TORONTO - Financially better-off individuals seeking a family doctor appear more likely to get an appointment than those who are poor, even though Canada's universal health system offers no monetary incentive for cherry-picking patients, a study suggests.
The study found that individuals who called a physician's office asking to be seen as a new patient were more than 50 per cent more likely to get an appointment if they presented themselves as having a well-paying job.
"Our study provides very strong evidence of discrimination, but it does not identify specific offices that are discriminating," said principal researcher Dr. Stephen Hwang, a specialist in inner-city health at St. Michael's Hospital in Toronto.
"It simply shows that you are more likely to get an appointment if you are of high socioeconomic status," he said. "We think this indicates pretty clearly that there is preferential access to primary care."
To conduct the study, published Monday in the Canadian Medical Association Journal, researchers phoned 375 family physician and general practitioner offices in Toronto, posing as a bank employee or a welfare recipient, either with chronic health conditions or needing only routine care.
"So every physician's office got a call from one person and there were four possible scenarios that they could be randomly assigned to," said Hwang, noting that the doctors' offices were chosen at random and most responses were from receptionists or other administrative staff.
The proportion of calls resulting in an appointment offer was greater for those posing as bank employees — 23 per cent — than for those presenting themselves as welfare recipients — 14 per cent.
When including those who were offered a screening visit or a spot on a waiting list, 37 per cent of so-called better-off callers got a positive response compared to 24 per cent for those of more limited income.
"Typically, the caller who was turned down would be told: 'I'm sorry, but Dr. X is not accepting patients currently' or 'The practice is not open to new patients,'" Hwang said.
"That's what they would be told, but what we observed is that you're more likely to be told that if you're of low socioeconomic status than if you're of high socioeconomic status."
Hwang stressed he was not trying to single out family physicians or suggest they discriminate more than other physicians or professions.
"We don't know if this is a subconscious bias on the part of the receptionist or if they're carrying out instructions that are given to them or if it's conscious bias. We don't know."
Dr. Marie-Dominique Beaulieu, president of the College of Family Physicians of Canada, said her organization promotes patient equality and would frown on any of its 28,000 members across the country choosing patients based on their social or financial profile.
"Socioeconomic status or any other (patient) characteristic shouldn't be considered" when a physician is in a position to accept new patients, Beaulieu said Monday from Montreal, where she practises family medicine.
The study has some limitations, including the fact that doctors' offices were called only once with a single scenario, not twice by two different researchers posing as patients on relatively opposite sides of the socioeconomic coin.
Hwang conceded that two calls would have been ideal — providing a "smoking gun" if each caller got a different response — but there were logistical pitfalls, including time constraints and concern about detection if the calls were made too close together.
"I think we have to take this study for what it is," said Beaulieu, "which is a small study that maybe adds to a body of knowledge, but certainly cannot be considered as conclusive at demonstrating bias."
Unexpectedly, researchers who said they had chronic health conditions — in this case, diabetes and low back pain — were more likely to receive appointment offers than those seeking routine care, such as a check-up (24 per cent versus 13 per cent).
"We were very surprised by that," said Hwang, who had hypothesized that patients without complex health problems would be more likely to be accepted as patients.
"We thought because patients with chronic health conditions take more time and more effort that physicians might be preferentially seeking to enrol healthy patients in their practices.
"But we were pleased to see the opposite, that physician offices were appropriately giving priority to people with health problems over those who did not have immediate health problems."
Beaulieu said the fact that patients with complex health-care needs were more likely to be offered an appointment is reassuring.
"So this would not support the idea of cherry-picking," she said.
The study found no evidence that the length of time a doctor had been practising nor the socioeconomic status of the neighbourhood where offices were located had any bearing on whether a patient was accepted.
Hwang said the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario, for one, recommends against doctors cherry-picking patients based on their health status, socioeconomic profile or other factors.
"They say 'it is not appropriate for physicians to screen potential patients because it can compromise public trust in the profession, especially at a time when access to care is a concern.'"
The College of Physicians and Surgeons has a clear policy that new patients should be taken on a first-come, first-served basis, but the policy does not appear to be enforced, he said.
"I think the first thing is we need to recognize is ... (that we're) all prone to treating people differently and discriminating," Hwang said.
"Socially, within the realm of health care, we feel that that's inappropriate."
