Pro-Palestinian Remark Cut From Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird's United Nations Address, Documents Show

Baird Palestine Un Speech

First Posted: 02/19/2012 11:14 am Updated: 02/19/2012 1:40 pm

OTTAWA - A Canadian expression of goodwill toward the Palestinian people was left on the cutting-room floor when Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird addressed the United Nations General Assembly last fall.

Baird rejected early departmental drafts of his maiden address to the UN that said Canada is a "leading supporter" of the Palestinian people and outlined major spending that backed that assertion, The Canadian Press has learned.

Baird ended up delivering a much tougher address than envisioned by his speech writers, one that unequivocally emphasized Canada's support for Israel — a position for which he makes no apologies and which has generated much criticism of the Harper Conservatives.

Copies of the draft texts of the speech, obtained under the Access to Information Act, show Baird used a radically reworked text when he represented Canada for the first time at the General Assembly on Sept. 26, 2011.

In his address, Baird drew a parallel with pre-Second World War appeasers of Nazi Germany, saying: "Canada will not accept or stay silent while the Jewish state is attacked for defending its territory and its citizens. The Second World War taught us all the tragic price of 'going along' just to 'get along.'

The only direct reference to the Palestinian people in Baird's address was to emphasize Canada's opposition to the Palestinian Authority's stated plan to seek recognition of statehood at the assembly.

The Palestinian statehood issue dominated last fall's session of the assembly, and Canada's opposition — mirroring that of many countries, including the United States — was well known at the time.

Indeed, the first draft of Baird's speech noted that "Canada has been very clear that it does not support the recognition of Palestinian state." The early drafts as well as the final version also urged the Palestinians to get back to the negotiating table with Israel.

But a lengthy paragraph that expressed positive Canadian sentiments toward the Palestinians was eventually trimmed over the course of a handful of early revisions and was eventually cut altogether.

"Canada is a leading supporter of the Palestinian people, having committed $300 million over five years to assist the Palestinian Authority to build capacity in the key areas of justice sector reform, security, and sustainable economic growth, as well as providing humanitarian assistance to Palestinians in West Bank and Gaza, including refugees," the first draft stated.

It went on to say that Canada provided $64.61 million in development and humanitarian assistance in 2009-10.

"Our support for the West Bank and Gaza demonstrates Canada's ongoing commitment to assist Palestinians in building the foundations of a viable, independent, democratic and peaceful Palestinian state living side by side in peace and security with Israel," the excised paragraph concluded.

Three days before Baird's address, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas formally announced his intent to pursue the Palestinian statehood bid in his own general assembly speech.

Two days before Abbas's speech, Prime Minister Stephen Harper held a face-to-face meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the UN. The two leaders expressed their mutual admiration and friendship.

Last month, Baird travelled to Israel, accompanied by an orthodox Jewish rabbi from his Ottawa riding, and repeatedly told his hosts that Israel has no greater friend than Canada. Baird told Netanyahu he was proud to watch his UN speech last September.

On a trip to the West Bank, Baird told Abbas in a separate meeting that the Palestinians should get back to the bargaining table with the Israelis — without preconditions — to search for a peaceful solution to the Middle East conflict.

Baird's office declined to comment on the UN speech writing process.

"The speech he delivered is Canada's foreign policy," said spokesman Joseph Lavoie.

Baird's speech clearly bore his own personal stamp, and reflected his characteristic penchant for fiery oration.

He injected the speech with previous quotes from Harper, Conservative icon Margaret Thatcher, and former Conservative Canadian prime minister John Diefenbaker as well as Winston Churchill.

Baird also changed the fact that the speech writers did not directly mention the government's plan to set up an Office of Religious Freedom in the department, a promise the Conservatives made in last spring's federal election campaign. Baird emphasized that point in his actual address.

As an example of religious persecution, both drafts cited violence against Coptic Christians in Egypt. But in the final version, Baird added some pointed criticism of China, adding the example of, "Roman Catholic priests and other Christian clergy, and their laity, driven to worship underground in China."

