Electro-Motive Lockout: Caterpillar's Aggressive Labour Strategy May Be A Sign Of Things To Come

Electromotive Lockout Caterpillar Stephen Harper

First Posted: 01/12/12 08:18 AM ET Updated: 01/12/12 03:11 PM ET

LONDON, Ont. -- On an unseasonably balmy afternoon in January, a few hundred union members, local residents and their families descend on the picket line outside the Electro-Motive Diesel plant in this southern Ontario city, where workers are embroiled in one of the most cutthroat labour disputes in recent memory.

Billed as a “solidarity barbecue,” the event is intended to keep spirits high among Electro-Motive’s 420 CAW members, who have been locked out of the locomotive assembly plant since January 1 -- and likely will be for some time. Peoria, Ill.-based manufacturing giant Caterpillar, which owns the facility through its subsidiary Progress Rail, barricaded the plant when the union refused to accept a 55 per cent pay cut, a concession labour leaders describe as unprecedented.

As volunteers fire up hot dogs and hamburgers, organizers and politicians deliver impassioned speeches atop a makeshift stage, eliciting enthusiastic applause from the captive crowd and sporadic honking from passing motorists.

“Caterpillar underestimated not only the response of the labour movement but of the response of the community as a whole,” proclaimed Tim Carrie, the president of CAW Local 27, which represents the workers at the plant. “This fight will be going on for a while.”

But beneath the bravado, there is a nagging sense of fear on the line, where workers are getting a bone-chilling glimpse of what could be the new face of the manufacturing industry. As they told The Huffington Post, they’re only too aware that the opponent they’re staring down has deep pockets, transnational reach -- and, perhaps most menacingly, a possible alternative to the labour they provide.

It’s a scenario that has the union and its members caught between a rock and a very hard place.

Previously on HuffPost:

Electro-Motive Locks Out 421 CAW Workers

Caterpillar CEO Warns Company May Leave Illinois In Response To Tax Hikes

The Decline of Unions: Has Canada Reached A Point Of No Return?

Ross Seeley, a pipe-fitter who has worked at the plant for 29 and a half years, says he is “hopeful that [Caterpillar] can wake up and realize that they have a good workforce here that build a world class product.”

But when asked about how he thinks the dispute will end, his easy smile fades.

“They can kind of do whatever they want to do. I think they’re probably going to close the plant and move it, which is terrible,” says Seeley, whose retirement is just six months away, and could hang in the balance. “It leaves you speechless.”

The past few years have been turbulent at the London plant. After producing locomotives for General Motors for decades, the firm was sold by the beleaguered automaker to Greenbriar Equity Group and Berkshire Partners in 2005, before Caterpillar took over 2010.

But in the last year, Caterpillar has opened several new locomotive assembly plants, including one in Muncie, Ind., where workers are paid less than what the company is offering its employees in London.

Though there are questions about whether Muncie has the skilled labour required to supplant the experience and expertise of the London facility, some speculate that the lockout may be a precursor to shifting production south of the border.

“This company doesn’t need those cuts,” says Michael Lynk, a labour law expert at the University of Western Ontario. “There’s no economic explanation for this aside from the fact that they think they can [pay workers] $14 or $16 an hour in an economically distressed area of Indiana.”

“The tea leaves seem to be pointing in that direction,” he says.

But Jonathan Cutler, a labour professor and UAW expert at Wesleyan University, has a different take.

"You do a lockout as a threat to employees that you will just hold out as long as it takes for them to make the concessions you're asking for," he says. “The lockout implies actually that you're going to stay.”

Caterpillar has so far been mum on its intentions for the London plant, forwarding an interview request to the Toronto office of public relations firm Fleishman-Hillard.

In an e-mail, senior vice-president Anne Marie Quinn told HuffPost, “The company isn’t commenting on operational questions in the midst of the dispute,” and offered a link to a website set up by Electro-Motive “to act as a reliable source of information on the London facility.”

But the cone of silence isn’t instilling confidence in welder Mike Scofield, who says that the threat of shutdown -- however speculative -- is contributing to sleepless nights. He says morale has so far been strong on the line, but as he points out, these are still early days.

“I've been doing the night shift. I’ve already seen some tempers. People get angry. People get upset, because they’re afraid of losing this job, and they’re afraid that their families are going to suffer from all this,” the 36-year-old says. “We’re only in the start of this fight. I’m sure morale is going to drop.”

For now, however, workers appear united in their absolute unwillingness to accept the terms of the new agreement, which would cut benefits and slash wages from $35 to $16.50 -- yanking them swiftly out of the ever-shrinking middle class.

