OTTAWA — Federal Environment Minister Catherine McKenna says her role is as a "kind of convener" among disparate factions of the progressive push for climate policies.
McKenna appeared Friday at a panel discussion on environmental policy at the Progress Summit hosted by the Broadbent Institute, a left-leaning think tank.
She was joined on the stage by Alberta Environment Minister Shannon Phillips and Vancouver city councillor Andrea Reimer, a lineup that illustrated there's no unanimity of thought on climate action even among those pointed in the same direction.
Phillips represents a sea change in Alberta politics with an NDP government that's imposing carbon pricing and a hard cap on greenhouse gas emissions, while still pushing for expansion of the oilsands and new market access.
Catherine McKenna responds to a questions during a discussion on the environment at the Progress summit in Ottawa, April 1, 2016. (Photo: Adrian Wyld/CP)
Reimer, by contrast, sits on a city council that is striving to make Vancouver the greenest city on Earth and is resolutely against the construction of new pipelines.
The Trudeau Liberals have made combating climate change a top government priority, but continue to frustrate some in the environmental movement with their qualified support for some as-yet, undefined new oil pipeline.
Reimer called new pipeline construction "probably the big elephant in the room here today" in her opening remarks, sparking hoots of applause from the audience.
"Climate change is not a partisan file, it should not be a partisan file," McKenna responded, speaking after Reimer.
"Everyone knows we need to take action and we need to take action now. So I see my job as a kind of convener."
In a question-and-answer session that followed, McKenna said the federal government is pushing the transition to a low-carbon economy. But she worries about alienating those Canadians who want action but fear economic disruption — saying she's trying to "keep everyone on board."
"Everyone knows we need to take action and we need to take action now."
"We need transition to a low-carbon economy, but we can't do it overnight. I'm a realist on this. There are a lot of people who have lost jobs in Alberta. I'm not saying that means we destroy our planet, but we do need to be thoughtful about how we move forward."
McKenna acknowledged she was "preaching to the converted" at the Progress Summit, but said many other Canadians "are a little bit there."
They want climate action, said the federal minister, "but if what we end up doing has a huge, immediate, dislocating affect on the economy, where tons of people lose jobs, I'm losing everyone. I'm losing them."
Phillips, for her part, won applause when she said success on the low-carbon transition will not come by taking the current oil patch malaise "and make it worse. That is not the way we are going to succeed."
But it was Reimer with her no-pipeline, no-how message who carried the room.
"Way too much risk, no benefit — on a planet that is dying because we're burning fossil fuels. So the answer seems fairly clear: let's put our energy into a debate about renewable energy," said Reimer, drawing the panel's longest and biggest applause of the afternoon.
Also on HuffPost:
The global hashtag #LoveEarth on the Eiffel Tower.
At the Facebook booth at COP 21 Paris
Eiffel Tower 2 - The Sun for power
Go 100 Percent Clean, Renewable Power - a mandate for the world to prosper
Robert Redford meets with a forest preservation campaigner from Papua New Guinea at this Natural Resources Defense Council event in Paris.
Climate activist Tom Steyer shares a lighter moment with climate activist Governor Jerry Brown at the United Nation's Foundation Earth to Paris event at the beautiful Petit Palais.
Jerry Brown was in fine form in Paris. "These conservatives don't get it. The right kind of government regulation sets off a race to innovation in the private sector. We've proven it in California."
Monaco's Prince Albert, a great conservationist, at a salon in Paris hosted by his cousin, anti-poverty activist Albina du Boisrouvray, founder of the FXB Foundation. She is next to him above.
Avaaz.org organized this show of Force
Kerry at his Paris press conference urging nations to reach an agreement.
At a demonstration at COP 21 in Paris. And if rich countries invested in clean energy in the global south, they would not only save human civilization but they could also make money back.
Inside COP 21 Paris. A human rights issue for sure as refugees mount.
A poster at the Chinese pavilion at COP 21 Paris. Looks like the Chinese are starting to get it. Hopefully Republicans in our Congress are next.
Poster at the Caribbean nations pavilion COP 21 Paris. The emergence of the 1.5 degree target is a big breakthrough. 2 degrees C is too much for sure.
The German Pavilion. It was great to see each country's display of progress and commitment.