Bob Rae: Interim Liberal Leader Says First Nations Poverty An Embarrassment

Bob Rae

First Posted: 01/28/2012 4:06 pm Updated: 01/28/2012 9:54 pm

VANCOUVER - Interim Liberal Party leader Bob Rae says the gaps in education, health care and housing between First Nations communities and other Canadians are an embarrassment and must be addressed.

Speaking at the YWCA in Vancouver, Rae said the relationship of governments with aboriginal people "is a great example of truly unfinished, unreconciled business in the country."

The wave of aboriginal "immigration" from reserves during the last 50 years means the poverty they face is no longer hidden, he said Saturday.

Rae said many of Canada's largest cities now include "aboriginal ghettos" where the anger fuelled by inequality has led to suicide and crime.

"Toronto has been described, quite rightly, as the largest reserve in the country," he said. "This problem is no longer out there, this problem is right here.

"As it gets closer to us it also has to be closer to our hearts and to our understanding, to extent that we have not embraced aboriginal culture, we have not understood First Nations history, we have not appreciated the loss, the indignity and the deep sense of injustice that now has to spur us to action."

The former NDP premier in Ontario said the federal Conservative government's response has been to build more jails but that hasn't increased safety in communities or reduced crime.

Younger generations of First Nations aren't getting the education they need to get ahead and many are living in foster homes, he said.

"There are more kids today across the country who are in foster care and being taken away from their homes than during the residential community time," he said.

But he said South Africa, Australia, New Zealand and the United States also deal with the same issues regarding their aboriginal people and no country has come up with the right policy.

Better social policies are also needed to address housing, which was abandoned as a priority by Ottawa and most provincial government 25 years ago, Rae said.

"Each level of government says,'It's not my responsibility, somebody else has to look at this,'" he said, adding that some cities have taken a leadership role to deal with the issue.

Rae said that when the Conservatives came to power in 2006, their first budget identified housing as a provincial issue with too much federal government involvement.

But he said Ottawa must be a reliable partner in housing because it's indirectly involved in interest rates and mortgages and can't pretend it doesn't have any expertise or resources to deal with it.

However, he said the federal government can't go back to the expensive programs of the past and must instead involve the private sector.

Rae also said Canadians desperately need better social policies for mental illness.

Every province has shut down its largest mental health institutions, but programs to replace them aren't adequate, Rae said.

Even soldiers and civil servants who served their country in Afghanistan and are suffering from post-traumatic stress aren't getting the help they need, he said.

"We, as a party, need to be the ones to say, `How are we going to deal with this problem?'"

Related on HuffPost:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

VANCOUVER - Interim Liberal Party leader Bob Rae says the gaps in education, health care and housing between First Nations communities and other Canadians are an embarrassment and must be addressed.Sp...
VANCOUVER - Interim Liberal Party leader Bob Rae says the gaps in education, health care and housing between First Nations communities and other Canadians are an embarrassment and must be addressed.Sp...
Filed by Jacqueline Delange  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:17 AM on 02/25/2012
Aboriginal discontent: An attitude of entitlement or a legacy of prejudice? (http://wp.me/p1h552-d3)
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
12:27 AM on 01/31/2012
White man's windfall | Macleans.ca - Canada - Features
White man's windfall ... But Ottawa is balking, raising questions about just how ... The letter, signed by Matthew Merchant, seems to promise a ...

www.macleans.ca/article.jsp?content=20060911_133025_133025

&

Aboriginals and First Nations news and information Front Page ...
... First Nations, Native Peoples' news and ... Just another empty white man's promise. http://www.thestar.com/article/154309 ... The Union of Ontario Indians is the oldest ...

www.turtleisland.org/news/kelownaaccord.html
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
12:14 AM on 01/31/2012
Another interestin­­g point in the Standing Committee’­­s report was:

“Gilbert Whiteduck of Québec’s First Nations Education Council told us that the 2002 Minister’s National Working Group on Education “concluded there were 6,000 reports on First Nations education in this country”. In his view, “It is now time to stop studying the issue and take action, by developing specific programs. … [W]e should really be thinking of the young people who no longer have any hope, and yet would like to make a positive contributi­­on to Canadian society in their own culture.”

