Quebec Adopts Emergency Law To End Tuition Crisis

CBC  |  Posted: Updated: 05/18/2012 11:21 pm

Quebec Emergency
Woman crying in front of a wall of Surete du Quebec riot squad police officers as they advance to remove striking students at the College Lionel-Groulx.The Canadian Press Images-Mario Beauregard

Quebec's legislature has voted in favour of an emergency law aimed at cooling tensions in the 14-week tuition hike crisis.

After debating the special legislation overnight Thursday, members of the national assembly (MNAs) voted 68-48.

The legislation calls for heavy fines for students and their federations, and strict regulations governing demonstrations, following months of social tension and protests that made international news.

Critics lined up to assail the law as an affront to civil rights, an overreaction, or ill-considered improvisation.

Thousands of people took to the streets in Montreal and Quebec City late Friday night to protest the bill's passage.

Even international activist collective Anonymous weighed in on the "draconian" legislation via Twitter, stating simply "Expect us."

The new law is based on three main pillars: It pauses the current school year at institutions affected by strikes; imposes steep fines for anyone who tries blocking access to a school; and limits where, how, and for how long people can protest in Quebec.

For some legal experts the law violates rights — while opposition leaders have called it "abusive."

"It's the worst law that I've ever seen, except for the War Measures Act," said law professor Lucie Lemonde, referring to the notorious legislation imposed in Quebec during the 1970 FLQ crisis.

"We knew something was coming, but I didn't think they would use it to change the rules of the game in terms of the rights to demonstrate," said Lemonde, who teaches at the University of Quebec in Montreal (UQÀM).

The law attacks an individual's rights to freedom of expression, association and conscience, she said.

The head of the Quebec Bar Association, Louis Masson, said Bill 78 violates constitutional rights, including freedom of speech and the right to demonstrate peacefully.

The law also creates many roadblocks to organizing a peaceful demonstration, and presents "so many risks that an honest citizen practically will not go there."

However, there were grumblings from some members of the bar that not all Quebec lawyers are opposed to the law.

Student groups promised to launch a court challenge against Bill 78 next week.

The law is designed to expire in July, 2013.

Critical reception

The Opposition has been extremely critical of the bill, pounding on the Charest government during the lengthy debate.

Parti Québécois Leader Pauline Marois calls the law "abusive" and promised to repeal it, if her party is elected to power in the future.

"The darkest moment always comes before the light," Marois said in the moments before the vote.

"It will be time to change the government soon."

Student leaders were also quick to denounce the bill soon after initial details of the legislation were released.

"This is actually a declaration of war against the student movement and not only against the student movement, but it restricted the liberty of speech, the liberty of association," said Martine Desjardins, president of university student group FEUQ.

It was among several protest-related developments in Quebec on Friday as Montreal adopted a new, municipal anti-mask bylaw.

Bill 78 summary

Fines of between $1,000 and $5,000 for any individual who prevents someone from entering an educational institution.

Penalties climb to between $7,000 and $35,000 for a student leader and to between $25,000 and $125,000 for unions or student federations.

Public demonstations involving more than 50 people have to be flagged to authorities eight hours in advance, include itinerary, duration and time at which they are being held.

Police can order the protest move to a different spot.

Offering encouragement for someone to protest at a school, either tacitly or otherwise, is subject to punishment.


Loading Slideshow...
  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

  • Rogerio Barbosa -- AFP/Getty Images

FOLLOW COLLEGE

Quebec's legislature has voted in favour of an emergency law aimed at cooling tensions in the 14-week tuition hike crisis. After debating the special legislation overnight Thursday, members of the ...
Quebec's legislature has voted in favour of an emergency law aimed at cooling tensions in the 14-week tuition hike crisis. After debating the special legislation overnight Thursday, members of the ...
Filed by Christian Cotroneo  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 238
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hagagaga
You can't take the sky from me.
09:18 AM on 05/21/2012
We do not forgive. We do not forget. Expect us.
05:15 PM on 05/20/2012
Unbelievable! I stand with the people of Canada.
10:14 PM on 05/19/2012
BREAKING NEWS! UQAM political science professor admits entire strike against fee increases started as a class project.
photo
NTodd
Aude Sapere
08:23 PM on 05/20/2012
BREAKING NEWS! Nobody cares.
09:46 PM on 05/19/2012
The latest CROP-La Presse poll indicates 66% of respondents favor Bill 78. Hmmm, an elected government being supported by a solid majority. Undemocratic indeed.
08:46 PM on 05/19/2012
Some learn as children, to hide when we do something wrong. Covered faces doing nothing wrong, I think not. Destruction of property and intimidation of other students/teachers/citizens/business? SHAME ON YOU. Bullies and terror hence terrorists. How would they like it if I protested , day or night, every day, down their street, with a covered face and body, ran up to their house and proceeded to destroy it, the contents, the vehicles they must use and the landscape and consequently cause fright and fear to the inhabitants? Increasing insurance rates etc, For reasons lets say, MY taxes were too high and they refused to lower them, because how else will education be subsidized. They have been told no, now, because they cannot have their way, and because they have behaved like bullies and terrorists, they have caused a law which affects future protests about other things to come into effect. Since they cannot identify individual perpetrators, all must pay with fines, that I hope go to restoration of the damages caused. GO BACK TO SCHOOL OR GET SOME KIND OF JOB. There are so many good things this energy could be used for. Special my butt.
02:36 AM on 05/21/2012
You are sort of reactionary and dumb. You are as much a bully as they are and you cannot see it. This is a natural phenomenon. They are acting naturally.

