OTTAWA — NDP Leader Thomas Mulcair misled Canadians when he said his party had received approval from the House of Commons to set up a satellite office in Montreal, new documents suggest.
The Huffington Post Canada has learned that the House of Commons administration, including clerk Audrey O’Brien, believed from October 2011 until March 2014 that the NDP had set up a caucus bureau for its Quebec MPs in Ottawa, not in Montreal.
“At no point was the House Administration informed that the employees would be located in Montreal or that their work would be carried out in co-location with a political party’s offices,” documents given to MPs sitting on the Commons’ Procedure and House Affairs committee state.
At a March 24 press conference, Mulcair told reporters that the House of Commons had signed off on the satellite office.
“This is work that is completely allowed, that has been verified and validated,” he said.
The NDP staffers’ own employment forms – signed by NDP MPs — said they worked in an Ottawa office, even though they were really living and working in Montreal.
In 2011, interim NDP Leader Nycole Turmel’s deputy chief of staff Jess Turk-Browne told two members of the House of Commons staff that the employees would be working for Quebec NDP MPs in Ottawa.
“Ms. Turk-Browne specified the employees would be working in Ottawa even though their home addresses are in Montreal,” the minutes of one October 2011 meeting state.
But NDP press secretary Marc-André Viau suggested Monday evening that Commons staff implicitly approved the arrangement when they agreed the party could hire staff who lived in Montreal.
“If we had not followed the rules would the director of pay and benefits...have agreed to send cheques? Nope,” Viau wrote in an email.
The offsite staff each received a House of Commons Blackberry with a 514 area code, Viau added.
“They live in Montreal, you expect them to drive four [hours] a day? Of course they work out of Montreal,” he wrote. “Clearly there was an arrangement between the [House of Commons] administration and the NDP … This is much more solid proof than the allegations coming out of the [Board of Internal Economy].”
The board, the secretive all-party committee that administers the House of Commons, is currently investigating whether the NDP broke any rules when it set up party offices outside of Ottawa with staff paid for by taxpayers.
There are similar satellite offices in Quebec City and Toronto and the party wanted to start one in Saskatoon.
The board is also studying whether the NDP abused its free mailing privileges when it sent out some 2 million pieces of mail within five months to 26 ridings where it has no MPs. That number included 385,619 letters sent to three ridings just before a by-election call. The letters talked about the NDP leader Thomas Mulcair’s experience and attacked the Liberals and Conservatives for unethical behaviour.
MPs are specifically banned from using their offices to promote their political party. They cannot use their resources to help the “administration, organization, and internal communications of a political party and the solicitation of member to a political party.” They also cannot use their office to fundraise or to support or oppose any candidate in an election.
Sources told HuffPost Monday that the NDP is refusing to turn over documents to help the board with its probe.
“We are having problems getting information from them and they are not being very co-operative,” said a person who wasn’t authorized to speak about the matter publicly.
HuffPost has learned that the board was recently advised that the NDP mailings breached the rules because they were too partisan.
The board’s inquiries into the use of NDP satellite offices, however, has ground to a halt because the NDP is refusing to turn over documents.
Turmel, now the party whip, wrote the board stating the NDP won’t hand over any records before Mulcair testifies at a Commons committee Thursday. The NDP wants assurances that any documents given to the board won’t find their way into the hands of MPs questioning their leader.
Mulcair is being forced to appear before the Procedure and House Affairs committee Thursday to explain the NDP’s use of taxpayer resources for partisan purposes.
So far, the NDP has refused to identify where the satellite offices are located, what jobs employees are performing, what MPs are paying for what services and what other Commons resources, such as furniture and Blackberry devices, are being used.
The board is holding a special meeting on Wednesday to try to get over the impasse.
Mulcair has repeatedly said his party “always followed the rules.”
In March, Mulcair said former leader Jack Layton was responsible for devising the plan that pooled the MPs’ office budgets to pay for extra support staff.
