A new report suggests Canada's wireless services are competitive with global peers both on prices and available technology and any regulation could hinder advances.
MONTREAL - Canada's wireless services are competitive with global peers both on prices and available technology and any new regulation could hinder advances, a new report suggests.
Canadian wireless providers are on the right track, offering consumers network upgrades, the economic note released Tuesday by the Montreal Economic Institute says. Canadians will continue to pressure companies to provide technology to support smartphones and other high-tech devices, it adds.
"When you look at the whole picture, Canada is very much within the norm for developed countries with regard to prices, available technologies and network speed," says author Yves Rabeau, associate professor at the Université du Québec à Montréal.
Canadians will continue to pressure companies to provide technology to support smartphones and other high-tech devices, Rabeau says, adding Canada's wireless market is in "full expansion" and "functioning well."
"Canadians therefore have every reason to want to maintain the approach put in place nearly two decades ago, namely refraining from imposing specific regulation on this important sector of our economy."
Rabeau argues that the CRTC, which is reopening the debate into whether to regulate the industry, should not crack down but rather maintain the current system.
In April, the CRTC asked for feedback on whether it needs to create a national wireless code to ensure that cellphone and mobile device customers are protected. It suggested it could develop a national code for wireless services after receiving several applications suggesting one.
The regulator decided in 1994 that it wouldn't regulate the wireless sector, convinced there was enough competition in the market.
The report stands in contrast to criticisms that Canada's service providers are not competitive enough and Canadians pay too much compared to telecom users around the world.
But Rabeau cites reports that support his thesis that Canada is keeping pace with international standards.
He cites a 2012 study by Wall Communications that found high usage Canadian rate plans are less expensive than similar American plans on average, as well as an OECD study that found Canada is the seventh least expensive of 34 countries for roaming fees.
The OECD study placed Canada 24th in terms of penetration of broadband services, ahead of Germany and Italy.
"When we use comparable figures to evaluate the prices charged by Canadian wireless companies, we can see that they are fairly close to the average of what we find in other developed countries," he said.
"We are therefore far from the caricature propagated by certain analysts of a Canada trailing the rest of the world in Internet and wireless access."
Canada's major telecom companies — Rogers (TSX:RCI.B), Bell (TSX:BCE) and Telus (TSX:T) — and consumer advocacy groups all support the idea of national standards that would apply to wireless devices, however they don't all agree on how those rules would work.
Share your vote on Facebook so your friends can take this poll
Canadians are more satisfied with smaller "stand-alone" wireless companies like Koodo and Virgin Mobile than they are with full-service telecoms like Bell and Rogers, according to a survey from J.D. Power and Associates released in May, 2012. <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2012/05/10/wireless-carriers-canadians-like_n_1507278.html" target="_hplink">Read the full report here</a>.
Source: <a href="http://www.jdpower.com/content/press-release/Y1JTKwn/2012-canadian-wireless-total-ownership-experience-study.htm" target="_hplink">J.D. Power and Associates</a><br>
<br>
Number represents score out of 1,000.
4. Fido - 706
Source: <a href="http://www.jdpower.com/content/press-release/Y1JTKwn/2012-canadian-wireless-total-ownership-experience-study.htm" target="_hplink">J.D. Power and Associates</a><br>
<br>
Number represents score out of 1,000.
3. Virgin Mobile - 725
Source: <a href="http://www.jdpower.com/content/press-release/Y1JTKwn/2012-canadian-wireless-total-ownership-experience-study.htm" target="_hplink">J.D. Power and Associates</a><br>
<br>
Number represents score out of 1,000.
2. PC Mobile - 730
Source: <a href="http://www.jdpower.com/content/press-release/Y1JTKwn/2012-canadian-wireless-total-ownership-experience-study.htm" target="_hplink">J.D. Power and Associates</a><br>
<br>
Number represents score out of 1,000.
1. Koodo Mobile - 752
Source: <a href="http://www.jdpower.com/content/press-release/Y1JTKwn/2012-canadian-wireless-total-ownership-experience-study.htm" target="_hplink">J.D. Power and Associates</a><br>
<br>
Number represents score out of 1,000.
Canadians are more satisfied with smaller "stand-alone" wireless companies like Koodo and Virgin Mobile than they are with full-service telecoms like Bell and Rogers, according to a survey from J.D. Power and Associates released in May, 2012. <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2012/05/10/wireless-carriers-canadians-like_n_1507278.html" target="_hplink">Read the full report here</a>.<br>
<br>
Source: <a href="http://www.jdpower.com/content/press-release/Y1JTKwn/2012-canadian-wireless-total-ownership-experience-study.htm" target="_hplink">J.D. Power and Associates</a><br>
<br>
Number represents score out of 1,000.
4. Solo Mobile - 680
Source: <a href="http://www.jdpower.com/content/press-release/Y1JTKwn/2012-canadian-wireless-total-ownership-experience-study.htm" target="_hplink">J.D. Power and Associates</a><br>
<br>
Number represents score out of 1,000.
3. Rogers - 668
Source: <a href="http://www.jdpower.com/content/press-release/Y1JTKwn/2012-canadian-wireless-total-ownership-experience-study.htm" target="_hplink">J.D. Power and Associates</a><br>
<br>
Number represents score out of 1,000.
