Canadian Oilsands: Harper Defends 'Misinformation' On Environmental Impact

Bananas

First Posted: 12/16/11 03:46 PM ET Updated: 12/17/11 10:46 AM ET

TORONTO - The need for Canadian oilsands is "overwhelming" and the government will work hard to combat misinformation about its environmental impact, the prime minister said Friday.

Stephen Harper launched into a defence of the controversial oilsands at an unrelated event in Toronto, saying his government will push to get the "real information out there."

"The fact of the matter is that emissions from our oilsands are comparable to other heavy oils and that the industry continues to invest and continues to find ways to reduce those emissions," Harper said.

"It is absolutely clear if you look at the trajectory of world supply and demand, of North American supply and demand that the need for this energy is just overwhelming."

Harper's comments came in response to a question about Chiquita Brands, which announced Thursday that it would avoid using fuel from Alberta's oilsands.

The company, which sells hundreds of millions of dollars of fruit, juice and snacks around the world, said it has joined 13 other companies and one city in trying to reduce its carbon footprint.

"We are committed to directing our transportation providers to avoid, where possible, fuels from tarsands refineries," Chiquita vice-president Manuel Rodriguez wrote in a letter to Aaron Sanger of the environmental group ForestEthics.

Cosmetics giant Avon and U.S. drugstore chain Walgreen's have both made commitments similar to Chiquita's.

Others, such as Gap, Levi Strauss and Timberland, have only said they are trying to reduce the environmental impact of transporting their products. The city of Bellingham, Wash., has guidelines minimizing fuel purchases that take oilsands feedstock.

ForestEthics wants oilsands producers to clean up their operations.

Harper threw his support behind the oilsands industry and stressed its role in the economy.

"I remain very confident about the future of this industry and its ability to generate wealth for the Canadian economy," Harper said.

"This is one of the sectors that creates some of the most jobs, not just in the oil patch, but around the country in terms of manufacturing and support services, and this government will continue to do everything to promote the Canadian energy centre."

Related: Memorable marketing campaigns
Loading Slideshow...
  • 'Ethical oil'

    The term "ethical oil" has become the centrepiece of a new application for a classic marketing strategy. After being added to the Conservative political lexicon, the slogan is slowly beginning to creep into the public discourse. And like other attempts by industry and advocacy groups to use value judgements to alter public opinion, it has the potential to change the way we think about Canadian oil.

  • Ethical Oil vs Conflict Oil

    Share this video with your friends and family.

  • Ethical Oil

    An ad from <a href="http://www.ethicaloil.org/" target="_hplink">ethicaloil.org</a>, a new site trying to rebrand Alberta's oil sands.

  • Ethical Oil

    An ad from <a href="http://www.ethicaloil.org/" target="_hplink">ethicaloil.org</a>, a new site trying to rebrand Alberta's oil sands.

  • 'Pork. The other white meat'

    In 1987, pork producers in the United States were steadily losing ground to chicken and turkey, which prompted the National Pork Producers Council to take a different tack. To counter the still-widespread belief that pork was a red meat, The New York Times reports that the council set out to appeal to health-conscious consumers by reminding them that pork was in fact <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/1987/01/15/business/advertising-dressing-pork-for-success.html" target="_hplink">considered a white meat</a>. The series of print and TV ads that followed featured pork prepared in ways that had been traditionally been reserved for poultry, such as cordon bleu and cacciatore a l'orange, as well as a new slogan: "Pork. The other white meat." (After nearly 25 years, the council recently changed its well-known catch phrase to "<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/03/04/pork-be-inspired-slogan-other-white-meat_n_831331.html" target="_hplink">Pork: Be inspired</a>.") (AP File Photo)

  • Pork Commercial

    Pork, the other white meat.

