Acertys was the uncontested winner of a $267,000 contract to carry out consultations on Ste-Catherine Street West.
Acertys was awarded the contract in March, but it wasn’t until Inspector-General Denis Gallant tabled his 25-page report on Monday that the uncontested nature of the tendering process was forced into the spotlight.
"It was not fair at all. All the rules of equity were not followed by the department at the city," Gallant toldCBC's Daybreak on Tuesday.
Renewal part of 375th anniversary project
Part of the conditions laid out in the initial call for tenders was that bidding companies needed to have at least 20 years of experience with these types of public projects and needed to have completed at least two previous consulting contracts that exceeded $100,000.
"Everything was so restrictive that most of the bidders who would have been able to bid, because of the restrictive rules, did not bid," Gallant said.
"Everything [in that contract] is terrible from A to Z."
Gallant said the city should have required 15 years of experience "at the most."
He said that if he had the power to cancel contracts, he would do so in this case.
The Ste-Catherine Street renewal project is part of Mayor Denis Coderre’s plans for Montreal’s 375th anniversary celebration.