"There's a bad stench coming from north of the border and the Red Sox left here smelling likes roses," Boston Herald columnist Michael Silverman wrote Friday.
The column's headline was "No mystery about Jays," with a smaller headline of "Biggest disappointment so far in 2013."
Silverman called the 10-19 Jays the "Astros of the North, a team spinning into what looks like a death spiral, and it's only early May."
Former major league pitcher Dirk Hayhurst, now a broadcast analyst for the Blue Jays said this week Buchholz was "absolutely" cheating in Wednesday's start. An article on the Sportsnet website included photographs of Buchholz, including one showing him wiping his first two fingers across his forearm, which appeared to be partially covered with a white substance.
Jays broadcaster Jack Morris,a former pitching star himself, agreed with Hayhurst.
Buchholz brushed aside the allegations, saying he puts rosin on his arm and occasionally wets his fingers to get a better grip.
Manager John Farrell, who left Toronto for Boston, insisted the photos were "false" and backed Buchholz's claim about rosin.
Buchholz (6-0) leads the majors in wins and the AL in ERA (1.01).
"What's unusual is how one baseball team was supposed to be so good turned out to be so bad," offered Silverman. "Maybe someone should stick the Blue Jays' announcers on that and see if they can solve that crime."