Justice Murray Sinclair, Truth Commissioner, Blasts Attawapiskat-Ottawa Feud

Attawapiskat

First Posted: 12/13/11 07:03 PM ET Updated: 12/15/11 11:35 AM ET

VICTORIA - The chairman of Canada's Truth and Reconciliation Commission for victims of residential schools has harsh words for aboriginal leaders and the federal government about the housing crisis on northern Ontario aboriginal reserves.

Justice Murray Sinclair said Tuesday that while Ottawa's silence on the squalid living conditions of the people in Attawapiskat is unacceptable, threats of civil disobedience coming from the James Bay area aboriginal leaders aren't helping bridge the divide that exists in aboriginal relations in Canada.

He said he is especially concerned about civil disobedience comments coming from the Cree leaders, saying they perpetuate among young people a disrespectful relationship between aboriginals and non-aboriginals.

"That's not going to establish a constructive relationship or maintain a constructive relationship," said Sinclair, in Victoria to announce a series of truth and reconciliation hearings on Vancouver Island in the New Year.

"I'm concerned that if we keep up this tone of conversation into the future that we're going to escalate as we go forward," he said.

"I'm very concerned that we need to establish a proper foundation for our leadership to talk to each other in a respectful way, so that our children will talk to each other in a respectful way and that everybody will grow up as Canadians believing in this country."

Theresa Spence, chief of Attawapiskat in Northern Ontario, has been harshly critical of Ottawa's decision to impose a third-party manager to control the Cree band's finances.

Prime Minister Stephen Harper has openly questioned whether money has been mismanaged, saying Ottawa has spent $90 million on the reserve over five years and has not seen satisfactory results.

As a result, there has been rumblings from the band about civil disobediance and Spence has said she will not co-operate with the overseer.

Sinclair said the commission, established in 2007 as part of the Indian Residential Schools Settlement Agreement, is seeking to create a national memory of the 150-year residential school experience through the voice of people who attended the schools.

He said the report, which aims to renew the relationship between aboriginals and non-aboriginals in Canada, is due by 2014.

The federal government has set aside $60 million for the commission's work, which Sinclair said was not enough money to fully explore the mandate of the commission, which now is looking to find ways to continue to tell the story.

Sinclair said the commission wants to change Canada's perception of aboriginals among non-aboriginals and aboriginals.

"Aboriginal kids were taught that they were savages, that they were heathens, their cultures were irrelevant and that they had to assimilate," he said. "That very same message was being given to you and your parents and your grandparents in the public school system."

Up to 2,500 Vancouver Island aboriginals are expected to speak at the hearings set for Port Hardy, Campbell River, Port Alberni and Duncan in February and March.

Two days of hearings in April are scheduled for Victoria.

Sinclair said the commission is planning an aboriginal festival in Vancouver Sept. 18-21, where it will invite new Canadians — people who have immigrated to Canada — to introduce them to aboriginal traditions.

The first government-funded, church-run residential schools opened in the 1870s. The last one closed outside Regina in 1996.

The commission was created under the Indian Residential Schools Settlement Agreement reached between the federal government, aboriginal groups and former students.

Former students are also eligible for compensation under the court-approved agreement.

The commission, which consists of Sinclair and fellow panellists Marie Wilson and Wilton Littlechild, has held national events in Winnipeg, Inuvik, N.W.T., and Halifax since June 2010.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

VICTORIA - The chairman of Canada's Truth and Reconciliation Commission for victims of residential schools has harsh words for aboriginal leaders and the federal government about the housing crisis on...
VICTORIA - The chairman of Canada's Truth and Reconciliation Commission for victims of residential schools has harsh words for aboriginal leaders and the federal government about the housing crisis on...
Filed by Christian Cotroneo  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 46
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
02:01 AM on 12/16/2011
RCAP
(Vol.1/Part1/CH.7)

"We have characterized this fourth stage in the relationship between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal people in Canada as a period of negotiation and renewal, and it is this stage that is still under way. By the early 1970s, it was clear even to most people in non-Aboriginal society that substantial changes in the relationship were required, and negotiations taking various forms ensued — at road block sites, in legislative offices, across the constitutional bargaining table and in international forums. These discussions gradually brought about a better understanding of the Aboriginal perspective and some movement toward a middle ground. A particularly important development was the adoption of a constitutional provision that recognized and affirmed existing Aboriginal and treaty rights The negotiations were far from smooth, however, and reversals were not uncommon."
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
01:43 AM on 12/16/2011
To further understand the issue:

Rolland Chrisjohn wrote about this: Indians being "clients" to settler policies & programs.
Kinda hard to encourage 'self-gove
­­rnance" is the funding goes to government depts. & agencies eh?

