Hospital Association Head Defends CEO Salaries

Stethoscope

First Posted: 01/ 4/2012 8:53 am Updated: 01/ 5/2012 11:36 am


The head of the Ontario Hospital Association says a cap on the salaries of hospital CEOs could impair their ability to attract top administrators.


Tom Closson made the comments Wednesday in an interview on CBC Radio’s Metro Morning, hosted by Matt Galloway.


“This province has a $16-billion deficit,” said Closson. “We need the best leaders we can get.”


This week the OHA advised hospitals to make public the contracts of their CEOs. Many of the hospitals posted the entire contracts of their executives online. CBC News has posted links to many of those contracts here.


The salaries of hospital CEOs have long been public information, disclosed each year on the province’s so-called sunshine list. But this week’s disclosure went further, outlining such perks as generous car allowances, money for golf club memberships and benefits for cosmetic plastic surgery.


Those perks come on top of annual salaries that range from $300,000 to $800,000.


NDP Leader Andrea Horwath has suggested hospital CEO salaries be capped at $418,000, which is twice the salary of the premier.


Salary cap is 'pretty arbitrary'


Closson, however, said the high salaries are needed to attract and retain top hospital administrators.


“The NDP suggestion is pretty arbitrary and certainly it’s political,” he said. “The savings you would make from capping CEO salaries is $3.7 million, we spend $23 billion in hospitals in this province. You’d likely not be able to attract the same calibre of people to go into the CEO stream in this province.”


“The more important question is: what value do we get from spending the money on leaders? We feel very strongly that you have to have good leaders if you want to make the system work better.”


Closson also said hospital administrators in the United States often earn much more than their Canadian counterparts.


Related on HuffPost:

THE 10 HIGHEST-PAID CEOs IN CANADA
Loading Slideshow...
  • 10: Jonathan Henry, Gabriel Resources $11.7M

    Gabriel Resources is a Toronto-based company focused primarily on a gold excavation project in Romania. <i>Note: An earlier version of this gallery reported that Gabriel Resources' 2010 revenue was $448 million. <a href="http://globeinvestor.sympatico.ca/invest/investSQL/sym.company_prof?company_id=160018" target="_hplink">It was, in fact, $448,000, according to publicly listed data</a>. A company spokesperson says the resource firm was in a period of pre-production in 2010, and did not generate revenue. Thus, Henry's compensation of $11.7 million exceeded the company's revenues for the year.</i>

  • 9: Gordon Nixon, RBC $11.9M

    Royal Bank of Canada (RBC) is the largest financial institution in the country. Henry's total pay of $11.9 million was the equivalent of 0.1 per cent of the company's $10.3 billion in 2010 revenues.

  • 8: Stephen DeFalco, Nordion $13.1M

    Nordion is an Ottawa-based health sciences company that specializes in medical isotopes. DeFalco's total pay of $13.1 million was the equivalent of 5.1 per cent of the company's $256 million in 2010 revenues. DeFalco left the CEO position in 2010.

  • 7: Steve Laut, Canadian Natural Resources $13.1M

    Canadian Natural Resources Ltd. is a Calgary-based oil and gas exploration company. Laut's total pay of $13.1 million was the equivalent of 0.08 per cent of the company's $14.6 billion in 2010 revenues.

  • 6: Richard Waugh, Scotiabank $13.8M

    The Bank of Nova Scotia is the third largest bank in Canada. Waugh's total pay of $13.8 million was the equivalent of 0.06 per cent of the company's $23.8 billion in 2010 revenues.

  • 5: Martyn Konig, European Goldfields $14.8M

    Despite its name, European Goldfields in a Canadian-based company, operating out of the Northwest Territories. Konig's total pay of $14.8 million was the equivalent of 29.1 per cent of the company's $50.7 million in 2010 revenues.

  • 4: Edward Sampson, Niko Resources $16.5M

    Niko Resources is a Calgary-based oil and gas exploration company operating fields mostly outside Canada. Sampson's total pay of $16.5 million was the equivalent of 3.6 per cent of the company's $455 million in 2010 revenues.

  • 3: Siegfried Wolf, Co-CEO, Magna $16.5M

    Southern Ontario-based Magna International is North America's largest car parts manufacturer. Wolf's total pay of $16.5 million was the equivalent of 0.07 per cent of the company's $24.2 billion in 2010 revenues. Wolf stepped down as co-CEO in 2010.

