that is not going to pay for this gold-plated emissary who is twisting his thumbs over in Winnipeg."

The appointee is getting about $1,300 a day, but he is not working on the reserve after band council members told him to leave upon his arrival last week.

Third-party management is being used to control finances in about 12 reserves across the country right now, according to the Aboriginal Affairs Department.

But a government evaluation of that type of intervention, as well as numerous reports from the auditor general, have shown the system to be inefficient and ineffective at solving basic problems that drive some reserves into crisis.

"Why did they ignore every single finding of the Auditor General of Canada with respect to management of these questions when it came to dealing with the crisis in Attawapiskat?" Liberal interim leader Bob Rae asked in the Commons.

The government has been revising the way it intervenes in the management of troubled bands' affairs, but in the case of Attawapiskat, quick action needed to be taken, said the minister's statement.

"This is an immediate measure taken to prioritize and take action to respond to the urgent needs of the community," the statement in response to questions reads.

"This is not a long term measure; our government strongly supports self-government for First Nations."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

OTTAWA - Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan says he's setting up a meeting with the chief of the troubled Attawapiskat First Nation in an attempt to resolve the impasse that has raised tempers on...
OTTAWA - Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan says he's setting up a meeting with the chief of the troubled Attawapiskat First Nation in an attempt to resolve the impasse that has raised tempers on...
Filed by Christian Cotroneo  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 47
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
butchcliff
The future is unwritten
07:43 AM on 12/14/2011
For this band alone, apparently $12 mil went to chiefs & other salaries. Spence claimed $70K yr. Where did the rest of the $34mil go? Certainly not to housing & infrastructure
09:10 AM on 12/13/2011
I'm sorry, but the 3rd party representative is receiving how much?!!!
$1300 per day??
Now you see, this is what's wrong with the system. When a government "allegedly" dedicated to stopping wastage is spending an obscene amount on someone to come in and fix an open wound with band-aids instead of examining the problem with a longer view taken, and a proper one, if it's not to come back and bite them in the buttocks again.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Miller Time
09:00 AM on 12/13/2011
If the Band has already made arrangements, why could it not have done so before?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nete peedham
09:41 AM on 12/13/2011
Because the Harper government is being obstructive.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Miller Time
10:20 AM on 12/13/2011
How have they obstructed the spending of $90 million over the past years? If they can build accommodation NOW, then they surely could have built accommodation THEN.

Nothing to do with the Harper Government.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Miller Time
10:21 AM on 12/13/2011
Now go and have a neat pee.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tony frm Banff
Search for truth,not spin
08:35 AM on 12/13/2011
Here is a link http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attawapiskat_First_Nation for some of you people spewing your hate for the people of Attawapiskat on here. Just read up a little and you can see the predicament these people are in.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Angus12
07:50 AM on 12/13/2011
I want to see a picture of Chief Spence's house.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Angus12
07:45 AM on 12/13/2011
I'd like to see a picture of Chief Spence's house.
02:14 AM on 12/13/2011
Anyone know what Chief Theresa Spence makes per year?

http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com/2010/11/23/lorne-gunter-want-your-kids-to-grow-rich-encourage-them-to-become-first-nations-chiefs/#ixzz1687X0nuw
A month ago, the Canadian Taxpayers Federation (CTF) released a report about on-reserve compensation based on partial statistics provided by the Indian Affairs department. At the time, the CTF calculated that 30 of the country’s 577 chiefs made more than the average — $110,000 – received by the 10 provincial premiers.

In all, nearly 60 chiefs examined in the CTF’s first assessment were paid more than $90,000 in 2008-09. And because their salaries were paid on-reserve, they were tax-free, the equivalent of about $155,000 for a non-Aboriginal Canadian.
03:00 AM on 12/13/2011
That is not true the numbers put together by the right wing Canadians Taxpayers Federation were adjusted to take into account that they did not pay tax as though that had something to do with it.
09:20 AM on 12/13/2011
If you look at the bands financials, the Chief makes 70k a year. Not unreasonable and not the point in this situation. Do a little research before you post.
01:11 AM on 12/13/2011
*sigh* I really hope that it's not one of 'those' situations I've experienced in the past working on reserves, where 90% of the people live in horrific squalor (we're talking black mold, unheated houses using the stove for heat, subflooring, etc. etc.) while 10% are driving brand new vehicles, populating the council with the same last names, and renovating brand new mansions. I understand the politics of poverty that leads up to that, but it's so darn sad.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nete peedham
09:38 AM on 12/13/2011
Name them.
03:36 PM on 12/13/2011
Why? What's the point? Shaming them or to argue my point? It's hardly an isolated incident.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
north of 60
Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati
01:04 AM on 12/13/2011
Native leaders all across Canada need to wake up to the fact that the Canadian taxpayers who foot the bill are growing increasingly dissatisfied with the greed, corruption, nepotism, and human rights abuses by leaders towards their own people.
The disparity between rich and poor is deplorable on most reserves, and it's time this issue was exposed to the light of day.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nete peedham
09:38 AM on 12/13/2011
Oh, yeah, another paternalistic jerk telling others what they "need".

What you "need", buddy, is an education.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
11:01 PM on 12/12/2011
They obviously need more chiefs and councillors, 4 chiefs and 19 councilors simply isn't enough for a band of about 1500 people.

May I suggest 200 chiefs and 1300 councillors?
photo
SiameseTrainer
...we are Sia..mese if you don't please..
11:24 PM on 12/12/2011
Same ol' karap, different day, eh chicken hawk?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gravescanada
07:49 AM on 12/13/2011
Canadastan is nothing more than a troll!
05:54 PM on 12/12/2011
My taxpayer money should be well spent and accounted for so the first question that the Chief needs to answer is where did all the money go over the last 10, 20, 30+ years ? Can you account for every penny and if you can not, why should you get anymore. Then for the minister don't send a useless third party manager there are capable "First Nation" managers out there, you and the chief(s) have to find them and vette them before appointing them or money will "vanish" as ususal. It is disgusting how the First Nation people have been treated and living in conditions you would expect in a favela or shanty town in some so called third world countries. The First Nation leadership can't just shurg off blame for thier own mis-management. They have/are failing their own people by making excuses. There are many First Nation bands that are suceeding, they need to find out and clean-out the leadership of those that are not and use the others as a model going forward.
06:37 PM on 12/12/2011
They whine and complain about self-goverment. Well--- let them manage their own funds. Don't come crying back after the cash is gone and there is nothing left to show for it. Stewards of the land?-- indeed.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
09:14 PM on 12/12/2011
It's an interesting situation.

I don't believe any reserve still wants full self-governance anymore, since the social problems on reserves would be crippling (Feel free to correct me. I'm reaching this conclusion because I don't think anyone -especially reserve leaders - thinks that all reserves could manage by being 100% independent). They don't want self-governance. and by giving them all this free money we've just created a culture of dependence.

If any group of people was segregated from society and then given free money, we would see all of these problems arise in the exact same way.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Glass Cannon
Let every eye negotiate for itself.
07:00 PM on 12/12/2011
First Nations groups do have to report to the government on finances even when not in third party management, and must have federal approval for expenditures on federal money provided to them. The federal government likely has records over the time period you proscribe. Perhaps they will become answerable too.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
09:06 PM on 12/12/2011
This is a false claim that's repeated on here many times.

The Indian Act says only vague reporting and general approval is required. A reserve doesn't have to report anything more than "We will be spending X dollars on administration", and have the funds released to them for use in whatever "administration" is.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Miller Time
09:02 AM on 12/13/2011
Proscribe? You surely mean describe.