TORONTO - Ontario's top court has lowered the sentences of a Hamilton couple who held a developmentally disabled man captive and tortured him while draining his bank account to buy drugs and video game equipment.
Dakota Thompson and Stanley Brown were part of a group convicted of aggravated assault and forcible confinement for inflicting horrific injuries on a 23-year-old disabled man over more than two weeks in 2009.
Brown was originally sentenced to 13 years — nearly double the sentence the defence and Crown had jointly suggested — and Thompson was sentenced to 10 years, which was also far more than the Crown had recommended.
Thompson, 23, and Brown, 33, appealed their sentences, arguing that the trial judge was wrong to depart so markedly from the Crown's position for Thompson and the joint submission for Brown without giving any reasons for doing so.
The Court of Appeal for Ontario agreed, ruling that though the crimes were "extraordinarily egregious," the joint submission for Brown should be reinstated, and Thompson should receive a lesser sentence since she was less involved in the abuse.
The Appeal Court sentenced Brown to serve seven years and two months and Thompson to six years and eight months.
With credit for pre-trial custody and the time they have already been serving since they were sentenced in 2010, they would be eligible to apply for parole in about a year.
The three-judge Appeal Court panel said that without the joint submission and Crown recommendation, "left to our own devices," they would have imposed sentences between what they settled on and the trial judge's original sentences.
"However, the guilty pleas were negotiated in the context of that joint submission (for Brown) and the Crown's stance regarding Ms. Thompson," the court said.
"Weighing the circumstances of these offenders and notwithstanding the egregious nature of the crimes they committed, we cannot say that the joint submission could be considered to be contrary to the public interest or that giving effect to it would bring the administration of justice into disrepute."
WARNING: Graphic details from this court case may disturb some readers.
The group of people involved in the torture — Thompson, Brown, their roommate and a youth — lured the victim to their apartment by telling him they were going to help him look for a missing cellphone.
Instead, they confined him there for 17 days, burned him with a hair straightener, made him eat feces and drink urine, beat him and poured cayenne pepper into the bath when he tried to wash his wounds.
They essentially used him as their "personal automatic teller machine," the Crown said, forcing him to give them his bank card and PIN. His account was completely drained and the group bought marijuana, Xboxes, iPods and video games.
When the victim was discovered by police he had facial fractures, disfiguring injuries and a gaping head wound. One of the first officers on scene thought he was dead.
The Appeal Court decision notes the victim has made a "relatively" full recovery, though he does have permanent scars.
The lawyers noted in the appeals that the abusers are not without their own impairments. Brown has Fetal alcohol syndrome, Asperger syndrome and is of borderline intelligence. Thompson had a troubled upbringing and was addicted to Percocet and OxyContin.
It was not a case of the strong preying on the weak, but rather the weak preying on the weak, one said.
Earlier on HuffPost:
Bad Process Server
According to Mitch Zarskey, of Piney Point Village, Texas, his surveillance cameras captured a process server urinating in his driveway on Sept. 29, 2013. <strong>Watch the video here:</strong> <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/10/03/mitch-zarskey-process-server_n_4038044.html?1380821535" target="_blank">www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/10/03/mitch-zarskey-process-server_n_4038044.html</a>
Man Returns Used Enemas
Federal prosecutors say Ronald Robinson returned used enemas to a pharmacy in Jacksonville, Fla. The products were resold to customers before workers discovered they had been tampered with. Robinson could be imprisoned for 10 years if convicted.
Illicit Manatee Riding
This unidentified woman may have had a great time catching a ride on the back of a manatee in Florida, but, unfortunately, it's a misdemeanor in violation of the Florida Manatee Sanctuary Act. <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/02/manatee-riding-woman-photo-crime_n_1933672.html?utm_hp_ref=weird-news" target="_hplink">Read the whole story here.</a>
Alleged Violent Naked Pooping Masturbator
Gregory Matthew Bruni, 21, is accused of getting naked and climbing onto a couple's roof, then assaulting one of the homeowners before pooping and masturbating inside the house. <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/23/gregory-matthew-bruni-naked-poop-masturbate-florida_n_2533967.html?utm_hp_ref=weird-news">Read the whole story here.</a>
Brandi Lynn Stuntebeck
Stuntebeck, 31, allegedly attempted to flee after crashing into the back of another car in Ohio. The driver of that car, Donald Brownlee, followed her, leading Stuntebeck to pull over. But when he leaned through her passenger window, she drove off again dragging him for nearly a mile, according to police. He eventually fell and the car ran over his ankle.