http://sci­­enceadvoc­a­cy.org/B­lo­g/2011/­11/­23/mor­e-on­-abor­igina­l-ed­ucatio­n-i­n-canad­a/

&

http://www­­.cprn.org­/­document­s/­51980_E­N.p­df

&

http://onc­­ampus.mac­l­eans.ca/­ed­ucation­/20­11/03/­22/a­borig­inal-­stud­ents-s­ee-­subtant­ia­l-increa­s­e-in-clic­­hes/

&

http://www­­.abo-peop­l­es.org/C­AP­/Media/­chi­ef/Edu­cati­on.pd­f

BTW: It was the Liberals who imposed a 2% CAP in 1996...

http://www­­.afn.ca/u­p­loads/fi­le­s/elect­ion­/20110­415_­assem­bly_o­f_fi­rst_na­tio­ns_resp­on­se_ndp_f­i­nal.pdf

&

http://www­­.psac-afp­c­.com/iss­ue­s/campa­ign­s/abor­igin­al/ed­ucati­onfu­nding-­e.s­html
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
12:13 AM on 01/31/2012
ABORIGINAL PEOPLE:/HI­STORY OF DISCRIMINA­TORY LAWS*

This paper will outline the history of federal and provincial laws applicable to aboriginal people.

Much has been written about discrimina­tory federal legislatio­n respecting Indians. The exclusive jurisdicti­on of Parliament over "Indians and lands reserved for the Indians"(1­) and the large body of resulting federal legislatio­n(2) are obvious reasons for the emphasis on the federal side of this story. There has been relatively little discussion­, however, of the discrimina­tory provincial legislatio­n and the joint impact of federal and provincial discrimina­tion on the basic human rights of aboriginal people. This paper does not attempt to identify exhaustive­ly every instance of statutory discrimina­tion and its implicatio­ns. It will, however, review the history of this issue and examine both federal and provincial strands of legislatio­n. The word "discrimin­ation" will be used in the sense of legal distinctio­ns singling out aboriginal people for special treatment and operating to the detriment of their fundamenta­l human rights.

http://dsp­-psd.pwgsc­.gc.ca/Col­lection-R/­LoPBdP/BP/­bp175-e.ht­m#CONCLUSI­ON%28txt%29

&

http://www­.vsw.ca/Do­cuments/RR­TimelineJu­ne10thFINA­L.pdf

&

http://www­.cbnrm.net­/pdf/un_00­1.pdf
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
12:12 AM on 01/31/2012
see page 12:
http://www­­.cmec.ca/­P­ublicati­on­s/Lists­/Pu­blicat­ions­/Atta­chmen­ts/2­21/abo­rig­inal_su­mm­it_repor­t­.pdf

Strengthen­­ingAborig­i­nal Success:Mo­­ving Toward Learn Canada 2020

© 2010 Council of Ministers of Education, Canada

&

CMEC Summit on Aboriginal Education: Summary Report. Strengthen­­ing ..... support has been capped since 1996 at an increase of 2 per cent per year. ...

http://edu­­cationisa­r­ight.ca/­en­/sectio­n/1­1

Inadequate funding has forced the Aboriginal communitie­­s who administer the Program to make difficult decisions about who can pursue a post-secon­­dary education. It is estimated that between 2001 and 2006, underfundi­­ng resulted in over 10,500 students being denied access to post-secon­­dary education, with an additional 2,588 in 2007 alone. This lack of resources has left Aboriginal students particular­­ly vulnerable to tuition and ancillary fee increases. While increases in funding for the PSSSP have been capped at two percent per year, tuition fees increased by upwards of seven percent per year, and have more than doubled since the introducti­­on of the cap in 1997.

In addition, non-Status First Nations and Métis peoples are currently not eligible for funding through the PSSSP, leaving many without the financial resources necessary to pursue post-secon­­dary education.­­Regardles­s of their place of residence, the majority of Aboriginal graduates return to work in their communitie­­s and are employed in their field of study, achieving economic self-relia­­nce and helping to develop healthy and stable communitie­­s.
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
12:10 AM on 01/31/2012
Lack of parity in funding...

To place the federal spending in perspectiv­­e, consider the federal government­­’s commitment to new immigrants to Canada. In the same year that the government transferre­­d $13.4 million to Native Friendship Centres, it spent over $256 million on immigrant settlement and integratio­­n.

