Family Denied Immigration Due To Down Syndrome

First Posted: 03/30/2012 9:43 pm Updated: 04/ 1/2012 2:24 pm


A New Democrat MP is demanding the federal government reverse a decision to bar a family from India from emigrating to Canada to join their son in B.C. because their adult daughter has Down Syndrome.


The son, Kevin Patel, of Vancouver, wanted to sponsor his parents and 27-year-old sister to come to Canada to become permanent residents.


But Immigration Canada rejected the request because it says the sister's condition could pose an excessive burden on Canada's health and social services.


NDP citizenship critic Don Davies says that conclusion is not supported by any facts, and in fact is contradicted by the evidence submitted in this case.


Davies told a news conference Friday that the refusal represents a bigoted and discriminatory view that's not in keeping with the modern understanding of people with Down.


The sister, Aditi Patel, lives with her parents who care for her, said Patel.


Promise to pay


He said he promised Canadian officials he would cover the costs of any services his sister would require.


Barbara Laird, the parent of a daughter with Down Syndrome, also attended the news conference in support of Patel.


"They have huge potential. They have huge intelligence," laird said. "They do things really well, sometimes better than the rest of us. They are extremely undervalued from birth up."


Davies is calling on Immigration Minister Jason Kenney to reverse the decision and allow the family to be reunited in Canada.


Down Syndrome is a genetic condition estimated to occur in about one in every 733 births, although is statistically higher among older parents. It is associated with some impairment of cognitive ability and physical growth and a particular set of facial characteristics.


FOLLOW HUFFPOST CANADA

A New Democrat MP is demanding the federal government reverse a decision to bar a family from India from emigrating to Canada to join their son in B.C. because their adult daughter has Do...
A New Democrat MP is demanding the federal government reverse a decision to bar a family from India from emigrating to Canada to join their son in B.C. because their adult daughter has Do...
Filed by Christian Cotroneo  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 52
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
12:24 AM on 04/15/2012
I am completely disgusted by these comments. You talk of "burdened health care" and "we have enough people with DS already". Take a moment and think about the facts here. Let me ask you; when you visit a walk in clinic or emerg room,How many people do you see are actually born and raised in Canada? In Toronto I would say at least 80% are from other countries (Asian/Indian) Now let me ask you this; the last time you visited a clinic or emergency room how many people had Down Syndrome? I am going to guess NONE!! I am simply disgusted by the fact we would impose specific immigration rules to people who possess a Chromosonal difference. This topic is near to my heart as my son has Down Syndrome. What I can tell is that he is healthier than most of the babies I know. He is no burden AT ALL!! I am appalled that in this day and age we still view disabilities as BURDENS when we know where the burden really lies. I think the bigger issue here is the influx of immigrants period. Why don't we ban immigrants who are old and ailing? Why are we picking on a person with Down syndrome who represents the SMALLEST % of immigrants and in return will have the LEAST impact on our health care system. I am going to be cheeky now but god forbid this person with DS actually has some skills that would be beneficial.
11:38 AM on 03/31/2012
The problem with the whole "family reunification" policy is it is abused and misused regularly. This policy should be limited to spouse/children and that's it. No more aged parents getting fast track immigration to then become a drain on a system already overburdened. No more siblings, with Down's or otherwise. Let them get in line with everyone else. The only people that should be fast tracked is a spouse and children. That's the family that needs to be reunified as quickly as possible.

When you move, guess what, you do so knowing you are many times going to be separated from extended family, siblings and parents. If that seems like a burden, then don't immigrate.

