EDMONTON - An Alberta health executive who quit after it was revealed he had billed taxpayers for almost $370,000 for lavish meals, car repairs and a butler says — if anything — he didn't charge enough.
Allaudin Merali, in a statement released to the media Friday, said his expenses were within the rules at the time and he could have charged more for business functions held at his home.
"I generally under-reported the true cost of these functions by not expensing the general use of my home or cooking and any additional food provided by my wife," Merali said in the letter.
The butler bills have been taken out of context because the butlers were part of catering staff routinely hired to work at the functions, he added.
"This is common practice at the senior executive level," he wrote.
"The imputation that I simply lived a high life at the taxpayers' expense is an invention of sheer malice."
On Thursday, Alberta Health Services, or AHS, reported the audited findings for Merali's spending during his tenure from 2005-2008 as chief financial officer for the now-defunct Capital Health Authority in Edmonton.
Merali — after meeting with AHS officials — agreed to quit his post last Aug. 1 just hours ahead of a television report that aired the details of his spending and pegged it at $346,000.
On Thursday, AHS reported that a subsequent outside audit revealed the final number was another $22,000 higher.
AHS said the auditors also found that all but $5,613 of Merali's spending was either in a grey area or was allowed under loose or non-existent rules and reporting standards that governed executive spending at Capital Health.
The AHS also reported that a check of four other executives who held positions with the former Calgary Health Region revealed that $5,100 out of their spending total of $234,948 should not have been charged to taxpayers.
AHS chairman Stephen Lockwood said that "non-compliant" amount was so small he chalked it up to a clerical error.
Merali, in his letter, wondered why he wasn't being given the same benefit of the doubt.
"I cannot accept that my past expenses are held up to a different standard and reported in the media without context and without regard to simple fairness, so as to cast implicit doubts on my integrity," he wrote.
In the days that followed Merali's departure, numerous media agencies sought him out for comment but were rebuffed.
Merali wrote that his expense payments were artificially high because he was often left with the cheque when he had to fill in for the region's CEO, Sheila Weatherill, or when he had to attend or hold a function at the provincial government's request.
"In a different organization, my travel and hosting expenses might have been shared among several executives, and would then have been a non-issue."
Merali's receipts included $2,303 to install a Bluetooth phone in his Mercedes Benz and $525 to fix a car window.
He defended those bills as necessities for an executive in a $3-billion organization who needed to be available at all times.
He also billed taxpayers $594 for an airline ticket for his wife. He said that was an innocent mistake and that he had otherwise scrupulously reimbursed the region for any of her expenses.
Records show Merali had a history of controversial spending.
He lost his job at Capital Health in 2008 when it and all other health regions and boards were merged into the current superboard.
He then began working in Ontario, advising the province on how to implement an electronic health records system.
By 2009, however, his contract was not renewed. Documents released to the public showed he had been billing taxpayers about $76,000 a month for flights, pricey meals and hotel accommodations.
In the spring of 2011 he was back in Alberta and was hired as chief financial officer for AHS.
Board members have said they were aware at that point of Merali's Ontario spending controversy but hired him anyway because of his skills. They said he also promised to adhere to new strict spending rules.
Shortly after Merali's departure, Weatherill resigned from the board of AHS. She had signed off on Merali's expenses.
Also on HuffPost:
Online Dating Scams
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/05/15/online-romance-scams-cost-50-million-in-2011_n_1518162.html" target="_hplink">Fraudsters feigned interest</a> in lonely online romance seekers to rob victims of about $50 million last year.
Debt Collector Scams
Phony debt collection agencies <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/11/ftc-busts-scam-debt-collector_n_1418582.html?ref=business&ir=Business" target="_hplink">have pressured victims</a> into giving up millions of dollars. The Federal Trade Commission recently closed down two California-based <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/21/ftc-indian-call-center-fraud-debt-collectors_n_1289751.html" target="_hplink">companies with call centers in India</a> after they defrauded Americans out of $5 million over the past two years.
Online Marketplace Scams
Craigslist and eBay are a playground for scammers. Consumers have sent payments to <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/23/craigslist-scams-tips-losing-money_n_1445763.html" target="_hplink">places like Nigeria </a>for items advertised online only to discover they have been scammed. Last year, Romanians pretending to be U.S. citizens put fake ads for pricey items on eBay and Craigslist, <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/23/craigslist-scams-tips-losing-money_n_1445763.html" target="_hplink">defrauding Americans out of more than $100 million. </a>
Prize Money Scams
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2012/04/28/lottery-scam-probe-nets-2_n_1460916.html" target="_hplink">Canadian police arrested a man </a>who tried to take a $70,000 processing fee from an elderly Californian woman who believed she was going to win a $7.5 million lottery prize in April. More recently,<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/05/17/jamaica-lottery-scam-fraud-suspects-arrested_n_1525498.html" target="_hplink"> eight Jamaican swindlers accused</a> of duping Americans in lottery scams were also arrested.
Fake charity organizations come out of the woodwork to exploit the generosity of others, <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/09/tornado-relief-fraud-scam_n_1334853.html" target="_hplink">especially during times of disaster.</a> Most recently, an organization that claims to help disabled veterans called Disabled Veterans National Foundation (DVNF) <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/05/08/charity-fraud-disabled-national-veterans-foundation_n_1499314.html" target="_hplink">took millions of dollars from donors</a> without spending the money on veterans.
Mortgage Foreclosure Scams
Scammers targeting struggling homeowners have offered false services to help with mortgage settlements. Mortgage foreclosure scams have shot up <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/16/mortgage-foreclosure-scams_n_1429805.html" target="_hplink">60 percent in 2012 as new federal programs</a> for mortgages have provided avenues for fraudsters to exploit.
Travelling Relative Scams
Scam complaints related to travelling surged right before <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/11/spring-break-travel-scams_n_1418954.html" target="_hplink">spring break last year. Crooks defrauded</a> grandparents out of money when their grandchildren were travelling abroad. The scammers, who find out about the travel plans from places like social media sites, pretend to be the grandchild asking for wire transfers on the phone. The scams have involved scammers pretending in an email to be a victim's travelling relative who has recently been mugged or has lost their passport.
Although there isn't much data on how often it occurs, food scams can pose a tremendous<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/20/food-fraud-hoax-grocery-store_n_1439995.html#s889480&title=Milk_" target="_hplink"> health risk. The chances</a> of dilution and counterfeiting increase when food is imported from other countries, and some foods like fish and olive oil are particularly prone to adulteration.
Online Prescription Drug Scams
Scammers have sold drugs to online consumers and then posed as government agents asking the buyers to pay money to <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/12/online-prescription-drug-scam_n_1420776.html" target="_hplink">avoid jail time. A Texas woman </a>killed herself after being caught up in one of these drug schemes.
Credit Card Scams
Credit card breaches allow fraudsters to make charges on other peoples' cards after getting a hold of numbers. Global Payments Inc., a third party payment processing service for MasterCard and Visa, made headlines in April for reporting that over a million card numbers had been compromised from their system, <a href="http://news.cnet.com/8301-1009_3-57407981-83/global-payments-calls-data-breach-contained/" target="_hplink">according to CNET.</a>