“When Jack Layton put these offices in place, of course we took care to look at that and we are always careful,” he said.
Party work was done by party employees and caucus work was done by Parliamentary staff, he said.
The Montreal office is “doing support work for caucus, which is allowed,” Mulcair said.
In April, when the board announced it would explicitly ban parliamentary staff from working in premises owned or leased by a political party, the NDP leader said the new rule was “proof” the New Democrats “were following the rules before.”
Layton passed away on August 22, 2011. According to documents provided by the Commons’ administration, many NDP employees working for the Montreal office were hired in late August. Public servants only started asking questions about the unusual arrangement, however, after they received the employees’ paperwork in late September.
Mulcair told reporters the offices were no secret and ever since becoming leader in March 2012, he had spoken openly about opening up new offices in Quebec.
Mulcair’s spokesman George Smith repeated his boss’s lines Monday.
“Everything was set up following the rules in place at the time,” he said.
Smith provided HuffPost with a copy of a letter that he said “demonstrates the clerk was given details of the arrangement.”
Nowhere in the letter does it mention that the employees will be working outside of Ottawa.
The nine employees working for the NDP Quebec caucus were to be paid a total of $503,036, documents show.
In March, after the Speaker’s office was contacted by a reporter inquiring about the Montreal office, the Commons’ chief financial officer Mark Watters wrote to the clerk. He informed her that the story must be related to the Ottawa office staff who were given approval to work for several Quebec NDP MPs at once.
“I do not believe that the NDP set up a Quebec Office,” Watters wrote.
“That is my recollection as well, Mark,” O’Brien responded.
If the board members agree with the findings, they can dock an MP’s budget or request the reimbursement from a member personally. Possible courses of action also include referring the matter to the House for discipline, taking legal action or referring the matter to authorities such as the RCMP.
Some reports suggest the NDP might be forced to repay up to $3 million in ineligible expenses.
The House of Commons committee’ probe, which begins Thursday with Mulcair’s testimony, will only look at whether the party intended to skirt the rules related to partisan and electoral activities.
The board will decide whether any breaches took place.
On April 1, 2014, members of Parliament received a 2.2 per cent pay increase, bringing the basic pay of each MP up to $163,700 from $160,200 the year prior. But while that base salary is the same for every member, certain MPs are afforded the chance to make much more. The full list of indemnities, salaries and allowances can be found <a href="http://www.parl.gc.ca/parlinfo/lists/Salaries.aspx?Menu=HOC-Politic&Section=03d93c58-f843-49b3-9653-84275c23f3fb" target="_blank">here.</a>
Member of the House of Commons
Tory MP Brad Butt (Mississauga-Streetsville) is an example of an MP who earns just the base salary afforded to all MPs. <strong>2014 Salary: $163,700</strong> There are currently 308 MPs.
Prime Minister of Canada
The Right Honourable Stephen Harper, however, makes double the salary of your average MP. <strong>2014 Salary: $327,400 Car Allowance: $2,000</strong>
Speaker of the House of Commons
Tory MP Andrew Scheer (Regina—Qu'Appelle) earns the base salary, plus $78,300 for serving as Speaker. <strong>2014 Salary: $242,000 Car allowance: $1,000</strong>
Leader of the Opposition in the House of Commons
NDP Leader Thomas Mulcair earns the base MP salary, plus $78,300 for leading the Official Opposition. <strong>2014 Salary: $242,000 Car Allowance: $2,000</strong>
Treasury Board President Tony Clement (Parry Sound–Muskoka), like other cabinet ministers, earns $78,300 on top of the base MP salary. <strong>2014 Salary: $242,000 Car Allowance: $2,000</strong> There are 39 cabinet ministers in Harper's government (including ministers of state who make slightly less).