Baird also added criticism of Burma for discriminating against Buddhists and Muslims.

And he singled out the East African country of Uganda, a country he has since come to repeatedly criticize for criminalizing the activities of gays and lesbians.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

OTTAWA - A Canadian expression of goodwill toward the Palestinian people was left on the cutting-room floor when Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird addressed the United Nations General Assembly last ...
OTTAWA - A Canadian expression of goodwill toward the Palestinian people was left on the cutting-room floor when Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird addressed the United Nations General Assembly last ...
Filed by Lauren Strapagiel  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 247
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
09:41 PM on 02/20/2012
The government of Canada took an historic step yesterday by signing the Ottawa Protocol to Combat Anti-Semitism. By doing so, it recognized anti-Semitism as a pernicious evil and a global threat against the Jewish people, the State of Israel and free, democratic countries everywhere. As Prime Minister Stephen Harper has noted, “Those who would hate and destroy the Jewish people would ultimately hate and destroy the rest of us as well.”

http://irwincotler.liberal.ca/media/irwin-cotler-delivers-remarks-at-signing-of-ottawa-protocol-on-combating-antisemitism/

Criticism of Israel must not be equated with anti-semitism

http://www.edmontonjournal.com/opinion/Criticism+Israel+must+equated+with+anti+semitism/5771800/story.html

By Laurie Adkin | November 26, 2011 | Edmonton Journal | Laurie Adkin is an associate professor in the department of political science at the University of Alberta.
© Copyright (c) The Edmonton Journal

Canadians abducted by Israel to address coast to coast audiences

http://404systemerror.com/canada-most-pro-zionist-government-in-the-world-activist/#canadians-abducted-by-israel-to-address-coast-to-coast-audiences

Dates, locations, and details of the speaking tour: http://www.tahrir.ca/speaking-tour-2012
Tour informational video: http://www.tahrir.ca/video-blockade-gaza-canadas-role

On November 4th last year, with a wink and a nod from the Canadian government, Israel sent a clear and unambiguous message to Canadian activists intent on challenging the illegal blockade of Gaza:
07:33 PM on 02/20/2012
Amazing our system where a Canadian foreign affairs minister can make a Prime Ministers (or his own) personal eccentricities National policy and claim to speak for me. The life, Happiness and security of Palestinians or any others are of no less value than the rest of humanity. Mr. Baird your big mouth and bullying abilities are truly impressive, but this is not a schoolyard and we are not children anymore. Time to grow up. Canadians are not idiots, however it seems at times that the inmates are running the asylum.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kenl77
03:12 PM on 02/20/2012
"Baird told Netanyahu he was proud to watch his UN speech last September."

This is called fawning.
It is unworthy of a serious person, let alone our nation's representative and foreign affairs minister.

But then, we're talking about John Baird here, aren't we?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
YankeeCanuck
dog
02:59 PM on 02/20/2012
Imagine the speech our foreign minister would have given if he were pro-humanity.
10:47 AM on 02/20/2012
If there was any doubt that Harper's middle eastern policy is totally hijacked by extreme right wing element of Israeli politics, this clears it off.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Keith E
Earth Warrior
10:37 AM on 02/20/2012
Until the injustice done to Palestinians is recognized and reconciled there is no chance of peace in the middle east. Zero.

I really despise that Canada defends Israel.
10:50 PM on 02/20/2012
I really love that Canada defends Israel.
photo
wisdom4you
wisdom is/ = alter ego perspectives :-)
03:23 AM on 02/21/2012
harley, why?
photo
wisdom4you
wisdom is/ = alter ego perspectives :-)
03:01 PM on 02/22/2012
Keith E .. I do not know you, however, without question, I totally agree with your crystal clear insult as to the truths.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Keith E
Earth Warrior
04:55 PM on 02/22/2012
Thanks wisdom,. fanned
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:25 AM on 02/20/2012
Blaming Jews for Harper Party policies is exactly what the Party wants. It plays right into the Harper Party's political hand.

