Mike Klink, Keystone 'Whistleblower,' Alleges Shoddy Materials Along Original Pipeline

Transcanada Pipeline Whistleblower Mike Klink

First Posted: 01/03/12 06:44 PM ET Updated: 01/06/12 01:30 PM ET

WASHINGTON - A former inspector for a company that did work on TransCanada's original Keystone pipeline is accusing the Calgary-based company of a cavalier disregard for the environment.

Mike Klink was an engineer for construction company Bechtel Corp., a contractor that worked on the first portion of the Keystone pipeline that carries Alberta oilsands crude to refineries in the American Midwest. It was completed in 2010; the controversial Keystone XL would extend that pipeline to Gulf Coast refineries.

In an opinion piece published over the weekend in Nebraska's Lincoln Journal Star, the 59-year-old Klink says he raised a series of concerns about alleged sub-standard materials and poor craftsmanship along the Keystone pipeline.

The Indiana man says he was fired by Bechtel as a result, and filed a complaint about his dismissal with the U.S. Department of Labor in March 2010. In his formal complaint, also sent to the U.S. Office of Whistleblower Protection Program, Klink says the company began treating him as a "problem inspector" culminating in one supervisor angrily ordering him to quit before he got fired.

"Let's be clear — I am an engineer; I am not telling you we shouldn't build pipelines," he wrote in the Nebraska newspaper.

"We just should not build this one."

His job as an inspector, Klink said, involved monitoring the construction of pump stations along the first Keystone pipeline.

"I am coming forward because my kids encouraged me to tell the truth about what was done and covered up," he wrote. "When I last raised concerns about corners being cut, I lost my job — but people along the Keystone XL pathway have a lot more to lose if this project moves forward with the same shoddy work."

TransCanada spokesman Terry Cunha disputed Klink's assertions, saying he "appears to have made a number of allegations against his previous employer and others, none of which have been proven."

Cunha added that whenever safety concerns are raised by inspectors, TransCanada takes them seriously.

"If a concern is raised, we investigate immediately. If corrective action is required, we act .... Safety is top priority for us. We monitor our Keystone pipeline system through a centralized high-tech centre 24 hours a day, 365 days a year."

Klink says, however, that he noticed substandard building materials, construction methods and safety standards as he inspected the pipeline.

"Cheap foreign steel that cracked when workers tried to weld it, foundations for pump stations that you would never consider using in your own home, fudged safety tests, Bechtel staffers explaining away leaks during pressure tests as 'not too bad,' shortcuts on the steel and rebar that are essential for safe pipeline operation and siting of facilities on completely inappropriate spots like wetlands," he wrote.

He said that he shared his concerns with his bosses, who passed them along to "the bigwigs at TransCanada, but nothing changed. TransCanada didn't appear to care."

Keystone remains in the spotlight in the U.S. capital after Republicans succeeded in having a provision inserted into legislation to extend payroll tax cuts and unemployment insurance benefits to Americans hard-hit by tough economic times.

The measure would force the Obama administration to make a decision on Keystone XL within 60 days. White House officials and Democrats say the provision has all but killed the pipeline since a thorough review of a new route for Keystone XL — around a crucial aquifer in Nebraska — cannot be conducted in such a short time period.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA BUSINESS

Filed by Christian Cotroneo  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 52
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:28 AM on 01/27/2012
Mike Klink graduated from University with an engineering degree and employed as a construction supervisor working for Bechtel Corporation (BC) on the Keystone oil pipeline that is owned by TransCanada (TC). He noticed sub standard materials and poor workmanship on the Keystone pipeline especially in construction of the pump stations, materials that did not meet specifications and incorrect accessories fitted. He correctly approached his supervisors concerning problems he observed using BC’s internal policies and procedures so the company could act to correct these concerns. If he had not spoken to his supervisors and brought his concerns to the attention of a newspaper, he would be known as an internal whistleblower. Klink was informed that the information was passed along to “the bigwigs at TransCanada, but nothing changed. TransCanada didn’t appear to care” Klink said.

Klink says the company began treating him as a “problem inspector” culminating in one supervisor angrily ordering him to quit before he got fired.