The Circle Game: Shadow & Substance in the Residentia­l School Experience­..‏

http://www­.nativestu­dies.org/n­ative_pdf/­circlegame­.pdf

The Circle Game: Shadows and Substance in the Indian Residentia­­l School Experience in Canada
By Roland Chrisjohn and Sherri Young
Genre: Native Studies
ISBN 978-1-8947­­78-05-3
http://www­­.theytus.­c­om/
http://rea­­dingcanli­t­.com/

speech delivered in Edmonton, Alberta by Dr. Roland Chrisjohn
Member of Iroquois Confederac­­y (Oneida), healer ("psycholo­­gist"), author of The Circle Game
Date of speech unknown

http://sis­­is.native­w­eb.org/r­es­school/­chr­isjohn­.htm­l

The Circle Game: Shadow & Substance in the Residential School Experience..‏

http://www.nativestudies.org/native_pdf/circlegame.pdf

&

http://www.indigenouspolicy.org/ipjblog/post/The-Apologia-Canadiana-lessons-for-an-Indian-Boarding-School-Apologia-Americana.aspx

&

http://www.irvingstudios.com/child_abuse_survivor_monument/ResidentialInstitutions.htm
04:34 PM on 12/14/2011
For the Canadian Government to keep pouring $$$ at the Fist Nations is not what is required. There MUST be more listening to the first nations people and they must have a Voice in the building of relationship between themselves and the non- aboriginals.
The chief of Attawaspiskat must abide by the same rules as the rest of us. She must be accountable for the 90 million$$ whether she likes it or not.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
05:56 PM on 12/14/2011
Agreed.

But I don't believe the majority of problems in reserves can be 'talked out'. You'll find the same problems with any group of people that's segregated from society. Only re-integrating the aboriginal population into Canadian society will put an end to their problems. Let's not forget that none of the other minorities in Canada have anywhere close to the same problems that aboriginal's face.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Glass Cannon
Let every eye negotiate for itself.
01:50 PM on 12/14/2011
Nothing wrong with a little non-violent civil disobedience if no one will listen to you. Sometimes you have to "throw an epée" to create a receptive audience. It's part of free speech and the freedom to speak. Communication can resolve all problems.

That said, this is a terrific stance expressed by the Justice, and far from being inappropriate I believe his comment go hand in glove with the purpose of his post, and his duties. He is on the side of open communication and mutual understanding.

We do need a new, better, and more respectful relationship between our peoples, especially in light of the educational errors the Justice mentions in relation to the curriculum of all parties.

Bravo!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wren Egan
01:22 PM on 12/14/2011
I feel as though a lot of these comments prove his point. An engaged dialogue, engaged by all sides, is not only the most productive way forward, it is, as Sinclair has mentioned, a good example to set for future generations, aboriginal and non-aboriginal alike. It's time we stop maintaining enemies and start to bolster cooperation on all sides. Not easy, but a refusal to discuss doesn't bring things forward with a government who they feel is happy to simply ignore the problem.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
12:57 PM on 12/14/2011
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=K9xzrD5tizI

Sunnews hits it out of the park again.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SayBlade
This micro bio intentionally left blank.
01:35 PM on 12/14/2011
More like out to lunch.

Charlie Angus mute on Attiwapiskat in the media?
Oct 29 2005
Nov 3 2005
Apr 29 2008
Jun 11 2008
May 26 2009
Aug 11 2009
Thanks for playing.

When has Stephen Harper visited Attawapiskat?

"...corruption and waste we would never let a non-Indian get away with..." G20 policing, fake lake, F-35s, prisons we don't need...

The reason DeBeers sent in the all weather mobile homes is because it was responsible for the toilets backing up destroying the homes. DeBeers dumped a sh_load of sewage into the system causing it to back up. This happened twice!

Nobody told Levant to feel personally guilty about anything. His tired script is his own.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
08:08 PM on 12/14/2011
Source please.
Are you sure it was all Debeer's fault?
Maybe a bit of maintenence on the sewage system would have prevented it.
Was it even their fault?

