Kevin Patel's Down Syndrome Relative Shouldn't Have Been Rejected By Immigration, NDP MP Says

CP  |  By Posted: 03/30/2012 3:53 pm Updated: 03/30/2012 10:42 pm

Kevin Patel Down Syndrome
NDP MP Don Davies is calling on Immigration Minister Jason Kenney to reverse the decision and allow Kevin Patel's family to be reunited in Canada.

VANCOUVER - A New Democrat MP is demanding the federal government reverse a decision to bar a family from India from emigrating to Canada to join their son in B.C. because their adult daughter has Down Syndrome.

The son, Kevin Patel of Vancouver, wanted to sponsor his parents and sister to come to Canada to become permanent residents.

But Immigration Canada rejected the request because it says his sister's condition could pose an excessive burden on Canada’s health and social services.

"Are we looking at immigration as a nation-building exercise?'' Patel said at a news conference as he questioned the government's priorities.

"Or are we looking at immigration as a commercial project where we only bring in young people, only smart people, so that they can fund our economy? Should we treat immigrants as a commodity and not as person or as a family?"

NDP citizenship critic Don Davies said the government's conclusion is not supported by any facts and is instead based on stereotypes of people with Down Syndrome.

Davies, who outlined his concerns in a letter to Canadian immigration officials based in India, described the daughter's condition as "mild Down Syndrome."

"Your officer has come to the disturbing and baseless decision that, while she would not be an undue burden on Canada’s medical system, the mere fact she has Down Syndrome means she would be an undue burden on Canada’s social security system," Davies writes in the letter, issued to the media on Friday.

"This conclusion is not supported by any facts, is contradicted by the evidence submitted in this case and, with all due respect, represents an outdated stereotype of a person with Down Syndrome that is not in keeping with modern understanding of people with this condition. Frankly, it represents a bigoted and discriminatory view that is unacceptable in 2012."

Davies said Patel, whose legal given name is Kaivalya, has been living in North American since 2000. He is currently working as a certified general accountant.

He applied in 2006 to sponsor his mother, father and sister to come to Canada, and that application was granted in 2008, according to Davies. The family submitted an application for permanent residency in 2009, and have since undergone medical exams and submitted financial information.

"The family has complied with all the requests your office has placed on them and they have also affirmed repeatedly that Aditi (the daughter) does not have any special medical, para-medical or respite care needs," Davies writes.

"Aditi has been extremely self-reliant, physically independent and healthy as an individual. On the contrary, Aditi has demonstrated great skill in knitting, candle and incense making as well as outdoor sports, for which her medals and certificates as well as inter-state trips for badminton competition are a testament."

Davies said if immigration officials refuse to grant the Patel family entry into Canada, the country will have failed Kevin Patel and denied him the opportunity to have his family live in this country with him.

Immigration Minister Jason Kenney was unavailable to comment on the story Friday, though his communications director, Ana Curic, responded on his behalf.

Curic wrote in an email that she couldn't discuss the Patels in detail because of privacy laws, but she said Kenney's office contacted Davies on Friday for more information and staff are looking into the case.

"Generally speaking, decision makers at (Citizenship and Immigration Canada) must apply the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act as it is written," wrote Curic.

"Under (the act,) which came into effect in 2002, permanent resident applicants and their immediate family members must be medically assessed to determine if they pose a danger to public health or public safety, and whether their presence would pose an excessive demand on Canada’s health and social services systems."

She continued: "Excessive demand is based on anticipated health and social service costs over a five- to 10-year period and/or the potential impact on waiting lists.

"Canada’s immigration law does not discriminate against those with illness or disability. It does strive, however, to find the appropriate balance between those wanting to immigrate to Canada, and the limited medical resources that are paid for by Canadian taxpayers."

(News1130)

Also on HuffPost:

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS

VANCOUVER - A New Democrat MP is demanding the federal government reverse a decision to bar a family from India from emigrating to Canada to join their son in B.C. because their adult daughter has Dow...
VANCOUVER - A New Democrat MP is demanding the federal government reverse a decision to bar a family from India from emigrating to Canada to join their son in B.C. because their adult daughter has Dow...
Filed by Michael Bolen  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 48
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
11:21 PM on 04/17/2012
It would be my opinion they would not be able to immigrate to the U.S or Australia. My suggestion to the family would be to check into immigrating to Mexico.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
06:30 PM on 04/02/2012
Appropriate picture for the story.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:26 AM on 04/02/2012
Jason Kenney is obese I think we should stop paying for his excessive healthcare costs. Go on a diet you fat CONservative swine.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Adrian31
60% of the time, it works everytime...
12:52 PM on 04/01/2012
"On the contrary, Aditi has demonstrated great skill in knitting, candle and incense making..."

Because that's exactly what Canada needs, more knitters and candle-makers. Sigh.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
06:31 PM on 04/02/2012
When what we really need are more right-wing pundits and politicians.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Adrian31
60% of the time, it works everytime...
12:49 PM on 04/01/2012
"Are we looking at immigration as a nation-building exercise?...Or are we looking at immigration as a commercial project where we only bring in young people, only smart people, so that they can fund our economy?"

Both, but more importantly the second one! The entire purpose of immigration is to get more people of working age to work, buy goods and pay taxes to "fund our economy".

Mr. Patel seems to understand exactly what we are looking for, so it should come as no surprise that the immigration request was rejected.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Adrian31
60% of the time, it works everytime...
12:39 PM on 04/01/2012
I FULLY support this move by Immigration Canada!

This is one of the main reasons I cannot support the NDP. The party is so in favour of opening Canada's doors to everybody - especially those from impoverished nations who are sickly, have nothing and can't/won't contribute to Canadian society. The NDP's vision always seems that of a Third World Canada. For the life of me I can't understand how anyone can so misunderstand the process of prosperous nation-building.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CommonWealth-SinglePayer
Walk on the Right, VOTE on the LEFT
11:46 AM on 04/01/2012
First Nations did not get a chance to play Gatekeeper at our Borders, maybe people who Voted for Harper Reform should start packing?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bbertaud
Je ne regrette rien, rien de rien
10:40 AM on 04/01/2012
"Are we looking at immigration as a nation-building exercise?''
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Or are we to become a nation where whoever has a disability comes to live on someone else´s taxes...I will have to work until I am 67 and pay taxes until then just to get a meager pension
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
BCPATRIOT
British Columbia
08:32 AM on 04/01/2012
The government acted in a very responsible way.

Good for "Immigration Canada".
08:21 AM on 04/01/2012
The stats tell us that the dollars are not going to be there for Canadians who have paid into the system all their lives. My parents are immigrants and it did not cross their minds that this country should accept their aging parents. Entitlement and taking for granted Canada's generosity is already hurting the system. My mother ran a business for fifteen years and paid salaries for five employees. If you need an emotional story, my mothe has been visiting friends in hospitals and chronic care where the staff do not help the patients, barely look at the old ladies when putting lunch in front of them and where one broke her hip falling when trying to get to the washroom. My mother, a major tax contributor, is terrified of having to go to hospital. So this emotional story should trump this article's emotional story. Sticking to stats does not give the response desired though.
06:49 AM on 04/01/2012
After reading most comments, I agree, our healthcare is overwelmed enough without adding to it. We have trouble enough with looking after born an raised Candians. Truth be told, I would put a ban on all imagration for at least 5 years, not to mention forgien spending, charity begins at home, lets clean-up our yard before we help others.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:54 PM on 03/31/2012
Kenney is a bible thumping freak. It's a shame the government of Canada is comprised of heartless religious nutcases.
12:42 AM on 04/01/2012
I require a second hip replacement should I be allowed to move to India and have the taxpayers over there pay for my operation and recovery. Nothing to do with religion
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:16 AM on 04/01/2012
They're immigrating not visiting. Very lame attempt to distort by the way.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
06:32 PM on 04/02/2012
I think you should get a job and pay for it yourself. No more leeching off young taxpayers by the "half-trillion in debt" generation.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Adrian31
60% of the time, it works everytime...
12:45 PM on 04/01/2012
Sorry Dude, perhaps you should do some more research regarding our healthcare system and the fact that many immigrants come to Canada to take advantage of it.

Canada is not a charity case. It is NOT the Canadian taxpayers responsibility to foot the bill of the sick from other countries. As a Canadian, I despise knowing that my tax dollars are going to help those who specifically come to this country to scam the system.

Bible thumping and religion have NOTHING to do with this topic at all.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
north of 60
Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati
08:31 PM on 03/31/2012
Any immigrant should be rejected if they have a medical condition that will make them an additional burden on our already over-used health care system.

Any immigrant coming to Canada should be ineligible for free health care for at least a decade of continuous employment and paying income tax.
12:45 AM on 04/01/2012
There are enough Canadians who were born here on waiting lists waiting for treatment. The health system in Canda is overwhelmed already why should people from other countries overtaxe the system that much more.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Saucy Tom
08:06 PM on 03/31/2012
Good for Immigration Canada, I believe our systems are already maxed, just look at the budget the other day. Down's can be taxing on the medical and support systems and as this child grows to adulthood and then what? we must care for him when his parents are deceased? it's great that we Canadians have a big heart, but enough already, it's time to fix the mess first, then we can be looking at helping others.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Francmon
Homo homini lupus
07:53 PM on 03/31/2012
Immigrants should be allowed in Canada on their own merits and the wealthier immigrants will indeed have more merit. After all, Canada will benefit from the economic input of immigrants: Canadians are not going through the biggest baby boom in history and someone will have to work to pay for all retiring baby boomers and their health problems. For once I do agree with the government's stance against incoming immigrants who bring more potential burdens on our fragile economy.