Environmental Assessment Report Slammed As 'Fictitious'

Oil Sands Canada

First Posted: 03/13/2012 2:58 pm Updated: 03/14/2012 6:35 pm


A report from the Commons environment committee has government MPs calling for the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act to be "modernized" and the opposition dismissing the committee's work as a fiction.


The majority opinion made 20 recommendations on how to bring the legislation up to date in the report released Tuesday. The main focus was on reducing overlap between provincial and federal assessments and speeding up the system.


"Quite simply CEAA needs to be modernized. Canada needs an environmental assessment process by which our country's great wealth of natural resources can be sustainably developed in a timely fashion while ensuring our natural heritage is protected," said Michelle Rempel, parliamentary secretary to the Minister of the Environment.


Rempel talked about the need for a "one-project, one-review process." Basically, it is a call to cut down on the regulatory hoops that companies must jump through to get a project up and running.


"We should be able to achieve positive environmental outcomes but ensure that the business process that surrounds [environmental assessments] are effective and efficient," said Rempel.


The report also recommended that the Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency, the body responsible for administering the CEAA, restrict itself to assessing "projects of environmental significance."


"In its current form, the CEAA requires an environmental assessment be completed before a new bench can be installed in a Canadian National Park," recounted Rempel.


Dissenting opinion


The New Democrats wanted nothing to do with the report and tacked on a five-page dissenting opinion at the end.


"We highlight the numerous and highly concerning ways that this process was flawed, which makes the report deficient. The long and the short of it, the report did not meet any acceptable standard for what a legislative review should look like," said NDP Environment Critic Megan Leslie. The report came out of a mandatory five-year review of the CEAA.


The opposition's main objections to the final report were that not enough time was spent on the review itself and that some expert witnesses were excluded from testifying. Leslie said the report was written just to provide the government with "handy messaging."


"The report you will have before you is a fictitious re-enactment of committee hearings," argued Leslie.


Green Party leader Elizabeth May was even more scathing.


"Pipelines, oil sands development, projects big and small will be rubber-stamped in jig time," May told reporters outside the House of Commons.


Among the committee's other recommendations:


- consolidate the minister's powers so that decisions to review projects are a one-step process instead of two.


- eliminate parts of the act that look at the capacity of renewable resources and that allow an examination of business alternatives.


- introduce binding timelines for all environmental assessments.


- if provinces are set up to assess a project, let them do it on their own, instead of a two-step process or a joint review.


- create a list of projects that should be reviewed, instead of assuming everything needs a review.


Related on HuffPost:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA POLITICS

A report from the Commons environment committee has government MPs calling for the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act to be "modernized" and the opposition dismissing the committee's w...
A report from the Commons environment committee has government MPs calling for the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act to be "modernized" and the opposition dismissing the committee's w...
Filed by Michael Bolen  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Planarama
Common sense will one day prevail.
09:29 AM on 03/14/2012
Harper is at war with the values of Canadians. This is clear now.

The NDP and Liberals MUST MERGE. Too much is now at stake.
yer
Stop the Alberta Taliban
08:48 AM on 03/14/2012
NDP and Liberals MUST MERGE if this litany of lies is to ever end anytime soon. Everyday is doesn't happen is another day the country suffers
yer
Stop the Alberta Taliban
08:47 AM on 03/14/2012
Alberta will rubber stamp their own projects without end. China gave the go ahead
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Norma Ward
08:03 AM on 03/14/2012
Here is an article that quite clearly outlines how much we already know about the impact of the mining process on watersheds in the Athabasca region, an issue that is only going to get worse as the scale of the mining increases:

http://viableopposition.blogspot.com/2012/02/monitoring-environmental-impact-of.html

