CALGARY - A Calgary psychiatrist used as an expert by the courts expressed dismay when interviewed by police about sexual assault claims against him, but failed to address the allegations.
Dr. Aubrey Levin, 73, was charged after one of his patients came forward and provided officers with secret videos he recorded during his court-ordered sessions with the psychiatrist. The videos, shown in court last week, depict Levin undoing the man’s belt and jeans and fondling him.
"I only wish instead of being charged I could have crawled into a hole," Levin said in a four hour video interview with a Calgary police detective that was played Monday for the jury of seven men and five women.
"Whatever happens there will be mud on my face. I'm horrified also to the name and the reputation of psychiatry to have somebody charged."
But any questions about the complainant or the allegations were met with a pointed no comment.
"'I'm not talking about him," said Levin. "I've been advised not to."
Levin said he often used the reflex test to deal with patients that suffer from erectile dysfunction.
"If it's a quick response, it's fantastic. If there's not, then you carry on until you get a response, which can take any amount of time," said Levin.
"Normally these examinations are less than 15 minutes, whatever happens."
The patient, identified only as R.B. in court, was on probation at the time the videos were taken and had been ordered by a court to see Levin twice a month.
The man said he had told authorities about previous assaults and no one believed him, so he bought a spy camera and brought it to his appointments.
After Levin was arrested, nearly two dozen other former patients came forward with abuse allegations. He is on trial for the alleged sexual assault of 10 male patients.
A urologist testified Monday that he doesn't believe the forensic psychiatrist was performing a medical procedure.
Dr. Ethan Grober of the University of Toronto said it appeared Levin was attempting to arouse the patient — something that would never be appropriate.
"It was almost as if the doctor was trying to elicit an orgasm."
Grober, who is an expert on male sexual reproduction, said he doesn't believe Levin was performing the reflex test normally used to determine the state of spinal cord injuries. He said the test is not used in resolving erectile dysfunction cases.
He said a patient's response to that test is almost instantaneous and would not require the 14 minutes shown on one of the videos.
"(It) is a very unusual test to perform," said Grober.
"It takes maybe a minute or two and that should be the end of it. It has never been described as a form of therapy."
He also rejected suggestions from Levin's lawyer that the technique was either an older procedure or something "cutting edge" that Grober was unfamiliar with.
"I don't believe that's possible," Grober replied.
He said the "manoeuvres" he witnessed in the videos went "well beyond" what is considered to be normal treatment. He said a psychiatrist's treatment of complaints of sexual problems is usually confined to counselling.
Levin, who said in the police interview that he had served as a psychiatrist in the South African military before immigrating to Canada 17 years ago, was frequently used by the courts to assess people and provide expert opinions at hearings. Most of his alleged victims were ordered to see him by a judge.
Levin served briefly as regional director for the federal Psychiatric Centre Saskatoon and was licensed in 1998 to practise psychiatry in Alberta.
Also on HuffPost:
MYTH: Therapy Is Like Having A Paid Friend
<strong>FACT: </strong> There is huge difference between a therapist and your best friend. "There's a myth that you pay someone to be nice to you and care for you -- what I tell my clients is that you pay for time and expertise and the caring is free," says Noah Rubinstein, founder and CEO of therapist directory GoodTherapy.org. Rubinstein adds, therapists are trained to avoid dual relationships and can't see their clients outside of the office.
MYTH: Therapy Means You're 'Crazy'
<strong>FACT: </strong> Most people are raised to be independent and solve problems on their own. "Seeking help is not a sign of weakness and the truth is, we all suffer and getting help doesn't mean you're 'crazy,'" Rubinstein says. He also adds that people at some point in time will go through periods of depression, hurt or feeling worried and mainstream media often has misconceptions of what a patient or client looks like. "Most people who go to therapists are ordinary everyday people. They don't have manic episodes or are hospitalized -- and I wouldn't call this 'crazy' either," he says.
MYTH: Therapy Is Endless
<strong>FACT:</strong> No, therapy isn't a never-ending session that will take over your life. "A lot of people are afraid that if they go to therapy it will go on and on," Rubinstein says. Depending on the type of therapist you see, therapists are trained to create a target plan of treatment. "Some people may never heal in this lifetime but for most people, the average therapy course is three or four months," he says.
MYTH: Therapy Will Cost A Fortune
<strong>FACT: </strong>Yes, seeing a therapist often can get expensive. Rubinstein suggests looking at your insurance providers to see if you can get benefits -- relying solely on paying out of your own pocket can get costly. But he also advises a holistic view. "When you think about price, what's the cost of not doing therapy? Your job performance?" he says. Think about how your distress many conflict with your work or relationship and then make a decision about pricing.
MYTH: Therapists Will Blame You And Shame You
<strong>FACT: </strong> "This is something that comes directly out of Dr. Phil. Therapists are portrayed like Dr. Phil and he blames, shames and confronts his clients -- this is not how therapy works," Rubinstein says. Good therapy is about compassion, he adds, and is intended to let the client experience their own emotional breakthroughs at their own pace.
MYTH: Medication Is Just As Effective As Therapy
<strong>FACT: </strong> Rubinstein says that not all problems can be fixed with medication. "The medical model assumes that most psychological problems are caused by biochemistry, rather than viewing biochemical changes as a symptom, and can overlook the experience of losing jobs, divorce, deaths in the family etc.," he says. Emotional stress, he notes, cannot be solved with just medication, and people relying solely on pills should look at their options for one-on-one therapy.
MYTH: Therapy Is Passive
<strong>FACT: </strong> Rubinstein says many people also think therapy is passive. Just think about all the scenes in movies or television shows where a therapist does nothing but nod his or her head. "Therapists are taught active listening skills and are trained to understand the client's struggles," he says.
MYTH: Therapy Is All Happy Thoughts
<strong>FACT: </strong> 'Think happy thoughts...think happy thoughts.' Yes, but not always. "Many new clients expect their therapist to change their perspective and convince them they should be happy. But therapy doesn't work by thinking happy thoughts, In order to become happy, a person needs to face the parts of them that aren't," he says. Working with a client one-on-one, therapists are able to go through a person's painful past and give them hope for a peaceful future.
MYTH: There's Nothing You Can Do About The Past
<strong>FACT: </strong> There's always an assumption that therapy is about moving forward and never looking back. "When we do this, our past still haunts us. Good therapy allows people to go to those places where they have been wounded and burned and resolve these feelings," he says.
MYTH: Therapy Will Make Your Painful Problems Worse
<strong>FACT: </strong> Yes, you will go back into the past and yes, it may bring up some bad memories. But don't be afraid. "Good therapists guide their clients through painful experiences, but in a way that is safe and not overwhelming."