The solidarity on that issue is so universal, says machinist Stuart Kerr, that going back to work at those wages, quite simply, “ain’t going to happen.”

“It’s not worth my time to be here [on the line] for that kind of money,” says Kerr, 47, whose father also worked at Electro-Motive, and whose wife, daughter and grandchildren came out to show their support.

As Kerr sees it, the threat of moving locomotive manufacturing to Muncie is a scare tactic, he concedes that it could become a growing concern in the years to come.

“If they ever do get some skilled labour and pay their wages good down there, then I might get worried,” he says.

At the moment, workers are gearing up for a war of attrition -- which Caterpillar has ample resources to fight.

NDP MP PEGGY NASH SPEAKS AT ELECTRO-MOTIVE LOCKOUT RALLY (Story Continues On Next Page)


FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA BUSINESS

LONDON, Ont. -- On an unseasonably balmy afternoon in January, a few hundred union members, local residents and their families descend on the picket line outside the Electro-Motive Diesel plant in thi...
LONDON, Ont. -- On an unseasonably balmy afternoon in January, a few hundred union members, local residents and their families descend on the picket line outside the Electro-Motive Diesel plant in thi...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 282
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
12:48 PM on 01/21/2012
Unions are at the deep end of the social world and sinking fast. At least this is what corporate Canada and corporate world are hoping. I am not a Union lover nor am I a union hater.
It does seem quite obious to me and a lot of others though that Unions have lost their apeal and are now nothing more than the greedy part of society they themselves are deploring. They speak of corporate greed...but what of union greed...the extreme high wage paid for minimun work ethics displayed by most if not all our so called ethical workforce. Teachers making 90 thousand with extras for six hours per day 288 days. Factory workers making 30 through 50+ per hour with minimumal training and / or non except how to turn a wrench or push a button.
The minimum wage across Canada is much less than the 14.50 these Caterpillar workers are asked to receive.
How is it that one part of society thinks they need thirty or forty dollars per hour with a cottage in the country , speed boat , trailers ect and the rest do not get near that. Yet they do the same job. What gives these so called elite [ though in my reflections I have seen more poorly trained union workers than mainstrean workers in society.

Methinks UNIONISM as we call it has outlived its usfulness.
Governments both federal and provincial now mandate all health and safety laws.
photo
novabird
Lover of Life, Radical Centrist
03:17 PM on 02/03/2012
My dear man - if you truly think that "teachers are making 90 thousand with extras for six hours per day 288 days" it shows your appalling ignorance of that job. Teachers work all day with students and then all night and all weekends prepping lessons and marking and completing massive amounts of required paperwork. The 2 months off in the summer is often spent taking upgrading courses to keep up with changes in knowledge and technology. It is a massive insult and a slap in the face to suggest they work only six hours a day.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:08 AM on 01/14/2012
DO NOT BELIEVE THE HYPE... THIS PLANT IS GONE!!! THEY WILL RAPE IT FOR NO MORE THAN 5 YEARS (AT BEST)...
welcome to the new world order...

watch what happens in wisconsin... why you ask??? cause that's what a comin'... (maybe)
09:42 PM on 01/13/2012
If we had a real gov't in power, as opposed to the puppets to the corporate powers, the PM would be on the phone to the U,S. stating 2 things:

1. Caterpillar does this, it will be the last item they ever sell in Canada.
2. All oil pipelines may be undergoing "emergency inspection repairs" very soon, and may be shut down for a day or 2 if any more mfg jobs leave Canada.

But that actually requires a gov't that has loyalty to Canada.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Adrian31
60% of the time, it works everytime...
09:41 PM on 01/13/2012
If they could actually hire the 700 workers they planned for in Muncie, Indiana, then they'd have probably already have moved operations. Unfortunately, Muncie is a renowned crack/meth capital in the US and only a handful of the prospective employees are passing the mandatory drug test. I believe it's an 85% failure rate at the moment.

