EDMONTON — Alberta's education minister says he is disturbed by the latest example of dysfunction at Edmonton's Catholic school board and he acknowledges that dissolving the board is an option.
"I'm very concerned because of course they are responsible for many tens of thousands of children and running one of the biggest boards in the province,'' David Eggen said Tuesday.
"We need to know the procedures for making decisions are clear.''
Board members met without the knowledge of their chairwoman last week to send out to all parents a letter from Calgary's bishop.
The letter from Bishop Fred Henry condemns a provincial guideline school boards have been told they must follow to develop policies for LGBTQ students.
Eggen was asked if he is considering dissolving the Edmonton Catholic board.
"Moving down that road is certainly one of the options I have available to me, and I have been reflecting on that in the last few days,'' he replied.
Eggen is to meet again with facilitator Donald Cummings in the next few days. The minister hired Cummings last fall to help Edmonton Catholic board members work together. That was deemed necessary after public meetings about a transgender girl disintegrated into shouts, anger, insults and tears.
Edmonton Catholic is one of 61 school boards across Alberta who have been told they must draft policies to make schools safe and welcoming to LGBTQ students. The drafts are to be submitted to the province for review by March 31.
Guidelines outlined by the province last week specify that transgender students be allowed to use the washroom of their choice, depending on their sex or on whether they perceive themselves to be a girl or a boy.
They say students should be allowed to dress based on the same principle and play on sports teams they feel align with their sexuality.
Eggen has said he expects the submissions will reflect the spirit, if not the letter, of the province's blueprint.
On Friday, Edmonton Catholic school trustees forwarded Henry's letter to all parents in the district. It was not a unanimous move. Board trustee Patricia Grell, in a blog post, said she opposed the decision and apologized to parents for it.
Calgary Bishop Fred Henry has condemned Education Minister David Eggen's guidelines for LGBTQ students in the province. . (Photo: Roman Catholic Diocese of Calgary/Facebook)
Marilyn Bergstra, chairwoman of the Edmonton Catholic board, also apologized for the letter being sent and told reporters that she was not part of the decision to send it out.
Also Tuesday, the Alberta Catholic School Trustees Association said in a release that it was disappointed in the process that led to the guidelines.
The association stated it "reaffirms its commitment to work with Alberta Education and regrets Alberta Education's lack of consultation during the development of the guidelines.''
The association also reaffirmed "the responsibility and the role of the Alberta Catholic bishops to provide moral and theological leadership to the Catholic community, including Catholic education communities.''
Also on HuffPost:
In the summer of 1987 in El Paso, Texas, 15-year-old Mexican American Aristotle Mendoza, known as Ari, meets a boy named Dante Quintana at the local swimming pool. Ari is closed up and often angry, and struggles with his family's secret: his brother is in prison, and his parents never mention it. Meanwhile, Dante is sensitive and intellectual, with a family he loves. As Ari and Dante's friendship develops, Dante falls in love with Ari. As Publishers Weekly noted, "It's a tender, honest exploration of identity and sexuality, and a passionate reminder that love--whether romantic or familial--should be open, free, and without shame."
In this satirical novel, a plane full of Miss Teen Dream beauty pageant contestants crashes onto a desert island, where they must struggle to survive in the face of giant snakes, a sinister Corporation (that has suggestive ties to the Miss Team Dream pageant), and an Elvis-obsessed dictator named MoMo B. ChaCha. It's all in the name of sending up our cultural obsession with beauty, and the diverse cast of crashed beauty queens includes lesbian, bisexual, and transgender characters. The New York Times declared, "Beauty Queens is a madcap surrealist satire of the world in which [Libba Bray's] readers have come of age--reality TV, corporate sponsorship, product placement, beauty obsession--but ultimately, it's a story of empowering self-discovery."
When high school sophomore Paul meets Noah -- a newly arrived senior -- at a bookstore, Paul falls into immediate crush. In some YA novels, this kind of experience would be followed up with coming-out issues, but there's no need for that here, because Paul has known he was gay for a long time. "I've always known I was gay, but it wasn't confirmed until I was in kindergarten," Paul explains. "It was my teacher who said so. It was right there on my kindergarten report card: PAUL IS DEFINITELY GAY AND HAS VERY GOOD SENSE OF SELF." From the book's first pages, it's clear that Paul's world could be called a "gaytopia," in which it's way more than okay to be gay. This groundbreaking novel is a modern classic.
