According to police, the two men approached first approached a 92-year-old woman in April and "solicited repairs to her home."
Police say the men caused the woman to worry about repairs on her home and requested money from her to buy materials and to obtain permits.
The two accused — Scott Eisemann, 43, and Anthony Taylor, 41, — were arrested Thursday. They are due to appear in court next month on fraud charges.
Police believe there may be other victims.