Get off your high horse and get real.
02:45 PM on 05/21/2012
Name calling, like the thugs you support. Nothing natural about it. I am very real.
photo
Another Pesky Canadian
Talk - action = 0
07:54 PM on 05/19/2012
By creating and nurturing an economy that fuels an increasing divide between haves and have nots; the ruling powers that be (Governments and Corporations) have virtually ensured that protests, violence and other such inconveniences will result.

By doing so; they can be said to have repeatedly struck the first blows of the confrontation, to which the protesters are, at last, belatedly reacting.

When the governing elite lose their connection to the people they are meant to lead, sometimes public acts of defiance become an expression as a last resort.

World History is full of blood-soaked Revolutions that followed excess pressure exerted by the few upon the many.

"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."
- George Santayana
photo
1846
Deir Yassin Survivor
11:50 PM on 05/19/2012
There is no free lunch friend.
Some one needs to fund universities and asking users to help is not increasing the divide between haves and have nots.
photo
Another Pesky Canadian
Talk - action = 0
11:05 AM on 05/20/2012
I would much rather see Canadian tax dollars go towards life-enhancing activities such as higher education and environmental protection than watch BILLIONS of our tax dollars flushed into the Military Industrial Complex and multinational Petro-Corporations .  (Talk about a free lunch!)
We can only imagine what might come of a Canadian society that was well educated, aware, compassionate and courageous enough to stand up for what they believe.
photo
Liz Wilson 2
“a small group can change the world
03:15 PM on 05/19/2012
Currently we seem to be surrounded on all sides by "my way or the highway" groups - I wonder what has happened to the voice of reason and where are the peacemakers?
photo
1846
Deir Yassin Survivor
11:54 PM on 05/19/2012
Good point.
Student leaders and the entire movement, have lost sight of what they originally asked for.
I suspect it has grown into a lightning rod for every malcontent with a gripe.

Student leaders would be well advised to pull back and compromise or this will tarnish them and their cause for decades. A pull out will isolate the radicals and identify them for what they are, trouble makers.
11:50 AM on 05/19/2012
Quebecois = Canadian-Mexican-Americans
photo
Another Pesky Canadian
Talk - action = 0
12:18 PM on 05/19/2012
philly282 = nonsense
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skookum1
truth can't be bought, but lies sure can be sold..
05:43 PM on 05/19/2012
=neo-GOP bigot
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
psnyder325
Yep, I'm a Socialist. Deal.
03:20 PM on 05/20/2012
Flagged. This is very, very offensive to the Quebecois.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hagagaga
You can't take the sky from me.
09:20 AM on 05/21/2012
It's also offensive to Mexicans.

Keep in mind that I'm solely intending that statement to be a form of humor, nothing else.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CymroTramor
saysomethinginwelsh
11:24 AM on 05/19/2012
Welcome to our world....a world of austerity and taking away from the middle class
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skookum1
truth can't be bought, but lies sure can be sold..
07:35 PM on 05/19/2012
profligacy and flamboyance for the rich, austerity and sackcloth and ashes for everyone else....
photo
Another Pesky Canadian
Talk - action = 0
07:55 PM on 05/19/2012
Mmmmmmmmm....ashes. So nutritious!
09:37 PM on 05/19/2012
Sackcloth? It's the 21st century. The poor protesters wear jeans. Preferably designer jeans.
photo
Charles Howarth
“I became insane, with long intervals of horribl
10:41 AM on 05/19/2012
This really isn't all that surprising. However, this confrontation has deeper roots and ties. This 'student protest' is one and the first of many bleeds before this cauldron of dissent and distrust fully boils over. Welcome to the 21st century Canada.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles the Great
Canadian/Israeli Goy in Alert,Nunavut
10:08 AM on 05/19/2012
So the 1% of Students who are protesting and while they managed to destroy the studies for the 99% are angry.

