The three 18-year-olds from suburban Philadelphia told The Associated Press this week that they bought bottles of HGH online in the past year. Turns out, what they bought was fake.
Their experiences are part of a growing trend.
Experimentation with human growth hormones by America's teens more than doubled in the past year, according to a national survey released Wednesday by the Partnership for Drug-Free Kids.
"I would say at least 20-25 per cent use anabolic steroids," said Frank Trumbetti, owner of Rock Bottom Nutrition and Fitness Center in Cherry Hill, New Jersey. "As for HGH, there is such an overuse of everything when it comes to looking for real stuff."
Many products claiming to be human growth hormones are widely available on the internet. But getting authentic HGH — which can cost up to $1,000 per kit for a monthly supply — isn't that simple.
"It's a lot easier for high school athletes to get over-the-counter pro-hormones than legitimate HGH," said Steve Saunders, CEO of Power Train Sports Institute.
Saunders trains thousands of high school and college athletes and hundreds of professional athletes at his 15 locations across six states, including Hawaii. James Harrison, Hines Ward, LeSean McCoy and even actor Liam Hemsworth are just a few of his previous clients.
"We tell all our guys you can't substitute hard work and a proper nutrition plan," Saunders said. "Using HGH and steroids is pure laziness."
But many athletes are looking for a quick fix and turning to performance-enhancing drugs.
In a confidential 2013 survey of 3,705 high school students, 11 per cent reported using synthetic HGH at least once — up from about 5 per cent in the four preceding annual surveys. Teen use of steroids increased from 5 per cent to 7 per cent over the same period, the survey found.
However, like the teenagers from suburban Philadelphia, many teens might not know what they're taking.
"We had no clue we weren't using real HGH," Guerreri said. "We figured it out when we didn't get any results from it and then a guy at our gym told us HGH doesn't come in a bottle."
The three friends were walking around the ballpark during a Phillies-Giants game on Monday night wearing fitted T-shirts. The attire showed off their bulging biceps, and the trio say they tried various supplements — both legal and illegal — throughout their high school years.
Guerreri, who is 6-foot-4, 220 pounds, is chiseled. He's closer to accomplishing his goal than his two friends because he looks a little like Randy Orton, his favourite WWE star.
Badalanato didn't even start at running back his senior year and remains undecided on college. O'Brien's fastball only topped out at 81 mph.
"A lot of guys we know are interested in HGH, but it's much easier to get other stuff that's cheaper and works faster," Badalanato said.
Dr. John Kolonich, a chiropractor in Franklinville, New Jersey, said authentic HGH is only injectable and also noted it is very expensive.
"It has to be refrigerated once it's constituted and it's not a testosterone where in two weeks you start noticing results," Kolonich said. "HGH is not the drug of choice for a high school kid who wants to play better.
That doesn't stop teens from looking for it.
Trumbetti said teens — and parents — ask him about it every day. He said he threatened to call child services on a dad who wanted to put his 14-year-old son on human growth hormones. The boy was only 5-foot-2 and 108 pounds.
"That's just one example," Trumbetti said. "You have some moms and dads that are afraid to have their kids take just protein powder and then you have parents that are encouraging it and more like steroids or HGH because they think it'll help their kid get a college scholarship. What made it worse was when Roger Clemens and Brian McNamee went up there before the House Oversight Committee. Having that publicized and seeing Clemens and Barry Bonds, two of the greatest players of our generation, influenced kids because they think that's how they can better."
John Chisholm, a high school teacher in Pennsauken, New Jersey, coached wrestling for 20 years at three different schools. He never heard of anyone taking HGH, but said steroid use was more common.
"I remember a kid wrestling at 160 pounds as a junior. The next year, he was a solid 215 pounds and jacked-up," Chisholm said. "He did that in one season and won the state title."
Guerreri, Badalanato and O'Brien went searching in the wrong places for their supply of human growth hormone. Other teens say they know where to get it.
Vince Castanzo, a young weightlifter who was working out at a fitness centre in Turnersville, New Jersey said, "Find the biggest guy in your gym, the guy who isn't just big but is lean, cut, has the six-pick abs and there's a good chance he knows where to get the real HGH."