  • 'Fair trade coffee'

    Though tracing the precise history of the fair trade movement is difficult, most observers agree that the concept was popularized by its application to the coffee industry. The <a href="http://www.maxhavelaar.nl/faq/how-did-it-start?destination=english&backtitle=FAQ's" target="_hplink">first official fair trade label</a> was launched by a Dutch NGO, which imported the pioneering fair trade product -- coffee from Mexico -- to the Netherlands in 1988. Billed as an effort to secure better prices for producers, and guarantee certain environmental and labour standards, the demand for fair trade coffee quickly spread. But it's still a niche item that carries a premium: as The Toronto Star pointed out in 2007, only a small percentage of the java bought by coffee-giant Starbucks is <a href="http://www.thestar.com/living/article/250730" target="_hplink">fairly traded</a>. (Photo: Getty Images)

  • Starbucks is the largest purchaser of Fair Trade Coffee

    Full of rich bodied flavor and great respect for the farmers who grew it. Caf

  • 'Clean coal'

    The notion of coal as a clean source of energy was thrust into the spotlight in the United States in 2008, when a $40-million industry-sponsored campaign helped make it a talking point during the presidential race. An attempt to counter the public perception of coal as an acid rain-causing, environmental scourge, Businessweek observed that the <a href="http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/08_26/b4090055452749.htm" target="_hplink">"clean coal" campaign</a> tugged at the heartstrings with emotional TV ads featuring teachers and farmers -- and won the endorsement of both presidential candidates. (AP Photo)

  • Clean Coal Ad

    Political

  • 'Blood diamond'

    The recognition in the late 1990s that diamonds were being used to fuel bloody conflicts in African countries like Angola and Sierra Leone prompted the United Nations Security Council to find some way to track the movement of the precious stones. The resulting identification scheme, dubbed the <a href="http://www.globalwitness.org/campaigns/conflict/conflict-diamonds/kimberley-process" target="_hplink">Kimberley Process</a>, was put in place in 2003 to separate so-called blood or conflict diamonds from those used to fund legitimate governments. Though the process remains imperfect, the terminology was cemented in the minds of the general public, and soon found its way into popular culture: Edward Zwick's 2006 film Blood Diamond grossed more than US$171 million. (AP Photo)

  • Blood Diamond - Trailer

    Trailer for the movie 'Blood Diamond'

  • 'Dolphin-safe tuna'

    Dolphins tend to stick close to the surface, making them easy to spot, and easy prey for fisherman angling to catch tuna, which often swim alongside the large mammals. Despite several attempts by the United States government to limit the killing of dolphins by U.S. fishing boats, by 1990 the practice of purposefully ensnaring <a href="http://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/aer793/aer793f.pdf" target="_hplink">dolphins in tuna nets</a> became so widespread -- and so highly publicized -- that it had prompted a public boycott of canned tuna. In response, Congress instituted a consumer labelling program, and canneries that bought from fisherman that steered clear of dolphins started identifying their product as "Dolphin safe." Though the designation initially carried a premium, the program soon spread throughout the industry, making the additional cost worthwhile. (AP Photo)

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

TORONTO - The need for Canadian oilsands is "overwhelming" and the government will work hard to combat misinformation about its environmental impact, the prime minister said Friday.Stephen Harper laun...
TORONTO - The need for Canadian oilsands is "overwhelming" and the government will work hard to combat misinformation about its environmental impact, the prime minister said Friday.Stephen Harper laun...
Filed by Kenny Yum  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:59 AM on 12/20/2011
Ethical Oil is like Safe Cigarettes, an oxymorn!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Stacey
Kill guns, not children.
05:18 PM on 12/19/2011
Here's why the oil companies like the sludgesands so much; 2007; Royal Dutch Shell released its 2006 annual report and announced that its Canadian oil sands unit made an after tax profit of $21.75 per barrel, nearly double its worldwide profit of $12.41 per barrel on conventional crude oil (Wiki). Oil prices in 2006 were high, though not as high as at their peak in '07.

So ...... basically due to a weak royalty agreement, the oil companies make more money on the sludgesands than they do from conventional sources. Little wonder distractions like 'ethicaloil.org' are popping up now - we're so busy debunking their bullsh*t we forget to follow the money.
photo
Jay from Ottawa
sovereignty sale, 1.3T OBO
10:18 AM on 12/19/2011
1- I don't care about the oilsands carbon footprint. What I do care about, is mass polluting our water !
2- I'm not going to let a organization started by a tobacco lobbyst (Erza) talk to me about ethics.
02:05 AM on 12/19/2011
I'm going to boycott "Chiquita"...