If this couple and their daughter would not be approved for immigration on their own without sponsorship, why should they be allowed because of it?
06:45 PM on 04/19/2012
I have to strongly dissagree with you! i'm bringing my mother here, not to be a "burden" as you call your and my parents, but to help us babysitting our children so I can continue working and paying more taxes for you! The real burden here are not relatives that will make life in Canada easier thenks to family support, is all those people in wellfare taht are totally able to work but they choose not to!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ppaatt
11:27 AM on 03/31/2012
This Conservative Canada we now live in is a harsh, cruel, unforgiving, survival of the fittest place. Sympathy and compassion no longer belong in Conservative Canada.
11:00 AM on 03/31/2012
If it weren't for the many thousands of FAS kids being born and subsequently raised by the government right here, perhaps we could afford to be more magnanimous with respect to allowing people with pre-existing conditions into Canada.
10:31 AM on 03/31/2012
Sorry, we don't need any more Down Syndrome people in this country... We already have nearly half a Parliment full of Libs and NDPs.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Imma Okay
11:04 AM on 03/31/2012
...to take care of the Conservatives with Down Syndrome.
photo
OhMyDog
OhMyDog ate my microbio.
11:31 AM on 03/31/2012
You must mean the Cons-serve-a-Republican Party of Canada.
photo
OhMyDog
OhMyDog ate my microbio.
11:34 AM on 03/31/2012
leftcoasterman eh? From a real Westcoaster, I think you've got your right and left mixed up. I think Ontario is calling you back
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rayma Allaby
09:50 AM on 03/31/2012
oh those compassionate CONS......sarcasm intended eh.
09:28 AM on 03/31/2012
Why can't the son move to India if he wants to reunite his family?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Brian Gorrell
Is this the 1950's or what?
10:05 AM on 03/31/2012
What a sad person you must be.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Medusa Sant
Jedi on the streets. Sith in the sheets.
10:23 AM on 03/31/2012
I agree. There is no need to further burden our already burdened Health and Welfare systems.
photo
OhMyDog
OhMyDog ate my microbio.
11:39 AM on 03/31/2012
And why, Medusa (tres apropos), do you think this would further burden the already inefficient H&W system?
09:11 AM on 03/31/2012
Every country has a standard medical for immigration and you don't get in if you fail on one part of it. This rule is no different. In Canada, people who suffer from specific categorized conditions like this receive disability payments and if they were refused that would be another big issue. It's always interesting to hear people cite compassion to allow someone in and in the next breath we have great numbers who have zero compassion for the poor, senior or struggling that are born in their own country and need financial help. Too many complexities to be a standard case but for anyone who has gone through the immigration process in this or another country, the medical limitations are known. Why is this a story unless it's to fill space and create just another divide to label everyone as people haters or lovers. It's the law. Work with it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:23 AM on 03/31/2012
Good post. It is surprising how many people think they have the right to live in Canada. It is a privilege, for us all.
07:52 AM on 03/31/2012
Several years ago there was a story of an Australian couple who vacationed in B.C. with their 2 children- they liked the climate there because their children suffered from some condition that when exposed to a lot of sunlight became ill. This couple wanted to immigrate to Canada but were denied the opportunity because of their childrens condition. Reason, because of the health care issue, even though there was only a slight chance the children may require hospital care.
Those immigration rules were put in place for a reason and apply to everyone, exceptions cannot be made unless the rules are changed completely, may be a sad fact but a fact.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
06:54 AM on 03/31/2012
Canada is turning into a shopping mall the size of a country.

A big, bland pathetic place with no ideas, no culture, no 'raison d'etre', no defining features.

We though multiculturalism would mean a plurality of ideas - instead - it means no ideas or movements can reach critical mass.

Mississauga - the most perfect civilization on earth on paper - is a piece of trash. I know - I am from there, and it is the future of Canada.

Canada is a meaningless place, full of meaningless people.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spinnerator
08:26 AM on 03/31/2012
I too am from Mississauga. One of the amazing things I've noted while living here is that there is no huge wall keeping me here. Don't like it? Move.
09:16 AM on 03/31/2012
The world is a big place. If you don't like this shopping mall then go shop in another one. Leave this shopping mall to those that want to make it the best in the world and it can't possibly be on the path to greatness with people whose only contribution is to complain. There is a place for everyone in the world and people need to find their own. It's not the place that's usually the problem, it's the attitude of the person in that place. You can choose your path.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
06:49 AM on 03/31/2012
'family reunification' immigration needs to stop immediately.

We all have many family members. This policy gives the ultimate right for billions of people to come here.

Nonsense.

Limit immigration to a few refugees and political asylum seekers, a few talented people.

Under 100K per year.

