Quebec Student Protest: How Their Fight Against Rising Tuition Went International

CP  |  By Posted: 04/28/2012 7:30 am Updated: 04/28/2012 7:28 pm

MONTREAL - What began as a provincial policy spat over tuition hikes in Quebec has transformed, in just over a year, into a movement of broader student unrest now receiving some international attention.

In the last few days, Quebec's student protests have received coverage in France, through Agence France-Presse, TV5, and a front-page photo in Le Monde. They also appeared in Australia, New Zealand, on Al Jazeera, and in the U.S., including on CNN.

A New York Times blog suggested tuition fees and student debt could become a key theme in President Barack Obama's bid for re-election as the president tries to energize young voters. The "French-Canadian students" were cited as an example in the tuition debate, as part of an international outcry against the high price of education.

The annual tuition for a private university in the U.S. is over $30,000 a year, with collective student debt poised to reach $1 trillion — which is even more than all the credit-card debt in that country. So why should Quebecers be complaining about a comparably measly $1,625 hike?

Protesters say it's because they want their education system to move in the other direction — away from the U.S. model and closer to a system like Sweden's, where post-secondary education is free.

The opposition has grown steadily, ever since the Quebec government announced its $325-a-year, five-year increases in the March 2011 budget. While the move would still leave Quebec with some of the lowest tuition rates in the country, protesters say they're fighting for principles.

Activists overseas are also joining in on the discussion about Quebec's tuition hikes, framing it as part of a larger historic fight.

Laurie Penny is a social activist and journalist for the U.K.'s Independent and Guardian newspapers who supports and writes about the international Occupy movement.

She's been paying attention to events in Quebec. Penny said the province's protesters represent the face of Occupy, as a growing demographic of graduates and students worldwide who fear they have piles of student debt but no future.

"I think it's a mistake to think of tuition hikes as a niche issue," she said. "Student debt and tuition hikes are not a niche or side issue in terms of what matters to young people, or to what matters to the future of the global economy."

The Occupy phenomenon began with student movements, she said, and the people involved are in fact mobilizing against similar problems — with youth leading the charge.

Martin Gendron, a student at the Universite du Quebec, said recent rowdy scenes have helped pique international interest.

At recent protests, a few vandals in the crowd have smashed windows and pelted projectiles at police. Police have responded by making multiple arrests and blasting chemical irritants into crowds — a reaction student activists have called excessive.

"The answer from the police is very violent," Gendron said. "That's something that's very strong in images and texts, and tends to go outside the local sphere."

In a statement last week, Amnesty International's French-Canadian branch expressed concern over the tactics employed by police and extended its support to Quebec students.

The human-rights organization denounced an excessive use of force, potentially arbitrary mass arrests, intimidation and profiling. It asked Quebec to "stop resorting to means which potentially interfere with the freedom of expression and the right to peaceful protest."

The student groups have received some support from neighbours in other parts of Canada as well.

Many Torontonians expressed solidarity with the protesters by handing over a petition with more than 700 signatures to the Quebec government on Thursday.

Alan Sears, a spokesman for the group that created the petition, said the student movement reflects a worldwide trend and could even influence actions in Ontario or elsewhere.

"Globally, we are seeing government after government adopt austerity priorities where they are cutting back on public services, increasing tuition fees — all these kinds of things," Sears said.

"Where there's an inspiring fight back against one part of this agenda, a lot of people start to pay attention."

Critics, however, have called protesters everything from deadbeats to unfocused — charges that Penny calls simply untrue.

"It's very, very naive and short-sighted when people say it's just lazy students who don't want to pay their fees. This is going to be a critical issue for everyone across the world economy over the next decade."

Note to readers: This is a corrected story. A previous version said the Quebec hikes were $1,625 annually, when in fact that amount would only come into effect over a period of at least five years.

