Quebec Student Protests: Unrest Costing Downtown Montreal Businesses Millions Says Chamber Of Commerce

CP  |  By Posted: Updated: 05/18/2012 8:09 am

MONTREAL - Bar hopping, shopping and dining out in downtown Montreal are taking a hit due to ongoing student protests that business owners say are chasing their customers away due to traffic headaches.

The owner of downtown landmark Ziggy's Pub, frequented by the late author Mordecai Richler, said his patrons aren't sticking around for after-work drinks. He estimates business has dropped 60 per cent.

"A lot of people, as soon as the day is finished, they get into their cars and go back home," said Ziggy Eichenbaum, whose pub is on Crescent Street, a well-known destination for restaurants and bars.

"You walk around downtown at night and you could take a bowling ball and throw it," Eichenbaum said Wednesday.

"If you don't hit a student, you won't hit anybody. You won't hit a client."

The demonstrations over increased tuition fees of several hundred dollars per year continued on Wednesday with a group of student protesters storming into a downtown university, many of them with their faces covered by masks, and disrupting classes.

The student unrest has lasted 14 weeks with almost daily demonstrations. Only one-third of Quebec students are actually on declared strikes, but the conflict has created considerable social disorder and has included smoke bombs that shut down Montreal's subway system.

The Quebec government was looking at the possibility of adopting emergency legislation — a law reportedly laden with financial penalties for people who have played a role in encouraging the ongoing disruption, which began in late February.

The owner of Thursday's restaurant, also on the popular Crescent Street, said he has about 20 per cent fewer customers, which he called the "difference between a profit and a loss."

"It's been devastating," said Bernard Ragueneau. "Nobody wants to go downtown. We're actually being held hostage."

Tourists and locals aren't frequenting the street as much, going from bar to restaurant to bar as they normally do, because of the demonstrations, he said.

"Forget it. Bar hopping is gone," Ragueneau said. "We're being held hostage."

The Montreal Chamber of Commerce estimated that business overall is down 15 per cent at retailers and restaurant owners in the downtown core and student protests have cost several million dollars in economic damage to the city.

"The fear is night-time demonstrations, which results in some streets being closed, and it leads people to want to go other neighbourhoods than the downtown," said Michel Leblanc, the chamber's president and CEO.

"It's not a worry about violence that's keeping people away, it's more worry about congestion," Leblanc said of traffic tie-ups and detours resulting from the protests.

Leblanc said the long-term worry is the protests will result in people becoming used to avoiding downtown activities.

"We've signalled to the government that there will be repercussions and we hope the conflict will be settled quickly."

Some merchants worry the students will try to disrupt the Grand Prix Formula One race, which is expected to bring in tens of millions of dollars to Montreal's economy when it's held on the weekend of June 9.

"We've got two weeks before the Grand Prix for the mayor and the premier to decide no more masks," he said of protesters who have hidden their faces.

Students have already blocked bridges, disrupted shareholder meetings for Power Corp. (TSX:POW) and the National Bank (TSX:NA) and entered workplaces where mining companies are located.

Meanwhile, police costs have escalated. Montreal police have temporarily hired 150 officers due to the protests and the police union has said overtime costs were expected to be between $2 million and $3 million. The Quebec provincial police overtime bill was estimated at $1.5 million.

However, Tourisme Montreal says the student demonstrations have had no impact so far on the number of visitors coming to the city.