Sergio, a bisexual teen, meets Lance, a gay teen, online, and the two arrange for a date at the local mall. Each brings a friend with them; Sergio brings his lesbian best friend Kimiko, while Lance brings his straight (or is she?) friend Allie. In this fast-paced, soapy story, Kimiko falls for Allie, who realizes she might not be as straight as she thought she was, while Lance struggles to accept Sergio's bisexuality. In a starred review, Booklist stated, "Sanchez [has] written another innovative, important book that explores, with empathy and sympathy, largely ignored aspects of teen sexual identity. While lip service is routinely given to these aspects in the acronym GLBTQ, there have been only a handful of novels that so plausibly and dramatically bring the nature of bisexuality and sexual questioning to life."
Fifteen-year-old Jesse Halberstam wears big green fisherman's boots, cuts her hair with a Swiss Army knife, and plasters the school with posters from NOLAW, the National Organization to Liberate All Weirdos. Jesse came out when she was fourteen. Emily Miller is student council vice president, wears cardigans from J. Crew, and is seeking out corporate sponsorship for the school's formal dance. Emily has a long-term boyfriend. The only thing Jesse and Emily have in common is every Tuesday afternoon in the library bathroom, where they make out in secret. Told in alternating chapters, this sharp, funny book explores love, politics, and what really makes us who we are. It's not necessarily sexual orientation.
Nicola Lancaster wants to be an archaeologist, and she hopes to focus on that when she attends the Siegel Institute Summer Program for Gifted Youth. But her first day there she notices Battle Hall Davies, a girl with beautiful blond hair who is also a dancer. Over the course of the summer, Nic and Battle's friendship develops into something more, forcing Nic, who thought she was straight, to question her sexual orientation. Written in the first person with excerpts from Nic's journal, Empress of the World realistically and sympathetically explores bisexuality and friendship.
Seventeen-year-old J was born "Jenifer," but J has never felt like a girl. He has always felt like a boy. This story about J's transition from female to male takes J away from his home to an LGBT high school and a transgender support group in Manhattan, where he finds a community of trans folk. In a starred review, Booklist described I Am J as "Easily the best book to date about the complicated condition of being a transsexual teen, not only sharing important information that is artfully woven into the plot but also creating, in J, a multilayered, absolutely believable character whose pain readers will share. Perhaps most importantly, the author brings clarity and charity to a state of being that has too long been misunderstood, ignored, and deplored."
High school senior Azure is recruited by her principal to turn their school's traditional prom into an "alternative prom" that will include everyone -- not just the popular kids who can afford to spend a lot of money on tuxes and limos. Azure invites her best friends, Luke, a theater geek, and Radhika, a straight-A student, to help out. One problem? Both Azure (who is an out lesbian) and Luke (who is openly bisexual) have crushes on Radhika.
When Angela Katz-MacNair comes out as transgendered, he chooses a new name: Grady. His family and friends struggle with his new identity, but Grady finds support in unexpected places, including a classmate who explains that parrot fish can change their gender, and a beautiful popular girl who seems to understand him. VOYA raved, "Peopled with wonderfully wacky characters and scenes, this narrative snaps and crackles with wit, even while it touches the spirit of the sensitive reader."
In this historical novel set in nineteenth-century England, seventeen-year-old Louisa Cosgrove is locked into Wildthorn Hall, an insane asylum for women, and is told that her name is Lucy Childs. The mystery of why Louisa has been sentenced to the madhouse under this different name unfolds through flashbacks that I will not reveal here, but suffice it to say: Louisa's not straight. After an attempt to run away from the asylum, Louisa is moved into a ward for seriously insane women, and the only kindness she finds comes from an attendant, Eliza. Though the setup might make readers believe there can be no happy ending, Wildthorn is a rare YA historical novel written in the Sarah Waters mode -- which means yes, happy endings are possible, even for lesbians in nineteenth century England.
Though the number of LGBTQ-centered young adult novels has increased significantly in recent years, there are still few YA fantasy or science fiction novels with LGBTQ main characters. For that reason (and because I'm writing this post!), I offer my second novel, Huntress, as #11 in this list of 10 titles. I cannot claim to be impartial on this book at all, so I will simply say this: This is a story for people who like high fantasy, complete with weapons and magic and adventure and save-the-world stakes. What makes it different is that it also includes a romance between two girls in a world where being a gay is totally normal. If you want your kick-ass girls to fall in love with other girls, this is the book for you.