The alleged statements by the supervisor can only lead to the conclusion that Klink was going to be fired if he did not stop putting in his concerns regarding work practices on the project. Usually, when a person utilises a company’s internal reporting system the outcome is to improve the company’s public image, reduce cost and future liabilities while achieving all project objectives. This does not appear to be the case according to the newspaper reports.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Lives
The Venus Project ... look it up
12:31 AM on 01/05/2012
"If a concern is raised, we investigate immediately. If corrective action is required, we act .... Safety is top priority for us." Hahahahahahaha, hohohohoho, stop it, hehehehehehe, you're killing me.
11:49 AM on 01/04/2012
Up next in the news... Kathryn Marshall's ethical oil apology.
11:49 AM on 01/04/2012
OMG pipe from India on a Candian USA job why? If it's built people lets use our own pipe and materials. Who is making the profit of the oil? Why would they use cheap steal from abroad not enough in it for them or what. 7 billion is a hefty price for a few lenghts of pipe.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
01:02 PM on 01/04/2012
"Why would they use cheap steal from abroad"
That's a silly question to ask...
02:22 PM on 01/04/2012
i wasn't asking.
11:23 AM on 01/05/2012
I've very seldom seen any American made pipe, and I've worked in the industry for over ten years. Most of it comes from Canada, and is of acceptable quality....The Indian stuff not so much.
04:50 PM on 01/05/2012
Hi there Mr.Bacchus in response to you seldom seeing USA pipe. That depends I guess at the tipe of pipe. Seamless or rolled steel. I am assuming the pipe would be high pressure so it should be seamless for the pipeline. Shedule 40 or higher depending if the oils will be abrassive. The Crap from Iandia might be good enough for pille driving maybe. There are pipe mills in Pitsburg that could easily handle the work.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ProgressiveCDN
A Progressive Moderate
10:53 AM on 01/04/2012
Kudos to this whistleblower!
This is old news however. Everyone knows about the many leaks along the original Keystone pipeline, which is why the idea of running this trash through a Nebraska aquifer is just rediculous!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Lee Harrington
There's still time to change the road you're on...
10:40 AM on 01/04/2012
Does the Keystone Pipeline Contain Defective Steel?

Yesterday Plains Justice released a report showing that defective steel might have been used in TransCanada’s already constructed Keystone pipeline...

“The Keystone pipeline is one of the largest pipelines in existence and will operate at very high pressure and high temperature, so it must not break,” said Blackburn..."

Government documents show that Welspun, a pipe manufacturer in India, produced hundreds of substandard pipe joints in 2007 and 2008. Photos taken during construction of the Keystone pipeline show that TransCanada acquired pipe from Welspun during this same time.

http://tarsandspipelines.wordpress.com/2010/06/29/does-the-keystone-pipeline-contain-defective-steel/

USE OF SUBSTANDARD STEEL BY THE U.S. PIPELINE INDUSTRY

"...The growing number of high-pressure, large diameter hazardous liquid and natural gas pipelines
are putting increasing numbers of citizens at risk.... Existing pipelines, especially large diameter pipelines, must be tested with greater frequency as they age.

To avoid further fatalities, injuries, and property damage, PHMSA must adapt its safety
standards, regulations, and enforcement activities to protect citizens and their property from the greater risk posed by new large high-pressure pipelines. To gain greater public trust and public support for its activities, PHMSA must allow citizens to easily learn what it is doing and increase opportunities for citizens to participate in PHMSA’s efforts to protect them."

http://plainsjustice.org/files/SubstandardSteelReport.pdf
09:56 AM on 01/04/2012
What a surprise!
Big Oil and Shoddy standards.
Like Fred Astaire and Ginger.
Tangoing together into new and significant oilspills.
Better living for you through ecodestruction!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Warren Yuill
Jesus Built My Hot-Rod
07:28 AM on 01/04/2012
The real story here is "Petrochina buys out AthabascaOil Sands"
It is the first wholly Chinese owned Canadian oils sands project.
This I predict will be trend that follows.
Migrant chinese workers flooding into Fort Mac. (They are already in Syncrude with China owning20%)
Seperate Petrochina workcamps built onsite using all Chinese labour and materials.
Rampant labour law violations.
Rampant enviromental law violations.
Friction between PetroChina and trade certification boards. (Sagd uses enormous amounts of superheated, 'superdry' steam. At unbelievable pressure. Properly trained and experianced personal are critical to safe production.)
Rampant royalty accountability discrepancys.
Enormous pressure/corruption to facilitate pipline construction.
And that leads us to this story of substandard materials and construction techniques.
Kind of like that whole lion king "circle of life' thing.
Except it centers on the single largest man made ecological disaster in human history.
Can anyone say 'Hakuna Matata"?
12:00 PM on 01/04/2012
Tumbler ridge is another example where a Chinese outfit buys the mine and imports a hundred workers to live on site. I was interested in a job posting the had for locals. They were looking for 36 caucasians to make the the grade. We sell of our resources to them they polute the atmosphere and we get the carbon tax slaped on us???? Wake up people this aint right and we all know it. How do we change this around???? Blowing smoke making comments about it at the post isn't doing much.What do u sugest super user?
photo
All Seeing Guy
DOWN WITH CORPORATIONS! *sent from my iPhone*
03:12 AM on 01/04/2012
Commie, we need this for jobs!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ProgressiveCDN
A Progressive Moderate
10:56 AM on 01/04/2012
lol.
screw national infrastructure! We need OIL!!
12:36 AM on 01/04/2012
Has there ever been a major pipeline oil spill in Canada? We (in Canada) use pretty much the same pipeline construction materials that will be used in the Keystone project, perhaps even better as materials technology will be the latest. Would we take short cuts to save a few million bucks and end up paying out billions and a PR nightmare the likes of BP?

I'm not quite sure why Canada or the us thinks the US is the only worthwhile market for Athabasca oil. There are plenty of eager buyers across the Pacific -China and Japan for example. One more delay on keystone and that increased pipeline capacity to BC will be built.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JBSCanada
They paved Paradise and put up a parking lot!
12:45 AM on 01/04/2012
There have been major pipeline spills in North America, one recently. If you do a Google search you will find some. You can then decide which qualifies for "major" status.