FOLLOW CANADA BUSINESS

MONTREAL - Bar hopping, shopping and dining out in downtown Montreal are taking a hit due to ongoing student protests that business owners say are chasing their customers away due to traffic headaches...
MONTREAL - Bar hopping, shopping and dining out in downtown Montreal are taking a hit due to ongoing student protests that business owners say are chasing their customers away due to traffic headaches...
Filed by Lauren Strapagiel  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:48 PM on 05/17/2012
What the protesters are doing is wrong on so many levels, but especially when what they are doing is stopping innocent businesses from operating.

see http://wp.me/p27AoJ-4i for my full opinion
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LIONNYC
09:32 PM on 05/17/2012
A very biased view. The students protests should have been resolved within days...Charest is too blame for the way it has turned out and for the money lost by business'
11:06 PM on 05/17/2012
Charest may be the cause of it all, but how can he be to blame. He made people angry, but it was the students who decided to cause trouble for innocent individuals.

why should a student who paid for his education not be allowed to attend class? why should a business suffer because the students are unhappy. the protesters should take their fight to the government, not to everyone else around them.
08:44 AM on 05/17/2012
Protesters aren't doing themselves any favors by disrupting local businesses.
Summer time in Montreal is nothing less than one big party, one even after another. All of these events, all the bars, restaurants, stores etc all hire students. If businesses are suffering and as a result have no need to hire students, its going to make life a lot tougher on a group of people who are already crying life's too hard.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Anne Mccormick
12:40 AM on 05/17/2012
well, i hope the protesters are proud of themselves over this one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
piceaglauca
The picture says it all....
11:12 PM on 05/16/2012
The Juvenile Offenders Act is so constructed that most of these students will maybe see the inside of a police car and probably to be driven home. I think this will get a lot uglier before it goes away. If the government thinks its emergency legislation is going to be respected, come on. What are you going to do with 5 to 10 thousand students on the street, pick a few up. They are very losely connected. They are now doing hit and switch tactics. They get quicker and smarter and they run faster than a forty year old. An alternate ploy would be for the government to order the close of all schools above the secondary level that student unions are involved with. This might turn the good ones against the bad. Keep them closed and continue to the fall. That should create some back fire then we can see what happens.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
contest d
06:13 PM on 05/16/2012
Oh please (and this is not to denigrate the business owners). The result of allowing private interests to dictate how public goods are distributed in society causes infinitely more socio-economic damage than a protest. The restructuring of health care, education, physical infrastructure funding, etc., is responsible for these events, albeit not as directly as to make it self-evident, yet....
http://www.salon.com/2012/02/05/the_privatization_trap/

Retired Canadian Gen. Rick Hillier stated after the Egyptian unrest (after a decade of aggressive privatization), that unrest would spread, and not just to developing countries. The UK riots were blamed on moral degeneration among the poor, Greeks are just "lazy, entitled citizens", Chileans whined that foreign companies are looting the public purse (eg. 4 largest grain traders absconded with $1 billion in taxes in 2010) so over 1 million people marched last summer, etc.

The fact that it's starting with students in Canada over tuition is just how this global problem is manifesting locally, but still a canary in the coalmine. Not placing this unrest in the context of increasing global dysfunction (thanks to corporate thievery and public policy geared to hoard wealth) is simply negligent in terms of geo-economic process and political history, and will allow the real architects of social dysfunction to keep getting away with it, while the majority just point the finger at each other.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
piceaglauca
The picture says it all....
11:16 PM on 05/16/2012
I have to agree with this " all for a few and nothing for all" trend. The more I see from government today regarding their respect for the environment (not), cutting the red tate of discussion, reducing citizen benefits, exploiting resources, passing laws to shut people up, coniving with countries who take from us then sell back junk all in the name of corporate profits. It is sad, so sad.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
02:23 PM on 05/16/2012
"with many opting for other neighbourhoods instead."
"have cost several million dollars in economic damage to the city."

That doesn't make any sense. If business is simply going elsewhere in the City, then how is it "economic damage" ?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
piceaglauca
The picture says it all....
11:17 PM on 05/16/2012
Montreal hasn't being doing well for years. They just want to hang their coat on another rack.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:51 PM on 05/26/2012
are you here? real estate prices have continued to climb here,even when they have stopped and even dropped elsewhere.we have community sprirt here spirit and the people are speaking up.a huge crowd just marched down my street and it was beautiful.many of my neighbors were out on their balconies too banging poys like they have been all week.regular people who work five days a week.this is not just about students anymore.i am very proud of my passionate and vibrant city