The Harper Party, emulating destructive US Republican policy, painted itself as the "pro-Israel" party and smeared opponents as antisemitic, even a Jewish Member of Parliament who, unlike them, has a long, distinguished record of supporting Israelis, because they were after votes in his riding.

http://www.ottawacitizen.com/life/smearing+Irwin+Cotler/5849789/story.html

Refusing to express any sign of friendship toward Palestinian people shows the policy is extreme, self-serving, divisive and rooted in religious fanaticism. It feeds off resentments towards both Muslims and Jews. It is not a "pro-Israel" policy in any true sense. In fact, it's counter-productive to the best long term interests of both Israelis and Palestinians. This kind of policy has dimished the ability of the US to play a positive role in accomplishing either.
10:17 AM on 02/20/2012
Thre are over 100 countries that want to recognize a Palestinian state at the UN, most of which are opposed to the recognition of the state of Israel or to its continued existence. That does not seem to bother the writer of this column. What bothers him/her is the fact that some nice thing that a speech writer had to say about Palestinians was left on the cutting room floor and not delivered by the Canadian cabinet minister. Canada's support for Israel delivered in a speech doesn't necessarily have to include statement of support for Palestinians. Just as criticism of Palestinian tactics in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict doesn't mean Israel must be criticised too.

This so-called conflict is not between two political parties competing in an election or over a proposed bill in some parliament. Anyone who is not blind and deaf knows that this bloody conflict is nothing less than a war the Arabs have been waging against Israel, and most conspicuously since September 1993. That was the year when the Palestine Liberation Organization (a terrorist organization) signed the Israel-PLO Agreement and thereafter became legitimized or dignified as the (innocuous) Palestinian Authority.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Keith E
Earth Warrior
10:40 AM on 02/20/2012
Israel are the terrorists. Anyone who is not indoctrinated by the western media knows this.
11:34 AM on 02/20/2012
That is the belief of those who read the New York Times and Toronto Star. The rest of us who read the Washington Times and the National Post know who the real terrorists are. And they certainly aren't Jewish.
09:43 AM on 02/20/2012
i can't beleive that here in canada we have the same "israel is always right" thinking. but we do

that spells trouble in the short and long run. this poster "harley open road" doesn't seem like the kind of person that will ever make sense. like his name you can pour gas into it but all it will ever do is make noise.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gravescanada
09:17 AM on 02/20/2012
The Holocaust perpetrated on the Israelis during WW2 is still relevant today. Why, because we dare not allow it to be repeated. When we talk of the Holocaust that was perpetrated against Native Canadians, and Native Americans, we are told that it is to far in the past, and not relevant today. Conservatives, you can NOT have it both ways. What we did to the natives in North America is relevant today as it was 200 years ago, because its been going on the whole time. The UN Carved out a nation for the Jews, we shuffled the native tribes around every time we found some profitable natural resource on their reserve. If we treated the Tribes of Israel the way we treat the Natives in North America, we would be called antisemitic. Every year we in North America give billions of dollars to Israel with no string attached. Then, people scream about the millions "given" to Natives. Palestine was under the rule of the Ottoman Empire when Europe was colonizing North America. Why is it that we recognize the claim Israel says it has over its lands, and dismiss the Native North Americans claims on their lands? We are the oppressors. We invaded North America and displaced its native people. We in North America grew and prospered to become an economic powerhouse of the world, while the original people of this land are treated as an inconvenience, and recipients of "welfare".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gravescanada
09:24 AM on 02/20/2012
People say, the natives should leave their reserves we put them in years ago and go find work. WE CREATED THIS SITUATION! Our ancestors committed genocide over and over, its in the history books, it is indisputable. We have tried to force these peoples to assimilate into our society, so that we can close the book on the atrocities our Great and Great Great Grandparents allowed to occur. We must stop blaming the victims and playing a game of false equivalencies. If Israel can claim a land based on history, why can Native not make the same claim here in North America?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
YankeeCanuck
dog
02:24 PM on 02/20/2012
These two struggles are related. Both atrocities were perpetrated by colonial settler societies. Both Canada and Israel are legitimate states now. One has at least acknowledged the past---that is inadequate IMHO, be it's a start. Israel is nowhere near acknowledging the atrocity that is ongoing: oppression and military occupation.
08:45 AM on 02/20/2012
The fundamental problem is that folks like Baird don't read.
01:10 PM on 02/23/2012
Can't read.
photo
fromdnorth
OK I checked my micro-bio (didn't know I had one
05:19 AM on 02/20/2012
Sucking up a la Newt...
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
03:23 AM on 02/20/2012
Canada supports Israel because it is a Christian country & there is much guilt over the Holocaust & it shameful treatment during WW2:

In 1939, the St. Louis arrived in Halifax with some 900 Jewish asylum seekers fleeing Hitler’s Germany. Like Cuba and the United States, Canada refused to accept them and they had to be taken back to Europe. More than 200 of them were later murdered by the Nazis.

& lastly born again Christians know that for Rapture...

"Briefly stated, Christian Zionism is a movement within Protestant fundamentalism that sees the modern state of Israel as the fulfillment of Biblical prophecy and thus deserving of political, financial and religious support. Christian Zionists work closely with the Israeli government, religious and secular Jewish Zionist organizations, and are particularly empowered during periods when the more conservative Likud Party is in control of the Knesset. "

http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article4930.htm
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Whistlejackett
Hey stop doing that
05:29 AM on 02/20/2012
Actually Donna it's a lot simpler than that. No one cares about the holocaust any more. No one cares that Israel is so combative and confused. People just want Palestine to be recognized and treated fairly. All the God stuff from Israel is senseless to discuss and certainly we know where that leads to.
09:05 AM on 02/20/2012
No one cares about the Holocaust anymore?!

I toured the Dachau concentration camp near Munich a few years ago. The pictures and stories of near-indescribable horror committed by the Nazis against the Jews, homosexuals, and mentally-challenged haunt me to this day.

Israel may be guilty of over-reaction when attacked, but now I understand why.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
YankeeCanuck
dog
02:30 PM on 02/20/2012
There are different ways to care about the Holocaust. There are commonalities among all atrocities, IMHO.
There is another camp that says that the Holocaust is unique--that camp says "Never Again" and means never again for Jewish people. This is the basis of the fortress mentality that makes Israel so authoritarian, militaristic and paranoid.
Others say "Never Again" and they mean it for all humanity. They care about the Holocaust, and they care about any attempt to de-humanise any peoples.
12:59 AM on 02/20/2012
The Jews are controlling Canada now?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nete peedham
09:03 AM on 02/20/2012
No, it's far-right, American segregation-state politics. Mostly hard-right Zionist and evangelicals in the states, like the idiot John Hagee. Hagee figures that when the rapture comes(and thought 9/11 was 'it'), then Jesus would sit on the throne of Jerusalem, and the Jews that held it faithfully for God would be 'accepted' as Christians. Isn't that WHITE of him?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
YankeeCanuck
dog
02:33 PM on 02/20/2012
No. But Zionist pressure groups have been far more organised, well-financed and effective than groups like Jews for a Just Peace and Independent Jewish Voices.
And don;t forget the extreme fundamentalist Christians who are shilling for the state of Israel so that Jews can be in Israel at the time of the Rapture--to either convert or be cast into the fires. Sort of like an eternal Inquisition.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SeanMartin
Everything in moderation.
12:58 AM on 02/20/2012
>> "Canada provided $64.61 million in development and humanitarian assistance (to Gaza and the West Bank) in 2009-10."

Where on earth did all that money go?
01:01 AM on 02/20/2012
Swiss bank accounts of _Ha'mas_ leaders.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SeanMartin
Everything in moderation.
01:05 AM on 02/20/2012
Given that the money no doubt had to be funneled through Israel's leadership, I rather suspect that the funds went into *their* accounts, not those of Hamas.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nete peedham
08:59 AM on 02/20/2012
AND, you've got absolute proof! Please enlighten us.