The US is not the destination of Keystone XL product. The product from this pipeline is to be exported overseas, it is not for domestic consumption. It's oil for export, not for us.

http://pri­ceofoil.or­g/2011/08/­31/report-­exporting-­energy-sec­urity-keys­tone-xl-ex­posed/
11:07 AM on 01/04/2012
The USA is not overseas
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
01:05 PM on 01/04/2012
Hi JBS,

Is all of the oil that's currently being produced in Texas already being exported overseas?

If not, then I see no reason to believe that this oil will be any different.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Lee Harrington
There's still time to change the road you're on...
10:44 AM on 01/04/2012
Canada not prepared for major oil spill: report

Already facing stiff criticism over its record on environmental issues, the Conservative government was dealt another blow Tuesday with the release of a critical report by the federal environmental auditor.

Scott Vaughan's 42-page report found Ottawa isn't doing enough at home to protect the environment, largely due to two fundamental problems -- ineffective leadership and inadequate information collected by departments about major environmental problems.

"… critical gaps in the federal government's environmental information hinder both its capacity to inform Canadians about key environmental conditions, and its ability to know if the billions of dollars it spends each year on environmental protection are making a difference," wrote Vaughan, the commissioner of the environment and sustainable development.

http://www.ctv.ca/CTVNews/TopStories/20101207/climate-change-federal-govt-auditor-report-101207/
yer
Stop the Alberta Taliban
09:31 PM on 01/03/2012
while I am not in favour of this pipeline, this is a separate issue. This man is indeed an engineer and it is his job to do exactly what he did. That's why you become an engineer, to uphold the public trust. It is the company that must explain itself, and not this professional.
darksideofthespoon
what we think we become
07:52 AM on 01/04/2012
Yup. I agree. He wants to see it built, but safely. He knows many people will rely on this income but at what price? Buying cheap parts to build something like a pipeline is silly anyways, more spills = wasted oil. They need to get their s**t together and invest in a properly built pipeline if they want to see revenue from their product.
12:08 PM on 01/04/2012
I agree build it right the first time and make the money afterwards. There will be plenty of it for the 1% who controll it. The citizens wont get a shilling as par usual.
photo
Computer Geek
Logician Atheist Lefty
08:57 PM on 01/03/2012
Perhaps if Transcanada is so sure of their lack of culpability, they would invite an independent panel of engineers to go inspect those already completed portions? But that would need to be people not selected by them or any other energy company or management of any energy company. Perhaps the Corps of Engineers in the US?
yer
Stop the Alberta Taliban
09:32 PM on 01/03/2012
This engineer had made complaints but no forthcoming audit occurred. Thus the process is already corrupted
12:13 PM on 01/04/2012
Absolutely if it was above board they would have called the inspections right away so they would have it in writting that the job was right. No they want to suppress the truth so they are guilty of a conspiracy. If something happens charge them all. If one person dies as a result the whole corporation is guilty of murder.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jumpinjezebel
I'll show U mine if U'll show me urs
08:49 PM on 01/03/2012
Better start wearing a bulletproof vest.
08:14 PM on 01/03/2012
The headline should read "Liar tried to discredit former employer."
But that wouldn't get the attention of the Cuttington Paste, would it?
"appears to have made a number of allegations against his previous employer and others, none of which have been proven."
No pipeline is safe. No highway is safe. No railway is safe. No oil tanker is safe.
There are risks moving oil and gas by any mode of transportation, but pipeline is, by far, the safest way.
You've made your point. You don't want Canada to sell oil in the US. We all know you'd prefer them to buy it from the Saudis, Iraqis, Iranians and Venezuelans.
Now lets see a story on how many people -- actual people -- the Cuttington Paste employs in Canada. Easy answer. One.
How many does TransCanada Pipelines employ? Thousands.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jumpinjezebel
I'll show U mine if U'll show me urs
08:56 PM on 01/03/2012
What article did you read?? The oil will go to Houston and then to China. None of its products will be sold in the USA. Today WE EXPORT GASOLINE!!!! So tomorrow we need more gas?? How many people will building the XL pipeline employ?? Best estimates are 2500 and that is temporary. Most of the rest of the residual staff (dozens) will be employed mostly in cleaning up the leaks that will invariably occur. Oh and hundreds of people and billions of dollars if it leaks into the auquifers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
haddanuff
Progressives think 'We' while cons think "Me"
10:52 PM on 01/03/2012
The tr0// is working you for his nickels.
yer
Stop the Alberta Taliban
09:35 PM on 01/03/2012
You can't claim high and mighty ethical oil.... when this is planned for export to Communist China. Y'know, where they torture people?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Sunwyn Ravenwood
Farewell my friends, time to go...
03:44 AM on 01/04/2012
You mean like we do, ever since the Bush Administration decided to make it legal? Oh, and by the way, it is now legal for the President to order the military to abduct anyone he wants, anywhere in the world, and hold them forever without trial, without lawyers, and without appeal.

We have met the enemy and he is us.