Loading Slideshow...
  • April 27 Protest

    The Canadian Press/Ryan Remiorz

  • April 27 Protest

    Photo Megan Moore

  • April 27 Protest

    Photo Megan Moore

  • April 27 Protest

    Photo Megan Moore

  • April 27 Protest

    Photo Megan Moore

  • April 27 Protest

    The Canadian Press/Ryan Remiorz

  • April 27 Protest

    The Canadian Press/Ryan Remiorz

  • April 27 Protest

    The Canadian Press/Ryan Remiorz

  • April 27 Protest

    The Canadian Press/Ryan Remiorz

  • April 27 Protest

    The Canadian Press/Ryan Remiorz

  • April 27 Protest

    Photo Megan Moore

  • April 27 Protest

    The Canadian Press/Ryan Remiorz

  • April 27 Protest

    Photo Megan Moore

  • April 27 Protest

    Photo Megan Moore

  • April 27 Protest

    Photo Megan Moore

  • April 27 Protest

    Photo Megan Moore

  • April 27 Protest

    Photo Megan Moore

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS

MONTREAL - What began as a provincial policy spat over tuition hikes in Quebec has transformed, in just over a year, into a movement of broader student unrest now receiving some international attentio...
MONTREAL - What began as a provincial policy spat over tuition hikes in Quebec has transformed, in just over a year, into a movement of broader student unrest now receiving some international attentio...
Filed by Lauren Strapagiel  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 130
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
BCPATRIOT
British Columbia
09:57 AM on 05/04/2012
We need big changes in Canada, these students can accomplish them if they stick to it. There is no reason on earth why we should be like the US. If our country was run properly ever child would be going to university FREE, but our country is not being run properly we have greedy people everywhere specially politicians in our governments, bankers and corporations.
Those of you who had to pay for your education in the past should not be bad mouth this generation of students, because they will be the ones running our country sooner then you think.
The Ministers of Mr. Harper's government waste billions and billions of the taxpayers money, enough to send all students to university or college for FREE!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SayBlade
This micro bio intentionally left blank.
09:57 AM on 04/30/2012
I support these students in Quebec because tuition fees are too high in Ontario. When the tuition fees go higher, it does not mean that university workers and faculty benefit. It is the ever increasing corporate control of universities that benefits. Meanwhile, there are debt laden students who cannot participate fully in the economy for years and even decades.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rolor
'round and 'round we go
05:54 PM on 04/29/2012
Barriers to education are barriers to a nation's success and progress.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tmzrules
07:49 PM on 04/28/2012
I should have lived in Quebec rather than the part of Canada where I do live. I could have been something. I could have studied and been a contributor to society. I can't comment any further on this subject due to socio-political reasons.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:44 PM on 04/28/2012
Here's to the Québec students who are protesting against the increased tuition fees.

Not surprised to see a plethora of SUN News viewers jumping on this and scratching at those who are speaking out against the government.
Just admit that you are jealous of Québec's low tuition fees, compared to other provinces.

Tenez-vous bien, les frères et les soeurs de Québec. Faire entendre votre voix !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ethrop
micro-bio-tic
09:54 AM on 04/29/2012
Tell me, why would you assume that anyone who considers this movement to be misguided is, by force, under the spell of nefarious propagandists, while you, being in favour, would be under no such influence? I live in Quebec and I have seen these things come and go. And you live elsewhere. What do you actually know about this conflict?

It seems when one looks at the facts coldly, one would have to conclude that perhaps you are the one who is under the influence?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:44 PM on 04/29/2012
What do I know?

I know that the aim of the student residents of Québec is to have their educational system similar to that of places like Sweden, Finland, etc.

In other words, free.
Nothing wrong in that goal of theirs.
03:16 PM on 04/29/2012
I live in Québec, and I will tell you that some of the forces behind this are PQ. The Parti-Québecois is inciting hatred for the Charest Provincial Liberals.

I keep seeing sovereignty slogans and Québec flags at these events, both of which have nothing to do with the issue... but EVERYTHING to do with the PQ trying to erode Liberal support with youth.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:51 PM on 04/29/2012
The same thing happened over here in Toronto during the G20 meetings (2010)
The focus, by the media, were on those lunatic so-called "anarchists" during the protests

