He wasn't alone.
None of his teammates produced at the plate, and now New York's season is over.
The slugging Yankees, who set a team record for homers and finished second in baseball in runs scored, were swept by the Detroit Tigers in the AL championship series, losing 8-1 in Game 4 on Thursday.
"You never expect this," Rodriguez said. "It's a terrible way for the season to end."
A-Rod got all the attention, being benched three times in this post-season, but New York did not get it done up and down the lineup — Raul Ibanez being an exception — during a series in which it failed to lead once.
"The one thing I don't want to focus on is Alex, in a sense, because it wasn't just him that didn't hit," Yankees manager Joe Girardi said. "You know, if the other guys hit, one guy's struggles aren't going to show as much."
Rodriguez batted .120 (3 for 25) with no RBIs in the post-season, including 0 for 18 with 12 strikeouts against right-handers and 1 for 9 against the Tigers.
He has $114 million and five years remaining on his contract — and a no-trade clause — and said he expects to be back with the Yankees next season.
"I love New York City and I love everything about being a Yankee," he said. "The highs are very high and the lows are extremely low. And there's no question the last few weeks was extremely difficult, not only on me but all my teammates."
Asked whether he would accept a platoon role or prefer to go to another team, the three-time AL MVP responded: "I've never thought about going to another team. My focus is to stay here. Let's make that very, very clear. Number two, I don't expect to be mediocre. I expect to do what I've done for a long time."
Several of Rodriguez's teammates were worse with a bat in their hands in the post-season.
Robinson Cano was at .075 (3 for 40) with no home runs, Curtis Granderson .100 (3 for 30) with 16 strikeouts, Nick Swisher .167 (5 for 30) with two RBIs and Russell Martin .161 (5 for 31) with one RBI. Eric Chavez was 0 for 16 with eight strikeouts.
Girardi seemed most puzzled by Cano's struggles, which included getting only one hit in 18 at-bats against the Tigers and enduring a post-season-record 0-for-29 skid that began against Baltimore in the division series.
"That one is kind of baffling for me because we have seen the type of hitter that Robby Cano is," Girardi said.
The only records the Yankees set this October were for futility.
They batted .188 (60 for 320), a low for seven games in the post-season, according to STATS LLC., and scored just 22 runs — six against Detroit.
And, New York joined the 1984 Kansas City Royals as the only teams to play a league championship series without leading a game. Coincidently, the Tigers dominated Kansas City en route to their last World Series title.
After Ibanez hit a tying two-run homer during a four-run ninth inning of the opener, it was all downhill for the Yankees. In the 12th inning, they lost shortstop Derek Jeter to a broken ankle that will keep him out until spring training. They looked lost after that.
As if New York's problems at the plate weren't enough, ace CC Sabathia had an awful performance when his team needed him most, and the Yankees played poorly defensively — especially four-time Gold Glove first baseman Mark Teixeira — in their last game of the year.
Sabathia lasted just 3 2-3 innings because the Tigers were teeing off on him with 11 hits, six runs — five earned — and striking out just three times.
"It's embarrassing to me to come out and not be able to give our team a chance to win," he said. "I pride myself on trying to give us a chance and I didn't do that tonight."