HOW OFTEN TO GO: If you're not sick, once a year for annual check-ups and flu shots, or several times a year if you're suffering from illnesses, need immunity shots or are pregnant THE DETAILS: Doctors are often the first people you visit as soon as something goes wrong. Coughs, runny noses, back pains and the flu shot — you doctor can both treat these ailments or refer you to a specialist who can help. Annual check-ups are also recommended once a year to update your family doctor with your weight, height and any changes in your blood, for example. DO I NEED A REFERRAL?: No, but you need to find a family doctor. If word-of-mouth doesn't work, the College of Physicians and Surgeons has an organization based in each province with a list of doctors accepting new patients.
HOW OFTEN TO GO: Once a year, and in warmer months if you're seeking advice on skin protection from the sun THE DETAILS: According to skin expert Dr. Jim Baral, how often you see a dermatologist depends on the purpose of your visit. If you're curious about the condition of your skin overall or have general inquires, once a year is sufficient. But if you're worried about skin spots or acne, make an appointment right away, he said in an article on iVillage.com. DO I NEED A REFERRAL?: Yes for medical procedures (like acne and moles), no for cosmetic procedures (like wrinkles or sunspots).
HOW OFTEN TO GO: Once a year or every three years (depending on your situation) — for many women, their general practitioner (GP) is sufficient THE DETAILS: Women over the age of 18 (both sexually active and not) should see a gynecologist (or someone with whom to discuss reproductive concerns) at least once a year, according to Everyday Health. If you're pregnant, for example, you're more likely to see the gyno more often. DO I NEED A REFERRAL?: Yes — if you have specific concerns or are pregnant, your GP can refer you to a gynecologist
HOW OFTEN TO GO: Six months for a cleaning, once a year for X-rays THE DETAILS: Depending on your health, your visits to the dentist can vary, according to the Canadian Dental Association. Do you smoke? Floss every day? Eat well? The organization says these are questions you should ask yourself before you see a dentist — and it will determine how often you have to sit in a dentist's chair. DO I NEED A REFERRAL?: No.
HOW OFTEN TO GO: Age dependent, but roughly, once every two to three years THE DETAILS: School-aged children (under the age of 19) should receive eye examinations annually, according to the Canadian Association of Optometrists. Adults between the ages of 20 and 39, especially if they wear glasses or contacts, should see an optometrist once every two to three years to keep their prescriptions updated. Anyone over the age of 40 should have eye exams once every two years. DO I NEED A REFERRAL?: No.
HOW OFTEN TO GO: Depending on the treatment, visits can vary from once a month to once every few years THE DETAILS: Occupational therapists cover everything from stress management to exercises to build strength after an injury, according to The Cleveland Clinic. Depending on your mood, injury and age, some clients visit OTs regularly to receive therapy. DO I NEED A REFERRAL?: No.
HOW OFTEN TO GO: Every 10 years (for people with average or low risks of colon-related illnesses) THE DETAILS: For most people, colorectal cancer screenings begin at the age of 50, according to MSN.com. Screenings should depend on your age, your risk factor and the type of screening you want. For example, fecal occult blood tests (fecal samples) should happen once a year, while double-contrast barium enema (an X-ray for the entire colon) should happen every five years after 50. DO I NEED A REFERRAL?: Yes, by your family doctor.
HOW OFTEN TO GO: For those who have allergic reactions, depending on the type of test, it could vary from every two to four weeks for the first five months and later, once a month for the next three to five years THE DETAILS: Allergy shots help your body get used to allergens — they actually don't cure you from having allergic reactions, according to WebMD. If you suffer from any allergic reactions during spring or summer months, and medicine doesn't seem to do the trick, these shots are designed to lower your risk of symptoms. DO I NEED A REFERRAL?: Yes, initially by your family doctor.
HOW OFTEN TO GO: Ask your family doctor if an ENT specialist is needed — course of treatment is on a case-by-case basis. Depending on the severity of your condition, you may have to see an ENT specialist as much as once a week to heal. THE DETAILS: An ENT (ear, nose, and throat) doctor or an otolaryngologist, is trained to treat everything from injuries to nerve damage in the ear, nose or throat area. ENT specialists can also provide treatments for cosmetic surgeries, sinus pain and head and neck cancer, according to the Canadian Society of Otolaryngology. DO I NEED A REFERRAL?: Yes, by your family doctor
HOW OFTEN TO GO: At least 10 to 20 visits after your first visit — at least once a week in the beginning THE DETAILS: Most people tend to seek chiropractors because of body pains and strains, according to the Canadian Chiropractic Association (CCA). San Francisco based chiropractor Dr. Eben Davis adds that people with fast-paced jobs or ones who perform a lot of physical activity, are more likely to see a chiropractor a few times a month. DO I NEED A REFERRAL?: You can ask your doctor to refer you to a specialist, but you can also find a list of chiropractors in your area through the CCA.