Have you heard about the lines being crossed by the Québecois police? The french canadian portion of Human Rights Watch recently heavily criticized the police force for their actions on the young students during their protest
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ethrop
micro-bio-tic
06:01 PM on 04/29/2012
It is not the PQ so much as the CSN, a powerful union central along with every alternative action group in the province. These organisaitons don't care about the students and essentially are trying to orchestrate an overthrow of the Charest government...
05:39 PM on 04/28/2012
Why aren't they trashing their mommies' and daddies' houses? It's the taxes of those people the government doesn't want to spend on these "students" so why not direct their rage where it's due? Dumb people make me crazy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SayBlade
This micro bio intentionally left blank.
09:51 AM on 04/30/2012
(Flagged by mistake.)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ethrop
micro-bio-tic
05:35 PM on 04/28/2012
The difference here being that, even after the raise proposed by the governement, Quebec tuition fees will still be the lowest in North America (except in Mexico where it is free but the quality is consequent). I am not certain this will lead to a sustained movement of sympathy in countries that have it much harder.
06:38 PM on 04/28/2012
Nope. If you sheepishly accept incremental increases then soon your tuition will be sky high. Quebec students have the lowest tuition in the country because they are willing to risk arrests and abuses to fight for accessible education, while all you do is whine about their lower tuitions. The DIFFERENCE between them and you is that they are NOT sheeps.
12:48 AM on 04/29/2012
Really? Do you also have tomorrows winning lottery numbers? FACT: tuitions even after the increase will still be lowest in North America. They are low not because you're willing to get arrested it's because the workers are paying the bill with taxes so that you can enjoy those low tuitions. Guess what the cost of living has gone up for EVERYONE time to pay your share.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ethrop
micro-bio-tic
08:33 AM on 04/29/2012
Sorry, munchkin. Quebec has the lowets rates in the country becasue it has been public policy for decades and has led to dramatic underfunding for universities. The prposed fee increse will, by law, be affecting the next 7 years and thereafter will be increased to the rate of inflation. Sweetie, the students are in this for thir pockets and not out of concern for anythign else. Quebec has teh lowest fees in North MArica.. but have the lowest attendance rates in Canada... Seems you are the sheep sweetie for swallowing whole everything is told to you by whoever it is talks to you... ;)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bbertaud
Je ne regrette rien, rien de rien
05:28 PM on 04/28/2012
I wonder if they are going to their protests with their expensive clothes, iPads and iPhones at hand....that would make the whole thing more cool....maybe not, those gadgets might get damaged as soon as they start smashing windows and vandalizing private property...or throwing bricks on the Metro rails and attempting against the safety of those who use the Metro, go to work, and pay taxes so they can go to school and protest
02:18 PM on 04/28/2012
"A New York Times blog suggested tuition fees and student debt could become a key theme in President Barack Obama's bid for re-election as the president tries to energize young voters. The "French-Canadian students" were cited as an example"

US, look after your own issues you have bigger problems than just student fees such as the crazy GOP people. Don't use Canada as an example we have our own thing going to create a better society and its good to see the students protesting. Create your own revolt and get your American people off the sofa watching "reality" TV and get with the reality in your streets of people suffering.
02:02 PM on 04/28/2012
The average university student comes from a family that is significantly wealthier than the average Quebecer. That's a fact. So the protesters are trying to get the government to FORCE poorer people to pay for wealthier peoples' education. That is simply unjust and immoral.

And the tactics of the student unions are offensive. At Laval University only 5% of all students formed the bare majority of voters who initially approved the strike, disrupting the education of the other 95%. The problem is that the voting procedure is made so difficult that only those with lots of time and who are the most militant vote. There was so controversy raised by the voting procedure that the next vote was electronic. In this case, participation was much higher and the students voted against the strike. Sure enough, for the following votes the union when back to the original onerous procedure and the strike was re-approved with something like 600 out of 40,000 students voting. The figures may be imprecise but they are in the right range.

That is not Democracy. That is not good for our society. Instead we are penalizing those who want to earn their own advantages and rewarding those who would rather manipulate the system to extract benefits from other.
02:13 PM on 04/28/2012
Quoted from Beejust: significantly wealthier than the average Quebecer.

I would love if you can provide a link to your statement of it being a fact.
It is interesting how people will post anything because they find Students offensive.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ethrop
micro-bio-tic
09:45 AM on 04/29/2012
It is actually true. And the reason has little to do with money or accessibility. The most important factor in getting students into university is the value accorded to education in raising a family. This happens much more often in better-off families. You can find this information fairly easily with a good search. It is also true cross-culture. Its the same everywhere in the world.
09:07 AM on 05/02/2012
It's not a Quebec thing. It's a general relationship: People with university degrees make higher incomes on average. The most important determinant of a child going to university is whether or not their parents went. Hence, universities tend to be populated with children of university educated parents - meaning they are, on average, wealthier than the average tax payer that pays for their education. See links below.

I don't find students offensive. I love being around students - I find them exhilarating. I'm offended by interests groups (unions, corporations, non-profits...) using their political pull to extract from individuals who have less political pull. In this case, tuition subsidies are a tax on the relatively poor to pay for the benefits of the relatively rich.

http://www.iedm.org/files/universites_en.pdf
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/opinions/opinion/tuition-isnt-the-problem/article2419410/print/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles the Great
Canadian/Israeli Goy in Alert,Nunavut
02:30 PM on 04/28/2012
True! the trust fund little rich kids protesting here is not even the 99% of students. It is exam time came and went in most universities and they just mess themselves up. I did go to university in Quebec and believe me the radicals are usually the crazy ones with trust funds from their parents. They are the ones with Mac computers, iPads, and iPhones but they can buy all of this but say tuition cost are too high . The rest of us have a job while at school and it is clear many of them do not. However I could understand why they do not in most cases most of them are not even university students, just the we hate everything people
01:39 PM on 04/28/2012
Hey, why are these white rich kids mad again?

