First Nations Summit: What Stephen Harper And National Chief Shawn Atleo Said (VIDEO, PHOTOS)

First Posted: 01/24/2012 3:27 pm Updated: 01/24/2012 4:22 pm

Prime Minister Stephen Harper spoke to First Nations chiefs from across Canada Tuesday morning.

He called for creative changes to the Indian Act but said he had no plans to abolish the document that some First Nations leaders call an outdated relic which fosters a relationship of dependency.

While Harper’s speech was met with polite clapping, the chiefs gave their own leader, the National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations’ Shawn Atleo, a standing ovation for his comments.

What did both men say?

Here’s The Huffington Post Canada’s version of he said, he said.

Loading Slideshow...
  • ON THE WAR OF 1812

    HARPER: Noted aboriginal participation.<br><br> "We have the 200th anniversary of the War of 1812, this year, in which aboriginal and non-aboriginal peoples joined under the Crown. Ultimately laying the basis for a distinct country in the northern half of this continent," he said.<br><br> ATLEO: Said British North America would not have won the war against the United States without the participation of First Nations.<br><br> "It is no exaggeration to say that without the courage and military skills of First Nation leaders and warriors in the War of 1812 that followed, Canada might be a very different place today. Our ancestors were central to every campaign and to the ultimate victory," he said. (Mark Wilson/Getty Images)

  • ON ENERGY DEVELOPMENT

    HARPER: Suggested that First Nations people work with the oil sands industry to achieve a quick path to prosperity.<br><br> "With inspired leadership, energy and enterprise, some bands have already shown that First Nations people are as quick to prosper, as capable of excellence and as able to enjoy all that Canada's vibrant economy has to offer them. I think of B.C.'s Haisla First Nation, partners in the massive Kitimat LNG project that will deliver training, employment and rich economic and social benefits to the community for decades to come. Or the Alberta First Nations, whose band-owned companies, do hundreds of millions of dollars a year in business with oil sands producers, employing thousands of aboriginal people in skilled, high-paying jobs."<br><br> ATLEO: Suggested First Nations invest in greener energy.<br><br> "Many of our communities are already moving forward, taking economic matters into their own hands, in sectors like clean energy and technology." (MARK RALSTON/AFP/Getty Images)

  • ON HARPER'S APOLOGY FOR RESIDENTIAL SCHOOLS

    HARPER: Said it was most of his most rewarding days in office to fix a wrong.<br><br> "That is why one of my most rewarding days in office was when I rose in the House to deliver an apology to those students. We acknowledged that sad chapter in our history. We repudiated the thinking that lay behind it. And, we went beyond symbolism," he said.<br><br> ATLEO: Said Harper's apology had set the stage for Tuesday's meeting. "The historic Apology, made possible by the leadership of Prime Minister Harper set the course for reconciliation - a journey together that helped enable today's gathering," he said. (Mike Carroccetto/Getty Images)

  • ON THE INDIAN ACT OF 1876

    HARPER: Said he would not get rid of the Act but would bring in incremental changes.<br><br> "Our Government has no grand scheme to repeal or to unilaterally re-write the Indian Act. After 136 years, that tree has deep roots blowing up the stump would just leave a big hole. However, there are ways creative ways, collaborative ways, ways that involve consultation between our Government, the provinces, and First Nations leadership and communities, ways that provide options within the Act, or outside of it, for practical, incremental and real change. That will be our approach. "<br><br> ATLEO: Said the Act was a painful obstacle to building any new relationship.<br><br> "Built on the disgraceful premise of our inferiority, aimed at assimilation and the destruction of our cultures - it was a complete abrogation of the partnership between respectful nations. Largely unchanged, it remains a painful obstacle to re-establishing any form of meaningful partnership. It is well past time that we began to undo the damage that Act has inflicted on our peoples, and to our partnership. For, from it grew the reserve system, the tragedy of residential schools and offensive prohibitions on our cultural and spiritual practices, a breach of faith that has devastated families and communities ever since,"ANTONIO SCORZA/AFP/Getty Images)

  • ON THE PLACE WHERE THE MEETING IS BEING HELD

    HARPER: Noted the meeting was taking place on traditional Algonquin territory, but spent more time talking about the building, 111 Sussex Drive, which his government had renamed after former Progressive Conservative John Diefenbaker.<br><br> "A building whose name honours the memory of a prime minister who cared deeply about the things we are gathered here to talk about: respect, rights and opportunity for First Nations Canadians," Harper said.<br><br> ATLEO: Made no mention of the building but acknowledged the Algonquin territory and the leaders of the Algonquin nation.<br><br> "It was the Algonquins who greeted newcomers to their lands on the shores of the Ottawa River in front of us here," he said. (<a href="http://www.flickr.com/people/mrpolyonymous/" target="_hplink">Flickr: mrpolyonymous' photostream</a>)