Minister of State
Minister of State for Democratic Reform Pierre Poilievre (Nepean-Carleton), like all other ministers of state, earns $58,700 on top of his base MP salary. But junior ministers do not received a car allowance. <strong>2014 Salary: $222,400</strong>
Leader of Other Parties
Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau and the leaders of the Green Party and Bloc Quebecois earn the base MP salary, plus $55,600 for serving as their party's top dog. <strong>2014 Salary: $219,300</strong>
Leader of the Government in the House of Commons
Tory MP Peter Van Loan (York-Simcoe) earns $78,300 on top of the base MP salary. <strong>2014 Salary: $242,000 Car Allowance: $2,000</strong>
Oppostion House Leader
NDP MP Peter Julian (Burnaby—New Westminster) earns the base MP salary plus a $40,600 pay bump for serving as Opposition House leader. <strong>2014 Salary: $204,300</strong> <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2014/03/21/nathan-cullen-ndp-finance-critic-salary_n_5007937.html" target="_blank">Former NDP House leader Nathan Cullen recently took a $40,000 pay cut to move from that role to NDP finance critic.</a>
House Leader (Other Parties)
Liberal MP Dominic LeBlanc (Beauséjour), earns the base MP salary plus $16,300 for serving as House leader for his party. <strong>2014 Salary: $180,000</strong>
Chief Government Whip
Tory MP John Duncan (Vancouver Island North) earns the base MP salary, plus $29,400 for serving as the Harper government's whip. <strong>2014 Salary: $193,100</strong>
Chief Opposition Whip
NDP MP Nycole Turmel (Hull—Aylmer) also earns an additional $29,400 for serving as the Opposition's whip. <strong>2014 Salary: $193,100</strong>
Tory MP Paul Calandra (Oak Ridges—Markham) is one of 31 parliamentary secretaries who gets a $16,300 pay bump on top of their salaries. <strong>2014 Salary: $180,000</strong>
UP NEXT: Pierre Poilievre Through The Years
Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre rises in the House of Commons to apologize for making an obscene gesture yesterday, in Ottawa Wednesday June 14, 2006. (CP PHOTO/Tom Hanson)
Ottawa-area Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre smiles as he talks with reporters on Parliament Hill in Ottawa Tuesday Feb. 27, 2007. Poilievre referred to "extremist elements" in the Liberal party that want to ease anti-terror laws and shut down the Air India inquiry last week.(CP PHOTO/Tom Hanson) Canada
Democratic Reform Minister Peter Van Loan (right), with Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre looking on, makes an announcement on the introduction of the Accountability with Respect to Loans legislation at the Canadian Museum of Civilization in Gatineau, Quebec across the river from Ottawa, Tuesday May 8, 2007.(CP PHOTO/Fred Chartrand) CANADA ,
Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre rises in the House of Commons to apologize for saying in a radio interview Wednesday that native people need to learn the value of hard work more than they need residential schools compensation, on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Thursday June 12, 2008. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Tom Hanson
With copies of the Conservative accountabilty booklets, Conservative M.P. Pierre Poilievre waits for the start of the Commons House affairs committee looking into allegations of Tory election spending misconduct during the last election, on Monday Sept. 10, 2007 in Ottawa. (CP PHOTO/Fred Chartrand)
Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre speaks in the House of Commons during question period on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Monday June 16, 2008. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
Pierre Poilievre, parliamentary secretary to the prime minister, leaves a news conference after speaking with the media about the gun registry in the Foyer of the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Tuesday September 14, 2010. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre listens to a question during a news conference in Ottawa, Friday October 15, 2010. THE CANADIAN PRESS IMAGES/Adrian Wyld
Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre poses with a bust of Sir John A. Macdonald after announcing the former Bank of Montreal building would be renamed in honour of Canada's first prime minister during a ceremony in Ottawa, Ont., Wednesday January 11, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre rises during Question Period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Tuesday February 28, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre holds up copies of legislation as he responds to a question during Question Period in the House of Commons in Ottawa, Friday October 19, 2012. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Pierre Poilievre is sworn in as the minister of state for democratic reform during a ceremony at Rideau Hall in Ottawa on Monday, July 15, 2013. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