Anyone can play that game...
09:31 PM on 12/18/2011
Harper is secretly hoping global warming is real for two reasons. First, the ice cap needs to melt for oil companies to be able to drill in the Arctic. Second, after our oil runs out we will be able to grow and export bananas like a true Banana Republic (they just won't be Chiquita).
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
okgranny
Egalitarian by birth
01:24 PM on 12/18/2011
When Harper says, "let me be clear", we can be sure he is spouting misinformation himself. It's doublespeak for "don't look too closely, I'm trying to fool you again".
11:57 AM on 12/18/2011
We got out of the Kyoto because of the oil sands. Defending it because it makes money is not an answer. The oil sands are an environmental disaster but it makes many rich and it keeps people employed. " In the manner of pigs, all is money, and in the manner of money, all are pigs."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mike Keohane
07:55 PM on 12/17/2011
Chiquita brands pays it's foreign workforce pennies an hour and gets along famously with unsavory governments just so they can make money. They're just so ethical.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Paul Stacey
Kill guns, not children.
04:58 PM on 12/19/2011
Pretty much describes most multi-nationals, including most of the major players in the oil industry.
02:18 PM on 12/17/2011
Might as well just bring in the Chinese and get on with it. As a last resort, Canada should go Albania on the world and we can heat our homes with it for the next 1000 years. Will be closely watching the Chiquita Banana Hypocrisy as they burn Venezuelan oil and eat up a few Venezuelans ground under Hugo's boot. I can only imagine how ethical the Banana business has been all these years. Too bad I like Bananas so much. Is there a choice other than Chiquita?
02:17 PM on 12/17/2011
Let me think. Peter MacKay - had to use a government helicopter to fly to a government jet to fly to an unimportant press conference - about 1.3 hundred thousand dollars. Fake lake. But we really needed it because Canada only has 1.5 million real lakes. Fifty million channelled secretly to a minister so he could disperse it to the mayors of really little towns. Three new jails we don't need because the crime rate is falling. Mandated sentencing to make sure there are some people to be put in those jails. Gun registry stopped despite all the entreaties of every police chief in Canada and the records burned. So why be surprised to find Harpo lying about the pipeline. If its oil the Americans need so much why not refine it here and get more jobs for Canadians. No. Americans have to have the refinery in Texas. Harper should read the ten commandments. One of them says he shouldn't tell a lie. But in his weird version of Christianity it is okay for him to do this. It takes one BTU of gas to make one BTU of the oil to be pumped down to Texas where more BTU's will refine it. Then there is the water, the toxic tailing ponds, the increased cancer rates, the destruction of our boreal forest which is more important to the world than the Amazon forest. Be more efficient. Then we won't need more oil. But efficiency isn't subsidized by tax dollars like
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
okgranny
Egalitarian by birth
01:33 PM on 12/18/2011
If harper says, "let me be clear", you can be sure it's oily.
01:13 PM on 12/17/2011
The commitment from Chiquita is to "avoid when possible" which is about as limp a commitment as it is possible to imagine. These so called commitments are simple Greenwashing: good PR but meaningless

SH is right: oil is here to stay until someone develops a viable alternate and that means that North American based development is crucial to everyone's strategic and economic well being
01:00 PM on 12/17/2011
So if the emissions are comparable to other heavy oils and continues to reduce emissions, why wouldn't you want to get it from here instead of a country/countries that treat there citizens like crap?
photo
Jay from Ottawa
sovereignty sale, 1.3T OBO
10:28 AM on 12/19/2011
I don't care about CO2 emissions, that's plant food. What I do care about, and a fact purposefully not mentioned by Harper, is that oilsand production pollutes a lot more water than conventional sources of crude.

Too much CO2 should lead to a boom in plant life.
Too much polluted water leads to degradation of all life on earth.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
haddanuff
Progressives think 'We' while cons think "Me"
11:55 AM on 12/17/2011
"The fact of the matter is that emissions from our oilsands are comparable to other heavy oils"

This is the point pinhead...we need renewable green energy sources, not MORE deathly, destruction!
11:11 AM on 12/17/2011
Yup, Harpo's REAL good at spreading misinformation alright. Lies, lies and more lies.
03:27 PM on 12/17/2011
Which lie are you referring to, that global warming is an anthropomorphic problem, or that oil processed from the surface in Canada is not the motivator for regional and global warfare.