When McDonald was accused by Seattle police of flashing a woman while masturbating in a park, <a href="http://www.seattlepi.com/local/article/Alleged-Seattle-park-masturbator-I-was-getting-3878136.php" target="_hplink">he told authorities</a> he was just getting "some sun."
After ramming into a deputy's patrol vehicle, this 18-year-old was handcuffed and thrown into the back seat. But not for long. She allegedly managed to escape from the cuffs, get into the driver's seat, and lead authorities on a chase that lasted a half hour and reached speeds up to 100 mph before the stolen SUV went off the road and flipped over. <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/25/shelby-figueroa-steals-car_n_1913973.html?1348604615" target="_hplink">Read the whole story here. </a>
William H. Masters III
This undated photo provided by the Huron County Sheriff shows William Howell Masters III, 60, of South Hampton, N.Y. Masters, the son of sex research pioneer Dr. William H. Masters, has been charged with exposing himself to a sheriff's deputy and another woman who were posing as recreational kayakers as part of a sting operation on a Michigan river. Huron County Sheriff Kelly Hanson says a completely nude Masters yelled for the women's attention Saturday, Sept. 1, 2012, then made obscene gestures. (AP Photo/Huron County Sheriff)
'Rules 2 Da game of Hoez!!!'
Sandra Russell and Steve McDaniel allegedly had a list of pimp game rules with them when they were arrested on charges of drugs and prostitution. <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/15/pimp-rules-list-for-da-game-of-hoez_n_1778493.html?utm_hp_ref=crime" target="_hplink">READ THIS LIST.</a>
This budding martial artist allegedly told deputies she was the "Karate Kid" before biting and slapping them
A DJ allegedly broke into the homes of men he saw at clubs and parties and performed oral sex on them as they slept, according to police in Pennsylvania. Harrisburg police said that Dajuan Porter, 27, stalked three men and sexually assaulted them in their homes, according to WHP-TV.
He allegedly lit a toilet on fire at a gas station. For religious reasons. After huffing 10 cans of Reddi-wip. Because the U.S. Constitution says he can. 'Nuff said.
Why is this man's head on fire? Because he lit it on fire. Bonner allegedly bet his bar buddies that he could pour a shot of 151 on his head and light the alcohol. And he did. Great job!
Ilyass Nabih and Thony Sengsoulya
Ilyass Nabih and Thony Sengsoulya, both of Nashua, New Hampshire, were arrested on drug charges in June 2012 after authorities spotted them allegedly trying to shoot up heroin while parked outside the Lawrence Police Station in Massachusetts.
<a href="http://www.seattlepi.com/local/article/Charge-Coffee-stand-masturbator-caught-again-3656307.php" target="_hplink">Mishkov is accused</a> of masturbating in front of a jail employee on his way to court to face a previous flashing charge.
Ray Woods allegedly tied 89 bags of heroin and cocaine to his penis. When cops found him out, he reportedly urinated all over himself. <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/12/89-bags-of-heroin-tied-to-penis_n_1420733.html" target="_hplink">Read more.</a>
He had a real sweet tooth. Cops say they found 22-year-old Andrew Toothman lying down inside Kentucky Food World IGA market on Feb. 2, completely covered in chocolate and peanut butter. He'd also allegedly written "Sorry" in NyQuil on the floor. Read more <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/09/naked-chocolate-peanut-butter_n_1265639.html" target="_hplink">here.</a>
Timothy Paul Shelby
Shelby, 53, was arrested in South Florida on June 1, 2012 for driving without a license -- immediately after leaving a courthouse after he appeared for the same offense.
Levon Davis used a picture of his girlfriend for target practice with his rifle. That's not illegal -- but it is against the law to accidentally shoot that bullet into your neighbor's house. He was charged with negligent use of a firearm.