Muncie has bigger problems than just high unemployment...
09:15 PM on 01/13/2012
Just an opinion...but with the economy south of the boarder looking as grim as it has over the last 2+ years, I believe the U.S. Government is playing their hand and convincing these U.S. companies to come back to the U.S. and start giving their own citizens the jobs! Think about it. The current U.S. Government recently blocked Canada from bidding on numerous contracts in the construction industry in the U.S. with there keep jobs in America commitment. So who's to say the cronies south of the border aren't convincing U.S. manufacturing companies up here in Canada to move back south, and probably offering them lots of incentives that we don't even know about? And I'm sorry, but as a former OPSEU employee, I think Unions, in some respects, need to rethink and revisit their respective Collective Agreements in this economy....sorry to say! And if you think Caterpillar will stay based on a comment about an unskilled labour force down south? your wrong, I'm sure they have plenty of out of work University graduates who would take on those jobs!
08:01 PM on 01/13/2012
Oh you can''t scare me, I'm sticking to the union. I'm sticking to the union.
Oh you can scare me I'm sticking to the union. I'm sticking to the union till the day I die.
01:52 PM on 01/13/2012
It's time we followed the lead of other socialist govts, like USSR, 1930s Germany, Cuba and China for instance, and banned unions - they only cause inflation, inferior product and feather-bedding as well as job losses.
08:04 PM on 01/13/2012
Um yeah. What would Hitler do?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Adrian31
60% of the time, it works everytime...
09:43 PM on 01/13/2012
Yeah, because China builds 'superior' products...sigh
08:49 AM on 01/13/2012
Hard working Laborers wages have to go down down, because greed their profit margins will never be enough, that simple.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
authorized-user
macho macho man
08:44 AM on 01/13/2012
“There’s no economic explanation for this aside from the fact that they think they can [pay workers] $14 or $16 an hour in an economically distressed area of Indiana.”

Will Canada cave and let their jobs get exported to a low wage territory?????
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Adrian31
60% of the time, it works everytime...
09:45 PM on 01/13/2012
There are lots of people willing to take a $16.50/hour job...just not, as it appears, in London.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gravescanada
07:42 AM on 01/13/2012
How Multinational Corporations are killing our manufacturing industries.

In October 2010, Caterpillar Inc. announced it is investing US$50 million to acquire and to renovate an existing 740,000-square-foot (69,000 m2) building for assembly of EMD branded locomotives and to build a locomotive test track on a 75-acre (0.30 km2) site located in Muncie, Indiana. In January 2012, union workers were locked out of the EMD London facility[16] after refusing to ratify EMD's proposed new contract. The labor costs at EMD Muncie are about half of those at EMD London, with the implication being that either the Canadian workers level their compensation costs with those of the Americans, or face shutdown.

Rio Tinto Alcan locked out 800 workers at its smelter in Alma, Que., this week after contract talks collapsed. Rio Tinto Alcan, if you recall, was created when Alcan announced a friendly takeover deal with multinational mining and resources group Rio Tinto.

These are recent, and very real, very scary examples of what is to come in North America. We either agree to the lowest wage, or our Corporations will just move manufacturing to a country of their choice. No more are Corporations even remotely concerned with building up the country that brought them from humble beginnings to the Mighty Corporation they are today. They are no longer Patriotic in the least, its all about greed, milking every penny possible and to hell with the people.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Adrian31
60% of the time, it works everytime...
09:49 PM on 01/13/2012
Especially when you consider the "Buy America" propaganda that is being stressed from the south. Tax incentives to American companies that bring jobs back into the country are very enticing to the corporate greed that has enveloped the continent.
photo
Newfoundlander
I'm a pessimist, an optimist with experience!
03:14 AM on 01/13/2012
Any working person (not of the CEO level) that votes Tory is like a chicken voting for Colonel Sanders.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:10 AM on 01/13/2012
canadians better be very careful... slowly and slowly things are starting to change and resemble the GOP usa model, until finally one day you will wake up and wonder how it all happened...
11:38 PM on 01/12/2012
All Canadians have been railroaded. Our so very Christian Mr. Harper is sly and cares abdolutely nothing for the poor. His new jails and mandatory sentencing will make crime doar but he isn't about to listen to judges, social workers or lawyers. He scapped the long gun registry despite the pleas of every police chief in Canada. He terminated the Wheat Board despite the wishes of the wheat farmers. He has spent us into high debt again. He ford not drrm oppodrf to ignorance and corruption in his own psrty. He has stifled the press and debate in the H of C.Despite his blandishments re having an elected senate he seems happy to stuff second rate conservatives into the senate with no election. His position on climate change is run by the oil companies. Harper supports Israel no matter what since they have to rebuild the temple so the second coming will happen. I guess he believes he will go to heaven. I, on the other hand think heaven isn't an option for someone who makes Canada a pariah.
10:55 PM on 01/12/2012
Stand strong CAW Local 27 members!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Northreader
09:42 PM on 01/12/2012
The free trade deals that began with the Mulroney government mean Caterpillar has no obligation to manufacture in Canada despite lots of past government assistance. And the new Harper majority government is unlikely to do anything other than stand on the sidelines. Yet another classic case of Ontario workers being screwed by free trade. That is why some voices express nostaligia for the days of the old Canada-U.S. auto pact which insisted on manufacturing in both countries.