The discrepanc­­y between these amounts becomes most apparent when seen on a per capita basis.
Federal immigrant settlement and transition spending in 1996-97 was $247 per person who immigrated in the previous five years, while the government­­’s contributi­­on to Native Friendship Centres was $34 per urban Aboriginal person.

Perhaps this helps to explain the difficulti­­es many Aboriginal people are experienci­­ng in adjusting to life in western Canadian cities...e­­h?

Hasn't changed as yet..
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
12:08 AM on 01/31/2012
Canada as a Fair and Enlightene­­d Society

Canada enjoys a reputation as a special place - a place where human rights and dignity are guaranteed­­, where the rules of liberal democracy are respected, where diversity among peoples is celebrated­­. But this reputation represents­­, at best, a half-truth­­.

A careful reading of history shows that Canada was founded on a series of bargains with Aboriginal peoples - bargains this country has never fully honoured. Treaties between Aboriginal and non-Aborig­­inal government­­s were agreements to share the land. They were replaced by policies intended to

...remove Aboriginal people from their homelands.

...suppres­­s Aboriginal nations and their government­­s.

...undermi­­ne Aboriginal cultures.

...stifle Aboriginal identity.

It is now time to acknowledg­­e the truth and begin to rebuild the relationsh­­ip among peoples on the basis of honesty, mutual respect and fair sharing. The image of Canada in the world and at home demands no less.

The foundation­­s of a fair and equitable relationsh­­ip were laid in our early interactio­­n.

http://www­­.aadnc-aa­n­dc.gc.ca­/e­ng/1100­100­014597­#chp­3
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
12:08 AM on 01/31/2012
1969 White Paper vs. 1970 Red Paper

After WWII the Joint Committee of the Senate House of Commons wanted to extend "human rights" to Indians. In 1969 the Federal Government­'s Statement of Policy declared total assimilati­on to be the goal within a short period of time. Indian Affairs was to be abolished. Special Indian legislatio­n was to be repealed. Treaties and Land claims were to be considered insignific­ant. The provinces would evidential­ly provide all the services. The primary theme of the Statement of Policy was that the Federal Government would relinquish her responsibi­lity for Indians and transfer it over to the Provinces. The Red Paper of 1970 prepared by the Indian Chiefs of Alberta condemned the 1969 policy and described it as: "A scheme whereby within a generation or shortly after the proposed Indian Lands Act expires, our people would be left with no land; and consequent­ly the future generation would be condemned to the despair and ugly spectre of urban poverty in ghettos."”
photo
butchcliff
The future is unwritten
07:16 AM on 01/30/2012
Where was Rae when he was Premier with Ontario First Nations under his jurisdiction?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mike Keohane
01:31 PM on 01/29/2012
The embarrassment is that Bob Rae will ultimately collect multiple gold plated pensions.
photo
Spanky McFarlane
ILLEGITIMUS NON CARBORUNDUM.
12:30 AM on 01/29/2012
No Mr. Rae, You are wrong...

You know it's documented that some of our First Nation's were purposefully traded/infected with blankets laced with the small pox virus (taken from the bedsides& bodies of those already afflicted). As the Native population knowingly had no immunity, this was a form of genocide.
Add to this their vilification, ostracism & their constant & sustained exposure to racism & you begin to see the commonality between our early FN's & plight of European Jews about 100 years later.

However , What you don't see today is the level poverty on the streets of 'Tel Aviv' that you do in our FN communities.
What you do see is Mr. Harper taking a direct interest in the affairs of Israel, but showing far less resolve toward our FN's problems & downright disdain when a community receives atd from the 'Red Cross' as a means of survival.

Yes,Mr. Harper has trashed signed Accords with FN's ,& replaced them with zip(?) ,so evidently if the FN's want to see 'more of him' or have him 'champion their cause' they will simply have to become much more affluent & influential it would seem- & that Mr. Rae is more of an "Embarrassment".to Canada than of what you speak. IMO.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
piceaglauca
The picture says it all....
10:33 PM on 01/28/2012
Bob, what's the problem. Jean Chretien did a working paper on revision of the Indian Act but the First Nations refused. They liked the deal. So what is you issue? When you get back in power you can resurrect the Kelowna Accord and ask Paul Martin to help you.