  • ON EDUCATION

    HARPER: Stressed the need get marketable labour skills.<br><br> "Such will be the demand for labour in our future economy that we are positioned today to unlock the enormous economic potential of First Nations people and to do so in a way that meets our mutual goals. Canada's growing and vibrant economy will require a skilled and growing labour force in every region: urban, rural and remote.Aboriginal peoples are Canada's youngest population. It is therefore in all of our interests to see aboriginal people educated, skilled and employed," he said.<br><br> ATLEO: Also stressed education but said that started with funding adequate schools.<br><br> "Collectively, First Nations leaders made education our top priority. Our kids, just like every Canadian family's children, deserve good schools. That's basic, that's proof of respectful partnership...Our people can make an enormous contribution to Canada if we tackle these obstacles. Our people are the youngest, fastest growing community in a Canadian labour force that is rapidly aging. Closing the education and employment gaps for our people would contribute 400 billion dollars to the national economy and save 115 billion in expenditures," he said. (ADAM JAN/AFP/Getty Images)

  • ON TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY

    HARPER: Said he wanted to make First Nations more transparent.<br><br> "We have tabled bills to strengthen First Nations governance, with 21st century rules on elections and transparency... Our goal is to promote improved governance."<br><br> ATLEO: Said First Nations were being unnecessarily burdened with paperwork.<br><br> "We are committed to financial accountability yet this must be mutual accountability from the Government as well. Former Auditor General Sheila Fraser undertook 32 audits related to First Nations. She concluded that the quality of life conditions had actually gotten worse after her decade of study... We struggle under layer upon layer of wasteful bureaucratic interference, useless and expensive controls are piled upon our people - squandering tax dollars and frustrating change. Now, we must turn this around - increase the rate and pace of change so that all First Nations children can achieve success.(Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

  • ON THEIR GOALS FOR FIRST NATIONS

    HARPER: Said he wants to create self-sufficient citizens, self-governing communities and full participants in Canadian society.<br><br> "Our goal is much increased aboriginal participation in the economy and in the country's prosperity... In terms of participation, standard of living and quality of life the time has come for First Nations to fully share with other Canadians from all walks of life in an equal opportunity to find the dignity of gainful employment and more than that, the ability to raise a family in the security that comes with it."<br><br> Harper said the way forward was Joint Action Plan and new commitments on change the rules in education, accountability, economic development and treaty relationships.<br><br> ATLEO: Said a complete overhaul of the system was needed to ensure services get to those who need them and said decision making should be made by First Nations themselves.<br><br> "Next must come new fiscal relationships that guarantee and deliver sustainable, equitable services based on mutually agreed standards and shared responsibility. We need to build new structures and processes that affirm our relationship and uphold our responsibilities to one another. Structures that guarantee our ability to make the decisions that affect our lives and our lands - agreements that allow us, and the Government of Canada to assume their responsibilities...Today our young entrepreneurs - together with partners, can generate the economic levers that re- build our economies. At the same time, we must not forget the basic needs that touch families most closely. As neighbours, we must all find a sense of community and extend a helping hand," he said. (CP)

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

Prime Minister Stephen Harper spoke to First Nations chiefs from across Canada Tuesday morning. He called for creative changes to the Indian Act but said he had no plans to abolish the document th...
Prime Minister Stephen Harper spoke to First Nations chiefs from across Canada Tuesday morning. He called for creative changes to the Indian Act but said he had no plans to abolish the document th...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
01:15 PM on 01/27/2012
Contact us at idla@live.com for more information!
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=13902305963
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
04:28 PM on 01/27/2012
For more information regarding the Wampum belts & Indigenous Bordercrossing Rights go to www.idla@live.com

or read:
Fighting Tuscarora: The autobiography of Chief Clinton Rickard by Barbara Graymont/ Syracuse University Press 1973

ISBN#0-8156-0092-5

ps: the "People of the Stone Weir" ( Barrierre Lake) is in it as well
It's all in there, pictures of my grandparents & stories of the many struggles both the Tuscarora & Algonquin had " holding the line" as requested by Deskaheh regarding the Jay Treaty & the Treaty of Ghent.
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
01:09 PM on 01/27/2012
Ipperwash Provincial Park was originally part of the Reserve for the Kettle Point Band negotiated in good faith by the Crown and the Anishnabe. The land was appropriated for war time use with the understanding that it would be returned after the war. Instead the land was retained - half as a military base and half as a provincial park. This scenario of the Crown reneging on negotiated land settlements is unfortunately fairly common throughout Canada,.. Haldimand Tract, Tyendenaga, etc. These groups just want what is legally theirs back. We are simply doing the right thing by returning their land to them and it is truly sad that it took the death of Dudley George to bring this about.