The left wants immigration to erode our common sense of identity and turn us all into perfectly secular slaves.

The right wants cheap labor and more national power through people.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Imma Okay
11:09 AM on 03/31/2012
I agree with the family reunification idea, but not with the rest of it. If there are jobs that cannot be filled by Canadians, which there are, then I don't see any reason why immigrants shouldn't be able to fill them. Immigration should be tied to the needs of employers, not arbitrary caps.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
06:43 AM on 03/31/2012
I know about 10 Indian dudes, all of them good, brilliant guys - who got their Canadian citizenship and within about 3 years were in the US working.

I don't blame them - their path is rational.

But they all admit that they should haven not been able to do it.
07:33 AM on 03/31/2012
And what does this have to do with the story? You think the daughter with Down is going to use Canada as a conduit to the USA?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:15 AM on 03/31/2012
I think jamster means that there people that use their Canadian citizenship to gain entry to other countries like the US.
09:34 AM on 03/31/2012
As an american living in Canada, your comment interests me. Why did they want to be "in the U.s. working?" I canI't wait to get back...Couldn't find a job here in a year. I have a bachelors degree and certified in CAT scan. Applied at Zehrs for part time cashier work..never heard a thing..and many other places too...no response.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kolach
06:25 AM on 03/31/2012
This seems blindingly obvious to me. Yes we should feed everyone in the world and get everyone free unlimited healthcare but that's just unfeasible at the current time.
03:45 AM on 03/31/2012
Not only should the sister not be allowed into Canada but neither should we be letting the parents in!

No other country in the world would have such an insane policy of letting landed immigrants sponsor their sick and aging parents.

Imagine what the cost to the Canadian taxpayer is in free healthcare alone?

To get an idea of the costs - a young pregnant Australian woman visiting Canada gave birth to a premature baby. She and the baby had to spend two months in Hospital before they could safely return to Australia. The Hospital Bill was over $1 MILLION!! . The Australian couple is making arrangement's to pay this bill but it really illustrates the real cost of providing free healthcare to foreign nationals.

Not only do these aging parents and grandparents get FREE healthcare - they get OAS after 10 years in Canada even if they have not worked one day of their life in Canada and paid one cent in income tax!

How much is this costing Canada? Future generations of low-income Seniors will be forced to wait until age 67 so that we can payout OAS to these freeloaders!
05:19 AM on 03/31/2012
You forget that skilled workers who immigrate to Canada went to school and college somewhere else - you know: to learn their skills. Thus, Canada gets to capitalize on their expertise not having spent a dime on their education, an education that would have cost Canada tens if not hundreds of thousands of dollars. You should factor that into your calculation of cost/benefit before you shoot your mouth about taxpayer money. Then, you should also factor in that the person will be a productive member of society for years and years paying taxes and contributing to the Canadian economy. Then, you can complain about that person bringing their family to the country.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spinnerator
08:34 AM on 03/31/2012
And you should take off your rose coloured glasses and accept the realities. The vast majority of these parents and grandparents do NOT assimilate, they self ghettoize and no one sees or knows their skills. Just look a Brampton, where whole neighbourhoods are made up of one ethnic group and keep to themselves. I recall several years ago that someone doing a story on it interviewed several elderly members of that community who saw a major benefit in the fact that they could live there, shop in their own ethnic shops to get all of the products they were familiar with and most importantly didn't have to learn English because they never had to leave their neighbourhood to get services.
photo
Counterglow
Werner Heisenberg may have been right.
02:29 AM on 03/31/2012
We're in a Conservative world now. Compassion is for losers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jamster88
06:45 AM on 03/31/2012
Compassion?

Are you doing to pay the hundreds of thousands of dollars for aging Indians and their mentally handicapped child who will all need lifetime care?

Do you think it is the right of the developing world to come and retire in Canada with all of our social and medical benefits?
photo
Counterglow
Werner Heisenberg may have been right.
09:21 AM on 03/31/2012
Do you see anything besides black and white? Do you see any solution that doesn't involve either opening the floodgates completely or closing them to everybody who doesn't meet a narrow set of criteria?

Do you know what "Eugenics" is?