Let's see some proof.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:02 AM on 12/14/2011
We have a "Truth Commissioner" ?? Wow, the conservatives must hate him.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mike vdB
Get involved, always question, don't just exist.
10:39 AM on 12/14/2011
Justice Sinclair's feelings and words speak the truth towards this issue, but I feel he is adding to the politicization of the whole process and to the commission he was charged to complete. Justices that are appointed to commissions and public inquiries are supposed to be non-partisan and impartial. Any comments they provide publicly should wait until after their tenure is done.
This comment has been removed.
09:57 AM on 12/14/2011
While I appreciate the sentiment of needing to work together it is inaccurate to suggest the people of Attawapiskat are threatening civil disobedience. Chief Spence has consistently said, most recently again in a press release of Dec. 11, that she will work with the government. She has not threatened civil disobedience. She objects, rightfully so, and will seek remedy in the courts if necessary (following the law) to the 3rd party manager which was not so much a punishment from Harper, than a communications exercise to change the national dialogue in the press. It worked, his numbers rose 10% in popular polls. Chiefs Spence's books are open and have been posted for the world to see on line since 2005, the audits are in, the community was on a recovery plan since the cost of evacuation a few years ago put them in the hole. If the budget for FN's only increases by 2% every year and the population grows by 4% - anybody can see where that leads. Funding shortfalls consistently that eventually push communities over the edge. BTW - per capita spending on each Toronto resident is: $24,000 per year. Per capita spending on each Attawapiskat resident is $11,000 per year. See http://www.oktlaw.com/blog/taking-a-second-look-at-those-attawapiskat-numbers/ for clear information. ALL of our conversations must begin and be based in fact for any resolution to be found and that is why I think Justice Sinclair should not be stepping into this.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Glass Cannon
Let every eye negotiate for itself.
01:56 PM on 12/14/2011
Thanks for this information, it provides good perspective for people who want to understand more about this, like myself.
photo
freeSpeakr
I stand on the shoulders of giants
09:03 AM on 12/14/2011
To understand Stephen Harper's human-dominionist views see these articles. They provide an interesting look at those who influenced him and helped him rise to power. They also help to explain and illuminate his view of humanity and his policies.

http://www.walrusmagazine.com/articles/the-man-behind-stephen-harper-tom-flanagan/

http://thetyee.ca/Mediacheck/2005/11/29/HarperBush/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
04:43 AM on 12/14/2011
Here we are again. BLASTING and SLAMMING our way through another day in Canadian politics.
Exciting times my friends. EXCITING times.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Good to know
01:10 AM on 12/14/2011
While I appreciate that Sinclair does not want bad press to unravel the good work of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, I believe he needs to support Chief Spence in this media war. Harper is NOT playing nice, neither is DeBeer with their sewage polluting the drinking water - and I believe there are another 20 reserves undergoing '3rd party evaluation' - meaning living conditions are unacceptable there too. Perhaps the Truth Commission needs to open the conversation to include all of these issues faced by our First Nations - there are many great lessons and strategies to be learned from the Occupy movement in the US.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
02:53 AM on 12/14/2011
"there are many great lessons and strategies to be learned from the Occupy movement in the US."

Yeah, if the phone lines go down that human mic thing could come in handy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gravescanada
08:00 AM on 12/14/2011
How is 60 million dollars not enough for the Truth Commission?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Leanne McKenzie
You can't make this sh*t up.
10:05 PM on 12/13/2011
Harper is going to nickle and dime them to death while pouring money into more prisons that he can fill up with disproportionate numbers of First Nations people.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
11:10 AM on 12/14/2011
Purely ignorant post.
Reserves receive more money than they need. Corruption is a big problem among reserves, and one of the biggest reasons why most reserves have so little to show for so much money.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SayBlade
This micro bio intentionally left blank.
12:31 PM on 12/14/2011
I would say prescient post. Corruption is a problem in the federal government and one of the biggest reasons a lot of taxpayer money has flowed into private coffers never to be seen again.

Besides, even if you do have a high salary, you still have to pay $18 for a box of cereal on sale in Att.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Leanne McKenzie
You can't make this sh*t up.
09:20 PM on 12/14/2011
And you know this how?

I'm pretty sure reserves without income generating natural resources have never received more money than they need. Never the money they do need.
09:12 PM on 12/13/2011
First, I don't see that 'talking nice' like the last couple hundred years have done much for our First Nations.

But secondly, having said that, don't think that the current fascist Harper government would not blink to bring in the military to quash any little civil disobedience, thus we're back to 'talking nice' and trying to work with a clearly ideologically far right-wing, fascist government.

No wonder the consideration of civil disobedience.
09:46 PM on 12/13/2011
Talking nice and handing piles of money to a moronic Chief who doesnt know where it went!
10:56 PM on 12/13/2011
the chief knows where it went, its all accounted for in the financial statements.
photo
freeSpeakr
I stand on the shoulders of giants
08:56 AM on 12/14/2011
If we're not careful we may hear the words of Nelson Mandela – "It is useless and futile to continue talking peace and non-violence against a government whose only reply is savage attacks."
Lets hope it doesn't get to that point.