  • 2: Donald Walker, Co-CEO, Magna $16.7M

    Southern Ontario-based Magna International is North America's largest car parts manufacturer. Walker's total pay of $16.7 million was the equivalent of 0.07 per cent of the company's $24.2 billion in 2010 revenues.

  • Frank Stronach, Magna $61.8M

    Southern Ontario-based Magna International is North America's largest car parts manufacturer. Stronach's total pay of $61.8 million was the equivalent of 0.26 per cent of the company's $24.2 billion in 2010 revenues.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

Filed by Michael Bolen  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gravescanada
03:31 PM on 01/04/2012
If you cap the Salary, they will still need the work. To compare the salary in Canadian Hospitals to American Hospitals is just stupid. Same with our Doctors who get their education here in Canada and then move to the USA. I say enough with greed. Greed is not a virtue. Mother Theresa was not greedy. Jonas Salk was not greedy. They did what they did for the greater good. Are they trying to tell us that we do not have competent people here in Canada that would be unwilling to work for that amount of money? I know they are out there, brilliant people who could do that job right now, but are stuck in some dead end job. Look for over educated over achievers and train them to do the job for 480,000. I guarantee you would find people in a heartbeat. The problems we face in our nation are human resource related. Hell, my wife managed a mammography department in the USA for 8 years. Yet the hospitals do not want her because they would have to train here with their systems. She would be a massive asset, but they would rather hire someone to do the job right now. Kind of a correlation there with how employers are only hiring people who are employed. Or you cant say certain words in your resume now because they are overdone. I say the managers of the Human Resources departments are overdone.
photo
tjdwill02
There is no free lunch
08:05 PM on 01/04/2012
The labor market is no different than any other market. Supply of high caliber ' Alpha" CEO's is small. The World wide demand is endless. The other end of the spectrum is middle managers. They're a dime a dozen and in this economy as replaceable as loading bullets in a gun.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gravescanada
04:57 AM on 01/06/2012
Yes, the Alpha CEO's as you put it are rare, only in that they restrict people from entering their exclusive club. You can take a brilliant and clever Middle Manager and train and groom him for a short period of time and he or she could easily take and perform the CEO's job. But currently, its a good old boys system and they like it that way, keeps those wages way up in the clouds.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Transitteer
and another thing . . .
03:20 PM on 01/04/2012
The excuse that you need to pay big bucks for good people sounds good but is total fiction. Larry Kuharich was paid big by the Stampeders and led them to last place. Let these prima donas go elsewhere - overpaid underacheivers. The system is worse than before, so what 'results' have they acheived for the money they received? Better to have a driven executive there to do good work, than to line his pockets and be able to sit with all the other overpaid underacheivers at the Executive Club luncheons.
02:28 PM on 01/04/2012
What a joke! Do they really think there are a ton of jobs out there that these so called "top talented" people would go to if they had a salary cap of 418,000? Give me a break! In this economy, they better start taking what they can get. And while we're at it...maybe some candidates that are motivated by something other than GREED will take the positions!
01:21 PM on 01/04/2012
I'm all for paying leaders well. However, when do you reach diminishing returns. If the suggested salary cap is $418,000, how much more quality of leadership and effective use of hospital operating budgets do you get for another $100,000 or another $200,000. Who is evaluating the performsnce of these hospital CEO's - usually a board made up of other over-paid executives. I suggest that there is plenty of hospital CEO talent prepared to work for $418,000. The other problem I have is that I hesitate to donate to hospital charities (except Princess Margaret) because I feel that the administrative costs of the operations and the charities themselves are too high.
photo
tjdwill02
There is no free lunch
08:08 PM on 01/04/2012
when do you reach diminishin­g returns.********* When the stock holders and the Board says so. Besides no one is poor because these over achievers are rich !
11:09 PM on 01/04/2012
Sorry but *********** does not qualify as a reply. The board doesn't say no because boards are most often made up of other people also ripping off the system or under-qualified and useless. To say no one is poor because over achievers are rich - I'm focused on misused funds that should be paying for more nurses or an extra MRI machine. I don't think you know anything about the subject matter.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
montezaro
12:24 PM on 01/04/2012
"The high salaries are needed to attract and retain top hospital administrators"???!!! How about attracting people who really successfully WORK in their fields with high salaries?
If those administrators were that good in managing hospital's finances, like they are in getting money for themselves, why do we have so many problems?
Reminds me to big banks CEOs threatening to go elsewhere if they don't get the salaries that they want. Go where? Europe, Asia? Everybody has their own crooks. More than they need. How about going to Zimbabwe? Forgot: they also have their own CEOs who won't let them take their money.
Give me a break!