The Honourable Pierre Poilievre, Minister of State (Democratic Reform), poses for a group photo after the swearing in of the federal cabinet at Rideau Hall in Ottawa on Monday, July 15, 2013. THE CANADIAN PRESS/ Patrick Doyle
Minister of State Pierre Poilievre stands in the House of Commons during Question Period, in Ottawa Friday, February 7, 2014. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand
Minister of State (Democratic Reform) Pierre Poilievre responds to a question during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, February 27, 2014. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
UP NEXT: The Fair Election Act
"The Fair Elections Act will ensure everyday citizens are in charge of democracy, by putting special interests on the sidelines and rule-breakers out of business," says Democratic Reform Minister Pierre Poilievre. Read more about the Fair Elections Act <a href="http://www.democraticreform.gc.ca/eng/content/harper-government-introduces-fair-elections-act" target="_blank">here.</a>
Crackdown On Illegal Robocalls
The legislation proposes a <a href="http://www.democraticreform.gc.ca/eng/content/backgrounder-protecting-voters-rogue-callers" target="_blank">mandatory public registry</a> for mass automated election calls, jail time for those convicted of impersonating an elections official, and "increased penalties for deceiving people out of their votes."
No More 'Vouching' For Your Buddy
In the interest of cracking down on voter fraud, the bill would prohibit the practice whereby one Canadian vouches for another's identity at a polling station. In fact, voter information cards will no longer be accepted as proof of identity. <a href="http://www.democraticreform.gc.ca/eng/content/backgrounder-fair-elections-act-cracking-down-voter-fraud" target="_blank">But the government says voters will still have 39 forms of authorized ID to choose from in order to prove their identity and residence.</a>
Independence For The Elections Commissioner
The Commissioner of Canada Elections office, responsible for enforcing the elections law, will be moved under the mantle of the public prosecutor's office, not Elections Canada. Conservatives believe this will give the commissioner <a href="http://www.democraticreform.gc.ca/eng/content/backgrounder-independent-commissioner-sharper-teeth-longer-reach-and-freer-hand" target="_blank">more independence</a> as the Chief Electoral Officer will no longer be able to direct him to carry out investigations. In future, the commissioner would be appointed by the director of public prosecutions to a non-renewable, seven-year term. The legislation <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2014/02/04/fair-elections-act-poilievre-robocalls_n_4723565.html" target="_blank">also bars</a> former political candidates, political party employees, ministerial or MP staffers or employees of Elections Canada from being named commissioner. <a href="http://www.democraticreform.gc.ca/eng/content/backgrounder-independent-commissioner-sharper-teeth-longer-reach-and-freer-hand" target="_blank">Tories believe the legislation will give the commissioner "sharper teeth" and a "longer reach" to seek out stronger penalties for offences.</a>
More Donations Welcome
The ceiling for individual political donations would be raised to $1,500 from $1,200 and party spending limits would be increased by five per cent. Union and corporate donations are still banned, though.
The West Won't Have To Wait
A long-standing ban on the <a href="http://www.democraticreform.gc.ca/eng/content/backgrounder-fair-elections-act-respecting-democratic-elections-defending-freedom-speech" target="_blank">premature transmission of election results</a> will be lifted, meaning voters in Western Canada will get to know how things are shaping up out East before heading to the polls. Broadcasters can share results from Eastern Canada on election night, even if the polls aren't closed in the West. The government believes this change will uphold free speech.
New Rules On Political Loans
The legislation would raise the amount candidates can <a href="http://news.nationalpost.com/2014/02/04/conservatives-unveil-fair-elections-act-which-they-say-will-crack-down-on-illegal-robocalls/" target="_blank">contribute to their own campaigns to $5,000.</a> Leadership contestants will be allowed to give their own campaign up to $25,000.
UP NEXT: Funniest Robocall Movie Titles
John Patrick Stanley
Also on HuffPost: