Restrictions Eased For 10,000 Foreign Caregivers

Nanny Canada Caregiver Permit

First Posted: 12/14/11 08:16 PM ET Updated: 12/15/11 08:34 PM ET


The federal government recently issued at least 10,000 open work permits for caregivers from other countries, CBC News has learned.


The permits allow the caregivers to continue to work in Canada, without being tied to the family that sponsored them to come here. Many caregivers have complained about alleged mistreatment, long hours for little pay and poor work conditions.


Granting an open work permit allows caregivers to leave sponsoring employers without losing their permission to be in the country.


Advocates for foreign caregivers in Canada said the government's move is unprecedented.


Early Christmas for caregivers


Manuela Gruber Hersch, president of the Association of Caregiver and Nanny Agencies of Canada, said it's an early Christmas present for caregivers.


"We're not 100 per cent sure what the motives are, especially in the light that there's been no announcement," she said. "We aren't sure what the government's position is or what their objective is."


Citizenship and Immigration Canada has not responded to requests for an explanation.


In past interviews, Minister Jason Kenney has said he was looking for ways to continue bringing in foreign caregivers while protecting their rights.


It's also not clear if this is a one-off or a permanent policy change.


Live-in caregivers complaining about alleged poor treatment has had at least one high-profile example in recent years: Former Brampton-Springdale MP Ruby Dhalla faced questions in 2009 over allegations she and her mother mistreated two live-in caregivers from the Philippines.


Dhalla denied the accusations, but it has been speculated that the controversy played a role in her losing her seat in the last federal election.


Recently in British Columbia, two immigrant women who had worked as live-in domestic help in the Lower Mainland said they were treated like slaves and kept in near imprisonment by their employers.


FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

The federal government recently issued at least 10,000 open work permits for caregivers from other countries, CBC News has learned. The permits allow the caregivers to continu...
The federal government recently issued at least 10,000 open work permits for caregivers from other countries, CBC News has learned. The permits allow the caregivers to continu...
Filed by Christian Cotroneo  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:10 PM on 12/15/2011
Does this mean that they can shift to a new "live in care giver" position with a different family or they can, once in the country, work for 2 weeks as a caregiver, then start competing for jobs the average Canadian actually wants to do?

I see this inflating costs and causing retention issues for upper-middle class folks who can afford this but can't afford to pay 2 or 3x minimum wage for it. There are already a lot of horror stories about nanny poaching when folks have non-foreign nannies.

I'm vehemently against abusive situations for these folks but at the same time having the stability of KNOWING you have a commitment and an arrangement that is stable with a nanny to care for your children is peace of mind. Knowing that every time your nanny goes out with her nanny friends on her day off is another chance she'll find out about another job somewhere else that pays a few dollars more and POOF, your are in deep trouble, burning vacation days while scrambling to find a replacement nanny (get ready to PAY a lot more for a local because imports take a long time to recruit) or a short notice day care slot (shudder!!! good luck).

For every happy story I hear of a great nanny I hear several parental nightmares... and yes occasionally one of an abused nanny. I just hope this policy doesn't shift some happy scenarios into the parental nightmare category.
photo
CarlyQ
Without followers, evil cannot spread.
11:57 AM on 12/15/2011
It's the conservative governments solution to the child care/elder care crisis - hire people who don't know their rights to work for peanuts. One (wo)man's exploitation is another (wo)man's advantage.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
06:22 AM on 12/15/2011
This way the workers have options. Stay, go home or find another job.Fair enough.
05:11 AM on 12/15/2011
Most care givers entering the Canadian program are Filipino . A fine bunch of People. They often have children back home and send money to support them. There are many stories of worker abuse in these relationships. The caregivers are expected to walk dogs, cook, clean, basically be house servants. The hours are very long. It takes a special person to be a good care giver. Most of the staff I have witnessed in old folks homes and many hospitals are also Filipino. A very tough job for someone to continue to care about someone else's family member at the point where human dignity sadly falls away. The demographic makeup of Canada tells me this is a growing field. Maybe we will be sending our old folks abroad for care.
thediamond0000
as above, so below.
12:52 AM on 12/15/2011
Also, I have no problem with immigration. In fact, diverse cultures and immigration have been shown to encourage economic growth.

However, temporary visa encourage people to think of Canada as a temporary home, which leads them to send the money away. Now, let their family come here with them, and they have no reason to go home or send their money there. There by, keeping the money here, and since were already in a big consumerist ponzi scheme, these people will spend that money here, growing our economy.
thediamond0000
as above, so below.
12:49 AM on 12/15/2011
Harper: helping non Canadians take Canadian jobs.

Then again, these people generally don't know much about workers rights, won't complain and will work for lower wages. Oh and most of their money LEAVES Canada in the form of remittance. Which then brings down the economy yet again.

Pay Canadians fair wages, keep the jobs in Canada, and help the economy.

For an economist, Harper is a complete fool as basic economic principle.
05:38 AM on 12/15/2011
Problem being the jobs foreign workers are taking- Canadians wont accept, beneath their dignity or I suspect maybe just too lazy!!
The "Occupy Movement" provred that to me- when they showed the faces on tv from the Halifax occuption, I recognized a lot of them- mostly from the busy intersections at rush hour traffic-Panhandling!
The same ones the farmers in Nova Scotia tried to hire at harvest time-no luck there, they had to bring in foreign workers!
Canada is a wealthy country but a lot of the deadbeats should realize that to be owed a living you have to work for it
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gravescanada
07:38 AM on 12/15/2011
Yeah, right, have the farmers posted the jobs on websites? Have they coordinated with any agencies to provide transportation to the middle of nowhere to do the job?

http://www.jobbank.gc.ca/res-eng.aspx?CmmGrp=GNS001,GNS002,GNS004,GNS006,GNS007,GNS008,GNS009,GNS012,GNS014,GNS015,GNS016,GNS018,GNS019,GNS020&Categ=8*&OpPage=50&Stdnt=No
11:28 PM on 12/14/2011
How about looking after the caregivers in this country. If one stays home to look after one that is disabled -there is little assistance from any agency - provincial or federal or private - let alone financial assistance.
These new caregivers will get paid for what most of us do for nothing. Are these new caregivers also going to work for nothing - oh I forgot - it's the Conservatives in power.
Now that we are of the Kyoto , our population will suffer major health issues - and the Conservatives are ahead of the game - they have got these caregivers already lined up for those that get will get sick.
Must say a real "PRO Act" rather than a " RE Act".
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
trying2help
mom doc
10:56 PM on 12/14/2011
But- they cannot speed up visas for family members of legal residents? Not fair!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:55 PM on 12/14/2011
This is wonderful news. It's so contrary to Conservative policy that I also wonder, "What's the catch?"
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
11:10 PM on 12/14/2011
Beats the liberals "Visas for Strippers Who Donate to the Liberal Party" program
02:59 PM on 12/15/2011
Someone donated to the liberal party? LIES!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mike Keohane
09:45 PM on 12/14/2011
They are doing this as caregivers who stay in Canada generally become responsible, productive & tax paying Canadians. We need more of that and fewer terrorists, scam artists, criminals and welfare cases. Harper''s definitely hitting a home run on the immigration piece.