It should be noted to all you patriotic Canadians that the loyalty, support and sacrifice of the Anishnabe, Six Nations Iroquois and other tribes has been a constant throughout our history in particular during the successful defence of Ontario in the War of 1812 from an invading American army eager to annex this great province for their land hungry people.

Were it not for these brave warriors we could easily be living in Northern Ohio.
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
01:06 PM on 01/27/2012
The aboriginal peoples backed the British with their combined efforts to defeat the Americans in the War of 1812. The Aboriginals under Tecumseh created a united First Nations Confederacy and swore allegiance to the King to ensure the continued survival of their tribes in the Northwest that were threatened by the Americans. General Isaac Brock and Tecumseh were allies and Tecumseh was crucial in the taking of Fort Detroit August 16, 1812. There was little official mention of Tecumseh's contribution in the official British record. http://www.galafilm.com/1812/e/people/tecumseh_detroit.html. The various battles of the War of 1812 and the support of the First Nations are what eventually led to the desire and fruition of Canadian Confederation.
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
12:58 PM on 01/27/2012
This policy sufficiently accounts for the acquiescence of the Government in the continued exercise of the crossing privilege upon the part of the inhabitants of Canada, with whom we have always been upon the most friendly terms . . . .30

http://www.bc.edu/bc_org/avp/law/lwsch/journals/bciclr/24_2/04_TXT.htm

[*PG313]NATIVE AMERICAN FREE PASSAGE RIGHTS UNDER THE 1794 JAY TREATY: SURVIVAL UNDER UNITED STATES STATUTORY LAW AND CANADIAN COMMON LAW
Bryan Nickels*
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
12:58 PM on 01/27/2012
However, passage of the Immigration Act and Citizenship Act in 1924 by the U.S. Congress led to the exclusion of Canadian Indians, as Canadian Indians not eligible for U.S. citizenship were thereby exclud[*PG318]able as immigrants.27 The 1927 Diablo v. McCandless decision was perhaps the first interpretive case in the U.S. discussing the Jay Treaty free passage right, some 130 years after the signing of the Jay Treaty.28 Similarly, Canadian courts did not address free passage rights under the Jay Treaty until 1954.29 The reasons for such late consideration of the free passage right in both countries was discussed by Justice Sutherland in the U.S. Supreme Court’s review of Karnuth v. United States ex rel. Albro:

It is true, as respondents assert, that citizens and subjects of the two countries continued after the War of 1812, as before, freely to pass and repass the international boundary line. And so they would have done if there never had been a treaty on the subject. Until a very recent period, the policy of the United States, with certain definitely specified exceptions, had been to open its doors to all comers without regard to their allegiance.

one more...
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
12:57 PM on 01/27/2012
B. The Treaty of Ghent
The War of 1812 subsequently broke out between the U.S. and Great Britain. At the close of the war, Great Britain pushed for the recognition of the Indian nations as full sovereigns, so as to create a “buffer zone” between the United States and Canada to prevent a possible U.S. invasion.22 The U.S. declined, compromising in a restoration of the agreements under the Jay Treaty:

The United States of America engage . . . to restore to such tribes or nations, respectively, all the possessions, rights, and privileges, which they may have enjoyed or been entitled to in one thousand eight hundred and eleven, previous to such hostilities . . . And His Britannic majesty engages . . . to restore to such tribes or nations, respectively, all the possessions, rights, and privileges, which they may have enjoyed or been entitled, to in one thousand eight hundred and eleven, previous to such hostilities.23

II. A Summary of Major U.S. and Canadian Cases
Despite the almost draconian relationship the United States had with Indian tribes, the Jay Treaty free passage right has persisted and survived.24 Prior to 1924, despite the developing antagonism to aliens in U.S. immigration laws,25 Canadian Indians were allowed to travel into the U.S., without being subjected to alien registration laws.26

con't..next post...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:21 PM on 01/24/2012
Too true. If Brock had not been killed at Niagara, Upper Canada would probably have stretched from Manhattan to Chicago and there would be no lake access at all for the US. Also if Tecumseh had not fallen at The Thames there might have been one single nation of Indians in partnership with Canada. That would have been interesting. Sadly the ponderous Prevost chose not to follow up on Brock's or De Salaberry's victories in New York and all of that gain was lost and Tecumseh cut off and left without support.
Let's not let them down again Canada.
04:03 PM on 01/24/2012
Too bad General Isaac Brock was killed early on in the war,he had promised Michigan to the native tribes.Tecumseh should be a name every Canadian Know,he was leader of the tribal confederacy.He too was killed in the war protecting the Canadian nation along side the Brits .We almost were beaten by those pesty southerners.
We did win that invasion despite some claims from the south .
This should be a big celebration on this anniversary.