Over a couple hundred dollars a year??!!
photo
CanuckistanCommie
I ain't no Commie but Pat Buchanan thinks so!
01:49 PM on 04/28/2012
Although my son who goes to a Quebec university is not protesting he is no rich kid. Nor are many of his school mates who are raised by single mothers.
02:04 PM on 04/28/2012
Perhaps not, but on average a university student is much wealthier than the average tax-payer. So this is a case of the relatively wealthy trying to force the relatively poor to pay for their education. That is simply unjust.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles the Great
Canadian/Israeli Goy in Alert,Nunavut
02:31 PM on 04/28/2012
They are buying Apple products and not using their money to pay for school
06:14 PM on 04/28/2012
And families with more than one vehicle are not using their money to pay for their health care.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles the Great
Canadian/Israeli Goy in Alert,Nunavut
01:07 PM on 04/28/2012
Most people my age have to work while we are at school to get through it. It is just a part of life. If these people have the time to 'protest' and say they speak for all students but I bet the majority of them are trust fund rich people. Just like of the majority of the fake 99%'er are most of the camps in that case were not even occupied at night. I'm wondering how are they getting the money to even do this. I bet most have to pay rent , pay bills and student loans. In Quebec you still pay the lower tuition rates in Canada either way
01:55 PM on 04/28/2012
It's not a part of life, it's a part of life we decided to impose on people in our society. We have the ability to pay for the tuition of every student but don't, because greedy people like you have convinced others , the those people want free tuition because they are greedy and lazy.

The problem is, you never went to University, because you obviously still believe socialism means being either a communist or a nazi. But these children have learned that other places in the world are prospering and have flourishing economies under socialist governments. Norway controls all it's oil and produces it's own products from it. Something we should be doing here in Canada. We could then use that money to pay for our countries education, health and mental care, old age security. And lower taxes for the citizens of our country.

Our citizens would have money to make purchases without having to accumulate massive peronal debt. Our economy could be much stronger, but people like you think you are educted.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles the Great
Canadian/Israeli Goy in Alert,Nunavut
02:24 PM on 04/28/2012
who is forcing them to even go? Also how am I greedy? I'm a recent grad and there is nothing forcing them to go to university in the first place after high school. But please tell us who 'forced' them to go in the first place? Also personal attacks are just tactics of the far left.
04:25 PM on 04/29/2012
It's a part of life that sane societies force on people, and should. If you're old enough to work, you should be working. Spending 4 years sitting in school just studying after you've become old enough to vote and serve your country, quite frankly, just isn't serving your country. You're a big boy now, you can juggle another responsibility in addition to being a student. Not working while attending school is a luxury, not some moral right. If you want something, you work for it.
03:28 PM on 04/28/2012
The workforce has changed, when you were in school or around our age the environment wasn't on the verge of collapse and there wasn't such a thing called corporations.. these students are protesting that the cost of tuition is higher relative to the money gained from paying off these loans..
07:16 PM on 05/16/2012
You need to read more history and spend less time soaking up left wing propaganda. No such thing as corporations? "The alleged oldest commercial corporation in the world, the Stora Kopparberg mining community in Falun, Sweden, obtained a charter from King Magnus Eriksson in 1347." There is nobody alive today who can say they were around before corporations existed. Hell, Canada owes its existence to corporations. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hudson%27s_Bay_Company Our environment is on the verge of collapse? We have never had stricter environmental policies in the history of humankind. 20 years ago, you couldn't eat a fish caught in the St. Lawrence river because of industrial pollution. Today there are viable commercial fisheries in that river. The students who are now protesting for a free post secondary education will be the same people who will benefit from North America's largest generation retiring and dying off. With a reduced workforce due to aging baby boomers, this generation of workers will be able to command higher salaries due to a shortage of qualified candidates. They'll have no trouble shouldering the expense of higher education. Anything worth having is worth working hard for. If a person doesn't want to work hard to earn a higher education, then they don't deserve one. Society pays basic education to make them literate to give an equal chance to make more of themselves. Subsidized education beyond that should be viewed as a gift from society, not rights that society owes you.
Anthropocan
Je est un Autre.
01:00 PM on 04/28/2012
Free vs. User fees. Why is the discussion never about a system focused on merit within education instead? It shouldn't matter how rich your parents are. I've been saying, we owe it to society to have the best (not the richest) doing what they do best. It needn't even be an (entirely) economic argument.
12:59 PM on 04/28/2012
People in other countries march because they want basic human rights, brats in Quebec march because they are losing beer money
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Larry Mutter
12:59 PM on 04/28/2012
Its nice to see some push back,the amazing thing to me is how long these kids have hung in there.If these kids can thwart the corporate agenda,i,e banks getting more money,and the influence of big business in getting their employees trained on the cheap by influencing curriculum,then keep it rolling.Nobody ever won a social battle by playing by the rules.