2. Bell - 665
Source: <a href="http://www.jdpower.com/content/press-release/Y1JTKwn/2012-canadian-wireless-total-ownership-experience-study.htm" target="_hplink">J.D. Power and Associates</a><br>
<br>
Number represents score out of 1,000.
1. MTS - 663
Source: <a href="http://www.jdpower.com/content/press-release/Y1JTKwn/2012-canadian-wireless-total-ownership-experience-study.htm" target="_hplink">J.D. Power and Associates</a><br>
<br>
Number represents score out of 1,000.
MONTREAL - Canada's wireless services are competitive with global peers both on prices and available technology and any new regulation could hinder advances, a new report suggests.Canadian wireless pr...
MONTREAL - Canada's wireless services are competitive with global peers both on prices and available technology and any new regulation could hinder advances, a new report suggests.Canadian wireless pr...
Canadians are more satisfied with smaller “stand-alone” wireless companies like Koodo and Virgin Mobile than they are with full-service telecoms like Bell and Rogers, a...
TORONTO - "Cell shock" is hitting too many Ontarians as they open their cellphone bills and find unexpected charges, Consumer Services Minister Margarett Best said...
Ottawa’s new rules for wireless carriers could mean Canadians will miss out on faster cellphone connections, a telecom consultant says, and some industry insiders say...
RUSSELL, Ont. - Ottawa moved Wednesday to level the wireless playing field by placing limits on the coming wireless spectrum auction and lifting foreign-investment limits...
The Liberal Party's industry critic has thrown his weight behind a new campaign to force open the doors of Canada’s cellphone industry to greater competition....
OTTAWA - Canadians should expect lower prices after Ottawa announces its decision on foreign ownership in the wireless sector and sets ground rules for the...
The best kept secret when it comes to cell phones and plans for the casual user is 7Eleven store. $20.00 will buy you a phone and $50.00 will buy you 200 minutes that don't expire for a year. By the way,they use Rogers network. Rogers has a better deal for them and Petro-Canada than they have for their regular customers.
leroybrown: The best kept secret when it comes to cell phones
I think the biggest con job with cell phones is the time limit. If I buy a $20.00 card for my phone I must use it within 30 days. If not, I lose the money remaining, unless I buy another card before the 30 days are up.
Cell phone companies are like insurance companies, and banks, they are legalized gangsters, aided and abided by our government.
Buffalobrave: I think the biggest con job with cell phones is
Buy a phone at a 7-Eleven store....20.00 for the phone and 50.00 for a card that doesn't expire for a year.After 364 days if you still have unused minutes by another card and the previous unused minutes will roll over.
leroybrown: Buy a phone at a 7-Eleven store....20.00 for the phone
$45 unlimited everything as I'm visiting as a student here in the US. No added fees. We did the math, and back home this same plan based on my usage would cost $135-$160 depending on carrier.
No contest. CRTC do your job. You are being watched.
Torontobound: $45 unlimited everything as I'm visiting as a student here
Bell, 60/month everything included. (If it is unlmt everything, then your usage doesn't matter)
I do not know a single person who has ever paid 135+/month (unless it was a part of a shared, or family plan)for mobile service. I pay less than 140/month for all three bundles services.
Blanken_Berry: I call BS on that one. Bell, 60/month everything included.
anything the CRTC says, you just need to take it and inverse it to understand the truth.
These guys are absolutely hand picked bought and paid for by the big Trio that screws Canadians into paying a fixed rate with no competition. It's absolute collusion.
Runey: anything the CRTC says, you just need to take it
A quick scan of their web site shows that while they do not disclose their funding, some of their articles have been published by the TorontoSun & Nat'l Post. A view of their topic headlines provides some insight into who is donating....
As someone who uses a US phone on a US plan, I beg to differ on the cost be comparable or the industries the same. I actually gave my rogers phone/plan because it was about half through Verizon & I have unlimited data.
It appears as though the various "think tanks" are building their case in the public for the CRTC to allow Rogers, Bell et all to continue the gouging.
bifster: A quick scan of their web site shows that while
It would be interesting to see how much of the Montreal Economic Institutes funding derives from telecommunications sources. Given what is reported here I would guess 110%.
Hardly a non-partisan group.
It is just the Quebec version of the Fraser Institute.
I would like a "think" tank to create new ideas, not regurgitate those from its benefactors.
Thanks, but no "tanks".
Lw-Ctr: Hardly a non-partisan group. It is just the Quebec version
Picked up a cell phone while on vacation in Texas this past winter. Got the phone, 260 mins of anytime, any use, time good for 3 months with no roaming charges while used in the States. Mind you, couldn't call back to Canada but used Skype for that. Cost was $25 plus tax (8% if I remember correctly)
Don't believe you could touch that here.
mtnestr: Picked up a cell phone while on vacation in Texas
when it costs $30 for 100Mb for roaming from AT&T in the US and $225 for 75Mb from Rogers in Canada and they can say we are competitive ---you wonder who's side the CRTC is on!
rving: when it costs $30 for 100Mb for roaming from AT&T
CP | By The Canadian Press Posted: 09/11/2012 4:08 pm Updated: 09/11/2012 8:27 pm