An Edmonton man who spent eight years in prison for sexually assaulting his nine-year-old stepson has been acquitted after the boy said that his biological father forced him to lie.
The man, who cannot be named under a publication ban, was convicted in 1995 and served his entire prison sentence. He was denied parole because he refused to admit to the offence.
The Alberta Court of Appeal directed a verdict of acquittal in a decision released Monday.
When the child made the claims in the early 90s, his biological parents were involved in a bitter custody battle. Charges were laid after he said his mother's common-law partner sexually assaulted him.
About five years into his stepfather’s sentence, the boy went back to live with his mother.
That’s when he told her that his biological father forced him to make up the story after threatening him with a knife.
While he was still in prison, the stepfather applied to the federal minister of justice for a review of the case.
A special commissioner, Justice Ernest Marshall, was appointed to look at whether the boy’s recantation of his original story could be admitted as fresh evidence.
The commissioner called a number of witnesses, including the boy, who is now an adult. His biological father also testified and denied forcing his son to lie.
In a report sent last year to the Alberta Court of Appeal, the commissioner found the boy’s original testimony to be unreliable and said that his evidence during the trial “consisted of accusations punctuated by retractions,” the appeal decision said.
The commissioner came to the conclusion that the boy’s recantations were “worthy of belief.”
“Consideration of this testimony gives rise to a reasonable inference that the allegations were false and the recantations were correct,” he wrote in his report.
The man's lawyer told CBC News that his client is relieved that the matter is over. The man is now back with his common-law wife and is on good terms with his stepson.
Also on HuffPost:
The Dunster House Murder
In 1995, Sinedu Tadesse, a Harvard junior from Ethiopia, stabbed her roommate, Vietnamese student Trang Phuong Ho, 45 times and then hanged herself in the Dunster House bathroom. The incident supposedly resulted from Sinedu's dependence on Ho. While Ho was popular and academically successful, Tadesse struggled in both areas. When Ho told Tadesse that she was going to room with someone else for her senior year, Tadesse purchased a hunting knife, sent a warning letter to the Harvard Crimson and then killed her friend and herself.
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/news/tyler-clementi" target="_hplink">Dharun Ravi rigged his laptop</a> to spy on his rooommate Tyler Clementi. Clementi frequently asked to have the room for himself when he brought a friend over, and Ravi usually obliged by heading to hang with friends elsewhere. Ravi decided he wanted to find out what Clementi did when he had the dorm room to himself, so he set up his laptop so he could view through its webcam when he wasn't in the room, and caught Clementi kissing another man. Ravi tweeted about it and told friends how they could watch too. After Clementi discovered he had been spied on, he left a suicide note (which has not been disclosed to the public) and jumped off the George Washington bridge to his death. Ravi was convicted on invasion of privacy charges and sentenced to 30 days in jail with three years probation.
iMurder At Bowie State
Alexis D. Simpson, 19, a student at Bowie State University, was charged for fatally stabbing her roommate. The roommates lived in an apartment-style campus dormitory. They began fighting verbally over <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/09/16/bowie-state-stabbing-alex_n_966924.html" target="_hplink">playing music from an iPod</a> and it escalated into a physical confrontation. After Simpson was <a href="http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/bowie-state-student-held-without-bond-in-death-of-roommate/2011/09/19/gIQAXuwUgK_story.html" target="_hplink">pushed into her bedroom</a> by someone else in the suite, she emerged with what appeared to be a knife and stabbed her roommate in the neck, according to court papers.
While American Amanda Knox was studying in Italy, her roommate, Meredith Kercher, an English exchange student, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Meredith_Kercher" target="_hplink">was murdered in their apartment</a>. The roommates in the apartment had come from different backgrounds and often smoked hashish, but the investigation into Kercher's death eventually focused on one roommate: Knox (along with her Italian boyfriend, Raffaelle Sollecito). However, after staying in jail for three years, Knox was acquitted of on her murder charge. Though acquitted, it was a dramatic living situation that caught international attention.
Alexander Kinyua, a 21-year-old Morgan State University student, admitted to <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/05/31/alexander-kinyua-kujoe-agyei-kodie-ate-brain-heart-roommate-maryland_n_1560149.html?ref=college&ir=College" target="_hplink">murdering his roommate</a> Kujoe Bonsafo Agyei-Kodie, who was reported missing last Friday. Kinyua also admitted to devouring his roommate's brain and heart, according to police. Kinyua's father called police when Kinyua's brother reportedly found human remains -- a head and two hands -- in a metal tin in the basement. The brother and father left the room for a short time, but when they came back, the body parts had been moved and Kinyua was washing out the tin.
Sexiled At Stonehill
The AP <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/03/02/lindsay-blankmeyer-roommate-sex-lawsuit-_n_1316791.html" target="_hplink">reported</a> in March 2012, that a former student at Stonehill College was suing the school, claiming administrators didn't do enough to help her when she complained that her roommate was having too much sex in their dorm room. Lindsay Blankmeyer said in a federal lawsuit that she already suffered from depression and attention deficit disorder before she enrolled at Stonehill, but was driven into a suicidal depression when the school refused to help her escape her allegedly promiscuous roommate.
Natural Born Copy-cats
The Jacksonville Times-Union <a href="http://jacksonville.com/tu-online/stories/071506/met_22335790.shtml" target="_hplink">reported</a> separate juries found a Jacksonville couple guilty ... of murdering their 22-year-old roommate, robbing him and then setting his body and apartment on fire -- crimes prosecutors say were mimicked after they watched the 1994 movie <em>Natural Born Killers</em>. <blockquote>Angus Wallen and Kara Winn, both 27, were tried separately and each convicted of first-degree murder, robbery and arson in the Dec. 18, 2004 crime. Separate juries for each defendant determined that Wallen and Winn shot Brandon Murphy, took his car, debit card, Nintendo games and other property and doused the body and the apartment with lighter fluid.</blockquote>
Janelle Henderson accused fellow University of Arizona student Galareka Harrison of stealing her student ID charge card, her social security card, some checks and $500 from her bank account. Prosecutors said Harrison spent days thinking about how to respond to Henderson's accusations. Her decision was to buy an eight-inch kitchen knife and use it to stab Henderson 23 times in the back and neck.
Joseph Hotz was allegedly under the influence of hallucinogenic mushrooms when he stabbed his Chadron State College roommate, Kennth Pfeiffer, to death. Police say he then committed a break-in several blocks from their house.