Question why are they saying they are the 99% again when they are not?
09:54 AM on 05/19/2012
It is about time that steps were taken to quell what amounts to a new form of terrorism. Here we have a minority group trying to overturn what an elected government has passed. These are not peaceful protesters trying to undo some societal wrong but groups of thugs trying to blackmail the rest of us.
photo
Another Pesky Canadian
Talk - action = 0
10:02 AM on 05/19/2012
Re: "It is about time that steps were taken to quell what amounts to a new form of terrorism. "

I would say this statement applies equally to the unprecedented use of Police forces to suppress legal dissent and freedom of expression.
01:36 PM on 05/19/2012
One could argue that, however legal disent and freedom of expression is not what has been happening. When protests infringe on the rights of others and directly interfere with people peacefully going about their normal business it is no longer a right. You then have one group saying they have a greater right then others. These so called protests are disruptive to so many others and shpuld be outside of the law. Why should other Canadians rights to peace and order be allowed to be taken away.
08:22 PM on 05/19/2012
Pesky, I would say, get back to school. What does destroying an innocent persons business or education have to do with peacefull protest. If I were to protest on your street and smash up your home, you would be ok with that? This is homeland terrorism by cowardly thugs wearing masks. When you are doing something wrong, you usually want your face hidden. They were given an answer, and the answer was NO. Apparently a word certain people refuse to hear.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bbertaud
Je ne regrette rien, rien de rien
09:12 AM on 05/19/2012
I would like to know if Madame Lemonde would be against the law if she had a store with the windows shattered, or her car turned upside down or she would have been forced out of her class by a bunch thugs wearing masks..or even worse, suffer injuries when riding the Mtero due to acts of sabotage
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Eileenla
Author, "Sacred Economics"
08:48 AM on 05/19/2012
What is becoming more clear today is that modern governments are becoming unwilling to tolerate policy dissent from their constituents, despite the protection of dissent being one of the main pillars of a free and democratic society. When we come to the point where governments are so fearful of the collective power of their constituents that they attempt to crush it so as to suppress all opposition, we've moved far away from democracy and into outright tyranny. It will be most interesting, in the era of modern communication, to see how long such oppression can outlive the desire for freedom.
09:09 AM on 05/19/2012
The law is not an attack on the students' right to protest or freely assemble. The kids are free to skip class and protest all they want....they just don't have the right to deprive others of an education.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Creox
Life is too important to take seriously.
10:04 AM on 05/19/2012
Yeah, go ahead and protest as long as it doesn't inconvenience the status quo...yeeeesh give me a break. That is what protests are designed to do...exactly.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rob Vann
Hope for the best,Plan for the worst,Take what cms
03:32 PM on 05/19/2012
What nonesense.. you obviously know nothing about Bill 78.. Do your D&D.

http://canadians.org/blog/?p=15222
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles the Great
Canadian/Israeli Goy in Alert,Nunavut
10:10 AM on 05/19/2012
Since when are these protesters the 99% of Students? Why did they attack or disrupted students who were working hard studying so they can get the year over? Well the fake 99% strikes again and will you pay for a another year of school out of your pocket for me?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:11 AM on 05/19/2012
Here's the solution.... Take the 25 billion there going to spend on fighter jets and provide free tuition to all young people who have the marks and want to go to university, pay off all other students loans for the last 5 years. If the students grades are not up to snuff cut financing.The economy will boom!

Sweden does it.....
05:31 PM on 05/19/2012
Just a touch overly simplistic. Remember that the money (who knows how much it really is) going to the F#%s is borrowed money. Let's not spend it at all. The increases originally proposed by the Quebec government were quite reasonable, considering Quebec has free junior colleges, the lowest university tuition in North America, and a huge deficit.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skookum1
truth can't be bought, but lies sure can be sold..
06:30 PM on 05/19/2012
And Sweden for all its neutrality, still has a military, too. They just don't spend profligately because some campaign donor from south of the line wants them to....
09:58 PM on 05/19/2012
Sweden's military recently said that it required 60 to 80 fighters to replace it's aging jets. Sweden gets its Gripen jets from Saab. Saab doesn't give them away.