All of this research was done independently of the oil industry and the federal government.
photo
Winterseeker
For the trees...we need them, not vice versa.
03:46 AM on 03/14/2012
This government is a mockery, it needs to come down fast and I'm beginning to think nothing short of a band of assassins (joking) can save our country...seriously who the hell had the idea of voting for this guy!?! Let this robocall scandal go full tilt and hopefully we can bring the Harper dictatorship down to a minority.
11:15 PM on 03/13/2012
The Harper government seems to be a branch of the mafia. It makes one think Madoff's biggest mistake was not getting the governmet to legalize ponzi schemes. One can be sure it will fill the new jails with small fry and legalize the big guns. We can look to have those nasty ads on cigarette packs removed - they may actually get in the way of sales.
yer
Stop the Alberta Taliban
08:52 AM on 03/14/2012
How is the current banking system not a Ponzi scheme?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DirkNeptune
I love raspberry pie, damn it.
10:28 PM on 03/13/2012
This is standard operating procedure for conservatives. Put someone in charge of the environment who is bent on destroying it. George W. Bush was famous for it.

The people running our country right now are enemies of Canada. And now we find out, they broke the law in their "the ends justify the means" campaign to get themselves re-elected.

These people are evil and an embarrassment to every clear-thinking Canadian. Dark days for Canada are ahead.
08:03 PM on 03/13/2012
The whole point is too ensure unfettered resource exploitation, and forget how sustainable it is. Business gets what it wants, when it wants, but the citizens and their descendants in Canada have their interests completely abandoned, by the very authorities whose sworn duty it is to protect those interests.

Is anybody still in any doubt that this is not your father's Conservative Party? This is a whole new mutation that places all of its blind faith, along with it's law-making power, in the free, unregulated market. Free-market outcomes, by definition and without debate, must be the best. It's kinda like....a religion, since attention to facts and evidence don't enter the picture.

This is a kissing cousin of the current Republican Party of America - and Harper's gang ARE in power and have it for the next four years.

Let's hope Canada survives in a recognizable form.
07:51 PM on 03/13/2012
And in light of what's happened in Northern Ontario/Alberta we should just trust the Tories to protect both Canadian residents and our environment? Sorry I'm not buying that but what the hey, instead let's build a few prisons, and throw our young offenders and mentally ill citizens into the slammer! Surely that will stop the poisoning of our northern communities....
01:42 AM on 03/14/2012
We need jobs and money. But we also need clean air, food and water. You cannot breathe money, you cannot eat it or drink it. The problem with sending everyone to jail is that the majority gets released back into the general population. The only people who make money are the ones that own the prisons.
photo
Newfoundlander
I'm a pessimist, an optimist with experience!
06:36 PM on 03/13/2012
Science? We don't need no stinking science!!
photo
freeSpeakr
I stand on the shoulders of giants
07:27 PM on 03/13/2012
Nope their plan is Deus Ex Machina. http://goo.gl/CVpe
photo
Another Pesky Canadian
Talk - action = 0
06:05 PM on 03/13/2012
"...while ensuring our natural heritage is protected..."

"protected"....ConSpeak for PAVED.
photo
freeSpeakr
I stand on the shoulders of giants
07:26 PM on 03/13/2012
Of course paved. Are we gonna let that good land go to waste. Nope. Cover it in asphalt and seal in the nutrients!
georgee2
My Canada Includes Everyone
05:29 PM on 03/13/2012
This government has used fiction time and time again to push through laws that simply ignore the facts. Why should this be any different.
06:53 PM on 03/13/2012
The price of freedom is eternal vigilance, they say. We must demand more from OUR REPRESENTATIVES! We can not become indifferent to the direction Canada takes in the world.
09:42 PM on 03/13/2012
We are not indifferent, the problem is that we have NO representatives in Ottawa with any power whatsoever. About the only way to prevent Harper from doing whatever he wants for the next three-some years would be to nuke 24 Sussex or the parliament buildings while he is present. As a less extreme alternative, plan for 2015, hope enough sheeple wake up and that the NDP and Libs come to their senses and join forces in some way.